9 ms·
More Android phones than ever are covertly listening for inaudible sounds in ads
- phreack 10y agoThis is the work of a library used by certain apps, not of Google (although it wouldn't surprise me if Google turned out to be doing the same, discreetly). I think Android should have way clearer notifications that your mic or camera are being used in the background, like iOS does, even if it may be cumbersome.
- bryanatwood 10y agoYes there should be an icon when your mic is active. I tried to build a service in Android to do this but there's no API to get whether the mic is in use or not AFAIK. I ended up disabling mic access for almost all apps, but the Google App and Google Play Services complain when you do this.
- CoolGuySteve 10y agoI'd go even further and light the notification LED the entire time something is reading the camera/mic from the firmware (such that applications can't disable it via software). The indicator works well for the webcams on most laptops.
- Grazester 10y agoNotification LED? A majority of phones(in the US) don't come with this and the ones that do need root permission to access it.
- lemuurd 10y agoyou are correct, but this was mostly brought up for historical reasons: researchers discovered an osx malware that after disabling the camera LED on older macbooks could secretly record the owner.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoI'd go even even further and have a physical switch on the device. I want absolute certainty that my devices are incapable of spying on me when they are switched off.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoYeah, that's wishful thinking. Because even if there were such a switch, it would be deliberately perverted. E.g. some SD cards have a "write-protect notch" the status of which can be changed by physically moving a sliding tab. Very reminiscent of write protect on floppy disks. Here's the gotcha[1]: The presence of a notch, and the presence and position of a tab, have no effect on the SD card's operation. A host device that supports write protection should refuse to write to an SD card that is designated read-only in this way. Some host devices do not support write protection, which is an optional feature of the SD specification. Drivers and devices that do obey a read-only indication may give the user a way to override it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Digital#Features https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Digital#Features
- pdkl95 10y agoThe LED should be in series with e.g. the Vcc pin on the ADC. Enabling the recording hardware needs to depend on the LED being on.
- overcyn 10y agoSo it would always be on if you use OK Google?
- nine_k 10y agoThis is exactly the idea. Be aware that you're being listened to.
- jsz0 10y agoThat's a great idea. Even better if there were tiny dedicated LEDs near the front facing camera and microphone to make it 100% clear what they mean. Communication privacy laws also need to be updated for modern times. It's a federal offense to steal someone's junk mail yet widespread electronic surveillance is somehow a business model.
- nom 10y agoI wouldn't be surprised if Google, Apple or Amazon are doing (or going to do) something similar. It doesn't create much traffic at all, a couple of bytes is enough and they can be tacked on to the data stream without anyone noticing. Someone should build an ultrasonic detector that can recognize these kind of packets and have a look how wide spread this technique already is. We could also need an ultrasonic jammer and ways to add low pass filters to our mics, like some special tape we can place over it to absorb the high frequencies... maybe normal duct tape is already enough.. hmmm
- pcl 10y agoIf you're interested in exploring ultrasound in your environment, SpectrumView Plus is a great tool for the job. http://www.oxfordwaveresearch.com/products/spectrumviewapp/ http://www.oxfordwaveresearch.com/products/spectrumviewapp/
- nom 10y agoNice tool, thanks for the link! However, we need someone to build an app that can detect ultrasonic FSK signals and log them / pop up a notification. I assume they use short bursts which makes looking at the spectrum constantly unfeasible.
- irq 10y agoApple would never do something like this. It's totally against their MO.
- EliRivers 10y agoApple is made of people. People who change, people who come and go. Maybe Apple today wouldn't, but tomorrow Apple will be a different company.
- p49k 10y agoApple's OS design philosophy makes this extremely difficult, even if someone wanted to sneak it in. The OS notifies of such activity (mic active) on a system level, and the permission model requires explicit permission at time of first access attempt, even for most of Apple's own apps.
- mistermann 10y agoI'd like to be able to find an Android utility that shows me apps/processes that are auto-launching in the background and kill them, but my last attempt yielded two that I tried and blacklisted (a feature it has) some apps, yet after booting I was still able to force stop them, implying they still had launched on their own. Is there any app that actually works for this, or is it somehow not possible?
