11 ms·
Why Is the TSA Scanning Paper?
- clebio 10y agoIs there an opt-out for this? What if you just refuse -- can they deny you boarding, and is that legal?
- cmurf 10y agoI found this, it may or may not be related. The gist is relatively recent research (2011) discussing using x-ray refraction rather than just attenuation and is capable of "creating precise images of the contours of all objects". A New Generation of X-ray Baggage Scanners Based on a Different Physical Principle www.mdpi.com/1996-1944/4/10/1846/pdf
- Trung0246 10y agoMaybe this? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printer_steganography https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printer_steganography
- CaliforniaKarl 10y agoSummary: Bruce doesn't know, and so he is asking his readers.
- YCode 10y agoYes, it would have been nice if the title explicitly stated that... i.e., "Does anyone know why the TSA is now scanning paper?"
- jeron 10y agoThat's Bruce's fault, OP just copy-pasted the title
- valuearb 10y agoA better summary is that Bruce is bring it to his readers attention because it's interesting.
- emiliobumachar 10y agoOkay, tin foil hat time. Maybe they have new machines that can see the print through the paper, and actually scan and store the contents of all these papers in a timely fashion?
- swiley 10y agoThere was an MIT reasearcher a while ago (it may have been posted here) using THz wave radar to do this. I think it's the same band (ish) the body scanners use.
- tjalfi 10y agoWere you thinking of Terahertz time-gated spectral imaging for content extraction through layered structures[0]? [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms12665 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms12665
- wyldfire 10y agoI kinda doubt those body scanners have anything remotely close to the spatial resolution required to find text written on a sheet of paper.
- CyberDildonics 10y agoHe said the same band. That wouldn't have anything to do with spatial resolution.
- wyldfire 10y agoSorry. I inferred that suggesting this meant (in the vein of this "tinfoil hat time" thread) that the body scanners might have the capability to read text from paper.
- coldpie 10y agoThis is only tangential (I don't think the TSA is doing this), but this is similar to a fascinating technique for finding writing on discarded paper used as filler in bindings and such in old books. https://medievalbooks.nl/2015/12/18/x-rays-expose-a-hidden-medieval-library/ https://medievalbooks.nl/2015/12/18/x-rays-expose-a-hidden-m...
- Havoc 10y agoI'm gonna go with TSA is looking for innovative new ways to inconvenience travellers.
- djsumdog 10y agoSecurity theatre. Make people think they're being innovative when their jobs are truly worthless.
- tajen 10y agoIn the 90's I landed in the cockpit, I was 13. In 2017, US is on my no-fly list...
- r00fus 10y agoAny organizations' first imperative is to sustain itself. If security theatre is all they have, that's what we'll get and more of it.
- sandworm101 10y agoBecause blobs of paper look to similar to blobs of potential explosives when xrayed. They arent scanning it so much as removing it from the scan of everything else.
- bbulkow 10y agoDo you know that to be true? Or is it that paper and/or ink blocks scanning and you can hide bombs in it?
- sandworm101 10y agoIt is the cellulose in the paper. Blocks of it are homogenous enough that they look similar in density to something dangerous. Add in ink, glue and other materials commonly soaked into paper and the situation is not totally unreasonable. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrocellulose https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrocellulose
- csydas 10y agoI lack the expertise to comment on the sensitivity of the cellulose specifically, but the metro stations where I live will perform random stops as you enter, and the monitors are in plain sight. Notebooks, stacks of paper, and note cards are usually pretty clearly detected by whatever software they're using to help highlight items. It seems weird to me that there could be such difficulty with TSA scanners versus the small, older ones set up at stations here. (St. Petersburg, Russia, just for reference for the location)
- learc83 10y ago>Notebooks, stacks of paper, and note cards are usually pretty clearly detected by whatever software they're using to help highlight items How do you know the problem isn't that the software flags dangerous items as paper incorrectly (which I think is the mostly likely problem here)? I doubt you've seen the X-ray image of someone smuggling nitrocellulose. The software is just using density--if you have an explosive of similar density to paper, it's probably not going to flag it.
- exabrial 10y agoI flew out of MCI (American Airlines) on Sunday evening, confirmed this definitely happened. They asked for books, papers, notebooks, etc. However, I disagree with one point in the article: I didn't witness them "scanning" the documents with a scanner. They went through the Xray machine in a separate bin, much like your laptop does. Perhaps I missed something.
- sandworm101 10y agoAgreed. "Scanning paper" has spying implications. They are just xraying it in its own bin.
- ferentchak 10y agoThey seem to like dense things to be in their own bin. Books are pretty dense.
- exabrial 10y agoMaybe someone got caught with a lead-lined hollow book concealing a weapon?
