8 ms·
Dissecting Marissa Mayer’s Yahoo Compensation
- kostyk 9y agoAfter five years of leadership the bottom line is value of investment to shareholders has tripled. Mission accomplished. Who cared about Yahoo web business even then anyway.
- bbcbasic 9y agoNothing to do with reversion to the mean then?
- brador 9y agoReversion to the mean still takes work.
- jpatokal 9y agoThe article's point is that virtually all of this tripling was due to Alibaba and Yahoo Japan, not anything she did.
- kyleschiller 9y agoI don't know, it mentions that she had "little control" over the investments, but then goes on to explain that: managing those investments was a key reason that Yahoo’s board hired Ms. Mayer. Mr. Loeb had accused Yahoo’s previous leaders of mishandling both their core business and the Alibaba relationship.... Ms. Mayer delegated the Alibaba issue, hiring an experienced dealmaker, Jacqueline Reses, to be the company’s principal liaison to Alibaba and its leaders, Jack Ma and Joseph Tsai. Ms. Reses helped the Chinese company navigate its initial public offering. She also renegotiated an agreement, struck just before Ms. Mayer arrived, that would have forced Yahoo to sell an additional 122 million shares in the offering. Those extra shares are now worth $15 billion.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lz400 9y agoYeah but those stocks were going up regardless. I thought the only point in Yahoo existing for the past few years was trying to figure out some way to avoid tax on selling the alibaba/yahoo japan stake. Yahoo critically failed at that and when it did it got sold soon after. Not sure if this all looks good for Mayer as a good value creating leader.
- kyleschiller 9y agoThere are a lot of good points here, but it feels like most of her compensation is explained right here To lure Ms. Mayer from Google and compensate her for options she forfeited there, Yahoo’s board offered her a lucrative employment agreement. She initially received restricted stock worth $35 million and stock options worth $21 million, based on 2012 stock prices for Yahoo, along with a cash salary and bonus. It sounds like Mayer was initially making way more than the 900k/week figure quoted in the title, so it almost doesn't make sense to talk about her performance the rest of the time if we're interested in explaining here salary. There were a couple of significant missteps that the article explains resulted in meaningful pay cuts, but it sounds like the bulk of her compensation was determined from the beginning.
- ebbv 9y agoThat doesn't mean it's not worth discussing. I could get hired to be the CEO of Ford and get a contract for a ton of money. But I'd do a poor job probably. It would be worth discussing afterward; how did this happen? Why are executive salaries so incredibly disproportionate to their impact and benefit to the company? What can be done? What should be done?
- korrach 9y agoEat the tich comrade.
- edanm 9y agoIt isn't clear that the salaries are in fact disproportionate. The article makes the case that there were many mistakes, but that it's hard to say if anyone else could've done better. And the shareholders did end up making a lot of money. I'm not sure anything should be done here. The shareholders chose to pay a lot to get her as CEO. Even if they lost out, it's not a reason to intervene. People make bad bets all the time.
- pooper 9y agoSomething must be done to rein in executive pay though. I am not talking about MM in particular. She is probably a fine executive. However, my point is that unchecked executive pay is not good for anyone. We don't live in a free market. There ought to be some way to cap pay. A progressive income tax that caps out at 90% of income above $3M a year? So if you make $3,000,001, you pay 90 cents in taxes on the last dollar you earned sounds fair to me.
- perryh2 9y agoSomething that is often left out from these articles is the $230 million acquisition of Polyvore in 2015 [0]. I still don't know the reasoning behind this decision other than the existence of prior relationships with people that worked at Polyvore. From casually browsing the Yahoo Style vertical, I don't see any connection to Polyvore's site and vice-versa. [0] http://www.businessinsider.com/eric-jackson-slams-yahoo-for-polyvore-acquisition-2015-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/eric-jackson-slams-yahoo-for-...
- smoyer 9y ago"Arguably, Yahoo was unfixable. The company’s DNA and technology were built around its original identity as a web portal" I have a theory that there's always at least one big web portal - AOL started as a dial-up ISP and turned into a portal. Yahoo started as a search engine and turned into a portal. Facebook started as a social network and turned into a portal.
