8 ms·
> But if we make it our social norm that bankruptcy is nothing to be ashamed of and to be taken lightly I don't know about "taken lightly" but bankruptcy and d
by ryandrake 10y ago
> But if we make it our social norm that bankruptcy is nothing to be ashamed of and to be taken lightly
I don't know about "taken lightly" but bankruptcy and defaulting on a debt should not be something to be "ashamed" of, for an individual, a company, or a government. Default is an option specifically written into every debt contract out there. There should be no more shame in choosing to default as there would be for choosing to exercise a stock option that causes your counterparty lose all his money. Lenders reap a huge premium for doing nothing but assuming the risk of default. If there was zero risk there should be zero premium.
No surprise that it's mainly bankers pushing the "it's immoral to default" line.
- cbr 10y agoI'm pretty sure taking out a loan that you intend to default on is fraud, but making a contract with someone that you expect to be very profitable to you is not.
- e0 10y agoWho said anything about taking out a fraudulent loan?
- cbr 10y agoI was responding to "There should be no more shame in choosing to default as there would be for choosing to exercise a stock option that causes your counterparty lose all his money." The idea is, if "default" were just a neutral acceptable option then we wouldn't think of it as fraud if you took out a loan that you planned to default on.
- analog31 10y agoIf I were to look for fraud anywhere, I'd start by looking at the people who give inflated ratings to bonds.
- lmm 10y agoStart there, sure, but don't stop there.
- candiodari 10y agoWhat about politicians that use the government to take action against firms when they lower particular ratings ? Are those committing fraud too ? What, incidentally, about politicians who force pension funds to buy bonds "they like" by legal means ? (at least 200 politicians in current service are guilty of this) These are US government bonds, by the way, if a default happens with them, the sort of organisation that will suffer the most is US pension funds. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_government_credit-rating_downgrades https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_governme...
- malnourish 10y agoIntent to default sure, but realizing that defaulting is the best option after your circumstances have changes is not fraud.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>I don't know about "taken lightly" but bankruptcy and defaulting on a debt should not be something to be "ashamed" of, for an individual, a company, or a government. It totally depends. There is nothing shameful about declaring bankruptcy because you got into an accident and your insurance company refused to pay your six-figure hospital bill. But if you take out a big loan to build a new hotel and blow it all on hookers and booze? Fuck yeah you should be ashamed (and also go to prison).
- njovin 10y agoThat sounds more like fraud. What if I take out a loan, am perfectly capable of paying it off, but the asset backing the loan has lost sufficient value so as not to be worth the continued investment? Is there any shame in defaulting and letting the lender suffer some of the consequences? In my personal opinion, no. Especially with secured or collateral-backed loans, the lender knew there was risk going in and there's no reason they shouldn't also suffer some losses in the case the plan doesn't work out. This is the situation many Americans found themselves in after the last housing bubble and it still makes me sad that some people still feel a sense of obligation to corporations that would screw them in a heartbeat if it would make them a legal dollar.
- myrandomcomment 10y agoSorry but what you are saying is since people are too stupid to understand the contract they signed and to do some math it is the companies fault? My wife and I at one point were in the hole nearly 1m. The crash put my house way under and the job money fun time went away. It sucked. You know what we did. We canceled the cable TV, we stopped eating out. We watched every penny. I work jobs I hated, hated, hated. We got credit councling and got on a plan with them and stuck to it. We paid our debt. I am by no means saying that banckrucy should not be an option in some cases. Our medical systems is a mess and that is a huge cause of banckrucy. However let's be clear people signed those loans without understanding it and it is their fault. I knew the cost of the interest only loan I had. I got burned but it was a bet I entered after doing research and math, etc. When it did not work out I sucked it up and delt with it. I agree that some companies did some shady stuff, but really? You get something to good to be true and you don't question it? The consumer has to take some responsibility for their actions.
- givinguflac 10y ago|Default is an option specifically written into every debt contract out there. Except student loans :(.
- brandonmenc 10y agoYou can default on student loans.
- n_ 10y agoOoop, yeah, you are right. Was thinking bankruptcy.
- dragonwriter 10y agoYou can discharge them in bankruptcy, too, it's just harder than most other debt to do so.
- n_ 10y agoMy mind immediately went to that too. Smh.
- vacri 10y ago> There should be no more shame in choosing to default as there would be for choosing to exercise a stock option that causes your counterparty lose all his money. Defaulting on a debt is not about shame. Governments don't feel shame. The ramifications are that future credit becomes much more expensive, as the next contract's debt provisions will be harsher. > No surprise that it's mainly bankers pushing the "it's immoral to default" line. Plenty of honest, hard-working individuals pride themselves on always paying their debts. Similarly there are those who think that you shouldn't extend yourself beyond your means. It's not just bankers who consider not paying dues to be immoral.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bnolsen 10y agoAnd the politicians who make the decisions to run up the debt have zero skin in the game. They just get to spend other people's money. In many cases it goes out the door as political payoffs for getting votes.
- gnode 10y agoYet the people elected them instead of someone pledging austerity and higher taxes.
