18 ms·
With latency as low as 25ms, SpaceX to launch broadband satellites in 2019
- jseliger 10y agoThis may help explain why Verizon is cutting FiOS prices and increasing speeds: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/04/verizon-bungles-launch-of-70-gigabit-plan-which-costs-more-than-70 https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/04/veriz...
- 27182818284 10y agoGigabit fiber is being rolled out in my area. It is amazing how quickly it is progressing compared to the work of Verizon or Google Fiber. So at least from that one example, there seems to be new players entering cities
- zwily 10y agoComcast just released Gigabit (over copper, DOCSIS 3.1) for all of Utah. It's only 40Mbit up, but I'm pretty happy with it. I thought it would take a lot longer.
- jsz0 10y agoThis is exactly why cable providers have been so reluctant to spend huge amounts of money on FTTH. Squeezing more bits through existing copper infrastructure is a win-win situation for everyone.
- MertsA 10y agoBut that doesn't scale. Gigabit speeds are possible with DOCSIS but that hinges on massively oversubscribing their last mile infrastructure and usage patterns to slowly increase. With DOCSIS, nodes can be huge and encompass hundreds of homes. The bandwidth available is shared with everyone on that channel in the entire node. For GPON it's similar, but nodes are somewhere between 16 and 64 homes and there's even more bandwidth available. ISPs aren't letting congestion get to record levels to YouTube and Netflix because they want to screw with you, they're keeping the congestion "contained" at certain peering links because that cuts down quite a bit of the amount of aggregate bandwidth they have to deal with at the last mile. If they upgraded their peering links then they'll just cause congestion for everything instead of just video services that will gracefully degrade to worse quality in the face of congestion. Moving to FTTH is a win-win situation, ISPs get a break from the endless struggle of keeping the last mile free of congestion and customers get something closer to net neutrality since the ISPs don't have perverse incentives when it comes to peering agreements.
- Klathmon 10y agoWell, they are cutting options. The price for 50/50mbps is staying the same in my area, however they have dropped the 75/75, 100/100, 150/150, and 300/300 options entirely and now offer 50/50 or 1000/1000 (which is actually 940/880 which is around the limits of "normal" ethernet). And while they advertise $69.99 on the site, clicking through to "more info" shows it as $79.99 and calling in to ask about it they are telling me it will be $89.99 for the first year, then $99.99 for the next year with a 2 year contract as a new customer only. And when I told them I am already a verizon customer, they had to re-run it and found that it will actually be $119.99 for the first year, $129.99 for the second year on a 2 year contract. And that's before I even get the bill which in my experience with verizon is often 10% larger than the quoted price with internet only (and when I had phone+internet+tv it was almost double the quoted price after taxes, fees, expired discounts, required equipment rentals, and other bullshit).
- smilekzs 10y agoIsn't this bait and switch?
- Klathmon 10y agoI don't know, but I know it's taught me to literally never believe a word of anything they say in terms of price, and to literally never sign a contract of any kind with them ever because they can't guarantee what the first bill will be (they can only give estimates), and by the time it actually comes you are already locked in for the 2 years.
- rhino369 10y agoI negotiated them down to 75 bucks (im still on contract for 6 more months). I had to pay 90 bucks to install a new fiber termination point though. And my price is only set until Nov.
- Blinks- 10y ago"SpaceX has also proposed an additional 7,500 satellites operating even closer to the ground, saying that this will boost capacity and reduce latency in heavily populated areas." This should be interesting, depending on how this is regulated on the legal side it could result in the major ISP's updating our infrastructure, of course nothing has stopped them from agreeing to update infrastructure then running off with our tax money in the past. Not to mention they will probably use legal means to hamstring this if possible. Hopefully this spurs competition in areas with stagnating ISP's and increases availability of low latency connections in sparsely populated areas.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> Not to mention they will probably use legal means to hamstring this if possible. I wonder how this could work. It's not like, e.g., Milwaukee has any legal oversight over LEO.