- mattmanser 9y agoAs far as I remember, Yahoo was a portal first and foremost, it didn't start with a search engine. The quick googling I just did seems to confirm that, it started as a human curated directory and didn't start crawling till 2002 (and almost bought Google at that point).
- mcherm 9y agoIt makes me feel old when people talk about doing historical research on events that I lived through. When yahoo first started out (and at that time I was using it) the role it played was equivalent to that which search engines play today. At that point in time there were no search engines, the only way to know about a website was to already have the address, or two read someplace that referenced or linked to it. Yahoo was initially "just a list of websites" but the role it played was very much the role that Google plays for so many people today: the site you start out on, and the place you go if you want to find something on the Internet. They eventually lost that role to search engines like Alta Vista, and later incarnations of Yahoo became a"Portal": a site you go to because it has decent implementations of many different features such as news, movie listings, stock quotes, and everything else that Yahoo offers.
- mgkimsal 9y ago"Yahoo was initially "just a list of websites" but the role it played was very much the role that Google plays for so many people today" More specifically - you went there and could "search" the directory. You put in a word or phrase and it searched the directory listings to find matches. It was just only searching its own very limited set of info, vs a crawled index of all the content of the sites. IIRC, they'd also started charging ($250 IIRC?) for adding a listing to their directory sometime in the late 90s or so.
- k__ 9y agoSounds like she and her friends she hired were some kind of locust who got lucky in the end.
- JewSlayer666 9y agoMuh Women in Tech Yet another crying over lack of meritocracy and propagation of women and minorytys. Everyone giving her a hand becouse of being "woman" insted of juding on merit read COC
- mks40 9y agoFrom reading this (and following this vaguely), I took the following assertions: i) MM had virtually nothing to do with tripling of stock value, that was due to ownership in Alibaba/Yahoo Japan ii) She did not turn Yahoo around as a business and made failed acquisitions. Yet, the article wants me to believe iii) Nobody could have done any better in this position. She achieved the best possible outcome If her net contribution to Yahoo as a business was 0, it seems pretty unreasonable to assert that NOBODY could have made any better acquisitions (e.g. buy Instagram, not tumble), or strategic initiatives (why focus on search?).
- danieltillett 9y agoI actually agree with the article that nobody could have done better, but they certainly could have done the same as MM for a whole lot less salary.
- curiousgal 9y agoYou didn't address OP's point: >If her net contribution to Yahoo as a business was 0, it seems pretty unreasonably to assert that NOBODY could have made any better acquisitions (e.g. buy Instagram, not tumbler), or strategic initiatives (why focus on search?).
- danieltillett 9y agoI don't think on average anyone else would have made better acquisitions. Sure in hindsight we can say other acquisitions would have been better, but I don't think anyone else hireable would have done better than MM other than through chance. Having said this I think Zuckerberg is massively undervalued as a CEO.
- pooper 9y agoI can't answer for anyone else but I can say with pretty good confidence that Yahoo! would not exist today if they put me in charge. I would fling poop left and right the moment I discovered the back door. I wouldn't have gave two poops about shareholder value. I am sure "they" would have found something sketchy about my past life that is worthy of at least ten life sentences and I would be sent away for good. I was already a little skeptical by the time Y! bought tumblr but I think the effort was there. I saw bringing in Katie Couric and David Pogue as a way to ease older people to watching "live TV" on Y!. I still don't think there was any fault with the vision. It might just be that the execution was a few years too early or bit too ambitious? I mean getting younger audiences to watch the news is not easy and getting majority of the "old" people to go from lean back to lean forward isn't easy either. It feels like a gamble and I still believe it succeeded in a parallel universe.
- pmlnr 9y ago900k/week? That is 46M$ for a year. That is 500 times more than a salary considered pretty decent in the UK tech world. No matter who you are, what you do, that is just plain too much money to receive as a paycheck.
- danieltillett 9y agoIt is not if you own the company. It is certainly too much if you are an employee.
- pmlnr 9y agoThat is what I meant, yes. If you own the company and/or properties, and get 900k per week out of it, you're family either have a lucky (or rather bloody) history or you're incredibly smart.