- nether 10y agook.
- baobrain 10y agoNot sure if it's exactly what you're looking for, but greenify might do the trick. You might need root. Also Android now has the doze feature that should hibernate apps by default when not used. [0]https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.oasisfeng.greenify https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.oasisfeng.... [1]https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/greenify https://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/greenify
- Markoff 10y agothat's quite amusing suggestion considering Greenify is closed sourced Chinese root app which optionally (only?) report data back to mainland China and dev worked for some companies producing shady apps, before according his LinkedIn profile
- voidz 10y agoCould you back this up / substantiate your claim, please?
- Markoff 10y agothere is option to send some statistics data back to developer, it's opt-in I am not saying he is actualy sending some other data without permission of user, but being closed sourced Chinese ROOT app is more than enough to stay away from it in days of Nougat/Marshmallow making this app pretty much useless anyway.
- rubatuga 10y agoWhy does android trust developers so much? Just lock down the apps already, and make microphone usage obvious.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- izacus 10y agoBecause we already have a locked-down platform and you're welcome to use it.
- rubatuga 10y agoWhich I do use, if you mean iOS. I'm advocating for further development of android, which hopefully stimulates some more competition. Or maybe it's a good thing that Android is so broken in a privacy sense. It allows government + malicious entities to target it much easier instead of iOS devices, leaving me safer. /s
- izacus 10y agoYou're missing the fact that we're using Android because it's NOT locked down and just like malicious apps can use hardware in background... that actually lets useful apps use hardware in background as well. Free market at its best - if you want a corporation to babysit you, you have a platform. If you don't (and want to accept consequences) you can use another one. Great for all of us.
- djrogers 10y agoNothing in iOS prevents an app from using the microphone in the background - I use apps that do it all the time. When I do however, there is a big, obvious, red bar at the top of my screen to remind me/let me know that it's happening. Why dont the android designers want to do something like that?
- 10y ago
- izacus 10y agoArsTechnica unfortunately again misleads people due to limited expertise. On modern Androids (6.0+) accessing the microphone requires an explicit permission granted by user (just like on iOS). Furthermore, due to Doze mode implemented in 6.0 and expanded in 7.0 running these kind of services without notifying the user cleary (with permanent notification) has become pretty much impossible and unreliable. To run in background when the phone isn't in active use the service needs to be marked "Foreground" which demands a permanent notification. Having said that - Google is failing here in several ways. First, they STILL let apps be published that don't target Android 6.0. Apps that target older Androids get permissions granted at install time (those can be revoked, but user needs to go to settings for that). There's no reason to let people publish new apps that don't adhere to new permission model, but Google just doesn't care. They also need to clearly mark use of system resources in the background - just like we have the GPS icon, we need a clear indication of active microphone, speaker and other hardware modules while running in the backgorund.
- macawfish 10y agoYes, I agree, including gyroscopes. As well as a way of seeing which apps are using the sensors.
- oneshot908 10y agoI would love love love if my Android phone would occasionally provide me a summary of which apps are making use of the camera, the GPS, and the microphone and allow me to disable them. Sure, I can hunt for this on my own. That's not the point here. If I'm walking around with a supercomputer in my pocket, I'd like it to do this sort of stuff for me automagically.
- izacus 10y agoSettings -> Apps -> Gear icon in the top bar -> App permissions should do what you want (at least it does on 7.1.2 / Pixel). Not obvious I know :/
- cwyers 10y agoNearly 2/3rds of Android phones that have accessed the Google Play store in the week leading up to May 2nd are not on Android 6 or later: https://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html https://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html
- terminado 10y agoIs it possible to damage human hearing with sufficiently loud pulses above 20Khz? Most search results point to a miniscule wattage delivered by typical ultrasonic noises, but controlling for wattage, I feel like it might be possible to overdrive a high-frequency pulse to deliver more wattage in the same range. Also, relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinavia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinavia
- amelius 10y agoI don't know but I would say that if the ear does not pick up the energy above 20khz, then it cannot be harmed either.
- slaveofallah93 10y agoWell you would be wrong.
