9 ms·
A link between video games and unemployment
- nabla9 9y agoThe actual paper is really interesting. Leisure Luxuries and the Labor Supply of Young Men http://economics.sas.upenn.edu/system/files/event_papers/leisure-luxuries-labor.pdf?download=1 http://economics.sas.upenn.edu/system/files/event_papers/lei...
- DamonHD 9y agoThe direction of causation (if there is one at all) is rather important as the article states. I have no time for video games at all, no I have no good feel for how likely they would be preferred over work and real financial independence for all but a very few.
- jorgemf 9y agoOf course, because the lower salaries, the high prices of the houses and the global crisis during these years has nothing to do with the unemployment in the young population.
- ethbro 9y agoThe article does note this, albeit using "good job" as a proxy for "all the things one might have historically expected to stem from having a good job." This seems like a forewave of the trends that point towards the basic income argument. Fewer productive jobs being necessary than labor force to fill them results in bifurcation of the labor market: between overpaid specialties (e.g. software dev) and underpaid make-work (e.g. McDonald's and Walmart) there's been a hollowing out "historically normal" jobs that don't take specialized knowledge but are still productive enough to afford a good quality of life. In the face of this, opting out and escaping into a virtual world seems fairly reasonable. Especially if you're on the losing end of whatever the current hot specializations are.
- fooza 9y agoI think this sector is now a embodied in sales/marketing. It's reasonable to expect from some one to become a productive salesperson after a few months. This professional will have many options from online marketing through mall cart sales to selling cloud services to corporations
- ethbro 9y agoAnything that can be eaten by software will be eaten by sufficiently advance software eventually. I can't think of any substantial value-adds from sales/marketing in the future to necessitate adding jobs there. High value (e.g. Apple) is currating a brand and most value is added at the top (average Genius salary looks around $45k [1]). Low value (e.g. Android OEMs) doesn't have the profit margins to support a larger human-sales/marketing team. And commodity (e.g. McDonald's) is high-level strategic branding with essentially no low level value add. [1] https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Apple-Mac-Genius-Salaries-E1138_D_KO6,16.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Apple-Mac-Genius-Salaries-E...
- emodendroket 9y agoYou need a particular kind of personality to do well in sales and most people don't have it. Most sales people end up dropping out.
- dv_dt 9y agoWhat a nightmare vision that gives me; Automation and lucky people who randomly chose the right skillset work, producing more and more of the core economy, and the rest of the meatbags are left selling stuff to each other? What happens when many business services are selected from automated markets... I guess we all sell custom hand-made widgets to each other?
- Analemma_ 9y agoThis is the easy response to the article. It is partially true, but the article is more true than you're giving it credit for. There are other articles about this (e.g. http://www.vulture.com/2017/02/video-games-are-better-than-real-life.html http://www.vulture.com/2017/02/video-games-are-better-than-r...) all confirming that unemployed people who play video games don't have the same increase in unhappiness that other unemployed people have. Which might be good for their short-term well-being, and is something to keep in mind for the post-scarcity UBI future if that ever happens, but in the medium term worrying, both for the individuals and for the economy generally. There are currently sectors- like construction- which are having trouble finding labor as the economy picks back up. Are these people going to avoid re-entering the labor force even when they can get a job, and are we ready for the consequences of that? And even if they do, they'll be starting out way behind on building household wealth and work experience.
- pharrington 9y ago-if the post-scarcity UBI future ever happens- I live in a country that throws away half of its prepared food. Like we're not even talking about some chopped up animal corpse that sits out for too long and has to be discarded before it goes rancid - in the US we strait-up assemble food in some factory, wrap it plastic, burn fuel shipping said wrapped and assembled food to a store halfway across the country, unwrap the food, put it in another container, and then at the end of the day just toss the remaining contents of the container into the garbage bin because you've got a few more tons of shipped and prepared food already in storage that needs to be sold. This is the post-scarcity future.
- kpil 9y agoIt won't be a problem* unless we make more of us. Political and religious leaders that oppose education and planned parenthood are the long term problem. Ok, slaughtering is a problem, but I think it will sort itself out eventually.
- metaphorm 9y agodon't you think it's a much bigger issue that we are normalized to a profoundly wasteful life style? this isn't really a population problem, it's an energy per capita problem.
- s_kilk 9y agoIt's the logic of Late Capitalism: all problems and failings are those of the individual, never of the system.
