20 ms·
Get your loved ones off Facebook
- bitmapbrother 10y ago>Facebook gives your data to “third-parties” through your use of apps, and then say that’s you doing it, not them. Every time you use an app connected to Facebook, you’re allowing Facebook to escape its own privacy policy with you and with your friends. Has anyone checked what data is given to these third party apps that connect to Facebook? Tangentially, I'm reminded of an Austrian that asked for all of the data Facebook had on him. Facebook then sent him a 1,200 page PDF containing the messages of every person he talked to, all of his IP addresses as well as messages that he had deleted.
- nvr219 10y agoI take a facebook "sabbatical" every couple of years where I delete my account completely and permanently, and then come back with a brand new account a few months later. It irritates my friends but I love it.
- hoopism 10y agoWhy? I've turned my account off before in attempt to walk away... Curious why you would set out to do that as an policy. Why not just turn notifications off and share little to avoid cacheing of data?
- quest88 10y agoWhy did you go back?
- hoopism 10y agoI go back because I derive enjoyment from sharing with my family who I don't see as often as I'd like. I have kids and they do amazing things (amazing meaning boring average things every kid does) and I want to show someone. FB is best way I know how to do that.
- nvr219 10y agoFor me it's a self control thing. If I just deactivate, I know I can go back at any time, and then I do. For permanent deletion, you have to remain logged off for two weeks, and then you're done. The time constraint helps me. Why do I do it at all? Being off Facebook is good for my mental health-- this is the main reason. Privacy reasons are secondary but also important. I've posted some really stupid stuff in 2004 that I'm glad is (theoretically!) stricken from the record.
- cylinder 10y agoAren't they preserving your deleted data? They could link your new accounts with your old data internally
- nvr219 10y agoAccroding to FB help: "When you delete your account, people won't be able to see it on Facebook. It may take up to 90 days from the beginning of the deletion process to delete all of the things you've posted, like your photos, status updates or other data stored in backup systems. While we are deleting this information, it is inaccessible to other people using Facebook." https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674 https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674
- cylinder 10y agoThat doesn't answer the question as to whether they are still using the data internally.
- ghostly_s 10y ago'Deleting' seems pretty clearly to convey that they do not retain that info, for any purpose. (IANAL?)
- nvr219 10y agoIt mentions deleting data stored in backup systems so I'm interpreting that as the data goes away.
- posixplz 10y agoI would imagine that they are either deleting it entirely internally or selectively deleting the data entirely in localities where the law requires them to do so. So far, only the EU has strict regulations requiring businesses to comply with valid requests to delete personal information. (EU GDPR) From a Facebook-makes-money-from-retaining-user-data perspective, I would imagine they are making every effort to ensure they're permanently deleting user data only where legally compelled to do so.
- er1c_ 10y agoI've done this a few times too. Facebook still knows who I am even though I sign up with different email addresses. I do have an account right now but I only really use it to authenticate on third party sites. It's interesting to me that my friends ask did you see my X post on FB instead of telling me about things in their life.
- ghostly_s 10y ago> Facebook still knows who I am even though I sign up with different email addresses. Do you have some evidence for this or just presuming?
- swsieber 10y agoGolden quote: Don’t confuse privacy with secrecy. I know what you do in the bathroom, but you still close the door. That’s because you want privacy, not secrecy. (From I have nothing to hide. Why should I care about my privacy? : https://medium.com/@FabioAEsteves/i-have-nothing-to-hide-why-should-i-care-about-my-privacy-f488281b8f1d https://medium.com/@FabioAEsteves/i-have-nothing-to-hide-why...)
- unabst 10y agoThis. The military has secrets, but should have no privacy. Same with the government. Privacy is the opposite of transparency. We can have secrets while we know exactly what we are keeping secret, such as Private Keys and passwords. Secrets do not hinder transparency.
- hammock 10y agoSo the military uses the bathroom with the door open, but... we don't know what they're doing in there?
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoOnly if you're standing above them and looking down.
- unabst 10y agoMaybe this was meant to be a joke, but an officer's superiors would be the one's looking over the stalls. No secrets no privacy. Privacy is a courtesy. And a right to courtesy. Secrecy should be all that is related to security. It's interesting because the military seems to know exactly what a secret is. It'd make more sense to have secrecy laws alongside privacy laws for citizens. Privacy laws are not secrecy laws. Hence the NSA get's to do what they did, and hence they trampled on everyone's privacy outright violating all courtesy. They then make it a security issue. As it stands, citizens are entitled to no secrets. Hence it's the wild west and we're left encrypting ourselves and standing in direct conflict with the government that would do far better helping us than being rude and insecure. Insecure is what they are. They have no trust or confidence in the people.
- sergiotapia 10y agoDelete timeline for me: - Delete account - 1st week, open facebook tab close facebook tab. - 2nd week, visit facebook once a day by accident don't login - 3rd week, visit facebook once a week, don't login - 4th week, stop visiting altogether It's been about 6 months now without an account and my wife and I are really happy about no longer have it. Try it!
- jtraffic 10y agoIt's been since 2009 since I deleted my Facebook account, and my timeline was roughly like yours for weeks 1-4. Then: - 2nd year, wonder if I should get back on to 'stay in touch.' - 3rd-5th year, never think about it - 6th year, wonder if I should get on Facebook so my family can see pictures of my kids. But, my wife does Instagram. - 8th year, smug comment on HN to show how long I've been off Facebook :).
