9 ms·
For all the talk by liberatians and their ilk that regulation is bad and unnecessary, that chart of median fuel effeciency due to government requirements should
by azinman2 10y ago
For all the talk by liberatians and their ilk that regulation is bad and unnecessary, that chart of median fuel effeciency due to government requirements should give them pause. Wow. Well over a decade of non-progress until a path forward is mandated. Suddently the needle starts moving, with car owners, the environment, and energy import needs as big winners here.
- minikites 10y agoBased on the libertarians I've talked with about seat belt laws, their argument would probably be to hand-wave it away with "It would have happened anyway thanks to the magic of the market."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kauffj 10y agoIndividuals have immediate, direct incentive to wear seat belts. Seat belts are not a collective action problem the way climate change is.
- barrkel 10y agoWhen health costs are socialised - and insurance is a way of socialising costs - it does become a collective action problem, because the negligence of the few increases the costs of the many.
- conanbatt 10y agoThat is applicable to alcohol, unhealthy foods, lack of exercise, improper sleep, smoking, etc. Should we ban all those too?
- azinman2 10y agoAt some point unhealthy foods might get banned, or other mechanisms like the soda tax put in place to help push things in the right way. You can't take an all-in or all-out approach to things. Each case is its own contextual matter that must be independently considered. If you want to see an example of where anything goes, the world has many examples of lawless societies. Not somewhere I'd want to live.
- conanbatt 10y ago> You can't take an all-in or all-out approach to things Sure, but its important to notice that the grave inconsistency with the which we apply policy has to be a consequence of systemic failures. For example, cigarettes have to show pictures of diseased people, but cheese doesnt have to show pictures of obese or diabetic people. Cars dont have to make a diclosure that "you might kill people with this" and show you pictures of that. The picture policy on cigarettes is pretty morbid to me. And then the defense for it is that "its good for people". Doing the wrong thing for the right reasons does not provide me satisfaction.
- barrkel 10y agoThis is one of the downsides to socialised medicine - people feel the right to judge people for their weight, for example. Taxes are high on tobacco because of the harms. Here in the UK, there's support for minimum alcohol prices, to stop alcohol getting too cheap. We already have loads of bans on smoking in different contexts. If politicians could find an easy way to try and force poor people to eat less fast food, they would; they don't have much moral compunction stopping them, rather they feel they have the right, because obesity etc have costs that need to be managed.
- conanbatt 10y ago> Taxes are high on tobacco because of the harms. Here in the UK, there's support for minimum alcohol prices, to stop alcohol getting too cheap. I will argue that the reason taxes are high on tobacco is because its become social suicide to defend tobacco. The taxes are high on tobacco because its an easy case to make that gets no opposition. Alcohol is next in line. I'd argue that if something is bad but popular its hard totax (i.e. special TV tax, special Netflix tax, special Facebook tax), or that something is good but unpopular its too easy to tax (tax foreigners, tax the poor, etc).
- jrs95 10y agoI think the argument would probably be more like "New cars would be substantially cheaper if it weren't for these regulations." Their preferred means of dealing with the pollution problem would be something like a carbon tax (assuming they're the type to actually believe it exists, anyways)
- refurb 10y agoSo when gas prices went through the roof in the 1970's and there was rationing, you don't think that created consumer demand for more fuel efficient cars?
- orf 10y agoClearly not, or not enough to make a difference. America didn't stop producing gas guzzlers after the 70's. If anything mpg went down as trucks got bigger
- ajross 10y agoThe article clearly shows mpg getting rapidly better in the 1970's, with an inflection point right at the passage of the mileage target.
- VintageCool 10y agoMoreover, as soon as the government-imposed target was met, carmakers stopped improving mpg fuel efficiency and made no progress on that front for 20 years.
- refurb 10y agoAverage fuel economy almost doubled from 1975 to the late 80's.[1] I agree that trucks hurt that trend overall, but there are a lot of consumers who value fuel economy even in the absence of gov't regulations. [1]https://i0.wp.com/www.curbsideclassic.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/EPA-fuel-economy.jpg https://i0.wp.com/www.curbsideclassic.com/wp-content/uploads...
