15 ms·
Norway's Progress Party calls for ban on circumcision for boys
- mmastrac 10y agoI don't understand how parents are allowed to make major, irreversible, cosmetic medical decisions for children on their behalf. I'm not against circumcision, but it should be the choice of someone who is able to consent.
- collyw 10y agoReligion always seems to get special benefits.
- grandalf 10y agoAbsolutely. That we tolerate genital mutilation of infants and that many people think it's OK/normal just illustrates how powerful the forces of convention are in swaying our views/beliefs. Genital mutilation is part of the general trend of subjugating children and depriving them of rights. Just because we've banned child labor in the US does not mean we've gone far enough.
- ythn 10y agoDo does that mean all circumcised males are brainwashed and were all subjugated and deprived of rights as children?
- grandalf 10y ago> brainwashed No but the parents who did it may have been. > subjugated and deprived of rights as children Those who were mutilated without giving consent were harmed in a way that could be significant. I certainly would not consent to it as an adult.
- ythn 10y ago> I certainly would not consent to it as an adult. Nor would I. However, if I could go back in time and retroactively give my parents consent to do it when I wouldn't remember it, then I would.
- grandalf 10y agoWhy not just go under anesthesia and have it done? You won't remember a thing!
- dade_ 10y agoVery personal question, but if you don't mind sharing: Why do you want to be circumcised? As it is a minor surgery and very low risk, and as I understand it, the pain is easily managed with medication so why won't you consider it? I am not encouraging anyone to do anything, just interested in your perspective.
- fiatjaf 10y agoWell, parents are allowed to mark their children with musical taste, their political views, their habits, their values. These are also irreversible. Parents are allowed to feed their children the way they want, to take their children to spots where they might get a disease, to pass on their own diseases to their children. Parents are allowed even to pass on their genes, which may contain horrible psychological tendencies, to their children.
- Brotkrumen 10y ago"Other bad things happen so we shouldnt try to improve this Bad thing!"
- hamandcheese 10y agoI think the parent is just pointing out that the outrage seems a bit disproportionate. There are far more damaging things a parent can do that most people accept, whereas the actual effect circumcision has on your life is basically zero.
- Brotkrumen 10y agoIf that's the argument, I'm not convinced. We as a society try to influence the saner parts of what parent mentioned, such as values and pox parties. Passing on genes, well we generally don't want to prevent that, because, contrary to forbidding circumcision, the cure would be worse than the disease.
- fiatjaf 10y ago> contrary to forbidding circumcision That's the part when you introduce your values and your judgement and try to make it sound as if everybody agrees.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dbansk 10y ago
- akamaka 10y agoI know someone who had to have a circumcision as an adult. If he decides to have the procedure performed on his son to avoid the same problems he had, then I will respect his choice.
- moshei 10y agoBy the age you would be able to consent (between 13 and 18 years depending on country) it would be a major surgical procedure involving days or weeks of pain, not the few minutes a baby experiences. Babies are remarkable in their ability to heal and adapt.
- bluefox 10y agoI too do not understand how parents can be allowed to force someone into existence without prior approval from said someone. Their parentland (motherland or fatherland, though I suppose there may be other categories nowadays) should surely not allow them to do so. Speaking of parentlands, why are they allowed to make major decisions for their childizens on their behalf? Even if some of the childizens approve, surely the others should be free to decide for themselves. Unfortunately we cannot bring this issue to that parentless entity in charge, who has never had anyone else decide something on its behalf. It may in time decide to look into the matter and inform us of its decision.
- spraak 10y agoIt's genital mutilation. There's no medical reason [1]. Yes, having a foreskin means you need to clean it regularly (or your caregiver if you're a baby). And then there are disgusting things like this [2]: > In a practice that takes place during a ceremony known as the bris, a circumcision practitioner, or mohel, removes the foreskin from the baby's penis, and with his mouth sucks the blood from the incision to cleanse the wound. [1] Just like anything, there are exceptions. Some people have their foreskin removed because it has an infection or something similar. That shouldn't be applied to all foreskins, and even so, most of that is preventable with good hygiene. [2] http://abcnews.go.com/Health/baby-dies-herpes-virus-ritual-circumcision-nyc-orthodox/story?id=15888618 http://abcnews.go.com/Health/baby-dies-herpes-virus-ritual-c...
