7 ms·
A 16th-century engineer whose work almost defeated the Ottomans
- metastart 9y agoGreat read! "...an early genius of military engineering, Gabriele Tadini." But more than 1500 years before him there were others such as Archimedes and Caesar. I wonder if Tadini was a polymath similar to other great military engineers like Archimedes and Leonoardo who would have been living at the same time as him.
- Kenji 9y agoI'd wager that everyone back then who made a name for himself with intellectual pursuits was a polymath. Simply because knowledge was hard to come by and you couldn't specialise so much that you remained ignorant about the grand scheme of things of everything else, like it is possible today.
- azernik 9y agoOr alternatively, the breadth of human knowledge was small enough that one person could hold most of it in their head.
- mordant 9y agoOne of my favorite party questions is, "Who was the last man who knew everything?"
- UweSchmidt 9y agoWho do you have in mind? Maybe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_von_Humboldt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_von_Humboldt
- hutzlibu 9y agoI doubt, that there ever was such a man. For example knowing about plants and animals. We as whole humanity are still far from knowing them all on the earth, so how could somebody from history knew them all? And even if you only count "everything" as the whole current knowledge of humanity, then also no, as there are for example tribes in the jungle who know about plants or hunting technics the genius in europe never heard of.
- a3n 9y ago> I doubt, that there ever was such a man. I've heard this question before. I think it's more useful to think of it as "When was the last era when it was possible for one person to know everything that's known?" Doubtful that there ever was such a particular person, at least because of geography, as you point out, and different concerns in different parts of the world. But there must have been such an era; I don't know when that was.
- theoh 9y agoApparently he knew Tartaglia, who was a figure of the type you have in mind...
- jballanc 9y agoSuleyman was not only a great military mind, but an extremely astute politician as well. One thing the article fails to mention is that Suleyman didn't just let the people of Rhodes "go free" after their defeat, the Knights Hospitaler had to hand over their fortresses in Kos and Bodrum as part of the deal. This was a smart move as the castle in Bodrum was much better fortified, and Suleyman got it without, in essence, firing a shot. For this reason, the castle in Bodrum is extremely well preserved and a must see if you want to get a sense of crusader architecture.
- aedron 9y agoI liked this part of the article: "Suleiman was respectful and generous in victory. The citizens of Rhodes were to be exempt from both taxation and conscription for the next five years. Tadini was allowed to leave. He went to the colonies of Genoa, where he again fought invading Ottoman forces and again lost. The Order of St. John was allowed to leave in peace and build a new fortress elsewhere. They did so on Malta, where their walls could be built on stone and therefore could not be undermined. Toward the end of his life, Suleiman sent a force to conquer Malta. This time the siege failed, in part because he was not there to keep order or impose his implacable will." This kind of graciousness in warfare does not seem to exist in modern times. Weird, considering how brutal war in those times looks compared with today.
- Avalaxy 9y ago> This kind of graciousness in warfare does not seem to exist in modern times. Weird, considering how brutal war in those times looks compared with today. Well, there was a ton of brutality then as well. Probably even much worse than today.
- Noseshine 9y agoI think so too. In our recent conflicts when you were caught you might get shot, the ancients used torture-killing so cruel I can't even read about it without feeling sick. Not even the Nazis used something like the Brazen Bull (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brazen_bull https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brazen_bull), and that's just a simple device and procedure, they were much more inventive than that in the past. 1000 years ago those involved in the assassination attempt on "Der Führer" would have faced far more horrible deaths than they actually got. It seems to me even the most evil Nazis didn't have 1% of the imagination of the ancients (possibly excluding Dr. Josef Mengele, but he didn't think a about how to create pain, he just didn't care if his subjects did).
- SnakePlissken 9y agoThere's a fantastic book by Roger Crowley called Empires of the Sea that covers the Habsburg-Ottoman war for control of the Mediterranean. The early chapters go into great detail on the Siege of Rhodes, including Tadini's efforts, and how the lessons learned there would set the stage for later battles (particularly Malta and Lepanto) and the end of Ottoman supremacy. For anyone interested in this article or the era in general I can't recommend it enough.
- jballanc 9y agoDefinitely adding that to my reading list. My understanding is that the Ottoman strategy for controlling the Mediterranean was to go the "long way 'round" and control as much of the surrounding ports, as opposed to the Knights Hospitaler, the Genoese, and the Venetians who took the approach of building unmatched naval strength. As an example, during the siege of Constantinople, the Genoese and Venetian navies were ultimately defeated when the Ottomans literally carried their ships over land to get behind the other's defensive line.