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoGas got really cheap in the mid/late 80s after it got really expensive in the late 70s.
- conanbatt 10y agoThe seatbelt argument is not about saving people's lives, its about not forcing people to do a precaution. If you can make the argument that you can force someone to use a seatbelt for his own protection, can you ban alcohol? loud music? driving altogether? bad food? Bathtubs? What is fundamentally different of the seatbelt than the other million things that endanger our lives everyday and we live with ?
- azinman2 10y agoI'm guessing the probability for death is far higher, or rather, the public safety benefit greatly outweighs the tiny cost. We also have regulations on building safety and construction, or would you rather not force people to have the precaution of getting a structural engineer when building homes and buildings? Alcohol has been banned for a while, but eventually it was decided as a society that we were willing to accept that risk and negative outcome. Bad food is also banned via food safety standards via the FDA. I could keep going on... but ultimately everything comes down to a cost : benefit analysis that's done collectively as a society. Recently we have the example of marijuana being rethought as a society and now those bans are largely going away. Things can shift in either direction.
- conanbatt 10y ago> I'm guessing the probability for death is far higher, or rather, the public safety benefit greatly outweighs the tiny cost. The tiny cost? First, its a tremendous cost! Why allow any 2 types of cars with different safety features? If safety is paramount on a car, then we should only one model: the safest. Second, the probability of death varies wth many activities. For example, biking is very dangerous in SF. So are many outdoor activities like mountain climbing. Or diving. There is a case for the seatbelt because when people die in a car accident, there are externalities, but forcing the seatbelt to protect someone is a paternalistic idea. > We also have regulations on building safety and construction, or would you rather not force people to have the precaution of getting a structural engineer when building homes and buildings? In this case, this is the safety of others. Very different to the safety of yourself: the whole concept of libertarianism is self-posession,that who you are is only owned by yourself. It is surely acceptable to use the powers of the state to protect one from others. > Alcohol has been banned for a while, but eventually it was decided as a society that we were willing to accept that risk and negative outcome. We have countries in the modern world that have banned alcohol still. Its purely cultural, its not a foundational moral or economical trade-off. And the negatives of alcohol are pretty bad! > Bad food is also banned via food safety standards via the FDA Depends on the definition of bad: if you mean toxic, sure. If you mean food that degenerates health, definitely the opposite. Sugar for example, could simply be banned to a very positive result in public health. > Recently we have the example of marijuana being rethought as a society and now those bans are largely going away. Things can shift in either direction. This is the appealing point from the libertarian stance: you dont need to depend on the mood of the moment for the direction of policy to benefit you. Marijuana would have never been banned under a libertarian conception. And neither would cocaine and other drugs, provided the harm is done only tos elf, and not to other.
- grandalf 10y agoLibertarians are not anti-regulation, they just believe that the good and bad consequences of regulations should be understood. Often, those who are not libertarians will support a regulation simply because they agree with its stated aim... things like "the patriot act" or "the affordable care act". Those names are chosen to sound good, not because they reflect the intent of legislation or the outcome of it. To give you an example of the folly of fuel economy regulation, consider that 90% of automotive pollution is created by the oldest 10% of cars on the road. Does it really make sense to force all buyers of new cars to pay extra? Why not charge a tax that increases for every year a car gets older, so that the person driving the smoke-emitting clunker has an incentive to upgrade into something that is cleaner and safer. Libertarians value having a clean environment just like anyone else does. The question is how to create regulations that are fair and don't create disincentives for innovation. Note that several automakers needed government bailouts partly due to the cost of complying with fuel economy regulations. But rather than letting those companies fold and allowing Tesla to rise to prominence much sooner, our regulators propped up the makers of the most polluting cars, a move which set back US emissions significantly (compared to the counter-factual I described).
- legopelle 10y agoI'm sure non-libertarians also believe regulation should be understood.
- ajross 10y agoYou spend a lot of words there describing what libertarians don't do and defending them from what I'm guessing you'd call a straw man. So... am I right that you, as a presumptive libertarian, support the fuel efficiency regulations passed in the 70's and 90's, as witnessed by the evidence in the linked article? If someone expert told you that similar regulation passed today would have a similar effect, would you support it?