- MichaelBurge 10y ago> If there was zero risk there should be zero premium. Suppose someone living the HN dream makes a bunch of money from his startup, and decides to pay off his mortgage. It might be structured as a loan from his company to himself, which then has zero risk. A bank processing an FHA loan has zero default risk, since the government steps in to pay them. And they often sell the loans to a government-run company anyways. A bank giving a conventional mortgage will often require 20% down, and again they resell the loans to a government-run corporation after a few years anyways. If you default in those first few years, they effectively get a 20% discount on the original purchase price of the house when they take it. Not zero-risk, but the 2008 financial crisis appears to have only had a 30% drop in house prices. (Obviously, subprime lenders can't resell their loans to the government, and didn't require a heavy down payment) Generally speaking, the idea that interest mostly pays for risk assumes that there is no 'low-hanging fruit' where guaranteed returns are possible if only there was money. Paying down high-interest debt is one form of guaranteed return, so theoretically there shouldn't be such a thing as high-interest debt if the market was mostly efficient. I guess the conclusion of your view is that: If people were more diligent about handling their money, banks wouldn't make as much risk-free money.
- marcosdumay 10y ago> I guess the conclusion of your view is that: If people were more diligent about handling their money, banks wouldn't make as much risk-free money. That's very likely the case. Although the real world does not like zeros and tries hard to push some complex high order effects that will be triggered before any zero is realized.
- briandear 10y agoNot paying your debts is immoral. Sure the risk is priced in but so is the risk of shoplifting in the prices you pay at stores. That doesn't mean that because the risk is priced in that it's somehow moral to shoplift. Also the reason for default does have some bearing on morality -- a person that declares bankruptcy because of years of buying a new TV every year and going on expensive vacations is much different than a default due to factors outside of one's control (such as being laid off or suffering a medical catastrophe.) Puerto Rico has, for years, knowingly overspent without much of a fiscal plan to pay debts. This issue isn't due to forces outside their control, but specifically because of decisions they consciously made. It is political malpractice and the people of Puerto Rico will now pay the price for generations. If that isn't immoral, then immoral has lost all meaning.
- onion2k 10y agoThis issue isn't due to forces outside their control, but specifically because of decisions they consciously made. It is political malpractice and the people of Puerto Rico will now pay the price for generations. So the children of the children of the children of people of Puerto Rico should accept their situation because of "decisions they consciously made"? They're not even born yet. How does that work?
- YesThatTom2 10y agoWhoa whoa whoa! If people default, then bankers might actually have to work for a living and actually evaluate potential customers instead of just cargo-curling their way through forms and praying that everything will be ok. The C- students that became bankers can't be expected to actually work for a living! (Sarcasm)
- candiodari 10y agoThe largest owners of US government debt are US pension funds. This situation exists mostly because politicians demand they get to pick what the bankers invest in (at least 80% in "safe" instruments, ie. from a short list with government bonds). Also how to resolve this situation ? You do want a pension, right ?
- basseq 10y agoThere's a difference in perception between personal, corporate, and government bankruptcy. Personal bankruptcy is seen as a black mark of either poor personal discipline or a string of bad luck. Corporate bankruptcy is largely ignored, held up in rare cases as a source of embarrassment (but little else), or more often in startup-land, a signal of "experience". Government bankruptcy is something else entirely, and generally unforgivable without significant outside catastrophes. You can blame the politicians, but in a Democratically-elected government, these are your representatives. Interesting to note on the corporate angle, bankruptcy laws are a fairly-recent invention. (Where by "fairly recent" I mean "several centuries".) The US's laws, in particular, are credited with fostering some of the innovation in this country, as they reduce the impacts of failure.
- baloneyman 10y agoAt the end of the day, they're all just humans making bad decisions But it seems like it would honestly be the opposite (i.e., government bankruptcy being bad). The more people that are involved, the higher chance there is of a tragedy of the commons
- colefichter 10y agoYou make a really good point. HN seems to venerate startups that fail, which isn't very different from defaulting on a loan (and in many cases these startups are defaulting on loans as they shut down). Yet, in any thread where Greece, Puerto Rico, etc come up there's this strong backlash against defaulting as being somehow immoral (as though it's not written into the lending agreements). What exactly is the difference between burning a bunch of VC money then shutting down and defaulting on a loan? In both cases we have an institution putting money at risk in the hopes of making a profit, and then losing it. I don't see the big moral difference here.
- ChemicalWarfare 10y ago>> HN seems to venerate startups that fail, which isn't very different from defaulting on a loan (and in many cases these startups are defaulting on loans as they shut down). I don't subscribe to the notion that "bankruptcy is immoral", it's just a business transaction within the established framework with checks and balances in place. That said though - situation with startups and business development loans in general is a little different because startups are by definition attempting to turn the idea they present to investors into reality with investors' money. So unless they fail because of a blatant mismanagement of funds (which does happen of course) - in a typical startup failure situation where something is built but there's no more runway and no more money coming in and no buyers to take over the operation - this just feels like it's easier to justify the less negative vibe around that situation.