13 ms·
> We owe money to the creditors... and what you do with a debt is to you pay it off. That's not the case. Sometimes, you pay your debt off. Sometimes, you defa
by vkou 10y ago
> We owe money to the creditors... and what you do with a debt is to you pay it off.
That's not the case. Sometimes, you pay your debt off. Sometimes, you default, and file for bankruptcy. For lenders, it's the cost of doing business. If they don't want to deal with the possibility of bankruptcy, they shouldn't lend out money.
Lenders charge creditors a premium, because of the risk of default. It's as much on them to be careful about who they lend money to, as it is on the creditor to be careful about being able to pay off their debts.
- knob 10y agoI will admit that you are right on that. It's a tough spot to be in. I bought, and yet to fully read, "Debt - The first 5000 years". One of the things the book states at the start is what you are saying: Not every debt has to be paid off. One of the risks creditors take is the possibility of having a debt not paid back. I also remember how Haiti was, to this day, punished via monetary means. Haiti wanted freedom? Fine... they will (and did) cripple the entire country. Another example from the book: Madagascar. The French invaded, and took out their Queen. Then imposed taxes on the population as to get back the money they invested in the invasion/war. wtf
- vkou 10y ago> Another example from the book: Madagascar. The French invaded, and took out their Queen. Then imposed taxes on the population as to get back the money they invested in the invasion/war. wtf We currently charge imprisoned people for room and board for their jail stays. http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-34705968 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-34705968
- thehappy 10y ago> Another example from the book: Madagascar. The French invaded, and took out their Queen. Then imposed taxes on the population as to get back the money they invested in the invasion/war. wtf That's a leveraged buyout. Borrow money to take control of another entity. Use revenue from the target entity to pay that debt. Profit.
- savanaly 10y agoThat's true in any individual case. But if we make it our social norm that bankruptcy is nothing to be ashamed of and to be taken lightly, won't it change the equilibrium for future generations of lenders and borrowers such that an inefficiently low amount of lending goes on? If everyone has the expectation that the lenders and borrowers will try their best to live up to the contract they made in good faith, wouldn't it be a better equlibrium? And we can work towards such a world bit by bit in how we respond to crises like the Puerto Rico one.
- fiatjaf 10y agoIf someone has already defaulted on a loan, that will make you not want to lend to him anymore, perfect. If the Puerto Rico government defaults now, no banks should lend money to it again ever. Perfect. This outcome doesn't affect other lender-borrower relationships.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>If someone has already defaulted on a loan, that will make you not want to lend to him anymore, perfect. Yep, for example this is why no American bank will give loans to Donald Trump anymore. Too many bankruptcies. So he isn't worth the risk.
- nsp 10y agoAll but one of the big banks stopped loaning him or his ventures money after the first few bankruptcies
- myrryr 10y agoThat isn't how it works. It is never how it worked. Plenty of countries have defaulted, and they can still borrow money. And yeah, it does effect other lender-borrower relationships. It's all people, and people get nervous.
- fiatjaf 10y ago
- fiatjaf 10y agoAbsolutely. Governments are stupid to borrow money and waste it, but banks were supposed to be even more stupid to lend money to these reckless institutions called governments, and it's not wrong if these banks pay the price of their stupidity.
- wyager 10y ago> If they don't want to deal with the possibility of bankruptcy, they shouldn't lend out money. This only works if lenders are private groups and if they have the ability to set the terms of the loan (or deny it altogether). Neither of these generally apply at the government level.
- vkou 10y agoNobody forces lenders to buy up PR bonds, or accept the terms at which they are issued.
- dragandj 10y agoEU institutions force them by controlling the policy. Sure, if you have a few millions to invest, you can go elsewhere, but if you have billions, you are most usually working with other people's or institutional money, and are fairly limited by various laws and policies, and large part of that money practically has to go in some sort of government bonds. Then, you can not just disregard those AAA ratings at return * 2 because you'll have trouble explaining that you do not trust the ratings...
- azernik 10y agoWhich is why people are so angry at the ratings agencies - they are private institutions that were supposed to be giving honest information, and they have misleading AAA ratings to investments that did not merit them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nihonde 10y agoYes, and the outcome is that you can't borrow again, in theory. Also, if a region is productive, it should be able to renegotiate, but it sounds like PR isn't up to the challenge.
- kbenson 10y agoThis is exactly why different people/companies/governments pay different rates. The rate you pay has your risk factored in.
- hardtke 10y agoMuch of the Puerto Rican debt has been sold at a discount by the original lenders. The risk of default was already priced into those purchases.
- prostoalex 10y ago> If they don't want to deal with the possibility of bankruptcy, they shouldn't lend out money. While a reasonable idea in abstract, it's of little value to Puerto Rico and its residents. For the next few decades no one will lend money to them unless backed by some kind of collateral like government land or revenue proceeds from tolls, and their ability to raise money via other means is highly questionable, as servicing current debt has likely exhausted all of the obvious venues. Every borrower in the municipal market will pay a higher price for this, as funds and other institutional investors will deal with write-offs and potential fund outflows.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> For the next few decades no one will lend money to them unless backed by some kind of collateral like government land or revenue proceeds from tolls Sounds like normal debt raising. No one will give you money unless you have a plausible story of how it gets paid off. Why do you consider it a good thing to be able to borrow money you have no plan to pay off?
- prostoalex 10y agoI don't. I was just pointing out that laissez-faire business-as-usual nothing-to-see-here-folks attitude is rarely suitable for municipal bankruptcies. None of the recently bankrupt municipal entities in the US - Stockton, Detroit, San Bernardino - are fun to live in, and most are in a downward spiral of cutting government services, which leads to employers leaving, which leads to residents moving, which leads to cutting government services, etc.
- rburhum 10y agoThe problem is the the holders of the bonds are largely the people of PR themselves...
- briandear 10y agoCompletely correct, but a default will mean a much tougher time borrowing in the future. So a bankruptcy now can solve the immediate problem, but this creates a tough situation for the future when debt is needed to finance large projects. What Texas has done was create a "rainy day fund" which is essentially a savings account designed to protect against these sorts of situations. But, that takes fiscal discipline and politicians who are unwilling to attempt to buy votes with money they don't have.
- jameshart 10y agoThere are other options too: borrow money from other creditors (preferably on better terms) and use it to pay off the original creditors; negotiate with the creditors to pay back part of the sum, rather than the whole sum; arrange for the creditor to forgive the debt; buy out the creditor (after all, if all they own are bad loans, they might be willing to sell out for cheap)... In particular municipal/state/government borrowers tend to prefer the first approach - usually by issuing bonds. In theory they are secured by the government's ability to levy taxes in its territory in perpetuity, so its ability to pay the bonds should be secure so long as there's likely to be future economic activity in the territory.
- taway_1212 10y agoIt's close to saying that, as a shopkeeper, sometimes you get robbed, which is the cost of doing business you charge your customers for - and hence the robbery is ok.
- marcosdumay 10y agoHum, no. Robbery and bankruptcy have completely different effects on society. That's why one is legal, and the other isn't.
- rubber_duck 10y ago>If they don't want to deal with the possibility of bankruptcy, they shouldn't lend out money. Except your pension fund probably lent them money too - how would you like it if you lost your pension because they decide to default ? This is maybe less true in the US but in EU mandatory pension funds are basically proxy for buying government bonds/funding government spending with a hope they will pay out in the future. I agree theoretically - but the reality is people don't like to see huge defaults - it breaks confidence/trust - and lower trust increases cost/slows down growth and this is not politically acceptable - therefore politicians do everything they can to eliminate corrections and create distortions to preserve confidence.