8 ms·
Are we ever going to see unity between these services, or are we doomed to have little walled-off fiefdoms forever? A phone number works anywhere in the world,
by mikeash 10y ago
Are we ever going to see unity between these services, or are we doomed to have little walled-off fiefdoms forever?
A phone number works anywhere in the world, to anywhere in the world, with anyone who has a phone. All e-mail providers work with each other. I don't care who you're with, and I wouldn't even have to know except it's usually part of the address. SMS works no matter which provider we both have.
It feels like we're taking huge steps backwards. Instead of sending a message to a phone number or e-mail address, I'll use iMessage or Google Hangouts or Skype or Slack or.... Video call? We can do FaceTime or Hangouts or Skype or....
Will these things start interoperating with each other eventually, or are we just doomed forever?
- tsunamifury 10y agoThis isn't that complicated or sad. You can still call anyone in the world and still text anyone in the world. Its that the remaining spaces to compete in are feature based, and features don't move forward quickly on open standards. There are plenty of working open standards to do the basics, its if you want to do anything beyond the basics that you end up in a walled garden.
- mikeash 10y agoVideo calling and instant messaging have both been around for ages at this point, and remain stubbornly walled off. Both should qualify as "basics" by now. Sure, you can still SMS worldwide, as long as they have a cell phone. But non-phone devices are becoming very common. What if you want to send or receive messages on your tablet or computer. (This works OK in the Apple world, but only because they hack it by routing SMS through your phone.) Video calls don't even have that. E-mail, for example, was different. I started using online services when you had AOL, CompuServe, Prodigy, etc. all in their own little worlds. That didn't last very long before they all bridged their internal e-mail systems to the internet and everyone could talk to each other.
- tsunamifury 10y agoVideo Calling is a HARD problem that still has not been solved even remotely to the broader markets satisfaction. Everything from latency/compression techniques to hardware is in flux. It is a long ways away from a standard that can be easily and widely adopted and work in all scenarios.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's hard, but I disagree that it hasn't been solved. As long as your device has a built-in camera and microphone, they pretty much Just Work these days. Sure, bringing everybody together would be tough. You'd need a lot of discussion and probably glue/bridging code between different services. But it could be done! None of the big services are even trying to integrate with each other.
- guelo 10y agoWhen IP video calling started being worked on in the 90s it was via an open standards process, specifically h.323. Back then the web was driven more by engineers, before money men truly tookover. It is a miracle that the web itself has survived as one of the few open interoperable protocols. Though I think this golden period will soon end, strangled by the death of net neutrality on one side and proprietary walled gardens on the other. Ultimately, a commons is not compatible with unrestricted capitalism.
- tsunamifury 10y agoIts easy to blame money (boogey) men when you don't understand the finite problems that have held back this space.
- tomc1985 10y agoThey are also very easy to blame when you do. Productization is ruining tech.
- 10y ago
- sagethesagesage 10y agoMatrix is capable of many advanced features, and can be used as the framework for others, while being an open standard.
- curun1r 10y agoFWIW, email only sorta interoperates...try running your own mail server and unless you get all the elements of server reputation exactly right, your email will probably not get delivered to people using the large email providers. Thanks to spammers, we've allowed our open, interoperable standard to be much more closed. And SMS is also frustratingly non-universal. After years of having cell service with one of the large providers, I switched to Fi last year since I was going to be out of the country a lot. The biggest annoyance has been most short code SMS not working. Each SMS shortcode is only supported on a provider-by-provider basis. I'm not disagreeing with you, I'm just pointing out that even your examples of open, interoperable protocols are instances where we've traded some of that open interoperability for convenience.
- mikeash 10y agoGood points, both! I think it's telling that the e-mail one is a relatively recent development. Is that also the case for SMS? I'm not too familiar with the history of short codes, but I have the impression that they're newer too.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI didn't even know what shortcodes were until this moment. I think this detracts from the main point, though. Of course automated commercial services will have their idiosyncrasies, but if you want to communicate with people, phone calls and SMS seem to work reliably, worldwide, in a universal way.
- Coding_Cat 10y agoI run my own email, on a vps no less, and the only blocklist that has given me trouble is Symantec's (and a bit of Googling at the time showed it had a high false-positive rate). Google, Hotmail, etc, all work just fine. Just make sure to set up DMARC (DKIM+SPF) and TLS by default.
- baudehlo 10y agoThat's a shame since I wrote the RFC/BCP on DNS blocklists while at Symantec.
- Eridrus 10y agoI think the free nature of these services is what leads to this fragmentation. Slack is an outlier because you don't actually need to communicate with everyone in the world on Slack. But for others, it would be completely unreasonable to ask your acquaintances to pay to install Skype to talk to you. And you probably wouldn't pay for Skype if it didn't interop with whatever other people were paying for. In a world where switching costs for consumers are so low, interop becomes less important because you can ask your contacts to install an app if it's useful enough.