- na85 9y agoThat's not even the highest, either. Pichai makes more than double.
- pmlnr 9y agoOut of curiosity, what is the known highest salary for a tech-type employee? (dev, sysadmin sre, whatever) You know, those whom without tech companies tend to sink.
- jacquesm 9y ago~350K / year afaihdp. Consultants can and do make (much) more on a weekly or monthly basis but they rarely have their dance cards fully booked, so then you have to discount the weekly rate by how much down time there is.
- icebraining 9y agoWhat about Anthony Levandowski? He worked for Google for about 10 years, and got $120M. How many tech people are getting hefty "incentive payments" which we don't even know about, since they don't end up getting sued?
- kome 9y ago"Arguably, Yahoo was unfixable." I really don't think so. Their product would have succeeded with a more humble and focused approach. A generalist company like IAC/InterActiveCorp is doing fine: Yahoo too had all the assets to keep a position of relevance on the global internet. Yahoo management was bad. That's all.
- kumarvvr 9y agoCan you tell me what exactly is their product?
- fnord123 9y agoEyeballs.
- gcb0 9y agowhich are all moving to whatsapp and wechat. yahoo could have retained some of those eyeballs if they had more than two developers working on IM. To list a single example that a toddler could have came up with. saying that nobody could have done better than MM is a huge stretch of imagination.
- fnord123 9y agoI agree. I'm not one of he people who think that no one could have done better than MM. On the contrary, my cat could have done better. My cat would have also chased a laser pointer around the room instead of pissing a billion dollars away on tumblr. Then he would have insisted that yahoo offset the capex on internal clusters by entering the cloud infrastructure field. This would offer another revenue stream not tied to eyeballs. Newspapers had been consolidating since they didn't know how to make money from the web. So I expect chairman meow to have also bought some papers. Cats love sitting on paper. And getting yahoos ability to make money from the web and the natural draw of journalism it seems like a good fit.
- 9y ago
- turbinerneiter 9y agoThey could have payed roughly 500 people for 5 years with that money. Maybe one of them would have caught the bugs that led to their data breaches. They also could have bankrolled 10 or more start-ups with that cash. Hell, they could have spent it on blow for their workforce. At least that would have made for interesting stories.
- pmlnr 9y agoOr ~100 highly qualified principal engineers.
- jacquesm 9y agoPG and company managed to bankroll 100's of startups with that kind of cash. And probably much less, considering that that was the whole take of the sale of Viaweb and I'm sure they didn't invest all they made with that sale into YC.
- exodust 9y agoI know right, I can't understand how we still place so much importance on the character sitting in the CEO's chair and not the people actually working on the products. I suppose not all companies do that. It's sad about Yahoo, my first email address was Yahoo, signed up around 1998. I still have it and use it.
- hobarrera 9y agoThe scale is ridiculous. What she made in a month is probably more than what my parents will make during their lifetimes. She's made more money in a week that twice what I've made in all my life.
- ensiferum 9y agoI know this is going to sound bitter but I could have trained a monkey to do her job. And I would have asked for only 50% of her salary. I'm sure she thinks she did a great job and earned her position etc. By realistically I think her best assets are like any other professional CEO' s. Good at bullshitting and at golf and knowing the right ppl. What really frustrates me is how nothing ever sticks to these guys. Lose or fail it's never their fault and they always earn their money's and bonuses.
- babyrainbow 9y ago>I know this is going to sound bitter but I could have trained a monkey to do her job.. You could have. But you could never have made the monkey make it to the interview...
- mcherm 9y ago> you could never have made the monkey make it to the interview You phrased that correctly. The hard part wasn't to do a good job in the interview, the hard part was getting invited to the interview in the first place. And to be fair, Melissa Myers' resume justified her being considered for the position.
- kumarvvr 9y agoIs it really hard to believe that MM knew about the Alibaba stake, calculated that Yahoo was beyond saving, waited some time and cashed out? Is it possible that the Loeb told her this and they made a deal? He needs a star performer and she probably has met a dead end in Google. It's a win-win for them, not so much for Yahoo employees.