- quadrangle 9y agoWhile that may indeed be the propaganda, blaming addicts for their addictions can be victim-blaming. Some of the rhetoric blames the video game companies more than the consumers…
- posterboy 9y agono, not if the addict's diction is directed ad everyone else's faults but his own. Of course I am bending the definition https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/addico#Latin https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/addico#Latin
- kbutler 9y agoThere's a pendulum swing - focusing on the problems of the system, and focusing on the problems of the individual. In truth, there are problems both in the system and with individuals, and failings in each reinforce the other, and effective aspects of each also reinforce each other.
- city41 9y agoThe article addresses this: "While games improved since the turn of the century, labour-market options for young people got worse." That paragraph goes into more detail how the market has not been good for young people, and thus they turn to games, not the other way around.
- jorgemf 9y agoIf you read the paper it doesn't say that in the conclusions.
- soreasan 9y agoThe second to last paragraph suggests it is a possibility though: "To draw a firm conclusion, however, would take a clearer understanding of the direction of causation. While games improved since the turn of the century, labour-market options for young people got worse. Hourly wages, adjusted for inflation, have stagnated for young college graduates since the 1990s, while pay for new high-school graduates has declined. The share of young high-school and college graduates not in work or education has risen; in 2014 about 11% of college graduates were apparently idle, compared with 9% in 2004 and 8% in 1994. The share of recent college graduates working in jobs which did not require a college degree rose from just over 30% in the early 2000s to nearly 45% a decade later. And the financial crisis and recession fell harder on young people than on the population as a whole. For people unable to find demanding, full-time work (or any work at all) gaming is often a way to spend some of one’s unwanted downtime, rather than a lure out of work; it is much more a symptom of other economic ills than a cause."
- jorgemf 9y agoI said the paper, not the article in the economist. It is funny the article it is based on a paper which draws different conclusions.
- codingdave 9y agoRight, but the question I'd be interested in hearing more about is why gaming as a response to that unemployment? I'm recently unemployed (by my own choice), and am playing less games. I'm spending my extra time hiking, swimming, kayaking, etc. I actually deleted the games I used to play from my computer. I certainly have the time now to play more... but I'm in my mid-40s, and I did grow up on games, yet it seems far more enjoyable to me to go outside and unplug. So there is definitely a generational difference going on here.
- pseudalopex 9y agoNow imagine you're in your 20s and were laid off 6 months ago. You have no savings, no partner, and no in-demand skills. You bought a console and some games last year when you still had a job. $10 will pay for a month of online play, bus fare and a day pass at the pool, or enough gas for two trips to the nearest trailhead. You don't really enjoy playing video games all day, but it keeps your mind off your troubles, which is more than you can say for hiking. I don't think your situation is typical even for people your own age. I suspect the biggest generational difference is TV vs. video games.
- ouid 9y ago>games will go on getting better I don't think there's any evidence for this, and the call to panic is based on it.
- boubiyeah 9y agoyeah that makes no sense. Games will go on getting visually better but Gameplay, fun, replayability has very little to do with it.
- bjt 9y agoNot just visually. Increased computing power and richer game frameworks will make for more compelling AIs. There are advances in procedural content generation that are getting past the saminess of endless variations on "kill ten rats." Open modding platforms (e.g. Minecraft) create whole communities around them, and endless supplies of content. I think we're still in the infancy of that trend. The immersivity of VR will make gaming experiences qualitatively more compelling than the screens of the past. There's a lot more going on than just increased polygon counts.
- EthanHeilman 9y agoI have spent some time going back and replaying older games that I found amazing when I originally played them. Outside of simple reflex games like Tetris or Mario, game play has not aged well. Play a strategy or RPG video game from the mid 90s and see how fast it takes you to find some exploitable feature that makes the game trivial to beat. Compare: 1. "Shogun: Total War" to "Warhammer: Total War" or 2. Civ2's city spamming to Civ5 really well designed gameplay. 3. 1993's Stronghold [0] is so easy for modern gamers to win it feels more like an interactive screensaver than a game and it was a great game when it was released. The only real exception to this rule is RTS games like Starcraft or C&C, but only in multi-player. tl;dr Gamers and game play are in a Red Queen's race with each other. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stronghold_(1993_video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stronghold_(1993_video_game)
- ouid 9y ago
- minimaxir 9y agoAfter recently becoming unemployed, and in my spare time when not looking for jobs, I finally started working on my gaming backlog from sales (e.g. Witcher 3) and experimented with games that have a time commitment I have been avoiding, such as MMOs and League of Legends (which I ended up stopping because the rumors of a toxic playerbase are not inaccurate) At the least, I got it out of my system and am now back to personal technical projects/blogging.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI think it's important to be mindful that entertainment like video games in moderation is entirely acceptable. We must not squeeze productivity out of every waking hour in the day.