- the-dude 10y agoI never had Facebook. Ha!
- instafacebook 10y agoYou do know Instagram is owned by Facebook right?
- dEnigma 10y agoFirst of all, I love that this prompted you to create an account. The author of the parent comment might not care as much if it is on Instagram, because one doesn't give away just as much information there, compared to facebook; and there's no equivalent to the "Like" button that tracks you across third-party websites.
- the-dude 10y agoActually the comment was first posted by a non-green account, then removed and the same comment was posted by this green account.
- stevecalifornia 10y ago"Addiction: (noun) Addiction is a brain disorder characterized by compulsive engagement in rewarding stimuli, despite adverse consequences." I would get my family off of Facebook because they cannot stop using it even though it makes them feel bad after being on it. That's reason enough for me.
- Theodores 10y agoI feel like I have been lucky to have not been peer pressured into Facebook because of the brain chemistry aspect. I also avoided class A drugs which have had a similar availablity level - there if you insist, seemingly in general circulation. Obviously a heroin addiction would not be what you want in life, I am thinking that constant checking in to Facebook is in a similar league of must avoid.
- lyra_comms 10y agoI used to work for a social network. We had meetings every day about how to "engage the users' dopamine systems." As a psychologist, this was an anathema to me - we call that process addiction. Check out Lyra instead (www.hellolyra.com), it's a conversation service that requests language and attention. We are also a nonprofit and solicit no investment.
- bioreactor 10y agoWill try for sure
- aesthetics1 10y agoI'm off of it and I could not be happier about the decision. Concerns about privacy aside, I realized how much time I was wasting scrolling through ads and news stories instead of photos and thoughts from friends and relatives. I didn't mind the Facebook of old where the content was mostly interesting to me, but today it is mostly full of ads, memes, fake news, and clickbait.
- Kequc 10y agoFacebook started to get worse after the first 3 or 4 major privacy calamities. When nobody left Facebook must have figured, well, great to heck with it then. Because beyond that point they just started straight up selling data. People stayed on. I needed an account again after nearly 8 years, just for one (very) important group I needed to take part in temporarily. Not only did Facebook somehow know who I used to know (and had absolutely no interest in speaking to) but every time someone visited my page it would tell me. That wasn't a feature that was there a long time ago. Doesn't it bother anybody there, when they visit someone's page the fact you did that shows up for them? Isn't that exceedingly creepy? I think it is. Terribly creepy. It also one day knew I met someone the day before on the street, as their face showed up as a recommendation. That is way too much info.
- aantix 10y agoQueue the onslaught of "I haven't used Facebook in.... years!" comments. You're probably already hitting the down-vote button. I wonder why there's so much anti-fb commentary on HN? Maybe it has to do with the software engineers tending to be less social and introverted, therefore a social service appears to have less worth? Just speculating. As for me, Facebook creates an emotional connection unlike any other service out there. I get to see my friends kids grow up, comfort lost friends when they lose a parent, share with my family when something great has happened. It's absolutely amazing and there's nothing out there that comes close to its reach. If Facebook were suddenly gone tomorrow, I would feel devastated (so many memories of my kids, deceased father, mom, all would be gone). The only other sites that would provoke a similar emotional response from me would probably be Google and maybe Github.
- bargl 10y agoDo you mind if I word for word quote your above to see if I get downvoted too? I want to repost with just the last two paragraphs to see what happens. I'm curious how this post would have been received without the intro.
- aantix 10y agoCopy/Paste away! :)
- bargl 10y agoHa thanks, I just want to see if people are just AntiFacebook or not because reading your post the third and fourth paragraph really resonated.
- aantix 10y agoHeh, must be a divisive comment. The points are just oscillating between a positive [2] and negative [2] range..
- bargl 10y ago
- ciocan42 10y agoBack in 2013, I decided to delete my account because was spending more than 8 hours per day on it (mostly on groups and managing pages for fun). Back then there was no option to remove it - the only option was to convert it to a page with the mention that all your friends will become page likes. Then you will lose all your content posted (statuses, pictures, messages, etc). It was written red on white as a warning prevention. They said it was not possible to revert back. Id did that, and the next day I felt so good afterwards. No guilt or fear of missing stuff. There were other means to stay in contact with people. Forward two years later I wanted facebook back because I moved to another country. I searched if there is an option to recover an old profile, and it was (even before they explicitly said there is none, and all your data is lost). I got back all that I've posted, only friends I needed to add back manually. Now I use news feed eradicator and I don't see anything. Also, I don't have that urge to scroll feeds anymore. Basically, I wanted only messenger, but back then there was no such option.
- NickSharp 10y agoThis browser extension changed my life for the better: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/kill-fb-feed/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/kill-fb-feed/ I like Facebook, it serves a lot of good roles in my life (including my job) so I can't just quit and/or block Facebook. But I was spending pointless hours a day reading my news feed, disgusted with my own lack of productivity. This extension kills the home page feed, but nothing else. I still have access to messages, profiles, events, invites, etc. I can still find everything I search for if I seek it out, only difference is it's not drip-fed into my eyeballs with an endless scroll. My productivity (and happiness) immediately took a step up.
- thatwebdude 10y agoFor what it's worth, you can now deactivate your Facebook, but maintain Messenger. It's what I've done in the interim while I figure out how much of Facebook I actually want.