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoGoing a little off topic now... I'm surprised nobody has combined 3D X-Ray Scanning with computer vision technology. At the moment we're depending on the human eye flicking between three dimensions and spotting bad things, with very basic shape detection to "hint" at objects of interest. This system kind of works, but has human error weaknesses. If you fed 3D X-Rayed objects into a computer vision engine, eventually you'd have a big enough catalogue so the computer could list off every object inside and flag things which may be odd or problematic, for example a book with seemingly no internal dimensions. Now this is an imperfect system, for example when a new form factor of laptop started getting sold it might flag it as unusual, but isn't that somewhat working as intended? Then they can scan it, clear it, and send back the scan as a reference image. Eventually it could speed up and improve the reliability of bag checks.
- tuna-piano 10y agoKansas City Airport doesn't use TSA screeners, they have a private contractor doing the screening: https://www.tsa.gov/for-industry/screening-partnerships https://www.tsa.gov/for-industry/screening-partnerships That said, it seems like this policy is likely a TSA imposed pilot program: https://thepointsguy.com/2017/05/paper-products-new-tsa-security/ https://thepointsguy.com/2017/05/paper-products-new-tsa-secu...
- exabrial 10y agoI don't believe this is true, how does one tell? They appear to be TSA agents, in the blue uniforms with the TSA badges
- tuna-piano 10y agoIt's true. Turns out blue shirts can be worn by just about anybody. Here's a story from last summer about the private security at Kansas City Airport: http://www.kansascity.com/news/local/article79795177.html http://www.kansascity.com/news/local/article79795177.html
- exabrial 10y agoGood find!
- bogomipz 10y agoOh interesting. I am curious is the experience of the privatized screening any better? Or is the amount of humiliation, infantilizing and browbeating of regular honest people about the same as the non-privatized TSA? There was big uproar about privatizing the TSA about a year ago when the time spent in lines was growing even more excessive. That narrative about privatizing seemed to go dark. Is the Kansas City Airport itself a pilot program for privatization of the TSA?
- madengr 10y agoYes; I live in KC. The ones in MCI are polite, as opposed to Baltimore where they strut around barking orders. Of course MCI had a distributed security and gates, so they are smaller and thus quieter.
- nealabq 10y agoMaybe they're looking for flash paper. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrocellulose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrocellulose
- evan_ 10y agoseems like regular nitrate sniffers would catch that, and x-rays would not
- philipkglass 10y agoMy guess, already voiced by "Ron" on Schneier's blog: they're looking for nitrocellulose. Nitrated paper is not obviously different in appearance from ordinary paper. Sheets of nitrocellulose have negligible vapor pressure and little dust so they could be missed by other means like the "puffer" detectors. If they're putting these materials through a separate machine my guess would be another detector based on optical spectroscopy - maybe Raman? Something like that. It wasn't clear from the article whether the paper products in their separate bin just went through the same inspection chute as everything else.
- mutagen 10y agoAgreed. IMO the other plausible theory is disguising a bladed weapon of some kind in stacks of paper. The rest of the speculation appears to be based on misinterpretations of the headlines (scanning vs X-ray).
- pfooti 10y agoThey're not putting them through a different detector, though. They take out the books and all papers the passenger has, put them in one of the normal trays, and run the trays through the xray. My wife traveled out of Kansas City last weekend and was subject to this. She's a teacher, and traveled with grading, so they took out tests, her books, everything that was paper. The line agent said they were worried about papers being used to obfuscate other things in the xray machine. But that was the line agent, so he could have been (a) uninformed or (b) lying.
- Iv 10y agoThey say it is a test program. Maybe they are not testing if it is effective but rather how much it slows down the screening?
- philipkglass 10y agoTrying to de-clutter the images by separating paper would fit the observed procedure too. It seems a little odd that it would start only now. Maybe screener testing recently showed better performance when paper is separated out.
- eli 10y agoSeems like TSA does a lot of pilot programs that (luckily, imho) don't end up going anywhere. They once set up a folding table and searched everyone boarding my Greyhound bus.
- Arizhel 10y agoThey tried doing that at an Amtrak station a while ago and were forcibly removed from the premises by Amtrak police.
- djsumdog 10y agoThat's awesome. I remember hearing about their VIPR squads harassing people after they had disembarked a train at their destination. I'm glad Amtrak fought their bullshit.
- goodcanadian 10y agoI was curious, so I went looking. This article seems to describe what you are referring to: http://www.cnn.com/2012/02/06/opinion/don-phillips-tsa-vipr-teams/ http://www.cnn.com/2012/02/06/opinion/don-phillips-tsa-vipr-...