- exhilaration 10y agoI found a big exception to your blanket statements: There is compelling evidence that male circumcision reduces the risk of heterosexually acquired HIV infection in men by approximately 60%. Three randomized controlled trials have shown that male circumcision provided by well trained health professionals in properly equipped settings is safe. WHO/UNAIDS recommendations emphasize that male circumcision should be considered an efficacious intervention for HIV prevention in countries and regions with heterosexual epidemics, high HIV and low male circumcision prevalence. http://www.who.int/hiv/topics/malecircumcision/en/ http://www.who.int/hiv/topics/malecircumcision/en/
- EliRivers 10y agoI'm sure there are a lot of physical mutilations we could make to people that would reduce the chances of various diseases. Nonetheless, I think there's a moral issue in slicing up children (or adults) for this reason. Do our bodies belong to ourselves, to the government, to someone's god, or to the people around us? Not that I'm saying you're advocating it; just continuing the train of thought.
- grandalf 10y agoGreat point.
- sidlls 10y agoThis is great. Genital mutilation is a wretched practice and should be abolished everywhere.
- fiatjaf 10y agoWhat if someone thinks you should be abolished and vote to do that democratically?
- oblio 10y agoLet's see if we can make a sort of equivalence between your statements: Him: wants to ban an act which is basically minor surgery performed (for no obvious medical benefit) on someone who is underage and can't refuse the operation. You: want to hold a popular vote which would decide if he should be killed because of his opinion.
- fiatjaf 10y agoI know, it is absurd, that's the whole point of reductio ad absurdum.
- bluejekyll 10y agoWe tried this in San Francisco and it gets dragged into some crazy anti-religious fight. It's about the rights of the baby, not about some religion's outdated beliefs. Children should be free of mutilation, regardless of their religion.
- Boothroid 10y agoExactly. And last time I checked Jewish people have a place to live that is violently protective of their way of life, namely Israel.
- dogma1138 10y agoMuslims also perform male circumcision it's called Khitan.
- Boothroid 10y agoThe article is about Jews/Israel: 'Regarding the Norwegian bill, Margolin said: “We will act in every way we can to fight this disgraceful bill... There is no doubt that this is an anti-Jewish decision that is blatantly antisemitic, because the bill does not harm Muslims who are not obligated to circumcise their children as infants and can perform the procedure even at an older ages as the bill allows.”'
- bluejekyll 10y agoPlease don't make this about any specific religion's practices. That wasn't exactly my point. Only that the welfare of the child should trump religion. In the US there is also a practice that all? hospitals offer this practice as just an additional procedure after birth. This should be stopped, and that is non-religious, it's almost worse because it's nearly thoughtless.
- Boothroid 10y agoHang on a minute - the article is explicitly about Jews/Israel!!! 'Jewish leader urges Israel to exert political influence in fight for religious freedom in Europe.'
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoIt's worth noting that male circumcision in the West is a relatively recent phenomenon, established in the 19th century by quack science and promoted by British and American doctors and industrialists as a way to discourage masturbation in boys. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_male_circumcision https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_male_circumcision
- ythn 10y agoShould we also ban the piercing of infant ears?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Boothroid 10y agoProbably, yes.
- ythn 10y agoGood, as long as you are morally consistent. I can't stand the hypocrisy of people that claim it's evil to circumcise your son but not evil to have your daughter's ears pierced.
- InitialLastName 10y agoI agree with you that infants shouldn't have their ears pierced, but let's all acknowledge that moral consistency can be allowed to draw a line somewhere below "permanent, irreparable damage that reduces function."
- 0xbadcafebee 10y agoWhy the hell would someone pierce an infant's ears???
- amscanne 10y agoThis is very common in Latin American cultures. In Mexico, they literally do it at the hospital before you leave. (They don't do this in the U.S., but a good portion of Latin Americans - I'd wager majority - will get it done at six months.)
- grandalf 10y agoWhile I would not do it to an infant, it's not a sex organ and will restore to fully healed/closed status if left alone for a few weeks, so it's hard to compare this to removing part of a sex organ that will not re-grow.
- ythn 10y agoThis is one of those topics where people have extremely strong opinions, yet the vast majority of people affected by this practice (circumcised males) have no opinion or even a favorable opinion of their circumcision.