- ouid 9y agoIf you replace "productivity" with "utility" you might find more consistency.
- pzh 9y agoIf nothing else, at least those economists have found the solution to keep people occupied when AI renders half the world unemployed. Now the premise of the Matrix doesn't seem so far fetched after all.
- hanoz 9y agoIsn't the premise, unbearably absurd even by the standards of the rest of the movie, that humans are used as a power supply?
- __s 9y agoThey wanted them to be used for processing, but producers: https://scifi.stackexchange.com/a/116473 https://scifi.stackexchange.com/a/116473
- ricree 9y agoWasn't that going to rest on the tired old "10% of your brain" trope? Pulling that one out would have bothered me a great deal more than the battery analogy.
- desdiv 9y agoNEO: The human body is the most inefficient source of energy you could possibly imagine. The efficiency of a power plant at converting thermal energy into electricity decreases as you run the turbines at lower temperatures. If you had any sort of food humans could eat, it would be more efficient to burn it in a furnace than feed it to humans. And now you're telling me that their food is the bodies of the dead, fed to the living? Haven't you ever heard of the laws of thermodynamics? MORPHEUS: Where did you hear about the laws of thermodynamics, Neo? NEO: Anyone who's made it past one science class in high school ought to know about the laws of thermodynamics! MORPHEUS: Where did you go to high school, Neo? (Pause.) NEO: ...in the Matrix. MORPHEUS: The machines tell elegant lies. (Pause.) NEO (in a small voice): Could I please have a real physics textbook? MORPHEUS: There is no such thing, Neo. The universe doesn't run on math. [0] https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/1263/is-the-basic-premise-of-humans-as-a-power-source-in-the-matrix-reasonable https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/1263/is-the-basic-...
- GuiA 9y agoThere is an episode of "It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" where Charlie, a character who never gets any success in life (a janitor living in a dump of an apartment, gets rejected by his love interest constantly, abused by his friends, etc) gets really engrossed in an online videogame. He becomes really good at it, and exclaims "I'm thriving! I never get to thrive, and I want to be the guy who thrives for once! It's like when I'm doing good in the game, I'm doing good in real life!" It feels like there's an interesting insight there - if you're near the bottom of ladder in life (in an area with few/no jobs, have a hard time making friends, have no money for activities, etc), positive feedback loops can be few and far between, and it is very hard to get a feel for whether you're actually making progress or not. Work hard in life, and maybe you can reap some rewards years and years later, or maybe not (working at Walmart 20 years won't make you wealthy, or a respected Walmart executive). But work hard in a videogame for a few weeks or months, and you can have very concrete evidence of your progress. It's not hard to see why people would prefer investing hours in the latter then. Maybe that's where the appeal of the army lies for some. The very clear hierarchy means you know exactly where you fit, and what the path to the next rung of the ladder is - something that is true in very few other organizations.
- noonespecial 9y agoVideo games also provide a quality sorely lacking in real life. They try very hard to prevent cheating, because if there's too much cheating, or too much inequality between players, no one will play. Hmmm...
- btdiehr 9y agoExactly, that's why runescape and world of warcraft have adopted the marxist game mechanic of automatically redistributing all resources and exp between all players at the end of every day.
- noonespecial 9y agoWarcraft is nearly a pure meritocracy. I might not have very much when I start, but there is a clear path that I can take to level up. In short, Warcraft is fair. It is exactly that dynamic of actually being predictably rewarded for hard work that people are finding in these games. Redistribution schemes may seem just but they are very seldom anything approaching fair. Its no surprise that they almost never appear in any game mechanics.
- jumpkickhit 9y agoThere's worse forms of escapism that are far less stimulating. Alcohol or drugs, for example. It's nice we live in an age where there's engaging entertainment like video games instead of just more passive entertainment like TV.