- pmoriarty 10y agoUnfortunately, none of my friends and family members who are on Facebook really care, and the reasons cited in this article aren't going to sway them. They don't take privacy seriously, and view people who worry about privacy as paranoid kooks. They also see Facebook as the way to stay in touch with their own friends and family, and that's probably the biggest draw to staying on. Until that changes, I don't see them leaving.
- Freak_NL 10y ago> and view people who worry about privacy as paranoid kooks. Or Luddites, or perverts, or criminals, etcetera…
- newscracker 10y agoI too find it very difficult to dissuade people away from FB or to convince people about the value of privacy and why it's important for us as a society to function better and retain more freedom. Almost everyone I know values what FB offers them, and don't care much about how we all are paying for it.
- exhilaration 10y agoI have a question regarding this: "tracking everything you read on the internet" I recently disabled third party cookies in Chrome and it's had no negative effect. Can someone tell me if this will block the Facebook code that's embedded in nearly every web page from reading my Facebook cookie and identifying me?
- stdclass 10y agoNo it only blocks cookies, but not the javascript code from facebook that gets loaded on the pages you visit. If you want to get rid of that, install a browser plugin like Ghostery (0). 0: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/ghostery/mlomiejdfkolichcflejclcbmpeaniij?hl=de https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/ghostery/mlomiejdf...
- jf 10y agoI also use a hosts file block to avoid tracking: https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts
- Xoros 10y agoOr privacy badger, from the EFF (0) 0:https://www.eff.org/privacybadger https://www.eff.org/privacybadger
- gavinpc 10y agoBut wait... can they still identify you that way? I'm not on facebook, so maybe it's moot in my case. But are you saying that blocking third-party cookies is not enough to keep facebook from tracking your other browsing activity?
- jonnymac 10y agoEvery time you go to a website with the Facebook like button, they see your IP address and the website you're on. Go to enough websites from that IP address and they can get a good idea of what you like. In addition, it is very easy to get your real address from your IP address, or at least your general area. Combining these gives them a good idea of who you are.
- wrycoder 10y agoWhat's Facebook?
- BadassFractal 10y agoI want to be listed on their site so people can find me (and don't think I'm a serial killer because I don't have an account), be able to SSO log in through Facebook when unavoidable, and be able to add people to my friends list if want to have them in my address book and reach out to them through Messenger. Outside of that I actually never want to log into facebook or use any of its other functionality. How do I accomplish that?
- xj9 10y agoJust Do It
- juhohei 10y agoJust don't login there. I use the Messenger and Events apps on my phone and log in to Facebook on desktop once a month to accept/decline friend requests. For me the reasons to stay in Facebook are 1) I can contact pretty much anyone via the Messenger - only a handful of the people I usually talk to use (for example) Signal. 2) I get event invitations. For that the Events app is perfect.
- shurcooL 10y agoFor me, these are the biggest concerns that motivate me to consider deleting my account (which I don't use actively, only occasionally): - Facebooks creates false endorsements for products from you to your friends without revealing this to you. - Facebook filters out your posts based on whether or not people will use Facebook more if they don’t see it. I don't mind/can put up with the rest, but those two things really bug me. But my concern is that there are some people I would lose the ability to contact if I delete my fb. Maybe I should ask those people for their email, etc., then proceed.
- aaomidi 10y agoCan't you export your contacts? Most of them come with the email too.
- radarsat1 10y ago> Facebooks creates false endorsements for products from you to your friends without revealing this to you. Not sure anything guarantees they'll stop doing this after you delete your account.. They knew your name before you created it, and they'll know it after you close it.
- shurcooL 10y agoThat's a good point, which further motivates the desire not to have an account or do anything to support the product. While there are no guarantees, it still helps a little, since your endorsements are less likely to appear as genuine to those who know you're not on Facebook.
- balls187 10y agoYou can't delete your account. You can disable it, and the moment you log back it, it's as if you have never left.
- zentiggr 10y agoYou can delete your account... I had one that I requested deleted back in 2009, and then had "reason" to get back on, and when I created my new account my prior data from 2009- was not there.
- bargl 10y agoAs for me, Facebook creates an emotional connection unlike any other service out there. I get to see my friends kids grow up, comfort lost friends when they lose a parent, share with my family when something great has happened. It's absolutely amazing and there's nothing out there that comes close to its reach. If Facebook were suddenly gone tomorrow, I would feel devastated (so many memories of my kids, deceased father, mom, all would be gone). The only other sites that would provoke a similar emotional response from me would probably be Google and maybe Github.
- Arizhel 10y ago>If Facebook were suddenly gone tomorrow, I would feel devastated (so many memories of my kids, deceased father, mom, all would be gone). WTF? How would they be "gone"? Facebook does not control your memories. So what else would you be losing if Facebook suddenly disappeared? Photos or videos? You don't say exactly, but I suspect this is the case. If so, then that's your own stupid fault for not keeping personal copies of that stuff. If you don't value that data enough to keep your own personal copies of it, then you don't deserve to have it IMO. Portable hard drives are not expensive these days, and store literally terabytes of data (I just bought a 4TB USB drive a couple months ago for just over $100). USB thumb drives are less than $10 for smaller sizes which will still probably hold everything that's on your phone now. There is absolutely no excuse for not having copies of data that's most precious to you.