- grandalf 10y ago> am I right that you... support the fuel efficiency regulations passed in the 70's and 90's No I would prefer a carbon tax charged per vehicle based on miles driven per year and the pollution emitted from the vehicle. > If someone expert told you that similar regulation passed today would have a similar effect, would you support it? What effect did it have? Do you think automakers would have continued to use 1960s era engines? The question to be asked is not whether I support it but whether a different policy might have been far better. I think a tax would have had a far less distortionary effect on the economy and potentially a more beneficial effect on the environment.
- spectrum1234 10y agoAs a libertarian my view is that in the short term often government does act faster than the market. The problem is that the in medium and long term the market can't act.
- coherentpony 10y agoWhat does that mean?
- maratd 10y agoOnce the government enacts a solution, there is reduced incentive for the market to come up with a better solution. For example, people want clean cars. Government mandates cleaner cars. Cars are now clean enough to make most people happy, but still somewhat dirty. If government didn't act, the overwhelming number of people who desired clean cars may have pushed the market to switch to electric cars. That's happening much more slowly now, because the solution the government implemented was "good enough" for most people.
- vacri 10y agoMeh. I saw this kind of reasoning on P & T's Bullshit, where they had a local business owner complaining about government regulations mandating the minimum number of parking spots for people with disabilities. Both Penn and the guest were crapping on about this while standing in a nearly empty parking area, and both saying that if it weren't for government regulations, the local businesses would create more disability parking spots, to pull in more business. The elephant in the room, of course, was that the government only mandated the minimum - there was nothing stopping the local businesses from creating more than that which, of course, they absolutely did not do. This is the essence of libertarianism in reality - a whole lot of complaints on restriction of activity and "if we were more free, this would happen", but never any follow-through.
- wand3r 10y agoThe environment is an unpriced externality so it has to be controlled by the government. Also, the needle starts moving with Tesla, Volt, GM etc. Breaking into electric. The government has helped there too. I am a libertarian and I am totally ok with that. Market solutions will almost always be better than government ones BUT some things can't be solved by the market. Whether perverse incentives or unforeseen issues, I would rather a gov solution than no solution and am not averse to a combination
- glial 10y ago> The environment is an unpriced externality so it has to be controlled by the government. Yes, and a commons, and must be protected for that reason. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- micahbright 10y agoAny libertarian worth his salt is going to first point out the fallacy of your argument: You can't know what the market would have done, so how can you say that the regulation is "good" and that libertarians are wrong? The other glaring failure in logic on your part is your assumption that fuel efficiency is what is best for your fellow man as opposed to whatever else the market would have alternatively provided without regulation. If you really wish to impose your preferences on everyone else, then by all means, just admit you are an asshole.
- sctb 10y agoPlease just leave out the personal attacks.
- wand3r 10y agoThe environment is an unpriced externality so it has to be controlled by the government. Also, the needle starts moving with Tesla, Volt, GM etc. Breaking into electric. The government has helped there too. I am a libertarian and I am totally ok with that. Market solutions will almost always be better than government ones BUT some things can't be solved by the market. Whether perverse incentives or unforeseen issues, I would rather a gov solution than no solution and am not averse to a combination
- rubyn00bie 10y agoI would like to point out this is due to confusion by almost all peoples who haven't formally studied the economics of regulation. There are in fact, two types of regulation: "Safety and Soundness" and "economic." Economic regulation is almost always a bad thing and results in gross market inefficiencies like barriers to entry, cronyism, and destroys any hope of a functioning capitalist system. Think trucking regulations in the 70s and before... Safety and soundness is almost always a great thing as it helps ensure we are able to have a healthy and functioning society. Seat belts is a great example of this... Where most people, and I agree, it's generally libertarians and republicans go wrong on the is conflating the two types of regulation or not being able to see which kind of regulation it is clearly. Granted it's not always easy to know which... A prime example of people getting it wrong is with banking regulation. Banking regulations, for example a lot of people thought Glass–Steagall was economic regulation and it was not-- it was in fact a safety and soundness regulation that made unbelievably great sense. It's destruction cost the world greatly because it allowed unsafe markets to be created, corrupted, and later destroyed as a result. Energy and environmental regulation is another one where it's strictly safety and soundness regulation but people complain about the cost. Then they start calling it "economic regulation" because there's a cost associated with it. Well there is a cost associated with everything including not protecting the earth and its inhabitants. I without hesitation say the cost of a de-regulated environment will be dramatically higher than the cost of implementing and progressing with the regulations. Unless of course one would prefer extinction. Yes some business and markets may go under because of safety and soundness regulation but this is because they were not correctly accounting for the true cost of business. If they had been, it would have NEVER been profitable. Edit: I'm very, very left but it's solely a result of my economics education. I started life right, then moved to a pseudo libertarian outlook, and finally abandoned all of that to move to the far left. Because it's what makes the most scientific sense-- and economics is in fact a science.