- JabavuAdams 9y agoHyperbole much? I understand your sentiment, but look at the stellar career that led her to this opportunity.
- timwaagh 9y agowhy does it need to be even a question whether she was overpaid. these ceos always are. in this case even more, because they paid for a big name. names dont produce results, but they cost a lot of money all the same.
- jackmott 9y agothe salary is absurd for any outcome. anyone getting paid that much is irresponsible, as is anyone paying then.
- TheGrassyKnoll 9y agoSure its absurd, but at least the Feds & state of California are going to get a rather large chunk of it.
- threepipeproblm 9y agoDid anyone else get a Dolores Umbridge vibe from that first photo? I'm not saying she's like that but I could not help thinking it. EDIT: "Marissa Mayer says working 130 hours per week is what created Google." Maybe not a coincidental impression.
- blunte 9y agoSummary: Mayer earned $240 million for pushing Yahoo further into decline, while a Yahoo investment that predated her skyrocketed, tripling Yahoo's stock price during her tenure (despite her destructive impact).
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoearned =/= was paid, IMO this is an important distinction.
- throw2016 9y agoI don't think focusing on Mayer is helpful. It is one of the more egregious cases but it shows just how badly c-level compensation, accountability and agency is broken. It also shows how some economic theories that sound good don't remotely work in the real world. And sometimes economic theories are designed to sound good. There are real world consequences of skyrocketing executive pay disconnected from performance and accountability. Bad or short term strategies can result in losses of thousands of qualified and experienced people, plummeting productivity and revenue, mid and long term setbacks and serious harm to future prospects. Golden parachutes usually mean no consequence to the implementing c-level teams. They usually end up easily soft landing at a consultancy or another gig. Carly Fiorina and Stephen Elop come to mind. Robert Nardelli and Home Depot also come to mind. You can't be hand waving around this for 2 decades counting.
- yourapostasy 9y agoIMHO the activist shareholders were the key decision makers in this story. The key I believe was the following. "The surging value of those investments [Alibaba and Yahoo Japan] — not any brilliant business moves by Ms. Mayer — is why Yahoo’s shares went up....managing those investments was a key reason that Yahoo’s board hired Ms. Mayer...Ms. Mayer delegated the Alibaba issue, hiring an experienced dealmaker, Jacqueline Reses, to be the company’s principal liaison to Alibaba and its leaders, Jack Ma and Joseph Tsai. Ms. Reses helped the Chinese company navigate its initial public offering. She also renegotiated an agreement, struck just before Ms. Mayer arrived, that would have forced Yahoo to sell an additional 122 million shares in the offering. Those extra shares are now worth $15 billion." Those two acts---knowing how to find Reses, and knowing how to delegate to Reses---combined with finding a buyer, were what made Mayer's compensation palatable to those activist shareholders. Those shareholders considered Mayer an enablement platform like a smartphone app store, and for the value "unlocked" enabling the shareholders to cash out, they were willing to pay the enablement fee. For a fee far lower than 30% of what they unlocked, they probably considered it well worth paying. That unlocking the value meant effectively dismantling Yahoo was incidental for the decision makers. I think the moral of the story for me personally is if I ever find myself within a company where activist shareholders successfully get on the BOD to "increase shareholder value" in any manner that smells of selling off all or the most profitable/highly-valued parts of the company, then I will send out my resume (always maintained and updated) and update my availability status. I'd like to hear contrary viewpoints, though.
- james1071 9y agoNormal rules don't seem to apply in Silicon Valley.
- hhh000 9y agosome people are just overrated and lucky, but she is certainly among the most luckiest overrated bloodsuckers
- gaius 9y ago"Yet most of Ms. Mayer’s paycheck ultimately came from the gains in Yahoo’s Alibaba and Yahoo Japan investments, over which she had little control. Thanks to an investment made in 2005, Yahoo had a 24 percent stake in Alibaba, which today is China’s leading e-commerce company." Quite literally money for nothing, and people wonder why CEO pay is such an issue.