- nayuki 10y agoPhotos and videos might be easy to keep a local copy of, because you would be uploading from your phone or computer onto Facebook. But memories cover many other aspects as well. Such as the descriptions that you write on your Facebook photos. The conversation threads that ensue. The face tags that you add and other people add to your photos. The set of photos that you selected for upload (rather than the outtakes). The way you name, organize, and describe albums. Storage may be cheap these days, but ensuring that you have copies of your data in multiple places - such as hand-typed text - can be very time-consuming.
- lucasmullens 10y ago
- sevensor 10y agoI never got into Facebook. I made an account about ten years back, and I used to check it every year. But lately I can't be bothered. I agree with the article that it doesn't seem to make people happy. Mostly it seems to make them sad and angry.
- Xoros 10y agoI mainly use FB as an RSS reader for the bands I like (because they obviously not having feeds). It saves me time for not having to go on each websites to check the news section. And not in my main web browser. For obvious privacy reasons. Despite that, no need.
- nvr219 10y agoThis is as good a time as any to remind everyone to install EFF's Privacy Badger https://www.eff.org/privacybadger https://www.eff.org/privacybadger
- dump121 10y agoAre people really concerned of privacy, or just witch hunt against some companies? Bigger privacy threats I see are always tracking, always listening device we keep in pocket, which sends it all to cloud. Still I see know serious effort to mitigate that, efforts by like of Firefox/Ubuntu are dissed as distractions. Developers on HN regularly proclaim wonders of Chromebook/Google Docs without any corresponding rhetoric about privacy.
- gavinpc 10y agoRegarding this question about a "witch hunt". What would a legitimate objection to an institutional practice look like? Would it not be a witch hunt against Google if people here complained about Google Docs? Would it not be a witch hunt against facebook if people here also complained about Google Docs? I'm putting "witch hunt" on my list of stop words. I don't see the phrase being used in utterances that move a discussion forwards.
- newtem0 10y agoYou could replace this whole article by saying "facebook is a private company and they have all your data, from posting and messaging as well as their cookies". Its just a bad idea at its very core. All these examples are trivial, who cares if they fake endorsements and track your location? Its like building a house out of sand and then people point out that a chunk fell off here or there. Its a house of sand, it was a retarded idea to live in there from the outset, of course chunks are falling off -- the whole thing will be in peices soon. Because facebook is an anxiety enducing and artificial experience, users will start leaving. Users who seem to need facebook in order to stay up to date with their friends, and who seem to have an interest in watching other peoples kids grow up (?) such as the one poster above me (and whos post will inevitably remain above mine) will stay -- but they will be the minority. Kids will stop signing up and at some point there will be a leak and the death of facebooks public image will finally be complete after starting years ago.
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago> Users who seem to need facebook in order to stay up to date with their friends It doesn't sound like you actually understand the service Facebook provides, which makes your claim that it's all about to come crashing down very suspect.
- crispyambulance 10y agoNope. The article makes pointed and convincing arguments and it doesn't rely on unsupported assertions like your comment.
- hammock 10y ago@dang Why remove the (2017 Update) from submitted title, yet not add (2015)?
- mgorenstein 10y agoFor those interested in archiving their FB content, note that FB's download tool supplies only a subset of the content available in the activity log (namely only the content linked to your timeline). I've been working on a sustainable way to export all activity log content and will post updates here: https://github.com/IonicaBizau/reset-your-facebook-account/issues/17 https://github.com/IonicaBizau/reset-your-facebook-account/i...
- newscracker 10y agoYour current script name seems to imply that it only helps delete everything one has posted/shared. But you mention exporting as well. Is it going to be anywhere close to the paid/subscription product digi.me [1], except for not being in a proprietary format? Digi.me allows export of one's content from groups and pages too. [1]: https://www.digi.me/ https://www.digi.me/
- mgorenstein 10y agoI didn't create the original scripts, which are indeed focused on content deletion. Having fumbled around with various possibilities for the last week or so, I'd guess that the most robust solution to data export from FB would require use of a scraper to extract individual items from the activity log. Ideally that scraper would also visit and clone referent posts (i.e. if I once commented on a post, also save the post itself). My best partial solution thus far has involved programmatically expanding the entirety of the mobile activity log and using Chrome's 'Save Page As.' I've written Python code to then replace all links to images in the HTML with locally stored copies that I obtain using FB's Graph API. I'm not familiar with what digi.me offers specifically. Moving data from one closed ecosystem to another doesn't seem especially desirable. I would gladly participate in an open source effort to automate FB data export--scraping, alas, isn't my forté.
- newscracker 10y agoScraping pages has limitations, and may also be prohibited/banned on the platform depending on how it's done (there are some Terms of Use and permission request forms to fill in if scraping is done by programs - I'm not sure if it applies to all kinds of scrapers, including personal ones). The way digi.me and other similar solutions work is by getting the user to authorize the app and use that authorization with the Facebook APIs to retrieve content. It'd be faster than page scraping, and likely less intrusive (guessing here) on Facebooks Terms of Use.
- gavinpc 10y agoI loathe Facebook, and I appreciate the author putting as much effort into warning about it as he once put into endorsing it. But Facebook has Ne10 users. I suspect this kind of blowing in the wind has the perverse effect of (edit normalizing this by) raising awareness of a problem that people are going to continue not changing (but knowingly). It's a kind of cognitive dissonance that seems (IMHO) to be one of America's main manufactures these days.
- lyra_comms 10y agoGet your loved ones on Lyra instead. Lyra is an open conversation service which respects language, puts the user in control, and is designed with harrassment protection in mind. We're a nonprofit and don't accept investment.