- coredog64 10y agoCan you please point out the exact parts of Glass-Steagall that, had they been left in place, would have prevented the GFC?
- 10y ago
- malchow 10y agoThe MPG chart is of median MPG among production vehicles, not mean, and not mean weighted by person-miles driven.
- highd 10y agoIt's unproductive to discuss political labels. It's sufficient to say this is a case where regulation was helpful - as are most cases involving protecting common resources. Issues are independent from each other. Continuing to discuss each point as it fits into the frameworks of the popular ideologies only serves to polarize when productive change requires unification.
- fenomas 10y agoThis is a huge meta-issue that I wish people would watch out for. When one says "Libertarians are wrong about X", and someone answers (as several did here) that Libertarians don't necessarily believe X, you're not arguing about X but about the definition of the word "Libertarian". But all too often that argument can then continue indefinitely, with both parties thinking they're arguing about X, even though they may not actually disagree about anything except definitions of terms.
- highd 10y agoExactly. Not to mention the inevitable "No true Scotsman!". This is the fundamental root of the degradation of political discourse over the past few decades, IMO. Conversations without labels I've found almost inevitably result in previously opposed party members finding common ground and shared paths to improvements. Policy discussion should revolve around 2 questions, IMO: 1) What should the world be like? 2) What could be done to make the world like we want? People will often find that different aspects of those two questions cut across party-line ideologies in surprising ways.
- azinman2 10y agoWhich is why I said 'and their ilk', generally meaning people who want favor the market to make decisions instead of the government. We do have a political party in power who's promise is to remove regulations, __especially__ those involving common resources (including this very one on cars!), so it's not irrelevant point. I agree with you that labels create sides, but the reality is those that want labels (e.g. each respective party) attach their label to their causes and vocabulary. Regulations (and the abolishment of) is one that the right seems to want to claim.
- coredog64 10y agoCAFE, as written, is hot garbage. It sets a ceiling on fuel economy, not a floor. The difficulty in writing good legislation (then or now) is that other markets that value fuel economy more have already created some great cars. As a consequence, the easiest workaround is to import those cars and sell them here. That would predictably lead to job losses in an industry with an influential union.
- bpodgursky 10y ago(most) libertarians are perfectly happy to structure a market to internalize the externalities of pollution, since it's not practical to privatize air O2 and CO2. A different, possibly more market-oriented, solution would have been a carbon tax on emissions instead of mandated efficiency standards. I think it would have gotten us to a similar place. But there's not anything inherently anti-market in saying "you cannot fill up collectively owned air with emissions." Libertarianism are against regulations they consider paternalistic and which prevent free exchange of goods and services -- for example, minimum wages and taxi unions.
- Pxtl 10y agoWhile small l libertarians may support that, my experience is that Libertarian political parties in the US and Canada are firmly against any action on climate change.
- MR4D 10y agoTo put an even finer point on that, big L Libertarians would like to see the governments (federal & state) stop subsidizing insurance for people who build or live in flood plains and tidal regions. So you could argue both sides of that, although I get your drift. Reason I mention that is they believe the market should be the master, and currently, the government won't let the market work in this particular area.
- saosebastiao 10y agoYou should see the things the Libertarian party fights about internally...they aren't anywhere near as unified as you claim.