- extrapickles 10y agoOne possibility is passing laws/regulations about how many sats can be in a orbital plane or single launch, as they will want to launch dozens, if not the full 53 they want to put in a plane, with a single booster to reduce costs. They could also get some silly RF regulations passed that make it not feasible economically.
- kuschku 10y agoThen the operator of the constellation would just shift to using Arianespace as launch provider (which is equally expensive at the moment).
- mxvzr 10y agoCouldn't a municipality/HOA/whatever put in place restrictions on what kind of satellite dishes you may setup on your property?
- ct0 10y agoI was able to pay $20/mo for each month remaining on my contract to end service and start a new contract as a new customer when moving form 50/50 to 150/150.
- mattcoles 10y agoDo we have space in orbit for this? This is a lot of satellites and I also don't get how the latency can be so much lower than current satellite ISPs?
- jfolkins 10y agoThe 4,425 satellites will "operat[e] in 83 orbital planes (at altitudes ranging from 1,110km to 1,325km)," and "require associated ground control facilities, gateway Earth stations, and end-user Earth stations," Cooper said. By contrast, the existing HughesNet satellite network has an altitude of about 35,400km, making for a much longer round-trip time than ground-based networks
- IIIIIIIIIIII 10y agoTo get an impression I think it's a good idea to start with these pictures taken from the ISS [0], which is at about 400 km altitude (it varies a bit but not that much) - https://twistedsifter.files.wordpress.com/2015/04/nasa-earth-day-gallery-6.jpg https://twistedsifter.files.wordpress.com/2015/04/nasa-earth... - Spain: https://twistedsifter.files.wordpress.com/2015/04/nasa-earth-day-gallery-8.jpg https://twistedsifter.files.wordpress.com/2015/04/nasa-earth... Note that they are to the side, straight down you would see a much smaller area! So the SpaceX satellites would be three times higher. Still, you can see you may need quite a few stations on the ground, and also why you need so many satellites. They will fly over the area very quickly and by then the communication will already have to have been handed over to the next one. There is so much earth to cover, with satellites much higher up you cover a much wider area and you can have them in a stationary orbit. Earth has a diameter of 12,742 km, I have to keep reminding myself that even the ISS is barely above the surface if you were to look at earth from a distance. [0] Source: http://twistedsifter.com/2015/04/earth-day-gallery-by-nasa/ http://twistedsifter.com/2015/04/earth-day-gallery-by-nasa/
- dharma1 10y agoYes, until some of the thousands of small satellites about to be launched (not just by SpaceX) star breaking down and creating space junk that will become a serious problem to the launch of new satellites and spacecraft http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/04/20/mega-constellations-satellites-causing-space-junk-earths-orbit/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/04/20/mega-constellatio...
- akgerber 10y agoMy aunt's town in rural Western Massachusetts still only has broadband in the library plus scanty LTE service and current terrible satellite— how and whether to wire the town with broadband is driving the first contested election in decades. This could make a major difference for that type of rural town.
- BenjiWiebe 10y agoI'm in central Kansas. The options here are basically satellite or if you are close to town, then up to 6Mbps DSL. We have DSL, but most of our friends/neighbors can't get it...
- mobilefriendly 10y agoSame situation for our mid-Atlantic home. There's a ton of pent up demand for this service in all of the rural and semi-rural pockets of the U.S. We have been very poorly served by Congress, state, and local government.
- ams6110 10y ago> We have been very poorly served by Congress, state, and local government I live in a semi-rural area. I chose to live there. Why should everyone else pay to give me top-tier internet access? If high-speed internet access is important to me, I need to move to a neighborhood that has that amenity
- alasdair_ 10y ago>I live in a semi-rural area. I chose to live there. Why should everyone else pay to give me top-tier internet access? One could as why everyone else should have to pay to give you postal service at the same price as someone in, say, NYC when the cost of provision is much higher. The reason the person above you mentioned government is that it's likely that government owns the streets that any net access would run through as well as having countless other regulations that would need to be followed.
