6 ms·
Strong beliefs, loosely held
- nerdponx 10y agohttps://xkcd.com/1273/ https://xkcd.com/1273/
- gonmf 10y agoI mean come on, is an article with pictures such as: https://lisacharlotterost.github.io/pic/170509_Republica_Talk84.png https://lisacharlotterost.github.io/pic/170509_Republica_Tal... worth discussing? What's next, the right-wing field sharing articles of IQ across racial groups?
- tzs 10y agoYou apparently found it interesting enough to get to that picture, which is pretty far down in a fairly long article. That would indicate that it has some worth.
- kevinwang 10y agoWhat do you think that picture is meant to say? To me, it is meant to convey that regardless of political affiliation, more "intelligence" makes you believe in your convictions more strongly, whereas - regardless of political affiliation - being more curious barely affects your beliefs, except to make you less skeptical of global warming. So I didn't see that image as bigoted.
- kup0 10y agoIt isn't claiming that one side is more intelligent than the other. It's talking about curiosity vs. intelligence and how that affects how people of different belief-sets agree or disagree with a given statement. You're really inferring a lot from this image that isn't there. It is clear there isn't an intent for this image to be "Dems are smarter than Repubs", but it's very telling that that is all you get from it.
- ythn 10y agoI liked the content, but I didn't like the conclusion. If you have a strong belief I feel like you should be able to strongly hold (i.e. defend) it. The philosophy "strong beliefs, loosely held" will just breed rabid dogs that obey whomever has the most convincing evidence (note that convincing evidence is not necessarily strong evidence). For example, watch this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ag4HN_jeYV4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ag4HN_jeYV4 Purple is obviously the villain here, right? Grab your pitchforks! Now read this: https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/69xqxh/reviewer_asks_question_about_product_safety_and/dhavgpv/ https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/69xqxh/reviewer_ask... Now it seems clear that the video creator was hiding something and that Purple is justified in their actions. Lynch the youtuber! Now read the youtuber's response to that and be prepared to grab your pitchforks again... I'm of the opinion that weak beliefs should be weakly held and strong beliefs should be strongly held. Something that you haven't studied yourself should be a weak belief, weakly held. Something that's only been on the news for a few days with very few actual facts should be a weak belief, weakly held (i.e. Ahmed Mohammed, Michael Brown, etc). Something you've studied or experienced over an extensive period should be a strong belief, strongly held since you are an expert.
- cbanek 10y agoThat's an interesting point. For most beliefs, they are pretty long held and tend to move slowly (morality), but it's interesting to consider how science changes and what people's thoughts on that are, and recent quick changes in beliefs. Example, diet fads, or what new thing causes or prevents cancer (red wine/chocolate/low carb/high carb). Some people really strongly hold these beliefs, and they do get moved around when new beliefs come out. To their detriment, usually (especially with diet fads). I'd rather have someone have a strongly questioned strong belief, a weakly held weak belief, and the ability to know that just because you believe something doesn't make it exist.
- Retric 10y agoNone of that is enough to get to a strong belief. Weak beliefs weakly held is a common and perfectly reasonable stance. The important part of weak beliefs is to not make major changes based on them. Now some things like gravity are very strong beliefs. But, you should be open to the possibility that something else is going on even with gravity. That does not mean you should stop believing in gravity based on a slick YouTube video, but rather accept that with solid evedince something else might be going on.
- draw_down 10y agoI've seen people mention this concept before. But how strong is a belief really, if you're not sure whether it's worth holding on to?
- Retric 10y agoSometimes I think bridging the gap is important. People rarely get offended when you talk about Humans causing an increase in carbon dioxide. It's not something they need to get offended about and the cause > result is obvious. Them talk about effects of CO2. Does it help plants grow or hurt athletic performance.
- ythn 10y agoPeople mostly get offended when you start demonizing them by comparing them to holocaust deniers. The problem I see is that people are more interested in convincing people that climate change will have apocalyptic consequences than they are in discussing solutions to the problem.
- Retric 10y agoI don't nessisarily think we need to do anything. It's like NYC gets flooded, well ok sucks for them, but not exactly a life or death issue for 100's of millions. Perhaps the will build a dike, perhaps they will move, or perhaps someone is going to dredge the oceans making artificial mountains to side step that problem whatever not going to affect me much. People get really wound up in these ideas, but the existence or non existence of the moon landing has no real impact on me. It's like sure people are dumb, at what point did you assume people where intelegent and rational because that's clearly not the case.
- bsder 10y agoThis doesn't address the problem of how to deal with someone who doesn't WANT to correct their worldview. That's the real problem. I start off too many conversations with: "Look, if you want to talk about <position>, fine. However, you have to tell me up front what evidence you will accept that your position is wrong. If you can't do that, then this is a harangue and not a debate or discussion."
