3 ms·
I don't know about disdain but I think there are good arguments for rejecting approaches like this "a priori" if you want to engage in science. Conscious is a
by joe_the_user 10y ago
I don't know about disdain but I think there are good arguments for rejecting approaches like this "a priori" if you want to engage in science.
Conscious is a subjective experience. There's no clear definition of it in terms of measurable and repeating phenomena however much a given person feels sure they experience it (go head, give a definition that's subjectively satisfying for consciousness. Notice the whole "philosophical zombie" schema rests on nothing about consciousness being measurable or verifiable). Psychology, linguistics or neuroscience may indeed come up with one at some point.
But as far as I can tell, the argument of the article and of theories of this sort, is that since consciousness is "real", it should be taken as a building block of one's model of the universe. The problem here is that using an ill-defined thing as a building block makes exact science impossible - unless your basic model is itself predictable, you cannot actually say whether your experimental results follow the model or not.
It's not simply that an approach like this may be wrong - science is wrong all the time. It's that an approach like is injecting an atom of "anything-you-want-tium" into the mixture, a situation that let's you claim any result verifies your theory ("God does it all" would satisfying Occam's Razor for the simple "explanation of everything" if we let the inherently unexplainable into the competition).
So in this sense, scientists have every reason to keep approaches like this entirely outside the realm of "legitimate science".
This may sound positivist and one may say that a lot of science is looser than a pure positivism. Sort-of but every serious scientific discipline has to boil down to verification of predictive models by experiment specifically because it's easy for things to move "in the clouds" for periods of time and the verification is needed to weed-out models without predictiveness at all (string theorists have speculated a long and gotten kudos but the call for predictiveness is there is getting louder - but with string theory, things may be abstract however no "unexplainable" is taken as a given).
- psyc 10y agoSimple solution: drop the science schtick for two seconds while discussing consciousness. I think the Hacker News culture betrays an unspoken terror of being wrong about anything for any length of time, and that's why it will admit no other tool for thought or investigation, other than its collective idiosyncratic caricature of science.
- joe_the_user 10y agoSimple solution: drop the science schtick for two seconds while discussing consciousness. I was not discussing consciousness per-se, I was discussing the theory and the sort of theory discussed in the article - the claim that a subjective experience needs to be added to the scientific process to explain various supposed problems. I have no objections to exploring subjective experience - believe it or not, I mediate, practice Qigong and Tai Chi and enjoy Eastern philosophies like Taoism. A text like the Tao Te Ching is more applicable to the immediate problems of living than a text book on physics but that doesn't mean subjective intuitions can be uncritically applied to physics. Science is a particular discipline, applicable in a limited but important level of reality, specifically intended to benefit from limiting the use of the subjective messiness of most human reasoning - not that this subjective messiness isn't highly useful elsewhere.
- Dylan16807 10y ago"science" just means checking if you're right or wrong. It's not a specific tool, and you can do science with any tool. What kind of tools would you suggest?