- bmcusick 10y agoThis is good news for the USA, but it's GREAT news for countries where the government regularly cuts off and controls the Internet for political purposes. If receivers can be as small as a personal laptop, expect a thriving black market in them in places like Iran and Egypt. Such receivers can also act as backhaul for mesh networks, providing access to un-censored information in times of turmoil and peace alike.
- bane 10y agoThey'll probably just end up turning off service over certain geographic areas.
- _archon_ 10y agoWhy would they do this? EDIT: Data customers would pay for access on an individual basis. Helicopter-parent countries might cry foul, but what leverage do they have? It's not like they were going to launch things with SpaceX and they can threaten to stop.
- elevensies 10y agoI think they need licenses to use the radio spectrum. I believe Iridium set up a system in China so that all calls are routed through Chinese systems, so there is some historical precedent. The government of China also has anti-satellite weapons: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Chinese_anti-satellite_missile_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Chinese_anti-satellite_mi... .
- linkregister 10y agoA nation using an anti-satellite weapon against another entity's satellite would be an unlikely, enormous escalation.
- ouid 10y agoAnd one with profoundly self-destructive consequences too.
- IndexicalDemon 10y agoIt's a cool system. There's a slight disadvantage that the satellite-to-ground link is at 10-15 GHz for users, so it will go down in a heavy rainstorm, and some fraction of the time due to other atmospheric effects. Should be reasonably reliable but far from fiber, and it will be interesting to see what uptime they guarantee. Assuming this all ever actually happens.
- alkonaut 10y agoI assume the sensitity to weather etc depends on the type of equipment you have? Couldn't a community use a huge high power and high sensitivity common receiver/transmitter station, that provides fiber to 10-1000 households? The community station could also provide some kind of limited bandwidth fallback such as DSL or LTE that just ensures peoples fiber lines limp along when the satellites can't be reached (so their juice machines don't stop working...).
- rhino369 10y agoThe cost of fiber is mostly the cost of hooking up homes. Once you have that, the cost of running a connection to a telecom is cheap comparatively.
- alkonaut 10y agoI think that's true in places like (large parts of) the US where the "last mile problem" exists. However for lots of rural Africa, China, Australia there surely must also exist a "first 1000miles problem".
- artursapek 10y agoOh how I wish I could buy SpaceX stock...
- boznz 10y agoYou can buy a Baseball cap and a hoodie, that was my way of supporting them :-)
- deegles 10y agoI'm seriously considering getting a job there someday for this this reason. (but mostly because Mars)
- artursapek 10y agoI once got a recruiting email from them, but when I looked later the guy was in prison. He was the "Silk Road 2" guy. So now I don't have any contacts there :(
- kinkrtyavimoodh 10y agoI wish they don't go public anytime soon if they can avoid it. There is already enough nonsense we have to endure about TSLA every time any discussion about Tesla or Elon comes up. We don't need the additional mindkill of 'Time to short SpaceX!'.
- T-A 10y agohttp://www.reuters.com/article/us-spacex-ipo-idUSKBN17Z1Q8 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-spacex-ipo-idUSKBN17Z1Q8
- protomyth 10y agoI thought the limiting factor for a satellite ISP was power on the satellite side as much as latency?
- ekimekim 10y agoI'm not an electrical or signals engineer, but IIUC the low orbits would also help there, since shorter distances mean much less power requirements for transmission.
- soheil 10y agoCompared to my connection Webpass with sub-1ms latencies this seems like ages. But of course not the same can be said about majority of ISPs so this is a big win.
- abuani 10y agoYeah my current options are Verizon DSL(1.5Mbps) or Comcast. During non peak hours, I can normally hit 200Mmb download/upload, but during peak hours I'm lucky to be able to stream a song or video without it lagging. I'm about 5 homes away from getting FIOS, and they recently started expanding in my area after years of zero growth, so I'm hoping I can get a single competitor to Comcast.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- slinger 10y agoDo this means that it'll be possible to play with folks from another continent with a good latency?
