12 ms·
Twilio stock plummets as major client Uber distances itself
- the_common_man 10y agoTwilio is really a one trick pony. As messaging apps proliferate, the need for sms/telephony will slowly die out.
- josh_carterPDX 10y agoNot sure I would say that. They have voice, video, messaging, SIP, etc. They have a lot of tricks.
- stale2002 10y agoThey've got a lot of attempts to expand to similar markets, but the problem is that most are second class. Twilio is the market leader for developer SMS, and voice. They are not the market leader for any of the other categories that they are trying to expand to.
- josh_carterPDX 10y agoNot yet.
- chrsstrm 10y agoAs someone looking to work with both programmable video messaging and SIP trunking in the very near future, can you name competitors that do it better?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoLook at bandwidth.com for SIP trunking. Edit: if I recall correctly from many years ago, this is who Twilio uses for their US telecom/CLEC interface. Edit 2: yep, bandwidth.com now even competes against Twilio: https://getvoip.com/amp/blog/2016/06/01/twilio-alternatives/ https://getvoip.com/amp/blog/2016/06/01/twilio-alternatives/
- stale2002 10y agoIt doesn't matter. Pick a competitor at random and the competitor will be 100X cheaper. Twilio is good at one thing. And that is the developer experience. If you are willing to pay 100X the price, in order to have awesome documentation, then Twilio is the right solution for you. Otherwise.... Well.... Anything else is probably better.
- jessaustin 10y agoIf that's true, it's hard to imagine why anyone at Uber's size is still using Twilio.
- phamilton 10y agoBecause big contracts give companies leverage for discounts. Netflix, for example, pays way less than AWS on demand pricing.
- getsauce 10y ago100X the price? When it comes to SIP trunking at least, Twilio is one of the cheapest[0] if not the cheapest pay per minute provider. Compare with Flowroute[1] for instance, another popular SIP trunking provider, Twilio is significantly cheaper, especially on origination. [0] https://www.twilio.com/sip-trunking/pricing https://www.twilio.com/sip-trunking/pricing [1] https://www.flowroute.com/pricing/ https://www.flowroute.com/pricing/
- derimagia 10y agoThey bought Authy as well.
- nix0n 10y agoI think an SMS/WhatsApp/WeChat/Hangouts/FBMessenger bridge could be an even more useful service than just an SMS bridge.
- mrbabbage 10y agoThere's a YC company called Front that does more or less this: https://frontapp.com/ https://frontapp.com/
- sotojuan 10y agoWe use this at work for talking to customers and it works fine, but note that they use Twilio under the hood IIRC. Also their SPA app is what you'd expect from JavaScript apps—buggy and prone to slowness once it reaches a certain scale.
- MichaelGG 10y agoWhatsApp would be huge. A WhatsApp PBX, auto-responders, etc. But it seems like FB would nix access pretty quickly so you'd constantly be playing whack-a-mole. They might even terminate the underlying account, making it too risky for businesses to even consider.
- kevinburke 10y agohttps://www.twilio.com/blog/2017/04/twilio-notify-public-beta-now-open.html https://www.twilio.com/blog/2017/04/twilio-notify-public-bet...
- panzer_wyrm 10y agoFor the observable future telephony is the only thing that guarantees that a connection will get to you now. And sms-s have very good track records of getting them while your coverage is spotty.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoNot really. If you're a business that needs to text your customers, you'd much rather use one API to send SMS messages than have to dick around with FB messenger, WhatsApp, etc.
- josh_carterPDX 10y agoLove the spin the media is putting on Twilio's earnings call. Uber load balances its traffic across multiple providers. Moving their traffic off Twilio shouldn't be seen as a signal that they're distancing themselves from Twilio. Twilio has a model that's hard to predict long-term revenue. This will continue until they figure out how to get more high value companies to sign contracts.
- paulsutter 10y agoSo you're saying they're a commodity offering with no customer lock-in?
