15 ms·
U.S. Startups Fail to Attract Expected Crowd of Small Investors
- muninn_ 10y agoYup. And this is because if you're a startup and you take investment from these "small investors" I can't recall the actual classification (class 3 maybe or something like that?) VC and accelerators simply won't touch you. So there's no point. And then, if you're a "small investor" and you had, say, $5,000 to kick toward a startup for speculative investing, the VCs simply say that it's not enough money and they're just not interested in your small change.
- mindcrime 10y agoAnd this is because if you're a startup and you take investment from these "small investors" I can't recall the actual classification (class 3 maybe or something like that?) VC and accelerators simply won't touch you. So there's no point. Sure there is, if you never planned to seek VC funding anyway. I'm sure there are plenty of companies that just need a little money to get over the initial hump or two, and then plan to rely on organic growth. If you're not worried about being a "moonshot" and don't have huge capital expenses (eg, manufacturing a physical product, drug trials, etc.) then this could quite possibly work for you.
- Lagged2Death 10y agoI thought the whole deal with startup investing was: Invest in a few dozen companies and hope you get one hit so big it makes up for all the others, which you expect to all go down in flames. That can work if you have millions to spend and the time, connections, and access to pal around with dozens of founders, looking for the good eggs. For a "small investor" who has a small fraction of a middle-class paycheck to spend and access only to the web, it would just be the most boring form of gambling ever invented. Who "expected" a crowd of small investors for this, exactly?
- ShannonAlther 10y agoBloomberg, apparently. It's just like day trading: sure, you might get lucky, but you have to know or have something the rest of us don't to get consistent returns. Just invest in an index fund.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoMy hope for crowdfunding would be that it would be exactly like you describe: spend the time, connections, and pal around with people doing projects, but the only difference would be the dollar amounts. $1,000 here, $10,000 there, on things like performances, food carts, etc. Stuff a VC would never touch because the max payout is like $50k. But for a small investor to make 10 ~$5k investments, and get back principal plus $50k over the course of a few years that's pretty good. And they can do it in their own community on projects that don't make sense for someone in New York or SV to even know about.
- bluetwo 10y agoHonestly I thought there would be some marginally ethical VCs that would team up with similar salespeople to scale up this type of investing. I'm a little surprised this void hasn't been filled.
- nathan_f77 10y agoI've had a look at a few of these startups that were trying to raise money this way, and none of them seemed very promising. I'm not going to give money to something just because it's there, it has to be something I truly believe in.
- tuna-piano 10y agoNot only that, the ones that are can be quite scammy. Highlights from this startup raising money: -Advertised with TV commercials by former Seinfeld actor -$160k in assets, raising $50million at >$200million valuation -CEO was formerly barred from leading companies by the SEC due to security fraud -The management team has a few more planned IPOs in the biomed and aeronautical industries, and has a graveyard of past businesses that got investor money and went bankrupt. http://www.businessinsider.com/yayyo-ipo-ads-tv-ramy-el-batrawi-sec-rule-jobs-act-2017-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/yayyo-ipo-ads-tv-ramy-el-batr...
- badloginagain 10y agoI would be willing to buy into a crowdsourced VC fund- I give money to the fund for a slice of it, which in turn vets and invests in early stage startups. They hit a big payout, my slice becomes more valuable. The thing is, I don't want to do any work. I want someone else to do the vetting and the paperwork to invest. Obviously, they get a bigger piece of pie. Basically, I want an index fund for early stage startups. It would be high-risk, but it's the same risk (in principle) as VC firms have.
- hkmurakami 10y agoIirc VC as an industry loses money (or has poor returns), with the top 10 firms dominating the returns and some small number of startup firms posting great returns (iirc this is from a Jason lwmkin's post) So i think your index fund performs quite poorly.
- petra 10y agoAre there any viable ways to open the top-10 for investment by bug funders ?
- jerf 10y agoI suspect that what you're seeing is basically than the large firms are successful enough and funded enough so they don't need more money that they "negotiate" themselves 100% of the value. What can you bring one of the top-10 investors that they don't already have, such that they'd be willing to share the benefits with you?
- hkmurakami 10y agoNo they are oversubscribed. They won't take our money even if we beg them.
- logicallee 10y agoWhy do you say it would be high-risk?
- goshx 10y agoI wonder how they are letting people know about this. I wasn't aware this was possible and I still had in mind that you had to be "credited" investor, even as a Hacker News reader, somehow this was flying under my radar. I don't expect a lot of people to know about it.