- williamle8300 10y agoWhat's Lyra? I just see a website that looks like a social media marketing agency.
- lyra_comms 10y agoPlease see www.hellolyra.com
- williamle8300 10y agoIt looks beautiful! It reminds me of Gingko (https://gingkoapp.com https://gingkoapp.com) and Pinboard. How are you guys going to make money? I understand it's a non-profit but you're gonna still need money for servers and man-hours.
- lyra_comms 10y agoThank you! We charge £2.99 per year ($3.80) to users in developed countries. We aim to keep access free for users in developing countries.
- williamle8300 10y agoAwesome. Do you do photo-hosting? I could see that easily sapping away all of your money. Or is it just text?
- lyra_comms 10y agoWe just do text - but we do it well. Text is both very cheap, and very expressive.
- gh1 10y agoIs there a way to enjoy all the advantages of the fb stack while preventing this breach of privacy? Would love to know how if someone has ideas.
- newscracker 10y agoOne can only minimize the privacy related ill effects, not eliminate them completely. To start with, see my recommendations on using Facebook from a browser (and never an app) in another comment on this post. [1] [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14395789 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14395789
- SaintSal 10y agoThe issue with technical interventions is that you're still allowing FB to collect information on you via other means via their TOS. I haven't read the latest TOS but at the time I did, they could trade your data with your bank because you've allowed that.
- Animats 10y agoUseful hints: - Put anything on Facebook you're willing to have on a public web page. Stop there. - Don't use Facebook's messaging or email. - On desktops and laptops, run Ghostery and Privacy Badger. This keeps Facebook's "like" buttons from tracking your browsing. - Don't run Facebook's phone app. It's way too intrusive; it gives your contact list to Facebook, just for starters. - Remember, sharing is spamming. Don't "share" links from others on Facebook. That makes you an unpaid employee of Facebook's ad engine.
- milcron 10y agoUninstall Facebook's phone app and check out mbasic.facebook.com. It doesn't require javascript to run. You can access Messenger and everything.
- simonswords82 10y agoI heard somewhere that version of FB was going to be depreciated at some point?
- w33ble 10y agoI use another browser on my phone for fb, and it's the only thing I use that browser for. This is amazing! I can finally read all of the messages I had without installing their app. Thank you so much for sharing that!!
- squeaky-clean 10y agomessenger.com also works well on the desktop to chat and avoid the newsfeed. Unfortunately it redirects to the app/play store on mobile, and has a terrible layout if you force desktop mode. I think a good enough compromise for me is to only use the messenger and contacts, and avoid the newsfeed/posts/pages.
- Shinkirou 10y agoThat's exactly what I do. I only use messenger.com and the fb messenger app. My friends warn me when there's something of interest on one of our college groups, but apart from that I don't go to the main site at all.
- jacksnipe 10y agoIs there an alternative way for me to stay this connected to the people that I care about?
- Skunkleton 10y agoDepends on who you care about. Facebook is really good at making you feel close to people who aren't really part of your life anymore.
- mozey 10y agoThing is, my social life isn't restricted to "loved ones". I just want a way to connect online with anyone I might bump into in the real world. I hate the fb ux and how it breaks the web in so many ways, but currently there isn't anything else that comes close. Taking my ball and going home is not an option. I wish there was some way to force them to make a decent API that allows you to do everything that can be done via the web or the app.
- hellofunk 10y ago> Facebooks creates false endorsements for products from you to your friends - and they never reveal this to you. Wow, really? That sounds to me just downright illegal.
- cryptoz 10y agoTheir legal defence would be that the word 'related' between the 'like' endorsement and the new 'content' creates a separation such that one wouldn't confuse the two. Hopefully a judge would then make it clear that the practice is intended to deceive, and is in fact illegal. That would be nice. Any time you have ever 'liked' anything on Facebook is a time that Facebook interprets that you like the entire organization behind the piece. So if you like The Washington Post, a day later, or 8 years later, Facebook will put your name and photo by an article that you've never seen and say that you like The Washington Post with a big news article, picture, author, etc, that you've never seen. It is certainly intended to make the user's friends think that this content is endorsed by you, to get your clicks and attention and ad dollars. It certainly should be illegal. They've been doing it for years though, so it seems that this kind of thing is the new normal.
- teilo 10y agoA while back I purged my Facebook account of all content. This was a long and tedious process, deleting things one-at-a-time, as there appears to be no way to do this in bulk. My account is now a blank page, no photos, tags, profile information, likes, etc. All they have is my name and birthdate (and that is set to hidden). I imagine Facebook hasn't actually deleted anything, but no one else, at least, can see anything. I wish I could entirely close my account, but unfortunately there are too many people who only use Facebook to contact me, and there are a few groups that I need to participate in. As for the apps: On iOS, at least, you can turn off location services and access to your contacts. Everything still works just fine.
- joshstrange 10y agoIt won't be a popular opinion here but here it goes: Well if it all goes to hell we will all be in the same handbasket. I'm simply not willing to cut people out of my life and miss out on things that are important to me because my data is mined and might be used against me. All these distributed platforms are a joke, no really they are technically cool but no one I care about is on them. Maybe if your entire social circle is technically sophisticated you can leave FB for something like diaspora (I don't know if this is the "new hotness" or if there is something better but I really don't care). My social graph is so far from able or willing to switch to something else it's not even funny. Like it or not there is a social stigma around NOT having a FB account. In fact I've thought on multiple occasions that someone is hiding something if they don't have one. You might hate me for that or hate the fact people think like that but good luck changing that mindset. Look I've been on the other side of this, I paid for App.net (I think that's what that twitter clone was called) and tried multiple distributed platforms but they all fall short or require too many compromises. I tried to get friends to use Signal but no one really cares. iMessage/FB Messenger are just easier and everyone is on them. You want people to leave the "evil facebook" then make something better and easier to use. The best doesn't win, the easiest does.