- noobiemcfoob 10y ago> you can ask your contacts to install an app if it's useful enough. Sure, for personal devices, but with business devices, installing an app can be a multi-month approval process.
- mikeash 10y agoSounds likely. I'd say that there's still a decent cost in terms of setting up and maintaining all these different accounts, but I'm sure many users don't see it that way, or don't care.
- tjoff 10y agoNo. I won't install a privacy invasive app (which they all are) just because you have it, never. SMS or nothing if we don't already use something else we'd rather use.
- robotresearcher 10y ago> Will these things start interoperating with each other eventually [...] ? They used to. We have open or defacto standards for texts, chat, voip, and video calls. We had/have free and paid clients available. They withered on the vine, without support from the big players.
- ribs 10y agoIt's all still quite new, and the drive to compete and gain market share keeps them separate, as it does in all industries. There will be consolidation in time. For now, it's a mixed blessing, but mostly a blessing.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoWhat's new? Messaging?
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y ago> For now, it's a mixed blessing, but mostly a blessing. In what way? You can accomplish all these things for free with your existing phone, Google Assistant, IFTTT, and very little effort. If you do it this way, your virtual assistant won't be as dumb as rocks either. Sorry, but Alexa is still riding on the short bus.
- jstandard 10y agoAlexa is positioned differently. There are typically configurable DIY solutions to most broad appeal consumer products. Many just want something that works out of the box, with minimal configuration or learning required.
- mikeash 10y agoPractical video calling has been around for a decade, and instant messaging for two or three decades. How long is it supposed to take?
- ihuman 10y agoThis problem was solved with XMPP/Jabber. Facebook and Google used to use it for their chat clients. You used to be able to use Google Talk to talk with other servers, but after a while they removed that, and then killed Google Talk. Facebook messenger used to have an XMPP-compatible API, but could never talk to other servers. I don't know why more messaging services use XMPP to bootstrap their userbase. It would allow you to switch to a new service, while you could still talk to your friends that haven't moved yet.
- Karunamon 10y agoNo, no it bloody well wasn't. XMPP is a horrible protocol with any number of incompatibilities depending on which set of XEPs your particular implementation supports and which set your clients speak. There's a reason it never took off, and it has nothing to do with corporate mendacity. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2069810 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2069810
- kalleboo 10y agoThere are plenty of horrible, incompatible protocols that are widely adopted by industry (FTP, CalDAV, IMAP, DLNA...). Where there's a will there's a way.
- dkrich 10y agoAgreed, and that's why I think iMessage and (BBM when people were using Blackberry's) are the best version of this. Two people with Apple devices can seamlessly take advantage of the Apple ecosystem or switch to SMS when communicating with a person who doesn't have an Apple device.
- tw04 10y agoI think you mean hangouts (as it was), which extended beyond the apple paywall onto PC desktops, mac desktops, linux desktops, chromebooks, android, and IOS. Too bad google can't get out of their own way and has started deprecating it with no replacement in site.
- ziikutv 10y agoThis is my biggest beef, thanks for pointing it out. All of this is great, but it adds to separation of market. In an idea l world, all of the 'big players' would sit together, and come up with a way to unify their services.
- lallysingh 10y agoWhat, jabber?
- ziikutv 10y ago:)
- test6554 10y agoEmail and phone spam also works everywhere. It's time someone did something about it with a whole new system. Calls that are not pre-whitelisted should be blocked and logged. Then at the end of the day, you should get an email summarizing all the blocked calls so you can whitelist the ones you want.
- jstandard 10y agohttps://www.truecaller.com/ https://www.truecaller.com/ does this to a certain extent. Users flag phone numbers / caller IDs as spam, giving you the discretion to block, whitelist, or subscribe to lists to autoblock common spam callers similar to adblock plug-ins.
- Spoom 10y agoThat is supposed to be what WebRTC is for. But major companies with their own motives are running the the major video chat solutions.
- MurMan 10y agoWebRTC defines how the browser supports audio/video/chat endpoints. A practical video calling system needs servers to manage firewall traversal, a directory of users, and ways to admin the system. Who's going to provide that at no cost?
- seanp2k2 10y agoXMPP too. It can do video calling: https://xmpp.org/about/technology-overview.html https://xmpp.org/about/technology-overview.html Sad that Google + Facebook pulled out of federation a long time ago. We could have had bring-your-own-client cross-network all of this stuff. We still can, but realistically we won't.
- pgroves 10y agoMore optimistically, it could be a step toward solving the problem if it adopted a Roku-like model where all those apps are installed and logged in at all times and you can pick one from a standardized menu. On Roku you can go to Netflix, Hulu, and single-channel apps like A&E. Bonus points if there is a standard way to 'get a call' or 'search for a contact' that cuts across the video conf apps.
- conradev 10y agoiOS 10 supports this with CallKit. The "Call" action in the Phone UI can call through Skype, Messenger, WhatsApp, FaceTime, etc. and receiving a call looks like the native phone UI.
- swalsh 10y agoI'm working for a startup that is trying to solve that problem :D