- zitterbewegung 10y agoI think that if they actualy want a crowd to do this that they have to improve discovery of not only the ability to do this and the companies that want to be crowdfunded. Up until know I vaguely knew that the JOBS act contained this wording (and I presumed that something changed about the JOBS act) which was false. The other part is discovery which could be helped by either partnering with Kickstarter or making an independant website that would do this. On the other hand it could be that Kickstarter is performing crowdfunding to the point that the technique of using the Jobs act is not needed. Adding up 2 or 3 large kickstarter projects and you get the total amount raised. Currently Kickstarter has funded around $3 billion dollars.
- mindcrime 10y agoSwat said the practice is still in its infancy. Wefunder, StartEngine and SeedInvest are the primary crowdfunding platforms, and many founders aren’t aware that equity fundraising is an option. This, and some people (like me) probably just got tired of waiting for the SEC to do their part, and quit paying attention to the whole thing. When the JOBS Act first passed, I was pretty excited. Then something like 3 years went by and you still couldn't do crowd-fund equity fund-raising. By then, the whole thing had pretty much dropped off my radar. I think as information about this percolates through the ecosystem, it will become more commmon place. But right now there's a lot of uncertainty and doubt surrounding the whole thing, and I expect that's hurting adoption.
- dave_sullivan 10y ago> some people (like me) probably just got tired of waiting for the SEC to do their part Yeah, same. Last I checked, the rules they did come out with were pretty restrictive. This article almost makes it sound easy, but if you read the full text, it basically comes down to "If you can raise money from any other source, like VC, private equity, institutional investors, or angels--do that instead because it's easier." You can read them here: https://www.sec.gov/info/smallbus/secg/rccomplianceguide-051316.htm https://www.sec.gov/info/smallbus/secg/rccomplianceguide-051... The SEC pretty much said to congress, "Nope, we know better" and they've effectively killed the bill by dragging their feet for 5 years and then coming out with guidance that kills the intent. Maybe there can be a new bill that takes "crowdfunding" out of the hands of the SEC? Not sure how you would word that exactly, but some kind of exception that removes their jurisdiction? Maybe even not classifying them as public companies? (SEC has no jurisdiction over private companies).
- Retric 10y agoSadly, the SEC is fairly correct on this one. At least in terms of the history of finance. If you let companies raise either a lot of total money or a lot of money from one person the incentives to make a company are less than simply get good at raising money and then skim as much as possible. Then run for the hills or repeat.
- Alex3917 10y agoWhat would the numbers look like if the authors hadn't excluded ICOs? Given that this is where the majority of the small-dollar equity crowdfunding is going, it seems weird not to include them.
- austenallred 10y agoI'm not seeing AngelList syndicates listed here, which is probably the most obvious way for a small investor to invest in a startup; you still need someone to do the diligence and find the companies to invest in, but I could put my money into an "Index Fund" led by dozens of smaller investors, which seems to be the most logical way to do something like this. As for direct crowdfunding, I would be comfortable angel investing if I knew someone was doing the due diligence, but no way am I putting my money into a startup blind, or spending the time to do that due diligence myself. After that, the signaling risk and additional regulatory complexity behind this type of crowdfunding is likely a bad thing for a company, and likely mostly filled with companies that can't raise by traditional means, so you have an adverse selection problem and you're making it worse. I think Naval and AngelList could change that, but there's quite a long ways to go.
- pilingual 10y agoI've been following the equity crowdfunding sites, and here are a few observations on why it seems disenchanting. 1. A lot of companies seem to be lifestyle and not startups; they don't plan to grow 7% a week. 2. Many companies aren't raising for the first time and are looking for a bridge or 2nd or 3rd seed round. 3. The cap on the notes is way too high. 4. Many sites incentivize by offering T-shirts and other crap. The purpose is investment so the sites should optimize around investment education and not what reward you can get for just a few hundred dollars more. In the end it is going to be hard to even 2x overall investment. I suspect most people will just lose their money.
- danvoell 10y agoMy problem has been that I haven't seen a single deal that I felt had moderately favorable investor terms.
- seibelj 10y agoThis is anecdotal, but I chatted with a VC for a while at an event and he said their firm will not invest in anyone who did equity crowd funding, on the theory that it signals a weaker company. If they were stronger, they would have raised proper VC. I think the existing VC investment structures hate the idea of crowdfunded VC as it threatens their model, which is personal connections and an old boys (and girls) network which allows more favorable terms for investors, especially for first-time founders. I hope that crowdfunding becomes more normal. Not every idea has to have billion dollar potential, which is what most VC's are looking for.