- lbstr_ftw 10y agoIt's amusing and sad that you honestly think leaving Facebook is the same thing as cutting people out of your life. I've been Facebook free for several years now. It feels great, and I didn't have to cut anyone out of my life to do it (who I wasn't otherwise already communicating with). Much less noice, more productive, both in my life and in my relationships.
- davidcbc 10y agoIt is great if it works this way for you, but every group had its own dynamics. Personally my group of friends primarily talks via Messenger, that's where all the planning for things takes place. We have one friend who isn't on Facebook and he unintentionally gets left out of things. He isn't cut out of our lives, but ultimately he pays a penalty for not being on Facebook
- 10y ago
- stevewillows 10y agoA good number of people I know have left facebook for everything but the events. Its still the one central location where pretty much everybody is. I would love nothing more than a standalone events app that not only had future events, but a, 'hey, I'm at %location%, anyone want to meet up?' that allowed for multiple degrees of social interaction --- e.g. just friends, anybody.
- Jtsummers 10y agoThis is the primary reason I use it. It annoys my girlfriend (who posts regularly) that I don't read what she posts (sometimes I do, but that leads to a time sink when I see everything else I've "got" to read). 99% of my use is to post event announcements, and respond to event invites from friends. If I could trust people to properly respond to emailed invites, I would, but most people I know have 1k+ unread emails. They'll never notice it. FB replaced my email+SMS+(various messaging app) approach from before, but caught almost all my intended audience in one place. There may be other services I could use, but people would have to create yet another account, which isn't likely.
- stevewillows 10y agoI don't know how people can live with an inbox like that. I'd go crazy. I first started leaving Facebook when my feed was consumed with children and lovey-dovey posts. That's cute and all, but I can only handle so much of that (let's round up to one per month...) Down the road, if things start going south for Facebook, I wouldn't be surprised if they broke off the events into a separate app.
- ionised 10y ago> It annoys my girlfriend (who posts regularly) that I don't read what she posts (sometimes I do, but that leads to a time sink when I see everything else I've "got" to read). This sounds batshit crazy to me. Honestly if my partner expected that of me and used it as a reason to be upset with me I'd be thinking of ending the relationship.
- trojanh 10y agoI just wish I could convince more people to stop using Facebook , I have started disliking it from last few years.
- jwhitlark 10y agoIf you think it, don't say it. If you say it, don't write it down. If you write it, don't sign it. If you sign it, don't be surprised.
- phoenixProgram 10y agodon't be surprised if people like it? don't be surprised if it takes work to make it better? don't be surprised if it catches on? don't be surprised if people love it?
- amadeusw 10y agoIf I delete my Facebook account but keep using WhatsApp, do I limit amount of collected data? Is this a viable strategy or do I need to remove WhatsApp as well?
- slowmovintarget 10y agoAs a related article mentions, if you use any Facebook-connected application in the 14-day working-really-hard-on-that-deleting-thing period, then Facebook cancels the account deletion process. Given that Facebook owns WhatsApp, you're likely to face the same problems down the road, if they aren't already doing those things the article has a problem with. ... Yeah, so here's a blurb from the WhatsApp ToS: Third-Party Services. When you use third-party services that are integrated with our Services, they may receive information about what you share with them. For example, if you use a data backup service integrated with our Services (such as iCloud or Google Drive), they will receive information about what you share with them. If you interact with a third-party service linked through our Services, you may be providing information directly to such third party. Please note that when you use third-party services, their own terms and privacy policies will govern your use of those services. There's language similar to Facebook's that says if other people share information about you to them... oh well.
- amadeusw 10y agoThe ToS is a good find, thanks! Perhaps I'll need to stop using WhatsApp for the 14 days, plus a few more days for a good measure.
- not_that_noob 10y agoOne of the more worrisome aspects of the FB is how it was used by the Russian trolls to influence the presidential election. http://mashable.com/2017/03/30/russian-trolls-fake-news/#LDbNXtOBvPqL http://mashable.com/2017/03/30/russian-trolls-fake-news/#LDb... It's not exactly Facebook that is doing it, it's that a set of smart external actors can use the data from fb advertising services to spread propaganda with unprecedented granularity. And to make it even scarier, there's no public record of what was shown to whom, and it can be run by smart actors in a completely anonymous fashion. I feel we have gotten to a point where there's a direct threat to the fundamental concept of a free democracy from the fb platform.
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agowhy would you love someone who uses facebook? you're all idiots.
- dgzl 10y agoRecently I had bought my mother her first smartphone to help being her into the twentieth century (she never had the mental or financial capacity to do it herself). I decided to sign her up for Facebook, and as I was going through some of the TOS, I started feeling dirty; I felt like I was giving away my own mother's privacy to Facebook for their profit. Not that I fully grasp the impact either, but she will never even begin to understand the damage I've done by simply putting that app on her phone. Quite frankly, I have disgusted myself.