- rosalinekarr 10y agoThere seem to be a lot of people theorizing that it could be something about the paper itself that they're looking for, i.e. flash paper, paper circuits or physical one-time encryption pads, but what if it's not about the paper at all? Maybe, the TSA is simply trying to discourage passengers from traveling with or using paper, thereby encouraging people to store their information digitally on phones and laptops where that data can be more easily copied and analyzed?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- djsumdog 10y agoOr it's simpler than that: security theatre. We're adding a new level of annoyance so people have this false impression their jobs aren't totally beyond worthless. Fuck the TSA and the airlines. These days I'll pay more to take am AmTrak or just drive. Next time I fly, it will be after taking a train to Canada first. If I have to fly internationally, I'd rather not fly out of a US airport. I've flown through over a dozen countries, and yes, it is getting ridiculous everywhere, but America is still the worst. Especially when it comes to pat downs. No other country I've been through did pat downs except Moldova; and even theirs weren't anywhere near as bad (typically police arms/leg pat downs. No reaching under your belt or any other TSA bullshit for the false-positive/random-number-generator they try to tell you are body scanners).
- oasisbob 10y ago> These days I'll pay more to take am AmTrak or just drive. I take it you've never been searched by Amtrak police. Once on a cross-country trip all my belongings were searched twice - in Chicago where I departed, and again mid-trip. It's not a great time.
- jmcdiesel 10y agoIt's not nearly so complex and conspiracy based... They simply have found issue with dense objects (like books, stacks of paper) hinder the xray imaging they use in the scanners... thats all. Nothing special here... Im sure over some bad-guy communication network it was mentioned to attempt to get contraband on a plane by masking its location in luggage under some seriously thick books or something...
- brianwawok 10y agoI got a paper game (star realms) pulled out of my bag last Sunday. Interesting. Was about 120 playing card size pieced of paper.
- falcolas 10y agoA friend of mine was also queried about books in his bags before going through security. I was two steps ahead of him and was not. This was in a comparatively small airport in Montana, so it's not an isolated trial, if it is a trial.
- badloginagain 10y agoDoes cash have a unique identifier that can be scanned for? If someone was trying to bring a wad of hundreds in a hole cut out in a book, maybe they'd be looking for that?
- phkahler 10y agoI think cash is already detectable.
- jeron 10y agoI'm pretty sure it's perfectly legal to fly as much cash as you want domestically. [1] However, if they're scanning for other paper products that are potentially illegal, LSD comes to mind. [1]: https://travel.stackexchange.com/questions/36740/is-there-a-legal-limit-to-the-amount-of-cash-one-can-carry-on-domestic-us-flight https://travel.stackexchange.com/questions/36740/is-there-a-...
- DoubleCribble 10y agoYep. Metallic ink is used in your green(/blue/red)backs. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2120883/A-step-spyware-Metal-detectors-tell-cash-pocket.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2120883/A-step-spywa...
- madengr 10y agoI was at MCI on Sunday and can verify this. Even with pre-check, I had to remove my engineering pad from my carry on pelican case.
- jedberg 10y agoOh man, even with pre-check? So it completely defeats the point of pre-check then by making everyone take something out of their bag. Ugh.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- madamelic 10y agoI can't wait till we have to travel in paper smocks, chained to our seats like the criminals we truly are.
- bogomipz 10y agoI'm wondering if that would actually be any less humiliating than the current level of harassment by both the TSA and airlines themselves. I wonder if being chained to our seats would reduce the risk of the airlines physically dragging us off of oversold flights?
- camiller 10y agoWhat about those of us that can't afford first class!
- ebcode 10y agoNo smock for you!
- to3m 10y agoEventually they'll just shoot you at the airport when you turn up, then throw your carcass into an incinerator, because aeroplane travel will have become so inconvenient that only the most devoted of terrorist would bother.
- coldcode 10y agoEach person is pushed into a tube from the top whilst the current resident is pushed out the bottom. Each tube is made of reinforced kevlar and whatever else you can imagine. Each person is naked and is allowed no carryons of any kind. This of course will also increase profits as you can fit more tubes than seats.
- tyingq 10y agoMaybe some intelligence that people are inserting sheets of metal foil into stacks of paper to attenuate the x-rays and hide something underneath? Assuming the airport X-ray machines aren't that powerful, I would guess that 15+ sheets of foil inserted into a book or similar might mask something underneath it fairly well?
- alimoeeny 10y agobut it would show up as masked or dark or low energy, then they can mark as "needs manual search". That does not require forcing "all" papers out of all bags.
- tyingq 10y agoI was assuming many thin sheets of foil, each separated by several pieces of paper might be more subtle, than say a slab of lead. Subtle masking vs completely hiding something else under it.
- glup 10y agoI thought this might have something to do with printer steganography [1] but not if they are just X-raying the paper. Also I'm not sure whether that practice is ongoing--I haven't heard anything about it for years. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printer_steganography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printer_steganography
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI've had agents ask me to take out a card game from my bag - apparently the thick stack of cards can look like C4 on the scanner.