- cstavish 10y agoAccredited investors/VC (disclaimer: I am neither, but co-founded a VC-backed startup) are often wary of crowd funding because of the idea that with more investors, the more headaches that can occur with additional capital raises. Having a big cap table doesn't make company operations easier. I honestly don't know how valid those viewpoints are, but that's what I've heard.
- seibelj 10y agoI don't see why this is an issue though, just promise quarterly updates and clearly state rights on future raises for existing investors. They can follow-on or not. All of these issues can be solved, it's just more excuses. It should be easier to have 100 investors who all agree on everything than 4 investors you have to baby and cajole and manage their whining because they feel entitled to personal service.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lumost 10y agoThat assumes that the company proceeds through successive rounds with an upwards trajectory. If the company falters and takes a down round the initial investors may disagree with the direction or even sue. If the company needs to be recapitalized or restructured under a time crunch, tracking down 100 loosely involved investors and getting them to sign the deal may not be feasible.
- inputcoffee 10y agoAs an investor, consider the following: 1. They give you very little information. Sometimes just sales numbers or some "traction" metric and a para on future plans. They talk about their unique angle but not about their challenges. 2. You put money in and you get very infrequent updates. Sometimes something along the lines of "sales are ok" or "sales fell" without much detail. It is treated as a favor to you, not an absolute right as an investor. 3. If they need to raise funds again, suddenly they become more chatty. 4. As an investor, my alternative is: public stocks! A lot more information, a lot more liquidity. For the large stocks you're competing with geniuses at hedge funds but the smaller stocks usually have less competition.
- boxcardavin 10y agoSmall investors lack the biggest benefit of a good VC – good connections. $120k from 12 non-F&F investors = 12 people to bother you without much benefit.
- kevmo 10y agoAnother slice of the explanation for this can be found in the ceiling there is on crowdfunding: Your investors aren't people with deep pockets; it's those who generally don't have even one full extra paycheck in the bank. When they give you $20, that may mean they don't see a movie with their S.O. that weekend, etc. The money pool is much shallower. Raising the minimum wage would be good for crowdfunding.
- OliverJones 10y agoHmmm. I'm an accredited investor. I'd have to be crazy -- or altruistic -- to invest in a typical SaaS / software / Sili Valley startup via crowdfunding. Why? * Waste: Absurdly high cost of living in places with startup culture means labor costs must be excessive or you can't get the people you want. * Focus: Not every software-style startup has Joel Spolsky or another leader with his kind of focus. * Unicorns. For investors they bring to mind the mid-20th century play by existentialist Jean-Paul Sartre. "No Exit." If I'm going to be altruistic I'll put my money into paying off student loans for young friends, to give them the freedom to make altruistic choices themselves.
- sidlls 10y ago"You can't the people you want" is itself a problem with these companies: often the people they want have credentials suggesting better suitability to academic or applied research when the job the need done suggests "average CRUD developer" credentials are just fine. This is, in fact, one reason I find the obsessive focus on the Valley as far as VC and other investment mechanisms a little perplexing. These companies have a giant misunderstanding about many aspects of software business, from basics like "who is best to hire" (as opposed to "how to hire the best") to really basic engineering processes and marketing. Maybe the point (from their perspective) of getting VC capital is to get the other benefits that come from it: a network of folks who (should) understand these things.
- david927 10y agoNone of those reasons are exclusive to crowdfunding, though. I get that there are few good investment opportunities and a lot of cruft, but I wouldn't list the same reasons. For me the biggest issue is vision: All startups hope are chasing money, but some are chasing it to the exclusion of everything else. They don't see a different future, a better future; they simply see themselves richer. Funding such startups isn't even altruistic. The opposite, it's enabling a broken culture.
- y_u_no_rust 10y agoThank you for your sanity.
- mceoin 10y agoICOs are wildly popular (granted, not all from U.S., but crowdfunding seed capital is proving successful for the right "idea spaces")
- rdlecler1 10y agoThe problem is supply side. Crowdfunded companies are giving the platform 5-10% of the capital raised. Why crowdfund and have a whole bunch of investors on your captable and give up some of that money AND deal with the compliance cost of you're strong enough to get it from angels/seed VCs. Current regulations force a broken model.