- JabavuAdams 9y agoAh, but look at her pedigree and previous accomplishments! Like some kind of orbit-injection-burn. She had to be at just the right place, at just the right time, with the correct velocity. Some days I'm jealous of these execs. Other times I realize that I was playing computer games or reading esoteric subjects instead of excelling at jumping through every hoop placed in front of me.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- abalashov 9y agoI think one thing that's important to keep in mind is that some part of that compensation is for effectively jettisoning her career. Proportional/justifiable? I don't know. But now she's the woman that drove Yahoo! into the ground - that'll forever be her "thing", regardless of what role she played vs. unavoidable reality of sinking ship. That can have the effect of depressing compensation elsewhere, even if it certainly doesn't stop her getting another executive role (as we all know). If you're going to pay someone to be the captain of a cruise liner that has an 80% chance of sinking on its next voyage (even if it's not like the Titanic where everyone dies), that's going to take some money, too. He won't be piloting cruise ships for a while.
- tyingq 9y agoThere's probably a niche for riding big, but tainted companies into either an exit or some cultural, product, or whatever pivot. For example, I could see MM being pitched as a replacement for Kalanick if Uber's board had any teeth.
- gaius 9y agocompensation is for effectively jettisoning her career It doesn't work like that. Take Carly Fiorina for example. Measured either by jobs or by shareholder value destroyed, she has a fair shot at the title of "worst CEO in history, ever". And yet people still thought that that experience qualified her for a shot at the Presidency. Indeed she even claimed that her business experience was what made her the best candidate! MM will probably be Uber's next CEO without missing a beat.
- abalashov 9y agoYeah, I know, and I was mindful of that in trotting out the hypothesis. But I suspect there is a taxonomy within the upper strata of the CxO world where the optics of "running Yahoo into the ground" may disqualify her from the crème de la crème CEO jobs or pay packages, forcing her to settle for merely $ungodly_sum with not so hefty a multiplier. They're also rules that most likely apply only when making lateral moves within the field, subject to the highly idiosyncratic rules of the Fortune 100 exec recruitment game. The headers get stripped when you move into something like the Presidency, since there is an alchemy by which you can parlay a previous stint as a Fortune 100 executive into the vague catch-all digest of "business experience". I mean, look at our current President.
- revelation 9y agoWhat is going on here? She was given a salary that made her preposterously rich no matter what she does, an unlimited checkbook to buy and do whatever she feels right, control over a huge enterprise with plenty of talent and capabilities in place.. and the best of all, two magic money making boxes that take no effort whatsoever but basically guarantee there is zero short term pressure from shareholders. And here we are joining a mad apologist chorus of "oh, but nobody could have done differently". That is crazy. If you believe that, you might as well stay in bed for the next month because apparently whatever happens has been predetermined a long long time ago.
- gcb0 9y agoThank you!
- 2_listerine_pls 9y agoYahoo is dying, let's put Marissa at Yahoo to avoid being seen as a monopoly.
- valuearb 9y agoAny article that claims to be "dissecting" her compensation and then doesn't detail her prices for her option grants and how much she made from each specifically and how much she made from her restricted stock, isn't "dissecting" squat. In reality she got options for a bunch of shares. The stock tripled, making her hundreds of millions of dollars. If the stock had gone down or just not gone up, she would have made far far less (basically just salary plus value of the restricted stock grant). Whether she deserves credit for that, or whether option grants are even a good mechanism for rewarding CEOs, is an entirely different conversation (answers are she deserves some credit and no). But she was never paid $900K a week. As of today she can make $900K a week if she sold all her shares right now. But until she cashes out her shares that amount changes daily. Next week her estimated earnings could easily be down to $700K a week, a year from now they could be nearly wiped out. "Dissecting" option grant valuations in detail would also have been interesting. For example her original option grant was valued at $21M. That means that based over the length of the grant, with a reasonable expected stock price increase (say 8% per year), compensation consultants estimated that she'd profit $21M. So how many shares, at what price, add up to that valuation? Why was that reasonable? I understand she walked away from a huge amount of compensation she was owed at Google to take the Yahoo job, and the board had to compensate her for that. But how much of that was reasonable? "Dissection" of it by a journalist should include details of that compensation, how the amount was determined, and quotes from those who had opposing viewpoints at the time.