- luord 10y agoI read the article and every other article explaining these very valid points and I just can't find it in myself to care. Maybe one day I'll regret it, hopefully I won't. For now, Facebook is a convenient way to be aware of people I care about. I don't use it much, but then again, I'm not connected to many people; only people I actually know and have interacted with IRL, and a few I interacted with extensively through other online means.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wchurchill 10y agoI'm having a ridiculously hard time finding archived versions of FB's previous ToS, privacy, and data policies. Can anyone point me in the right direction? Disclaimer: I'm trying to avoid going to facebook[.]com directly because I'm a paranoid ninny.
- phoenixProgram 10y agoFacebook is a huge problem. I think it is a huge drain on the taxpayers who must fund a government that keeps Facebook users safe. The upside is that the terrorists may use it and thereby get caught. The problem is, who defines the terrorists? The problem is that Facebook can get the government to define "terrorist" on its own timetable rather than the government's timetable. Society already defines membership through exclusion: an "unhealthy" Facebook account is grounds for stripping you of the privilege of being a member of society in good standing.
- linkregister 10y agoI'm surprised to be the only one to point out that many of the examples the author uses are misleading. "Facebook is impersonating you to post things!" -> Facebook clumsily attaches an advertisement to a post with a prominent Related Post header. "Facebook selling your data to Mastercard!" -> anonymized data is being sold to Mastercard to understand browsing habits and interests. "Facebook buries posts that it doesn't like so your friends don't see them" -> The News Feed is a compilation of the most popular items of your friends postings; all shared items are available by looking at a friend's page. "Facebook influenced the 2016 election because it only showed news that was in each users' bubble" -> The little-used Trending Topics section showed news that a given user was likely to want to click. Most users just click on what their friends post. If they're in a bubble, it's because they don't have friends outside of it. "Facebook gives direct access to the NSA via Prism" -> Facebook receives a National Security Letter and then is forced to give the information to the government. At least 2 of the most outrageous claims (insurance companies getting Facebook data, Facebook teaming up with data brokers) lead to broken links. Other evidence is on forbes.com/sites, which is not far off from Medium in terms of oversight. There are some good points. The issue of Facebook's adding the @facebook.com email address as the default (and in some cases deleting the contact's existing email) was a hugely unethical and unpopular thing to do. Many of the future risks the author mentions are realistic and damaging to privacy and personal liberty. Also, looking at idealized pictures of friends' lives can cause feelings of envy and inadequacy. Not to mention the near-constant outrage effect of sensational news being shared. The author has some good points about the potential future risks of being on Facebook. And some excellent suggestions on how to mitigate it, especially the anti-web tracking tips. Why water it down with deception? It serves only to weaken the argument.
- ricardobeat 10y agoTo offer a counterpoint, I don't find those deceptive at all - your depiction is the one that sounds too forgiving and downplays the real impact. Also, "anonymised" data just doesn't have your name attached to it, but can still be a very detailed personal profile. All it takes is one link between your identity and that data to de-anonymise it.
- 10y ago
- known 10y agoUse FB anonymously
- newscracker 10y agoIt's possible to be pseudo-anonymous to a good extent, but full anonymity from FB while having a network of close friends, relatives and colleagues and interacting with them is not possible. Many people who use FB share their entire contacts/address book with it (this includes names, phone numbers, email addresses, etc.). FB can use that information easily to figure out who you may be, collect and correlate information and target ads for you.
- Bakary 10y agoThey even have shadow accounts that are placeholders for people not using their service. They have anticipated probably every plan you've concocted.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoThe greatest gift Facebook gives to governments and police is tagging for the purposes of facial recognition. Basically everyone's identity and facial information is available now. And even worse, childrens' identities are on there already. Children who don't know that they want their privacies preserved are having their privacies squandered for the purpose of a few Likes. Those children who eventually grow up and become spies, police officers, etc, will have no chance of escaping identification at this point.
- throwaway32131 10y ago[offtopic] This struck me as being very similar in goals to Aadhar and projects like GSTN and NCIL (all private entities) being pushed by its promoters in India: "mining every aspect of human life, for serving 'customers' better". This is offtopic and political, but it's perhaps also a reification of the fears that many have for when a state entity merges with such corporates from SV. US definitely has a better constitution when it comes to fundamental rights, but with the likes of NSA slowly chipping at it, backed by a lack of understanding of the tech in Congress, "legality" is not exactly a bulwark it was hoped to be. Anywho, in India's case, we've a Quasi-Governmental entity (backed by private promoters) which came into being without a legal charter. Has ramrodded ("charmed") its way through two administrations. Illegally pushed for making it mandatory for access to state services, and has now made the case (via the state) that "Indians have no right to privacy or their bodies" as an argument in the Apex court (!). Usha Ramanathan speaks in length about the play in play. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJe986ADPE4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJe986ADPE4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7p6cPIkn48M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7p6cPIkn48M The tech (in contrast to SV) however is terrible, but it hasn't stopped them from getting the state to make it "mandatorily voluntary" for every single aspect of life. The technocrats have even gone to the extent of requiring "aadhar-fingerprint" authentication so that little kids get their free meals at schools, and the poor (and I mean Indian poor) have access to food (aka "subsidies are not wasted"). These biometric identifiers are known to barely ever work, since many are involved in manual labor. A lack of authentication means lack of subsidies dispatched - these being counted in typical corporate-speak as "savings". How Orwellian is that ? Some democracy. Perhaps other countries can learn from India's case, and succeed in realizing how dangerous it is for corporations to be running a country, or be in charge (without adequate checks) of critical infrastructure, or indeed to have a corporate sponsored legislature.