- tptacek 10y agoCrowdfunding appears to be a terrible deal for retail investors: * VCs survive by maintaining portfolios of companies in which 1-2 in 10 survive (most VCs fail to generate returns that beat the public markets). This means more than that you need 10 companies --- it also governs the kinds of companies you can invest in. Despite being a message board in part dedicated to startups, it feels like very few of the relatively specialized people here understand why VCs don't back quietly, steadily profitable companies. * VCs compete for access to dealflow. The very best startups don't need to crowdfund and will usually get better terms from VCs. Moreover, there are logistical hassles with adding retail investors (in any form) to your cap table. All this is compounded by a signaling problem, where taking crowdfunding taints your company in the eyes of future VCs. So there's a huge adverse selection problem. * Retail investors are given a deceptive view of the outcomes for startups. We all know most startups fail and zero out their investors (any S&P 500 component that did that would generate nationwide headline news for weeks). But more startups fail than we think, because many (maybe most) startup acquisitions are really managed failures. There are probably more reasons than this. I think equity crowdfunding is structurally broken, and more likely to hurt people than to do anything for our technology market.
- skdotdan 10y agoWhy not to create a massive crowd-funded or publicly traded VC fund? (as opposed to crowd-funding for a single startup) Thus more people could expose themselves to VC but in a diversified manner. Also, more capital would be available for startups.
- tptacek 10y agoSomeone has to get paid to do that, so now the premise of equity crowdfunding has been reduced to: in the best case, you can crowdfund another venture capital firm, and pay a tax out of your returns that wealthy investors don't have to pay. And, again: most VCs fail! A lot of money is invested in VCs not in the expectation of those investments being lucrative, but instead in the hopes that VC returns are uncorrelated with the public markets. But no retail investor does that.
- skdotdan 10y agoWhy not to create a massive crowd-funded or publicly traded VC fund? (as opposed to crowd-funding for a single startup)
- prostoalex 10y agoFidelity does this (FBGRX, FDGRX) and GSVC has been around (top investments are Palantir, Spotify and Dropbox) http://gsvcap.com/portfolio/ http://gsvcap.com/portfolio/ So I'd guess that demand for high-risk investment of the kind is well-served by existing instruments, and even if Schwab or Vanguard have evaluated a possibility of launching such fund, they have not pulled the trigger yet.
- wehadfun 10y agoI went to a workshop and asked a the guy what benefit does the investor have to buy shares of Tom's Tire Shop. The guy said it is just like buying Apple or Microsoft, and blah, blah, blah. No it is not like buying Microsoft. There is no way to liquidate your shares.
- grellas 10y agoI wish the crowdfunding platforms well but, in the end, there is an inherent tension between the core idea of crowdfunding and the idea of investor protections under the securities laws. U.S. securities law give two broad choices to issuers trying to raise money: take your company public or do a private placement. With the former, you can deal freely with all sorts of investors, in any number and with whatever background. With the latter, you deal with sharp restrictions on the number of investors you can deal with (if unaccredited) and on the qualifications of investors for investment in such offerings (accredited, unaccredited, etc.). Conceptually, crowdfunding tries to straddle these two worlds when it offers true equity (as opposed to promotional giveaways only) in the ventures. It seeks to broaden the number and type of investors who can invest in a startup venture while simultaneously trying to protect prospective investors from dishonest or otherwise improper offerings. Problem is: the larger the number of investors and the more latitudinarian the standards for who qualifies, the more it looks like an unregulated public offering and the more it becomes susceptible to all the problems that brought public offerings under strict regulation in the first place. So today we have a hybrid that theoretically tries to open up startup investment to all sorts of small investors but that practically attempts to keep a whole variety of restrictions in place to ensure investor protection. This hybrid is what is failing to gain popular appeal. There are too many restrictions needed to ensure investor protection to make it a fluid vehicle for small investors to invest and to make it attractive for startups to use it as a means of doing their funding. Thus, the technology is there today to facilitate a robust crowdfunding marketplace but the law is not there for traditional reasons of investor protection. And so the current efforts sputter along akin to how an otherwise intriguing startup might seem to have almost unlimited potential but never quite seems to gain traction. It took five years to get the regs in place to support the statute that put this funding mechanism in place. That is slow because the issues (in my view) are intractable. Will another five years make a substantial difference. In my view, no. But who knows? My free market side says do away with the investor protections and let it rip. But the lawyer in me says, no way - such a free-for-all will likely cause many to be duped and few to prosper. It is not an easy choice and that is why I think this will ultimately remain sputtering along with highly uncertain prospects of effecting true change in the investment landscape.
- tptacek 10y ago
- david927 10y agoI don't know why investors would be interested. There's really no innovation happening at the startup level anymore. There was a time when you would hear of some interesting startup that had a huge, grand vision of the future. But the last ten years have brought us startups like Facebook and Snapchat -- and that's just not very inspiring. I, for one, am looking forward to the next economic correction and Sili Valley implosion, so that the froth will clear away and all that will be left are those fighting for a vision instead of scheming for a profit.