- josh_carterPDX 10y agoThey're a SaaS play with no lock-in. Which is great for businesses who want to use Twilio on a small scale then grow strategically. Sucks for Twilio because they want to have as much predictable revenue as possible.
- ithinkinstereo 10y agoI disagree about the no lock-in. Twilio just works. You can set it up and then forget about it, which I think is very appealing to the SMB market. The hassle of moving off Twilio likely outweighs the cost savings. So LTV is prob high and churn pretty low. As long as they can grow accounts, (which they are doing and the pace is accelerating), I think they'll be fine.
- mooreds 10y agoI think they are just like stripe. When you get to a certain volume you start to do the cost benefit analysis of moving off the saas provider. Until then they are the first choice for a large portion of the developer population. After that, it's just a numbers game: will it cost more to redevelop the functionality they provide (either on your own or with another vendor) than you will save over a reasonable timeframe? If the answer is yes, you keep paying twilio, otherwise out migrate. I have no first hand experience on what size makes sense for twilio, but this article gives us an upper bound (a huge one, to be sure).
- elmar 10y agoA Guide To Twilio's $53.5B Opportunity, Why It's At Risk, And 3 Ways The Company Can Win. https://exponents.co/twilio-market-opportunities-risks/ https://exponents.co/twilio-market-opportunities-risks/
- jeffjose 10y agoThat was a fascinating read. Thank you!
- appleflaxen 10y agogreat write up. when was it written? it's frustrating there is no date on the post.
- daro 10y agoIt's pretty recent; there is no date given but it references the Twilio 10-K report from February 22, 2017.
- lucasmullens 10y agoYou know where I am nearly every single time I get an Uber or Lyft? Right outside my building, where my phone is hanging onto a Wi-Fi connection that won't work from there. Maybe it's not as common as it is in my life, but SMS seems essential until phones figure out how to deal with the Wi-Fi limbo state.
- chambo622 10y agoThis is very accurate. I've gotten in the habit of manually killing my phone's WiFi as I leave my apartment and start walking down the hall calling a Lyft/Uber, and the same when outside my office. This remains an unsolved problem.
- theossuary 10y agoIt really isn't. It'd be trivial to allow mobile data to always supplement wifi data. There are apps that do this already ([1] and [2]), and some phones have the option as well (either stock or as a ROM). The problem are cellular data caps, nobody wants to blow their caps by using cellular when they could be using wifi only. There is no way for wifi to know when you're about to lose coverage, or have spotty coverage; the only way around it is to always have the mobile antenna connected to towers so it can take over. But that costs money, many mobile phone companies even disable these options on their phones to reduce congestion in their towers ([3], though it may be out of date now). One day we might solve this problem, if we're ever able to pressure phone companies into reinvesting into their infrastructure instead of their investors. [1]: http://speedify.com/mobile-vpn http://speedify.com/mobile-vpn [2]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=it.opbyte.superdownload_lite https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=it.opbyte.supe... [3]: http://forums.androidcentral.com/samsung-galaxy-s5/402722-how-enable-download-booster-sprint-t-verizon-galaxy-s5.html http://forums.androidcentral.com/samsung-galaxy-s5/402722-ho...
- acchow 10y agoYou can enable Wifi Assist on your iPhone to automatically switch to Cellular data when Wifi is weak.
- CephalopodMD 10y agoAs a layman, I don't understand. I mean it's bad news, but they may probably lose 12% of their business vs a 30% stock price drop while still hitting estimates (admittedly at the low end) for revenue this quarter. The price should definitely drop, but why is this not an overreaction?
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoMight be an overreaction, might not. If Uber dropping out is a leading signal for "major clients aren't getting value out of their business relationship with Twilio", then that's a major problem going forward.
- josh_carterPDX 10y agoIt's great for those that targeted their puts at the $25 range and definitely for those that have been sitting on the sidelines waiting to jump in. It's not going to stay down here for long. I agree. Total overreaction.