- newscracker 10y agoIt's really sad to see how privacy is being knocked off everywhere (around the world). When most people don't even care or don't bother to understand, I don't see how things can ever improve without getting a lot worse and causing some irreparable damage first.
- samirillian 10y agoHow is this post not higher on HN? It's got 500 points at 14 hours.
- SaintSal 10y agoI'm the guy who wrote that post - My guess is the front page might block urls that have been posted before. This post finds its way to HN every 6-12 months as a fresh post. Still, it's really nice that it still gets attention from the HN community, and even nicer that each time, the discussion is more productive and inquisitive.
- davnicwil 10y agoFor anyone looking for an alternative right now, there's https://postbelt.com https://postbelt.com - a text-only social network that's built around privacy, and has no ads. It charges a (small) monthly subscription over a certain number of connections, making you the customer rather than the product. If it sounds interesting, please check it out (it's a side project of mine).
- newscracker 10y agoI like the idea of privacy focused sharing platforms, but yours will be a niche one for several reasons (I'm sure you already knew that). Not allowing images or video, which comprise the majority of the content types shared on social media (including memes, GIFs and videos), is a huge drawback when it comes to attracting users. The ones who do prefer privacy focused services and would pay for it may not like that it's still yet another centralized platform. It's not clear to me how your text-only platform is different from web based forums that have been around for a long time and continue to thrive. That said, we do need more experiments like these to see what could work on a larger scale and learn.
- davnicwil 10y agoYou summed it up perfectly - it's an experiment based on my own curiosity into whether a niche noise-free discussion focused social network would be something people would pay for. I'd been saying for a few years that if something like it existed, I'd pay for it and use it. I got various responses to this ranging all the way from agreement to mocking :-) so I built it to actually test it in the wild.
- intended 10y agoShadow Profiles: shouldn't they be disallowed/illegal? The fact that I am not on facebook, means that I am not even covered by the privacy of their ToS. Anyone who knows me, ends up exposing my information and privacy, which I have not consented to. How does that make sense? The only way I can deal with this intrusion, is to open myself up further and get on Facebook? I'm unsure how to parse the rights and restrictions here
- chrischen 10y agoFacebook's business model counts on erosion of privacy. This means their whole purpose of being is to constantly erode privacy as this means higher revenue for them. This puts us at a dangerous trajectory as long as Facebook is allowed to grow its business unchecked.
- Bakary 10y agoI haven't been on Facebook for years. The result? A weakening of my friendships and of my social life. I often hear the argument that "if they were your real friends you wouldn't need that" or some variation but the truth is that unplanned interactions are a major part of how friendships thrive. If you are no longer part of a place where a lot of these interactions happen, it will definitely affect your social life, even if your friends are well meaning. For reference, I was born in the early nineties, and people my age and in my region are definitely very much still on Facebook for a large portion of their day, even extroverted and outdoorsy individuals. I tried the author's method of using phone and text but did not have the encouraging results he did. I'm also really sick of having my absence of a Facebook be commented on by all sorts of people. All in all, I'm starting to regret my choice and despite the warnings of the author (all of which I was already assuming to be going on behind the scenes as I always judged Facebook to be untrustworthy).
- chii 10y agoyou are unlikely to make more than a handful of "true" friends. as long as those are kept, what remains of the tens or hundreds of "friends" in Facebook is no more than a passing aquaintance, and they do not add much, if any, your life by reading their feeds or comments (any more than comments on HN).
- seanwilson 10y agoIt's not possible to predict who is going to change from being a passing acquaintance to a meaningful long-term friend.
- Bakary 10y agoI can confidently say based on what I observed that I in all likelihood missed out on forming a number of strong friendships due to not having facebook, as I was able to compare the before and after in very similar environments. I would say it becomes much less crucial after university, but during that period it affects a whole lot. Light acquaintances are actually a boon when travelling or trying new things. Facebook makes it quite straightforward to tap this resource, and surprisingly people are quite receptive to being called up by semi-distant people.
- borabora123 10y agoWhen CEO calls user "dumb fu*ks", what do you expect from this kind of company ? I cant understand why people still support these old dinosaur aged platforms.
- MikeVanBike 10y agoFacebook is bad platform to layout your social life... I hope people understand to get out of it asap.
- NotUsingLinux 10y agoEthereum and Dapps build on top, like uport will fix many of the FB problems.
- skellum 9y agoGood read, and missed out the shenanigans of Cambridge Analytica. This is a company owned by Robert Mercer, and claims to have influenced the Brexit referendum and Trump election. It did this (or claims to) through personality profiling using facebook likes (see Michal Kosinski for further reading). With personality profiling you can be microtargeted with fake news that matches you confirmation bias. Accurate microtargeting a known confirmation bias is effective for many reasons. It bypasses the person's critical faculties. That's the nature of a confirmation bias. It also bypasses social critical scrutiny. It's aimed at you, no-one else, so the chance of someone else calling is lowered. And yes, you may redistribute the fake news thereby opening debate, but that will be into your social group, a like minded echo chamber that will ruminate and magnify the effect. Did this happen? Who knows. The evidence is ephemeral, no paper trail to prove or disprove. Which is another scary thing about facebook. https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/how-our-likes-helped-trump-win https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/how-our-likes-hel...