- valuearb 10y agoIf the TSA was shutdown entirely leading to terrorists blew up 10 planes a year in the US, flying would still be as safe as it was in the 1960s. http://www.sfgate.com/nation/article/U-S-commercial-airlines-have-safest-decade-ever-2435203.php http://www.sfgate.com/nation/article/U-S-commercial-airlines...
- wand3r 10y agoFor those w/o a working knowledge of 1960s air safety; are you saying removing the TSA would make us safer, less safe or simply that we tolerated the same level of safety w/o TSA 50ish years ago?
- valuearb 10y agoI'm not advocating removing the TSA entirely, just pointing out that we are paying a heavy price for a likely small benefit. Locking the cabin door virtually eliminated the threat of turning jetliners into terrorist weapons at a tiny cost. But on top of that we've cost the country maybe a trillion dollars in excessive and invasive security procedures to prevent planes from being blown up. The TSA is only one part of those costs, longer travel times, reduced travel and lost liberties are a big part of it. The value to terrorists blowing up an airliner is relatively small, there are far easier and cheaper ways to kill a few hundred people to make a political statement. So my real question is, if we reduced spending on airport security, and reduced the level of security significantly so that we shaved 15 mins on average off every trip, would it be worth accepting a plane being blown up every few years? Every year the US has nearly 1 billion trips by air. If you value travelers time at $20/hour, saving 15 minutes per trip directly saves nearly $5B a year. If the cost of saving those 15 minutes per trip is 50 lives per year, we are valuing each of those lives at $100m each. That seems incrediably excessive to me. Of course this is just a rough estimate, run your own numbers but it's hard to imagine the costs get down to a barely reasonable $10M per life level. and remember that doesn't include the cost of the TSA or the cost of flights not taken.
- DKnoll 10y agoThe TSA doesn't just exist to stop terrorism. Also if the US didn't screen passengers, many other nations likely wouldn't accept flights originating from it. How are you assessing the value of a human life?
- evan_ 10y agoWasn't there a scene in one of the recent Bond movies where a huge pile of cash had been treated in some kind of chemical that turned it into a bomb?
- alan 10y agoThe World is Not Enough is the movie you're thinking of. From 1999, if you want to call that recent; going back 18 of the 55 years of Bond movies.
- evan_ 10y agothat's right. I was thinking it was one of the Daniel Craig films. In my defense I remembered the explosion was at MI6 and MI6 blows up twice under Daniel Craig's watch...
- alimoeeny 10y agoI think the point many people are missing is that this is a "new" development. All the talk about paper composition / features could overlap with other banned material cannot be new.
- wwwigham 10y agoGiven that I've had this happen to me at a checkpoint (in Seattle) and had it explained to me, I think I have a reasonable potential answer: Stacked paper produces false positives in the scanning machines which can be flagged as suspicious substances. By separating the paper into a separate bin, it can be more quickly inspected by human eyes and the flag cleared, allowing the security line to be cleared more quickly.
- chrismeller 10y agoPerhaps a bit cynical, but that is exactly the reason I would expect from the TSA. It's not that they're enhancing their screening of anything in particular, they're just helping you get through more quickly... sureeeee.
- r00fus 10y agoI had my bag pulled out of the scanner while at SAN - was very frustrating as I was going between the 3-9 gates and the 1/2/2A gates on a connection - amazingly had to go back through security - and had only a few minutes before my connection left. In an exasperated voice I asked the security person why she had to dig through my bag and she indicated that the paperback novel that I had in there was the trigger. So I replied - guess I'm not going to take a paperback next time. Another freedom impinged.
- robert_tweed 10y agoMy theory: they aren't looking for paper, they are trying to rule it out as something else. My understanding of these scanners is that they colour-code "organic" and "inorganic" material differently. Explosives generally show up as organic. Now, if you have a block of such organic material in just the right position next to some electronics, the conveyor gets stopped and you will be taken to one side and asked some very direct questions about the contents of your bag. I know this because I once had a protein bar in the same bag as a portable DVD player and that aisle went into lockdown for about 30 minutes because it looked exactly like a bomb, from all angles, in 3D. Expert called over, agreed they couldn't start the conveyor until they knew it was safe. My guess is that paper (in the form of small pads) is the commonest cause of this type of false positive.
- ckrailo 10y agoI found this story by checking Google for updates in the news... sounds like the TSA has reversed course: http://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/news/2017/05/05/tsa-folds-new-checks-on-passengers-paper-goods.html http://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/news/2017/05/05/tsa-fo...
- makecheck 10y agoThis sounds more like the "department of imagined threats" justifying its existence, not actual security. Even if there is ANY possible risk, what was their analysis? The odds of this are probably lower than being struck by lightning. The only new things I want to hear out of the TSA each week are: which rules have now been REMOVED, and how many fewer minutes security lines are taking on average.