- selestify 9y agoI don't know if drugs are less stimulating. Simulation of a different kind, to be sure, but probably not less in intensity. Certain drugs, such as psychedelics, can also provide opportunities for personal reflection and growth.
- dominotw 9y ago>Alcohol or drugs, for example. drugs like marijuana make everything more stimulating. Food tastes better, music sounds better, you can enjoy movies from almost any genre.You can get into great conversations with your partner where you are actually interested in what they are saying. Get over musicians block and let the music flow. so on.
- posterboy 9y agoUtter bollocks. That's the placebo effect that comes with being so doped up that one couldn't tell a good painting from a bad one, eg.
- dominotw 9y agomillions of people smoking marijuana for the placebo effect? ok. read this https://munchies.vice.com/en_us/article/science-says-weed-makes-food-taste-and-smell-better https://munchies.vice.com/en_us/article/science-says-weed-ma... You think it's being perceived to chemo patients for the placebo effect? https://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects/complementary-and-alternative-medicine/marijuana-and-cancer.html https://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects...
- posterboy 9y ago
- jboggan 9y agoVideo games become the sole source of agency in many people's lives. This isn't just for the unemployed, but also for folks stuck in a job where they feel like they lack control. I couldn't understand at first why my fellow Googlers found so much time to play video games, but after a couple of months I understood. Afternoon Halo matches became the highlight of my day, I felt like I had more choice and responsibility in a 20 minute match than I did the rest of my programming work.
- kemiller2002 9y agoA friend of mine felt the same way. He was undergoing a tragedy in his family, and he would play video games after returning from the hospital at night. It's funny, looking at him and talking to him, you'd never think he'd be a huge video game player, but it really was a source of stress relief. He could focus his unspent frustrations and hurt into competing online, and the way he explained it, I think it kept him sane during those times. It's funny, I can tell how in control of my life by gauging how much I play games. When I start obsessing about playing games (I like playing them, but when I feel I have to play them to escape), I know something needs to change in my life. I'm saying it's that way for everyone, but it really is a great tool for stress relief for some.
- J-dawg 9y agoI haven't been able to find it, but I remember a comment here on HN by a guy who basically said that gaming saved his life by helping him to zone out during a period of severe depression. I guess it's a form of mindfulness, in a way.
- sametmax 9y agoThat's the exact opposite actually. Nit saying it's a bad thing though. But it's important to understand that screens are taking your attention away. You are not in the moment at all.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bhewes 9y agoLeisure time comes from wealth. So a bunch of young men are wealthy enough to not work and play video games instead. All these articles miss the point someone is paying to keep these men playing games.
- pc86 9y agoWho is?
- hbosch 9y agoThat's a very broad generalization. Videos games, computers/consoles, and internet access are essentially commoditized to the point where an Xbox, some games, and a TV (+ maybe internet) can be found cheaper than an iPhone. You could easily drive part time for Uber and get your emotional fulfillment from video games without being supported by wealthy parents.
- bhewes 9y agoPerfect point Uber is paying them and they play video games. (I love games, and the US is a wealthy country across the board so it does not surprise me that men are enjoying more leisure time at a younger age.) I am pro more video games.
- jakozaur 9y agoOn positive side, until recently economic crisis caused crime rate to go up. However, after 2007-2008 crisis the overall crime rate has not increased. https://phys.org/news/2015-09-link-economy-crime-broken.html https://phys.org/news/2015-09-link-economy-crime-broken.html There are a lot of hypothesis to explain that, but I believe computer games played some role in that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nabla9 9y agoThere also seems to be inverse relation between consuming porn and rapes. However I think the strongest connection seems to be in the amount of lead in the blood and crime. The crime rates seem to fall everywhere in the world (with predictable delay) after that country restricts lead in gasoline. We know that lead is causes developmental problems in children (like problems with impulse control).
- kpil 9y agoThe causation is clear. If you have free time, you spend it. There might be an indirect causation which is homework vs games, but I suspect that students with less encouragement from their parents to do their homework spend the time on games. So forbid homework and make the schools take responsibility for actually learning their students something.
- dimitar 9y agoVideo games are cheap compared to other entertainment. I can buy a good enough PC for $400 and I can clock almost an infinite amount of game-time on it with friends all over the world. Most other activities - playing pool, eating out, bars, most sports, vacationing - cost a lot more per hour of possible entertainment. So if you don't have the money and you have the time you should choose activities that provide the most entertainment for the least $ Previously unemployed people would watch a lot of TV for affordable entertainment, an they probably still do it a lot. However video games can be more cognitively engaging and more social, so they might be actually an improvement.
