9 ms·
A Theory of Consciousness Can Help Build a Theory of Everything
- kneel 10y agoPlease no, no more 'Theory of Consciousness' pseudoscience. If we can't even get a solid consensus on what consciousness is we're not going to have a theory for it anytime soon. Every time this comes up we have a split between actual neuroscience and everyone's subjective interpretation of consciousness.
- nefitty 10y agoDo you propose researchers continue looking for answers exclusively in a bottom-up fashion? Should the question just be scrapped?
- mannykannot 10y agoThe idea that the answer is being sought in an exclusively bottom-up fashion is one of the many straw men in this article. The recognition that consciousness is some form of emergent phenomenon has been around for a long time.
- lefnire 10y agoI too hate when people dare to dream out loud about interesting unsolved riddles in the universe. For some, sci-fi psuedoscience is their inspiration into the field, boosting their achieving the impossible - take Musk. I recently landed my first machine learning job, brought here precisely because I think synthesized consciousness is possible, swayed by none other than this community's most hated quack: Ray Kurzweil. Many choose science because they're inspired to achieve incredible (literally "not credible") things. If journalists should shut up, I wouldn't have my rewarding job. I've learned to ignore psuedoscience whistle-blowers, they just sound curmudgeonly to me.
- mannykannot 10y agoPeople who dare to dream out loud about interesting unsolved riddles in the universe are fine, but all too often in these articles, what we get is an unjustified claim that the riddle has been solved (or that a whole class of possible answers are ruled out), resting on little but straw-man arguments, appeals to intuition dressed up as objective facts, and attempts to rule issues out of consideration by definition, through wordplay. This is not the way to a true understanding. Of the authors I have read on the subject, Scott Aaronson stands out as someone who tries to (and succeeds in) avoiding this form of argumentation.
- cscurmudgeon 10y ago> If we can't even get a solid consensus on what consciousness That is what the damn problem is. This is like saying since we don't understand gravity full, we should not study it.
- monocasa 10y agoWe come come up with a test that detects the presence of gravity. Can we do the same with consciousness?
- lioeters 10y agoThat's an interesting question, and I think it reveals something about the difficulty of studying consciousness strictly in a "scientific" way, i.e., based on experimental results, empirical evidence, falsifiability, reproducibility.. How can we test the existence of a wholly subjective/interior experience? This seems to relate to, for example, if it's possible to measure and quantify pain (or pleasure I suppose) objectively.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoWe understand gravity very well. General relativity is a beautiful and highly tested theory of gravity.
- cscurmudgeon 10y agoWe understand it very well but not completely! https://beyond.asu.edu/workshop/unsolved-problems-gravity https://beyond.asu.edu/workshop/unsolved-problems-gravity We don't go around declaring that "No talk about gravity till we know everything about it and have solved all open problems."
- monktastic1 10y agoNot really. With gravity, we always basically agreed on what we were trying to explain: why things fall or attract each other. With consciousness, we don't have anything much better than "why is it _like something_ to be conscious?" Even if we agree on such a definition, what do we do with it? And the more objective our definition ("why do organisms respond to their environment?") the further we get from the thing we seek to explain.
- collyw 10y agoConsciousness is entirely subjective. There is no objective element to it.
- naasking 10y ago> Consciousness is entirely subjective. There is no objective element to it. Conjecture!
- monktastic1 10y agoIs it? Sounds like a definition to me. Consciousness is the sheer fact of subjectivity (i.e., that it is "like something" to be you).
- mannykannot 10y agoDefinitions are not explanations. Anyone wanting to claim that subjective phenomena cannot have objective causes needs to justify that claim.
- monktastic1 10y agoI was responding to the above comment saying that it's a conjecture that consciousness is subjective. I'm saying it's a definition not a conjecture. That fact makes objective investigation very hard. If I don't know whether a person is a p-zombie, I cannot know whether any objective events cause his consciousness. And if it's my consciousness we're talking about, I cannot be there to investigate the objective causes of it.
- mannykannot 10y agoI believe the conjecture lies in the claim that there is no objective element to it. The fact that objective investigation is difficult does not make the case. BTW, your specific arguments for it being hard seem to me to border on solipsism.
- psyc 10y agoPlease, no more disdain for people's ideas and hypotheses about a fundamental topic that nobody has an answer for yet.
- lend000 10y agoSome people do have an answer for it... Schmidhuber's answer: consciousness is a byproduct of data compression. Anyway, there's certainly no evidence to suggest that consciousness requires anything more than our current understanding of physical laws. This article was pretty interesting with its topical exploration of self organization and a more math-based approach, but once it got into quantum physics it started to delve into the realm of pure conjecture and pseudo-science.