- Klasiaster 10y agoNot really, you still are limited to speed of light – so > ~100 ms roundtrips for half of the globe.
- slinger 10y agoSad.. Let's hope for breakthroughs on quantum entanglement research then
- maxthegeek1 10y agoThat still won't give us faster than light speed communication.
- bostonvaulter2 10y agoYes it potentially would: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_entanglement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_entanglement
- undersuit 10y agoHow do you reconcile your claim of FTL transmission with this statement directly from your link: "It is not possible, however, to use this effect to transmit classical information at faster-than-light speeds"?
- gknoy 10y agoThe speed of transmission of Quantum entanglement would, I believe, be limited by the speed of light between the two points in space, without having to traverse a path that follows the curve of the surface of the earth. So, communicating from Australia to Norway would traverse the diameter of the earth, rather than half of the circumference (plus satellites of course)
- oceanswave 10y agoSeven years. US Broadband providers have seven years to take us over the coals, practice full bore capitalism with our data and generally run oligilistic practices until their time even begins to run out
- hackuser 10y agoYou have alternatives now; 4G cellular is one example. But they are difficult and/or expensive. We'll have to see if this solution is different; right now it's just a plan.
- shmerl 10y agoIf it's difficult and/or expensive, it's not a real alternative, isn't it?
- ben_w 10y agoI'm using 3G or 4G as a cheaper alternative to landline broadband. It's… acceptable, but not amazing. 20 GB per month doesn't go as far as it used to before I started watching so many YouTube videos, even though I use 144p whenever possible.
- mlindner 10y agoYou should check out T-Mobile. They have free video streaming if you enable it, but it forcibly downgrades the video streams to no higher than 720p. That still sounds like much better than you have however.
- PopsiclePete 10y agoI'll believe it when I see it. They managed to somehow stop Google Fiber, they might be able to stop SpaceX as well.
- shmerl 10y agoThey didn't stop Google Fiber. GF own gutless management did.
- api 10y agoPlease call it Skynet. :)
- modeless 10y agoShorter summary of SpaceX's Senate testimony https://www.commerce.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/6c08b6c2-fe74-4500-ae1d-a801f53fd279/655C5CBED75A50881172C1E9069D91E6.testimony-patricia-cooper---broadband-infrastructure-hearing.pdf https://www.commerce.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/6c08b6c2...: Initially, the SpaceX system will consist of 4,425 satellites operating in 83 orbital planes (at altitudes ranging from 1,110 km to 1,325 km). SpaceX has proposed an additional constellation of 7,500 satellites operating even closer to Earth. For the end consumer, SpaceX user terminals—essentially, a relatively small flat panel, roughly the size of a laptop—will use phased array technologies to allow for highly directive, steered antenna beams that track the system’s low-Earth orbit satellites. In space, the satellites will communicate with each other using optical inter-satellite links, in effect creating a “mesh network” flying overhead that will enable seamless network management and continuity of service. Later this year, SpaceX will begin the process of testing the satellites themselves, launching one prototype before the end of the year and another during the early months of 2018. Following successful demonstration of the technology, SpaceX intends to begin the operational satellite launch campaign in 2019. The remaining satellites in the constellation will be launched in phases through 2024, when the system will reach full capacity.
- CoolGuySteve 10y agoFor comparison, the Iridium constellation gave a mode of 1300ms latency with a constellation of 66 active satellites orbiting at 780 km in 6 planes. SpaceX launched 10 new Iridium satellites in 2017. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellatio... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_Communications#Iridium_satellite_constellation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_Communications#Iridium...
- shaklee3 10y agoWhere do you see anything about the antenna size? All I've seen is that this will be for Enterprise customers, and the antenna will be very large. By the way, a very small phased array will be very low gain, thus using more capacity on their satellite for the same speeds. Unless they've invented a new type of antenna...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- faragon 10y agoSo Musk wants to be the Internet, too. I, for one, welcome that.