- emodendroket 9y agoI think it's hard to beat books for economical. But certainly games are in reach.
- rubicon33 9y agoI really wish books could hold my attention like video games. I would read a lot more.
- magic_beans 9y agoYou might not be reading the right books? But also -- getting into a reading habit takes a small amount of patience if you are used to the intense stimulation of game.
- emodendroket 9y agoIf your goal is to start reading more often, stop reading so many books you think you ought to read and read more books you want to read. Variety and challenging yourself are good but sometimes you can get carried away and just make yourself not want to read anything.
- soreasan 9y agoThis is very true. I am usually not the best reader but I recently picked up an excellent fantasy novel and couldn't put it down and ended up reading like 4 or 5 hours straight. On the flip side when I read nonfiction or textbooks it's hard to push myself to keep learning.
- sksareen1 9y ago^Clearly written by a non-gamer.
- chasing 9y agoThis is a weird article. "Young people earn less, face higher unemployment rates than ever, and have been hit hard by financial recessions. Are video games to blame?"
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoI used to joke that unemployed players with nothing else to do ruin online play with hyper competitiveness when someone like me wants to play once a week or month. May not be far fetched after all. Aside being a former gamer (no time anymore) and having worked in the games industry for 6 years, that stock photo is a prime example of the ridiculous way game playing is portrayed on TV and film and by publications that don't know much about games. No one ever plays games with their controller held that way and their arms reaching out.
- aidenn0 9y agoAnyone new to video games does things like that photo (push the controller forward when punch/kick/shoot/go fast, turn the controller to the side you want your character to go, &c.)
- ensiferum 9y agoIt's time to start questioning the underlying idea if jobs. We're close to a society that could make work optional or at least people could spend much less time doing it.
- teekert 9y agoWhy is this piece all about jobs? Where's the family aspect? The hours playing games that could have been spent socializing, courting, going to a bar, having sex? Those things are even more important than working hard at a career. Sorry but this does sound very American to me. You have a very work focused culture, it's where esteem is earned it seems. I think that is also a bit troubling. In the end it is very simply though wherever you are from, you can either spend your time consuming or you can spend it creating.
- bootloop 9y agoDepends on who you ask. Some people tend to work harder on their careers than their social life. Might benefit them more even if it looks different to you. In my opinion there is not much difference (in regards to being social) between me going to the bar with my friends or joining a voice server to play games with my friends.
- prodmerc 9y agoMore like a link between easy entertainment and unemployment. Before games, TV and movies did the same thing.
- voidhorse 9y agoVideo games are sometimes hammered a bit too hard. They certainly have their negative impacts, but the media harps on the downsides so much they often obscure benefits. They're one of the few forms of entertainment that actually force you to think--it's very easy to consume movies, television, and even leisurely books without thinking hard or at all, 'passive consumption'. Video games, by their nature, force you to at least use your noggin a little. Sure it probably becomes passive consumption too once you've played a particular game enough and have habituated skills, but at least it's engaging your mind on some level at the start. They can also fuel a healthy (though of course, potentially unhealthy) sense of competition, which other entertainment, aside from physical sports, can't. I've become more aware of these little benefits as I've stopped playing games in lieu of other priorities. That being said, I don't think I'll go back to playing video games to any intense or serious degree any time soon--they really are quite addictive. I guess because they tap into those natural human drives for accomplishment, control, and competition, unlike other forms of entertainment. It's a fun hobby, and probably third best as far as general benefits go, behind creative hobbies and sports. That being said, it is way too easy to get sucked in, and to, as this article seems to suggest, let games become a substitute for more meaningful structures in your life.
- edem 9y agoI also play games because it keeps my mind active even when I have fun. That's the reason why I don't like watching series beacuse it is passive. I've also noticed that I have more fun nowadays writing games than playing them.
- MichaelMoser123 9y agothe article says that a lack of good jobs in the real word is contributing to this. Now gamers have their own online communities; I guess that the network of online friends could help to build a real world network to solve real world problems. This would be of great value to the players. I wonder if future games will have a built in social networking functionality...
- RugnirViking 9y agoMany modern games (especially MMOs) already do, not to mention platforms like steam or xbox live that facilitate both buying games and talking to friends