- whatshisface 10y agoBy answer, he meant answer beyond conjecture. I can always wave my hands and suggest that drawing a special medicine wheel in the sand makes consciousness, or that arranging some information-theoretic properties in a certain way makes consciousness, depending on how mathematically difficult I'd like my pseudospirituality to be!
- joe_the_user 10y agoWell, the thing is that quite possibly professional swimmers say, might claim that the theory of hydrodynamics doesn't explain how moving through water feels to them and so say hydrodynamics doesn't answer the question of water movement "beyond conjecture". An experience people would label "conscious" exists in the sense that many people would label their state of mind with it. A scientific explanation would involve describing why people are attracted to this position and might or might-not involve describing actual brain states could be considered "consciousness states". There's no reason to think such an explanation would be "subjectively satisfying" - that it would make people lean back and say "oh, now I understand". But the problem is the "theory of consciousness" folks want to create a theory that is both scientific and "subjectively satisfying" and indeed they sort of start their argument with a unit of that thing that's subjectively satisfying and try to go from there. That seems like recipe for non-science.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoScott Aaronson discussed Integrated Information Theory in 2014. His conclusion was that it is a failed research program. [1][2][3] [1]http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1799 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1799 [2]http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1823 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1823 [3]http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1893 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=1893
- mannykannot 10y agoI think the last paragraph of the first reference is worth considering: "But let me end on a positive note. In my opinion, the fact that Integrated Information Theory is wrong—demonstrably wrong, for reasons that go to its core—puts it in something like the top 2% of all mathematical theories of consciousness ever proposed. Almost all competing theories of consciousness, it seems to me, have been so vague, fluffy, and malleable that they can only aspire to wrongness."
- svara 10y agoI just want to say that this is probably the best online discussion I have ever seen. Scott and Giulio respond to each other in clear, well thought out, detailed posts. Christof Koch and David Chalmers chime in in the comments section of Scotts blog, and all of the commenters there really try to contribute something substantive to the discussion. I'm super impressed, as in, the internet is actually better than I thought! ;) I would really recommend to anyone interested in that discussion to take the 3-4 h it takes to read through it all.
- nsxwolf 10y agoIt seems to me that it is not possible for science to explain to me why I am me and not someone else - why I was born on this planet and not some other, why the date I was and not some other. That's simply outside the reach of science. Science is not a tool that can answer that question. I'm sure someone will tell me that my question is meaningless to begin with - ironically I think the answers to the questions scientists seek about consciousness are permanently beyond the event horizon of that very meaningless they accuse my question of.
- ithkuil 10y agoIt also depends a lot from what you consider a satisfactory answer.
- henearkr 10y agoA variation along the lines of an Anthropic Principle would be like: - why am I born a Saturday? - because if you were born a Monday your question would have been different accordingly
- henearkr 10y agoAnd it is also equivalent to considering all these realities coexisting in parallel universes. It kinds of "brings back the missing symmetry" of the situation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- behnamoh 10y agoReminds me of Sheldon and Amy discussing the same issue in "the Big Bang Theory" TV show!
- daliwali 10y agoA variation of this already exists, called the Cognitive-Theoretic Model of the Universe (CTMU) [0]. It is dismissed by critics as not being based on empirical methods or pure reason, which is what it's getting at: science isn't the answer to everything. Some questions can't be answered by reason alone, mind-body dualism for example. [0] http://www.ctmu.org/ http://www.ctmu.org/
- castle-bravo 10y agoScience can't express all of the truths about the universe. Scientists know this. What science does provide is a reliable framework for finding out some truths about the universe. So far the science approach has been very successful. Art projects like CMTU do not provide any such framework. While entertaining, the information presented is of little to no use. At worst, pseudoscientific presentations like CMTU are used to persuade certain people that the scientific establishment is engaged in a conspiracy to mislead and defraud the public.
- daliwali 10y agoI think abstract, non-empirical knowledge can be useful. For example, all of mathematics. It is unreasonably effective at modeling nature, there is no reason why nature must adhere to abstract mathematics. For example the invention of the imaginary number preceded its explanation of alternating currents. I disagree with the claim that "pseudo-science" as you call it is used to discredit the establishment. Rather it is exactly the opposite, the establishment uses the label to discredit outlandish ideas. Every scientific theory starts off as hypothesis and maintains falsifiability, to accept it as dogma is worse than not exploring other ideas.
- fsiefken 10y agoI'm intruiged by Kastrup's view on the mind-body problem. He explains it in very a recent paper: "An Ontological Solution to the Mind-Body Problem" http://www.mdpi.com/2409-9287/2/2/10 http://www.mdpi.com/2409-9287/2/2/10
- henearkr 10y agoAm I the only one thinking this approach should allow to address the conditions in which a social mind could emerge in societies of individuals? Including humans, or more likely slightly modified versions of humans.
- tnzn 10y agoEnacting anyone ?