- nl 9y agoI came here to recommend this. Crowley's book on the siege of Constantinople is great too.
- bricksmart 9y agoInteresting subject, but why does it feel like I'm reading a passage from a standardized test?
- bricksmart 9y agoFollowup: why the downvote? This article has a bizarre and amateurish ending: "Despite Tadini's losses, his methods have continued to influence combat into the present. Mining and countermining, with all their attendant surveillance and engineering, are still staples of warfare." This is actually worse than a passage from a test -- it sounds like a student essay written in response. It's little better than: In conclusion, Tadini's mining is still influential today. which is vague, abrupt and unsubstantiated -- the article makes no mention of mining in the current day. Am I the only one who finds this odd?
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI notice you're new to HN. Welcome! https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html To understand what makes HN different from other sites, you may want to familiarize yourself with the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html In particular, we try to write comments that are interesting to read. That rules out swipes and one-line dismissals: calling something amateurish, or complaining about downvotes. HN has a lot to offer as a community, and we started out as a tight-knit group of refugees from sites like Reddit. This place has grown up a lot since then, but those fundamentals were the reason for HN's success. Your second comment was better than your first -- a substantive dismissal is always preferable. And you can write comments like that if you really want to. I usually find it's more productive to focus on what's cool about a piece. There's usually something. However if an article is mistaken, that's worth calling out. Some of the best HN comments are refutations. Though you'll want to be certain you're correct, or else you'll get called out yourself. :)
- bricksmart 9y agoThank you for the reply. Having lurked on HN for a while, I'm used to some negativity, or at least very critical, comments. So when most of the comments for this piece appeared positive something seemed off. Anyway, I appreciate the environment on HN and the steps users like you take to preserve it.
- berlincount 9y agoFor people who love alternative history stories, the "Ring of Fire" series (starting with "1632", which you can get for free at http://www.baen.com/1632.html http://www.baen.com/1632.html) is highly recommended. The Suleyman portrait there (in http://ericflint.wikia.com/wiki/Ottoman_Empire http://ericflint.wikia.com/wiki/Ottoman_Empire) is also rather astute.
- jeff_petersen 9y agoGreat series of books, I'll second this recommendation
- antocv 9y agoOh, the last sentence reveals the purpose of the article" "See, kids, the reason mass surveillance ala Snowden has to exist is because the other side mines and we undermine, its always been like this."
- na85 9y agoI up voted this post because I think the greater conversation regarding astroturfing and media conditioning us to accept certain policies needs to be had, but I think you could have found a better way to say it.
- feral 9y agoA personal anecdote from a non-historian: Some years back I took a holiday in Malta. Taking the ferry to Valletta, climbing the ramp up from the dock, I was shocked to see the scale of the fortifications. I knew it was a strategically important place, but what surprised me was how obviously the entire walled peninsula of Valletta seemed to have been constructed first and foremost as a fortress. It's easy to forget the scale and scope of historical conflict and the effort that went into it, and this was a stark reminder. The other thing that surprised me was that they had the old suits of armor of the commanders of the order, and I was surprised how big they were. I'm pretty tall (6"6) and was surprised to see the suits were close to my height. Presumably bigger than the men that wore them, but what occurred to me was "these are the guys who made it to the the top of their organization, the commanders, and they must have been very big for their time. This is probably an organization that values brute strength." I don't know if that's a valid inference or not, but Malta definitely left the impression it was created by folk who mean business. This linked article is really interesting context, makes me realize why Malta was built so well.
- YZF 9y agoIsn't there still a correlation between status and size these days? Tall with good hair and you're already leadership material... It's amazing how much of that story could have been written yesterday. Tunneling is still used in the middle-east as a war tactic. North Korea tunnels to South Korea. The value of engineering ;) Embargoes are essentially siege tactics.
- Camillo 9y agoThere's even a correlation between height and intelligence (presumably due to nutrition).
- _pmf_ 9y ago> Isn't there still a correlation between status and size these days? Yes. The wage gap between short men and huge men makes any perceived gender based wage gap between male and female look very, very puny.
- literallycancer 9y agoIt seems that mining is still used today: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwTj0tWMh2A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwTj0tWMh2A
- choonway 9y ago> Villiers (the leader of the defenders) had ignored the many warriors who told him the same (that the city was no longer defensible), but listened to the engineer (Tadini). This made my day. :)
- Abishek_Muthian 9y agoBut I'm sure, by the scale of successful conquests on the ottoman side; there are several successful engineering innovations at their end as well. What makes Tadini's work note-worthy is the usual 'David vs Goliath' emphasis and also Ottoman Empire did not survive; history is written (mostly re-written) by the victors !