- hueving 10y agoThe Libertarian parties are tiny in the US. Every libertarian person I know ends up making a sacrifice of ideals and votes with Democrat or Republican when it comes to elections. The Libertarian parties in the US are not representative of many libertarians.
- m_mueller 10y ago
- zanny 10y agoObviously compelling improvement will result in... improvement. That, or manufacturers couldn't adapt with regulations and would have to drop out of the market. The US auto industry is mature and wealthy enough to be able to handle the burden. However, in a general case, market forces should theoretically be pressuring the manufacturers to improve in that 10 year standstill. The real question is why they didn't compete. You could fill up an entire book exploring the economic motivations that might stifle that, though. There is probably some low key argument here about how these regulations price out new entries into the industry, but what was the last successful gasoline car startup in the US that survived? I remember Delorean, launched 75 and bankrupt in 82. Doesn't seem like an industry that is disruption friendly, especially when Chrysler seems to be on deaths door. I'm surprised they float every year. The only real disruption is coming from parallel industries in Tesla, and the volume of Tesla sales is a blip on Fords and GMs revenue.
- moron4hire 10y agoDelorean had an issue with its founder being a raging cokehead, using company funds to smuggle drugs into the country, so that's probably not the best example to lay at the feet of regulation.
- zanny 10y agoI'm more interested in the last attempt at a gasoline car startup that actually worked. Ford and GM absorbed a bunch of different auto makers like Cadillac and Lincoln, but most of those were founded pre-1950. My point is that there is something to it if, on one hand, the industry stagnates without forced improvement through regulation like CAFE while at the same time nobody can enter the market disruptively. Since the stagnation period indicates that trying to brush it off as legitimate competition is wrong, it implies there is market collusion or some other force impeding disruption of a noncompetitive market.
- sien 10y agoDoesn't it strike you as dubious? As in there is some way people are cooking the books. Hello VW! That the moment the government says 'though shalt be more fuel efficient' the numbers go up. Is that the mix of cars they offer for sale rather than by the numbers with real fuel economy? The US is a fair sized share of the global car market but it's not even 25% any more I think. It would be interesting to look at fleet efficiency in other countries.
- clarkmoody 10y agoWell if the government sets out to mandate something, it has the power to punish those who don't comply. So when the edict comes down to improve fuel efficiency, auto-makers comply. Other dimensions not mentioned in the article: safety and affordability. A quick search shows that the affordability of cars has declined steadily, which makes it harder for the bottom of the economic ladder to get into a car. No car means it is harder to get to a job and climb up the ladder. It looks like road fatalities have declined over time, but I couldn't find data on non-fatal injuries. Also very interesting to see a whole lot of "they" and not a lot of "we" when defining what libertarians believe.
- lend000 10y ago> median fuel effeciency due to government requirements As if engines weren't improving due to other factors as well, like market forces for lower fuel costs and improved overall technology? What if there were more sensible regulations that taxed externalities directly, like pollution taxes? This is a pointless, illogical politicization of a topic more complex than you're aware of.
- awqrre 10y agoMaybe the government should force mass transit modes... much bigger impact...
- slackingoff2017 10y agoI used to be in the auto industry and it probably has nothing to do with regulations. It's a leap in technology, analogous to the jump from carburetors to electronic fuel injection. Specifically, there's been a huge advancement in turbochargers in the last ten years. Advances like water cooling, ceramic bearings, and ceramic wheels. Turbos are far more efficient, durable, and well behaved than they were just ten year ago. The massive advancements in turbochargers coupled with dual variable valve timing and direct injection means we can get huge amounts of efficiency and power out of the tiniest of motors. Customers want power and fuel efficiency, the government mandating it did little to enhance that. There's plenty of loopholes for auto makers to skew their mileage numbers and make regulations basically useless. The driver behind faster and more efficient engines was customer demand and the technology to make it possible.
- glial 10y agoIt seems clear, to me at least, that the regulations were intended to motivate auto companies to create technology to improve fuel economy and then deploy that technology widely in production. That there has been subsequent technical advance is evidence that the regulations were effective, if anything, rather than the opposite.