- theprop 10y agoThis isn't an accurate assessment or headline. The accurate headline or assessment is "Equity Crowdfunding sites fail to attract legitimate, investment-worthy startups"! I've seen the startups posted at the crowdfunding sites and they look terrible / borderline scammy e.g. a site that's not growing and doesn't have much going for it raising at a $25 million valuation. Part of the reason is that there's a big gorilla in the room and it's Kickstarter! If you have a great product, it's better to take it there than to an equity crowdfunding site -- at Kickstarter, you get pre-orders, gauge demand, get actual buyers/users, and don't lose any equity or have those legal complications. It's much better than equity crowdfunding. I also think AngelList should be evaluated as I bet it's enabled a lot of brand new folks to get into angel investing.
- nowarninglabel 10y agoSmall dollar amounts, but not necessarily "few" in numbers of people. Granted, I'm not particularly interested in crowd-funded equity, but crowd-funded interest-free charitable loans that Kiva has been doing in the U.S. have been steadily growing. https://www.kiva.org/lend/kiva-u-s https://www.kiva.org/lend/kiva-u-s Growing at the bottom may not produce eye-popping changes right now, but could have some great long-term effects for re-invigorating small business growth (which has been on the decline in the U.S. as I've posted elsewhere).
- mempko 10y agoTurns out only the rich have enough money to invest. Everyone else is living paycheck to paycheck.
- dharma1 10y agoI was chatting with a startup that recently raised £1m crowdfunding as their second round. They were really happy with their choice and not having VC strings attached. I think an undervalued aspect of this is how powerful crowdfunding can be in creating a few thousand early product evangelists (who have vested interest in the company). And I think TheDAO - though it was too early /fragile, had a half-baked voting model and got too big too fast - was onto something. I think cryptocurrency based equity/ dividends and decentralised, crowdfunded companies will definitely happen at some point in the future.
- crispytx 10y agoThe problem with equity crowdfunding right now is that most of the tech startups aren't raising money through the portals. What percentage of the YC Summer 2017 batch do you think will go on to raise money through the equity crowdfunding portals? My guess is that few, if any, of the YC Summer 2017 companies will raise money through equity crowdfunding. And this is a huge problem for potential equity crowdfunding investors. Equity crowdfunding investors simply do not have the opportunity to invest in large number of the best startups. Go check out the types of companies raising money on the funding portals, most aren't tech startups. You'll find all sorts of bullshit companies, everything from board games to restaurants!
- pnathan 10y agoStartups have an enormously high risk profile. I'm simply unable to come up with enough money to spread around enough startups that my expected ROI will beat an indexed fund.
- zby 10y agoThe main problem for investors is the principal-agent problem - simply that the managers of the company will use the funds invested into it for their own advantage instead of advancing the company. There are degrees of this - from blatant fraud to slightly overpaying themselves or making deals with their friends instead of best offerers. It is impossible to entirely stop this - but there are ways to diminish the impact. 1. Become involved in the company - this can work only if you have a big stake in the company (with dispersed ownership you get collective action problems) and the company is a big stake of your activities (you cannot get involved much in many companies). 2. Lend not buy equity (and require collateral etc). 3. The laws for public offerings - with all that red tape involved: the strict accounting, governance rules, information disclosure rules, etc. 4. Investing in startups. This is a small special case where investing can be something between becoming fully involved in the company operations and being a small shareholder of a public company. This relies on the theory that startups goal is to grow a 100 times or die - so small continues extractions by the executives are ruled out. The crowdfunding initiatives, try to reduce the red tape involved in a public offering of equity - but they don't even try to address the problem that the bureaucracy addresses in the first place.
- SirLJ 10y agoVCs will always do much much better, they have the connections to do the exits...
- blazespin 10y agoI think the huge win here will be things like Kickstarter. Just takes one oculus to inspire folks. I could have potentially made 40K off my $400 investment. Oh, and a free rift!
- imoldfella 10y agoAnother reason for Small Investors to stay away is the senseless tax hassle. I didn't invest because I had any ambition to get wealthy, I just wanted to "give back" and help some ambitious young entrepreneurs get started. Now I'm filing complicated tax forms for money I'll never see because those young companies made 10$ in interest from the money sitting in a bank.
- arikrak 10y agoI looked into investing a small amount in crowdfunding, but there are very few platforms offering it and the companies seemed to be raising money at overpriced valuations. It would be nice if crowdfunding could grow, since ordinary people could get a share of large growth and they could also offer certain unique benefits for a company the raising money (e.g. help with marketing).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]