- kodfodrasz 9y agoUsually a claim is most effective if it has some substance, for example some proof. Could you please provide some references to those innovations instead of shaming another culture, who is remembering one of its lost ones? Also the knight orders have not survived. Should I blame the victors (whoever they are, as in this story the Ottomans won, for example), for writing history?
- raintrees 9y agoI will have to remember to mention this article to the next person I play Stratego with.
- lucio 9y agoInteresting note. It's a funny thing that in the current climate nobody mentions the underpinning of the conflict depicted in the article, hundred of years of struggle between Christianity and Islam. Wikipedia: >According to Ottoman understanding, the state's primary responsibility was to defend and extend the land of the Muslims and to ensure security and harmony within its borders within the overarching context of orthodox Islamic practice and dynastic sovereignty
- eternalban 9y agoThat's the state propaganda. Turkic people in that area are later arrivals, and the Ottoman Turks basically pinned their legitimacy on the religion of the region. Suleiman was "generous" because the state propaganda of the time was "Ottoman Justice". Consider a hypothetical history with Persian empire not falling to Muslims and Byzantine also enduring. Best buddies forever or likely the same pattern of pull-push on borders and a cultural clusters boundary condition? Geography is the key here, not people's misunderstanding regarding the meaning of it all.
- mda 9y agoAs if almost anything written about events in history is not propaganda. There is barely any complete truth. English Wikipedia in general just spews same thing western historians words, others do the same to fit their agenda. History is a joke.
- oblio 9y agoHistory is not a joke. Just use the scientific approach of comparing and contrasting various sources.
- eternalban 9y agoWell, not really what I was saying. More like 'geography is history' ala 'character is destiny'.
- teddyh 9y agoThis event was covered in part II of Extra History’s series on Suleiman the Magnificent: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGZSkLq3Eng&list=PLhyKYa0YJ_5Be8gG49Sh7rsW_fFNcbGOE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGZSkLq3Eng&list=PLhyKYa0YJ_...
- bane 9y agoMost people casually interested in the crusader period know about the Knights Templar. But it turns out the Knights of St. John are just as fascinating, still exist, and have sovereign status similar to a nation-state. They built the impressive fortifications at Rhodes, which have technically never been defeated (they surrendered after a six month siege and only with the word of Suleiman the Magnificent that the survivors would be granted safe passage off the island). Then moved to Malta where they built an even more impressive set of fortifications and civic structures. The Knights were composed mostly of nobles from Europe and thus brought tremendous wealth with them. Initially they set up hospitals in the 12th century to care for pilgrims traveling from Europe to the Holy Land. That role grew into a militarily defensive role and then grew some full-on military features by the 14th century. Being composed of rich Nobles, the order at one point may have had access to more wealth than the entire rest of the Roman Catholic Church during this time period. During the early Malta period of the 16th century, the Knights built one of the most incredible and beautiful buildings I've ever seen. The outside isn't much to look at, but the inside is one of the most decorated buildings I've ever been in -- pictures don't really do it justice. The local "real" Cathedral built by the Catholic Church looks positively spartan in comparison even though it also is a beautiful building. http://www.maltacultureguide.com/admin/images/stjohn_04_big.jpg http://www.maltacultureguide.com/admin/images/stjohn_04_big.... http://www.divine-name.info/worldwide/malta/mdina/Mdina2.JPG http://www.divine-name.info/worldwide/malta/mdina/Mdina2.JPG The order survived into the modern age, and over the ages did a number of works, continued to administer Malta, and happened to colonize parts of the Caribbean. Weakened during both the Protestant Reformation and the Napoleonic wars, but returned to the roots as a human welfare and religious group. They eventually changed their name to "the Sovereign Military Order of Malta" (SMOM) which they keep to this day as the oldest surviving order of chivalry. Amazingly it actually is a "sovereign" order, meaning they're viewed in many circles to have power equal to that of a minor nation-state even though they have no territory at all -- the only example in the world today. For example, SMOM is a permanent observer in the U.N. [1] and maintains diplomatic relations with 106 countries. It can enter into treaties, issue passports, coins and postage. Their headquarter buildings in Rome are treated as Embassies and enjoy diplomatic extraterritoriality. 1 - https://www.un.int/orderofmalta/ https://www.un.int/orderofmalta/ 2 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Military_Order_of_Malta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Military_Order_of_Ma...
- michaelcampbell 9y ago> or crenelations for releasing boiling oil In various trips to the UK and dozens of castle walking tours, almost to a guide they said (paraphrasing) "no one used boiling oil. It was way too precious a commodity." Water, sure.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]