- joshvm 10y agoYour eyes are also unable to see infrared, or ultra-violet, yet either with sufficient power will blind you. In fact it's often much more dangerous than visible light, because the light won't trigger your blink reflex. Sound is just vibration in the air, and if the pressure is high enough, you're going to suffer. High frequency ultrasound is used for various medical treatments, most of which involve localised killing of cells. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_focused_ultrasound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_focused_ultraso...
- thaumasiotes 10y ago>> I would say that if the ear does not pick up the energy above 20khz, then it cannot be harmed either. > Your eyes are also unable to see infrared, or ultra-violet, yet either with sufficient power will blind you. Sufficient power delivered by IR radiation can easily set you on fire, regardless of whether the part of you that's burning was sensitive to light or not. And UV can do much nastier things. But it's hard for them to have any effect without depositing energy. It's absolutely correct that if an ear, or anything else, doesn't pick up energy from whatever you're throwing at it, it cannot be harmed. Why worry about hearing specifically as a target for ultrasonic damage? As you yourself point out, sound can deposit energy regardless of the particular physical structure it's hitting. Delivering enough IR to the ear will destroy your hearing, but not because of any property of your hearing or your ears. Is there reason to believe that ears or hearing are more sensitive to ultrasound than, say, your nose is?
- jameslk 10y agoThere's an app called D-Vasive (no affiliation) that alerts of mic and camera usage on your phone. I've been using it for years, but it's only alerted me in predictable situations so far. I don't download a whole lot of apps however. It’s nice to have as a bit of peace of mind.
- macawfish 10y agoI've become totally superstitious (convinced, even) that phones are listening to more than just ultrasound. There have been too many uncanny situations where youtube or google have recommended results that were far too specific to the conversation happening moments before. For example, one time I was telling my girlfriend about fourier transformations, something she'd never heard of before. She typed "Fo" into her phone. "Fourier transormation" it suggested. Maybe this was due to the IP address we were connected through. That alone is creepy enough as it is. Sometimes I wonder if it isn't something more though. Facebook messenger and google voice search are my number one suspects. But moreso, all it takes is a single person in a room full of phones to have installed an app that's using the microphone unethically, and suddenly everyone's conversation is being turned into marketing/spy data. Anybody who's connected somehow to that location is going to be statistically associated ("implicated") with this data.
- scottlegrand2 10y agoNo common friends, but college girlfriend recommended as potential friend on Facebook is my creepiest data mining moment ever.
- anchpop 10y agoIf she searched for you, it can make you show up in the recommended friends list
- H4CK3RM4N 10y agoI think that works based on location. A few years ago there were reports of people who shared a psychiatrist being recommended to each other, based on their frequent visits to the office.
- moioci 10y agoWhat about friends who are two degrees of separation? I suspect your social graphs are closer than you might realize.
- elFarto 10y agoI've had this with someone who I emailed (completely separate from Facebook) being recommended to me. The only logical conclusion I could come to is that Facebook was mining their emails for contacts.
- oneshot908 10y agoBetween this and the recent research paper I read about using the front-facing camera on mobile phones to track where I'm looking on web pages, I just want to unplug.
- dbrian82 10y agohi,i'm Brian, i had my friend help me hack my ex's email, facebook, whatsapp,and his phone cause i suspected he was cheating. all he asked for was a his phone number. he's email is (hotcyberlord425@gmail.com (mailto:hotcyberlord425@gmail.com))..IF u need help tell him Brian referred you to him and he'll help. Am sure his going to help you do it, good luck
- swop 10y agoFound some more details on this technology. https://github.com/MAVProxyUser/SilverPushUnmasked https://github.com/MAVProxyUser/SilverPushUnmasked
- xenithorb 10y agoI wonder what it would take to make an app that does this exact thing and listens in order to hook into whatever and prevent malicious apps from beaconing. Also seems useful in order to see if there are any such ads out in the wild yet.
- beejamin 10y agoIs there any legitimate need for a phone mic to pick up sounds way outside the range of human speech and hearing? If this sort of thing should not be allowed, why not just add a software low-pass filter in the front of the audio input chain? What would the side effects of this be?