- vincnetas 10y agoI guess you have to just accept it if you have been circumcised, because you can't undo that. By you i mean anyone who has been circumcised. So this is like cognitive dissonance, you don't want to eat that cheese if you know that it can't be reached...
- jquery 10y agoConsidering the studies show that the cheese they can't reach is either slightly worse, slightly better, or the same, it's pretty understandable they'd get offended when told their cheese is mutilated.
- Declanomous 10y agoDo you have any any evidence to back that claim up?
- RightMillennial 10y agoHere's one data point to back up ythn. I was circumcised as an infant. I'm glad my father chose to have the procedure done so that I didn't have to go through the uncomfortable recovery period as an adult. I would have done it regardless for religious reasons with the medical reason as a bonus. If I have any sons, they will be circumcised as infants. That being said, I don't care whether you are or if your sons are circumcised or not. However, I do care if you infringe on the rights of parents to do what they think is best for their children whether it's for medical, cultural, or religious reasons.
- GordonS 10y ago> I do care if you infringe on the rights of parents to do what they think is best for their children whether it's for medical, cultural, or religious reasons Serious question: how far should that be allowed to go? What if someone believes cutting off their child's earlobe is best for their child (for the sake of an example)? As I see it, religious freedom does not mean you get to do whatever you want with no comeback.
- vincnetas 10y agoCutting of dogs ears or tail is not ok, even illegal somewhere , but somehow it's ok to do similar things with your baby, because of ... because of religion? Might be my dog is Pastafarian. Is it ok then to cut of his ears?
- adamnemecek 10y agoIt's not even religion, it's convention.
- quotemstr 10y agoI love this particular controversy. It really highlights how most political opinions don't come from specific applications of universal principles, but from ingroup-outgroup signaling and status quo bias. A little part of my smiles whenever I see hypocrisy exposed.
- jquery 10y agoThere's a lot of yelling and very little dialogue. It doesn't make me smile at all.
- jacknews 10y agohttps://www.google.com.kh/search?q=circumcision+damage https://www.google.com.kh/search?q=circumcision+damage http://madsciencewriter.blogspot.com/2013/05/the-foreskin-why-is-it-such-secret-in.html http://madsciencewriter.blogspot.com/2013/05/the-foreskin-wh...
- pugio 10y agoLet's add some nuance: Circumcision, for (orthodox) Jews, is one of the most fundamental conditions for identification and belonging to that group. Leaving a Jewish male baby uncircumcised would most likely lead to feelings of alienation and isolation later on in life – feelings which could have significant psychological impact and could largely negate the benefits one gains from strong communal structures. Regardless of the process's inherent morality, a blanket ban may cause more harm than good. Cultures have dependency trees, like a Jenga tower: remove one block, even one that, in isolation, is a negative, and you risk destabilizing the entire structure and causing significantly more net harm than that single negative you erased. More generally, I'd propose a corollary to Chesterson's fence [1]: Before you (in righteous external-observer outrage) destroy an element of a culture, make sure you understand what role that element plays, and what harm you may cause with such heavy handed destruction. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#Chesterton.27s_fence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#Chesterton.27...
- wyager 10y agoThe same is true for female genital mutilation in certain Islamic cultures. I still don't think "it's culturally important" is a reasonable defense, and I doubt you do either. And just to cut off this objection, the vast majority of female circumcision involves removal of the clitoral hood, which is (mutatis mutandis) anatomically equivalent to removal of the foreskin and has similar effects and risks.
- gotchange 10y agoBy the way, FGM is not an exclusively Islamic tradition in some Muslim-majority countries. There are certain non-Muslim African communities that engage in these awful practices.
- EGreg 10y agoYou are factually wrong about the majority of FGM removing just the foreskin. Most FGM is type II https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_mutilation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_mutilation Saying it has similar effects and risks is just handwaving. And it is largely practiced in Africa, where tribal ritualistic bodily modification has remained a much bigger thing (compared to the rest of the world). Consider women who stretch their lips with disks to attract men etc.
- claar 10y agoGenesis 17:9-14 and Leviticus 12:1-3 do not give Jews any leeway in this practice. I may not be Jewish (though I am Christian and circumcised), and I realize my American values do not directly apply in Norway, but freedom of religion is a basic human right. Devout religious followers would have no choice but to "obey God rather than men", so laws like this proposed ban are simply a veiled authorization of persecution.