- tehwhynot 10y agoDo the same thing on Mars. Then get self-driving space internet machines that transfer internet from here to Mars. They always position themselves to be between here and Mars for best RTT. Thank me later, humanity. And yeah, I know latency would be between 6 and ~45 minutes.
- c22 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Internet https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Internet https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2017/nasa-taking-first-steps-toward-high-speed-space-internet https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2017/nasa-taking-first-...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoNeat, TeleDesic[1] V2.0 (or is it 3.0?) :). That effort stalled when single stage to orbit rockets became impractical due to insufficent launch demand when Regan's StarWars program was cancelled. With a fast turn around re-usable F9 booster (so its relaunch costs are significantly less than launching a new one) Musk would have control over his destiny in this case. When Iridium was being built the whole ground station thing (up/down links into the switched telephone network) was nearly a decade slog of permission, licenses, and regulations. That said, if he is successful he will suck a lot of money out of wallets that belong to some pretty big fat cats companies. And if he made every ground station a Tor exit node it would really mess with the powers that be. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teledesic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teledesic
- mistermann 10y ago> it would really mess with the powers that be I'm fairly surprised the US government is a-ok with all of this, or maybe they've already sat down and had a chit chat with Mr Musk. Or, if everyone moves to SpaceX internet service does it make no difference whatsoever to the NSA?
- BenjiWiebe 10y agoThe NSA will probably monitor the lines going from SpaceX ground stations to what ever Tier 1 ISP they are peering with.
- woah 10y agoThe US funded tor for most its existence
- fpgaminer 10y agoI was curious about the financials of this project. Here's my back of the napkin: According to (https://www.quora.com/How-much-does-it-cost-to-set-up-and-launch-a-communications-satellite https://www.quora.com/How-much-does-it-cost-to-set-up-and-la...) it costs ~$80-$100 million per satellite to build, launch, and run. So that's ~$354-$443 billion for all the satellites. Let's call it $443. Now, I pay ~$60/m for internet. That's $720/yr. If they want to recoup costs after 10 years, it'll take ~61.5 million subscribers. For the U.S. alone, that'll probably never happen. But worldwide? Maybe. Though worldwide the price per subscribe will be less, often times substantially less. On the other hand, SpaceX will have lots of operational discounts because its their own rockets, and they already have all the supply channels for building space tech. And maybe they aren't looking to payback in 10 years for this initial run; maybe they only want to break even so payback in 15 is good enough. Just some numbers for thought. P.S. Businesses unlucky enough to be in "rural" areas, aka most commercial business parks outside of tech cities, are in the unfortunate position of paying the local telephone company/AT&T/TimeWarner thousands per month for roughly dial-up speeds. SpaceX could charge the same but offer broadband speeds and get a nice chunk of business, methinks.
- mrinterweb 10y agoI doubt that the per/satellite cost would be anywhere close to $80-100 million. I remember hearing that the plan was for these satellites to have significantly less mass than other satellites and therefore, one orbital launch could deliver many satellites. With these satellites orbiting ~30-34x closer to Earth, the satellites would need to have significantly less mass if they were going to not have their orbital distance not degrade too quickly. I don't know what the expected lifespan of these satellites will be, but I assume they will eventually burn up in the atmosphere.
- wolfram74 10y agoSaying their mass needs to be lower to reduce orbit degradation is the opposite of true. Assuming two spheres of equal size, their drag and thus change in momentum will be the same at the same altitude. But if one sphere was made of lead and the other made of styrofoam, the styrofoam one will decelerate much faster than the lead one. So: lighter satellite of the same shape means shorter life span. But drag dies down roughly exponentially in altitude, so if they're at 1000 km, rather than 100km, that's not a super big factor.
- mabbo 10y agoIt's been said before, but what people need to understand is that the goal of this service isn't to make money- it's to balance demand. SpaceX can plan to launch be 30% more launches than their actual customers need. All those extra rockets are used for internet satellites. If there's an accident (boom) or a sudden need for more rockets, the internet satellites get delayed, and the paying customer gets a rocket. If customers are finicky about using re-flown rockets, that's fine, the internal customer doesn't care. If a customer backs out for any reason, the internal customer takes their place. Rocket production gets a smooth flow going, which improves production efficiency.
