6 ms·
This is why apps that shouldn't need the mic or speaker but still require it should not be installed. Permissions on an app should be checked carefully by a us
by chii 10y ago
This is why apps that shouldn't need the mic or speaker but still require it should not be installed.
Permissions on an app should be checked carefully by a user, and users should be educated in this!
- strmpnk 10y agoThat model is backwards. If there is one thing iOS got right, it's the permission prompt. Nobody reads those lists and it's hard to know what the intent is without context in the app. Having the app ask on first use makes much more sense. It's much less likely to get away with this. Even better, you can still use the app if you say no. It will just get dummy values back.
- Drakim 10y agoOn the flip side, this means you have already installed and committed to having this app on your phone. Lots of people might just press "accept" at that point out of being lazy, instead of uninstalling it and going back to the app store to look for an alternative. If you ask me, both should be in place. When I install an app a list of permissions (and a short text next to each from the developer explaining why they need this permission), along with manual prompting once the app is installed and the thing in question (like the mic) is to be used.
- mrtksn 10y agoAsking for mic permission with no apparent reason is scary, many people will not allow it. Also you can easily change it from the settings. Apps on Apple App Store can't stop functioning just because of a permission is not given. If the app can't perform it's function without a specific permission the developer needs to explain it to the users and ask them to go into the settings and lift the ban. So if an app that does not have a really good reason for asking for the mic, the use can just deny that permission and continue using the app. No need for fishing in the sewage until you find the gold among the sh*t and it's my main reason to use IOS over Android(Though I hear its getting better).
- appetizer 10y agoMany other people don't click accept for any reason
- pidg 10y agoI think Android 7 does now ask on first use rather than at time of installation.
- samat 10y ago1. build you app targeting earlier versions 2. No dialogs in any android version
- dtech 10y agoThis works the same since Android 6 (2015)
- ClassyJacket 10y agoOnly on apps that target Android 6 however. They couldn't retroactively apply it. Just build your app targeting Lollipop and you get all the permissions you want. Plus their app store isn't as strongly vetted, so apps can refuse to work if you don't grant a bullshit tracking permission.
- 0x0 10y agoThis I never understood. Couldn't they just supply the app with empty lists and black pixels for restricted APIs until the user approved the permission? iOS managed to do this retroactively just fine.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoI believe they do, but you have to specifically go into your settings and explicitly block the permission for the app and click thru a warning that the app might break, rather than ever being asked. I don't remember when iOS did this retroactively, do you have an example? When have they even added a new permission that wasn't a new API entirely?
- s73ver 10y agoI don't think iOS did it retroactively. It's just that, since so many more people actually update (because they're not at the mercy of their carrier), devs update their apps more often.
- 0x0 10y agoI believe you are incorrect. iOS have introduced more and more permissions (most recently, for iOS10 a permission prompt appears for apps trying to access the built-in media library, whereas this was a silent free-for-all in earlier versions), and existing apps are not grandfathered in. According to at least https://www.macrumors.com/2012/06/14/apple-requires-user-permission-before-apps-can-access-personal-data-in-ios-6/ https://www.macrumors.com/2012/06/14/apple-requires-user-per... apps will just receive empty/dummy data until the permission is granted. From my personal experience, camera APIs return black pixels until the permission has been granted, even for apps that were released when iOS 5.0.0 was the latest version and never updated since.
- retube 10y agocough youtube cough
- roryisok 10y agoYoutube has a video recording function, that doesn't work so well without the camera and mic
- Neliquat 10y agoClearly, that is better as a seperate app. 99.99% of viewers will never upload, much less use that feature.
- s73ver 10y agoIt's still part of YouTube. And if Google is following their own guidelines for it, they won't ask for those permissions until you try to do something that needs it. Seeing as how I've been using YouTube for a while and have not been asked for those permissions, it seems to be working fine.
- msabalau 10y agoOr, of course, users could avoid installing apps altogether. Which, apparently, is the approach that many people take: https://www.recode.net/2016/9/16/12933780/average-app-downloads-per-month-comscore https://www.recode.net/2016/9/16/12933780/average-app-downlo... It seems likely that lots of folks already realize 'experiencing the joy of the Krispy Kreme app" will not improve their life in any way, shape, or form.