- wyager 10y ago> freedom of religion is a basic human right. Freedom of religion means the state can't tell you what to believe. It emphatically does not mean that you have carte-blanche authority to do whatever crazy stuff your religion asks you to do, including murdering infidels or performing cosmetic surgery on babies.
- claar 10y ago> does not mean that you have carte-blanche authority to do whatever crazy stuff your religion asks you to do And how shall we decide what constitutes "crazy stuff"? In Daniel 6:4-9, it was decided that it was unlawful to make a petition to any god or man except the king. In fact, this was done explicitly to provide an excuse to persecute Daniel. To help illuminate the issue, what if Hinduism required nose piercing at 8 days, instead of Jews with circumcision? Some in this thread find piercing babies to be wrong, while others find it acceptable. Who gets to decide? And what about the poor Hindu who is now jailed for the practice? It's ironic to me how easy people find it to run merrily down this slippery slope, and yet complain so readily when their own freedoms are infringed.
- DanBC 10y agoIf a religion required nose piercing at 8 days that would be a mutilation, with some risks of additional harm, and no medical benefit (at the time it's done), and so it would be banned.
- deleted 10y ago
- relics443 10y agoThe debate here seems to boil down to(from my Orthodox Jewish perspective at least): 1. There is a subjective morality that says a parent must not make decisions for a child that will affect it in a manner that could possibly be perceived as negative 2. There is a subjective morality that says to follow your religion, and one aspect of the religion is circumcising your son at 8 days old The people ascribing to the first believe it to be an objective morality. The people ascribing to the second believe it to be an objective morality. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- cryptarch 10y agoWould both subjective moralities taken to the extreme arrive at similarly harmful conclusions, though? 1. Not giving your child tattoos, piercings or a circumcision. 2. Female genital mutilation.
- Balgair 10y agoWow, now THIS is an off-topic flame-war thread for HN if I ever saw one....
- sarahtine25 10y agoI was cured of HIV with the used of natural herbs. My name is Sarah and am from US. I love herbs so much. Most times, injection and drugs are just a waste of time. I was cured 8months ago, i suffered from HIV for 13yrs but with the help of DR. Baba Ogu herbal medicine, i was cured within few weeks of drinking the herbs he sent to me through courier delivery service. This same doctor also cured my Aunt from herpes, as soon as i heard she had herpes, i quickly refer her to Dr. Baba Ogu and she was cured too after drinking his herbs.I have referred more than 15 persons to Dr. Baba Ogu and they were all cured from their various illness. Have you taken herbs before?. You have spent so much money on drugs,injections,surgeries etc and yet you have no good result to show for it. Contact Dr. Baba Ogu now, he is a herbalist doctor, i assured you of a cure if you drink his natural herbs. Dr Baba Ogu have herbs that cures Hiv, Herpes, diabetics, asthma, hepatitis,HBP, STD, cancer, chronic, etc. He is also a spell caster, he can cast a spell to bring back your EX lover. Contact Dr. Baba Ogu through his Email address on: drbabaogu@gmail.com or WHATSAP/CALL him on +2348137291215. Share the good news to other people once you are cured. Thank you.
- sarahtine25 10y agoI was cured of HIV with the used of natural herbs. My name is Sarah and am from US. I love herbs so much. Most times, injection and drugs are just a waste of time. I was cured 8months ago, i suffered from HIV for 13yrs but with the help of DR. Baba Ogu herbal medicine, i was cured within few weeks of drinking the herbs he sent to me through courier delivery service. This same doctor also cured my Aunt from herpes, as soon as i heard she had herpes, i quickly refer her to Dr. Baba Ogu and she was cured too after drinking his herbs.I have referred more than 15 persons to Dr. Baba Ogu and they were all cured from their various illness. Have you taken herbs before?. You have spent so much money on drugs,injections,surgeries etc and yet you have no good result to show for it. Contact Dr. Baba Ogu now, he is a herbalist doctor, i assured you of a cure if you drink his natural herbs. Dr Baba Ogu have herbs that cures Hiv, Herpes, diabetics, asthma, hepatitis,HBP, STD, cancer, chronic, etc. He is also a spell caster, he can cast a spell to bring back your EX lover. Contact Dr. Baba Ogu through his Email address on: drbabaogu@gmail.com or WHATSAP/CALL him on +2348137291215. Share the good news to other people once you are cured. Thank you.