- jblow 10y agoIf there's an accident (boom) then the paying customer's payload is destroyed and in most cases they will not have a duplicate payload just standing by to be launched. Building satellites takes a while.
- mcbits 10y agoI think the theory is that the next customer scheduled for the dead rocket can share some other rocket instead. The internal satellite(s) on that rocket get delayed, but at least it would be loaded to capacity even if the previous rocket didn't go boom.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoWrong. The goal is to make money. Billions of dollars. That money is to help fund Mars colonization, which has been SpaceX's ultimate goal from the beginning. There's also some nice synergy in that similar tech can be used to deploy a global communications network for Mars as well.
- namlem 10y agoMusk himself has stated the goal is to make money to help pay for colonizing Mars.
- rsync 10y ago
- devrandomguy 10y agoIt would be super cool if amateur cubesats could interface with this network. I've always wanted to run a server on orbit, where energy is free and regulations are limited to RF spectrum issues.
- stubish 10y agoGet it up there, and you will have Australia as a client. We have made a mess of the national broadband network rollout, and this might be going live before the NBN rollout is complete. Probably faster, cheaper, and with reliability still to be seen.
- candiodari 10y agoInteresting. What would this be able to do ? Current wireless speeds, even with state of the art technology, is going to be something like 10Gbit. That'll have to be shared by an entire city at least (correction: about 2 satellites per state on average. Less for New York), and of course there won't be any CDNs or HTTP caches "upstairs" so to speak. So 1 bit in = 1 bit back out. Even at 4425 satellites that means, let's see. The earth is 500 million km2, and they don't need the same density everywhere, so some optimizations may be possible, so let's say 5000 satellites. That means 100,000 km2 per satellite. That means one satellite per decent sized country, only about 100 for the entire US. This is not geostationary orbit, so they'll have to aim for evenly spaced satellites. Let's say they fix their satellites and do 10x what is currently possible, so that means 100Gbit/satellite. Current internet traffic into and out of the Netherlands is 50 times that (granted, more and denser cities than portugal, but the Netherlands would have to share one SpaceX satellite with Belgium and parts of the UK). They would only be able to provide about 1/10,000,000th of a Satellite to a cellphone in the US, and if they have 100 Gbit/satellite, that's not even 1kbit on average. Even 10x or 100x that capacity wouldn't change much. Doubling or tripling the number of satellites won't fix this, we'd need between hundreds of thousands and to millions of satellites. This will either need to be rather expensive (certainly as much as your cellphone, probably more, as this seems to indicate the system can only support 100x less users than the mobile network in the US, and even less in smaller dense countries or cities like the Netherlands or New York). Even at state of the art technologies, bandwidth limits are going to be tight. Like any satellite service, I can't see this work at city densities, or for mobiles.
- onion2k 10y agoThe benefit of a satellite network is ubiquitous connectivity regardless of where you are, not speed.
- lmm 10y agoWithin the city there's usually wifi. Broadband that you can use anywhere on the world (or at least anywhere there aren't so many people), even Antarctica or Everest or Crimea or the middle of the ocean, seems like it would be worth paying quite a premium for.
- 10y ago
- dboreham 10y agoUgh. Are they really talking about Latency, or are the numbers they cite actually RTT? And are the numbers the loop latency, or end-to-end latency to some destination on the public network such as 8.8.8.8? For comparison my CableCo connection in the left-middle of America achieves a loop RTT of about 10ms (5ms Latency), and an RTT to 8.8.8.8 of 25ms (12.5ms Latency).
- Retric 10y ago1,110km ~= 4ms each way so 8ms from ground to satellite to ground but that only get you to the internet and you need to do that again on the way back so 16ms is the minimum latency possible. However, ~25ms round trips seems possible especially if they have enough ground stations near major interchanges. PS: Remember, they can put these stations near anything that people want low latency connections to.