- yunoe 10y agoThis is a pretty ironic comment though. The article is basically arguing that our views, to a large degree, are based on our previous held ideas and that the way to remedy that is by taking a more complex and serious view of things. And now you're essentially saying "ignore that, here's what I think" in reference to the article.
- bsder 10y agoExcept that this doesn't work. Or, perhaps more appropriately, it doesn't work faster than the forces spewing misinformation work. Converting people one at a time doesn't work when the opposition is converting them via mass media.
- UweSchmidt 10y agoOh sure, no doubt others are so wrong and the struggle is so real. It is easy to see the flaw in others' arguments, but the true challenge is to identify your own biases and irrational worldviews.
- bsder 10y ago> Oh sure, no doubt others are so wrong and the struggle is so real. And sometimes you ARE objectively right. Truth DOES exist. This false equivalence that social validation is equivalent to being correct is what got us to this point. And that's the trick to finding your own biases. Which of your beliefs are based on "social validation" rather than any notion of evidence? Which of your beliefs requires you to dismiss actual facts to the contrary?
- amelius 10y agoI'm afraid this is too abstract for the intended audience.
- mac01021 10y agoWho is the intended audience?
- tabeth 10y agoThis article doesn't address what I believe to be the actual problem: why should you "believe" in facts to begin with? Despite popular belief, there's no inherent reason to believe in facts. You could argue that factual information can make you money, however that's not necessary true. One can become quite rich by spreading lies, actually. So... why believe in facts at all? The answer to this will generally include some intellectual elitism, driving away the group I describe in the first paragraph even further. People might use words such as correct and right, but those words already impose a value judgement to begin with, only further begging the question.
- lgas 10y agoThe value in having (true) beliefs comes in being able to predict the future more accurately and therefore make better decisions.
- fictioncircle 10y agoTbpfh, that is only true for people of above average ability to remain calm in the face of failure. I've seen many, many people make dumb decision after dumb decision despite having all the facts because of emotions.
- fnovd 10y agoWhen irrational actors are the ones making decisions, knowing facts won't necessarily help you and may end up coming back to bite you. As they say, the world around you can stay irrational longer than you can stay sane.
- lgas 10y agoI was referring to you, the individual as being the decision maker. If you are irrational there's nothing I can do to help you. The reason we should want to believe true beliefs is the same reason we should want to not be irrational.
- travmatt 10y agoKnowing that fact sounds very useful...
- xupybd 10y agoInteresting, the author uses the 97% of scientists agree the human activity has caused climate change statistic. I do think we have but that stat is terrible and misleading. The paper it comes from is dubious at best. Referring to that in an article like this is a little ironic.
- guelo 10y agoI just skimmed through this paper that supports the 97% consensus and nothing jumped out at me to suspect the paper is "dubious". It seemed like a strong conclusion to me. http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/4/048002/meta;jsessionid=E5246116C465592C9FE0F33CC2A1129D.c2.iopscience.cld.iop.org http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/4/048... What issues are there with that paper?
- xupybd 10y agoThanks you, I was only aware of the problems raised with Cooks 2013 paper. I was not aware that new research backing it up. You have changed my opinion. But I would say that it's worth noting there is criticism of the original paper http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/4/048001/meta http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/4/048.... But as I said you've changed my mind, the 97% figure seems to be accurate.
- mrslave 10y agoIn addressing the question of 97% consensus of blah (where blah varies)..., and not the paper specifically, this article provides a good summary of the quality of this figure: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/425232/climate-change-no-its-not-97-percent-consensus-ian-tuttle http://www.nationalreview.com/article/425232/climate-change-... The “97 percent” statistic first appeared prominently in a 2009 study by University of Illinois master’s student Kendall Zimmerman and her adviser, Peter Doran. Based on a two-question online survey, Zimmerman and Doran concluded that “the debate on the authenticity of global warming and the role played by human activity is largely nonexistent among those who understand the nuances and scientific bases of long-term climate processes” — even though only 5 percent of respondents, or about 160 scientists, were climate scientists. In fact, the “97 percent” statistic was drawn from an even smaller subset: the 79 respondents who were both self-reported climate scientists and had “published more than 50% of their recent peer-reviewed papers on the subject of climate change.” These 77 scientists agreed that global temperatures had generally risen since 1800, and that human activity is a “significant contributing factor.”
- cjsthompson 10y agoA really good article, which makes me wonder if women are more likely to have strong beliefs which are loosely held as their social value overall does not depend as much on tribalization.