- kevinburke 10y agoThere were (are?) a ton of people shorting Twilio so it may have been hard to find a buyer
- this_user 10y agoStock price is about expectations for the future. The last quarter only matters insofar as it offers insight into the future development of a business. And that 30% drop is also not necessarily about a single issue like Uber leaving. TWLO guided lower for Q2, coming in below expectations on both profit and sales. Furthermore, Uber may be 12% of their business now, but that company is growing, and this means the market expected TWLO to make even more money with them in the future, which is not happening anymore. This also highlights how concentrated TWLO's business is, and how quickly they can lose a meaningful chunk of their revenue. Lack of diversification means more risk, and maybe the market had not fully priced that in.
- tedmiston 10y agoIt is overreaction. Give it a few days and it'll bounce back from where it is now. http://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/overreaction.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/overreaction.asp
- dade_ 10y agoTwillio's business made no sense to me until now. I can build the exact same apps for customers using SMS gateways for a lower rate. Sure, they provide a single provider for a small company, but there are better features and rates offered by local companies in each country. So how many small companies have an SMS app that requires global SMS gateways? From a technical perspective, I think what they built is great, but at rates around a penny per message, how could I make a profit? A single large customer such as Uber makes sense, but if your business success is based on a unicorn, then good luck to you. I really think that Twillio is first to market because of the inept management of telcos, but how do you compete when they figure it out? Further, the rates per message drop dramatically on a contract for volume, especially in the wholesale market. Then of course there is O365 Microsoft Skype for business, and I expect that all of these capabilities will be available with their UCWA api.
- carlosdp 10y agoOn the note of "I really think that Twillio is first to market because of the inept management of telcos, but how do you compete when they figure it out?", the time for them "figuring it out" has come and passed imo. All the big players tried to create their own offerings to compete with Twilio years ago, but they didn't catch on because they weren't developer-friendly. At this point, they prefer to remain the platform that companies like Twilio build upon from what I can tell. (disclaimer: former Twilio engineer)
- caseysoftware 10y agoBefore I worked for Twilio, I worked for an tier-1 SMS aggregator. Integrating with the various providers - even in the US - was a pain in the ass and connectivity fees started in the $10k+ range with monthly minimums and 10c/message iirc. When I played with Twilio then, I knew they'd win, it was just a matter of when. When I joined Twilio, I focused on use cases that connected communications to revenue.. either on the sales side or the customer support side. Sure, 1c/message in isolation seems expensive until you realize that by sending a handful of messages (aka pennies) and being more transparent with customers, your churn drops (aka dollars). At that point, it's not even a debate. On the international front, it got even more complex. The aggregator I worked for had contracts in the US, LATAM, and throughout Europe, each one had different interfaces, connectors, and agreements. Twilio has one. Once again, not even a debate. Disclosure: I've been out of Twilio for 3.5 years, so no inside info here but I still have shares.
- sgustard 10y ago"revenue would fall between $356 and $362 million for the year." There's a sentence that should be written more carefully.
- neom 10y agoYeah I read that and almost sold all my twilio stock till I dug in.
- jaxn 10y agoThe reason companies move away from SMS is because they are using it wrong. SMS is for two-way communication and not notifications. I have a small company that is having great success with a niche product that uses SMS as a two-way customer communication platform. SMS is perfect for customer service (universal, no app to install), but it hasn't caught on yet. SMS notifications are like noreply@ email addresses.
- sidlls 10y agoPerhaps I'm not a typical person but I strongly prefer SMS for my one-way notifications from service providers for appointments I've set up. I don't want to have to answer a call to hear a recorded voice tell me about the appointment or, worse, actually respond to a real human. E-mail is okay but I don't check it often. For me SMS message notifications fit just right.
- jaxn 10y agoYeah, but what if you want to respond to the text? There should be a human on the other side.
- sidlls 10y agoWhy would I want to, other than to send "C" or "N" or whatever the prompt is to confirm/reject the appointment in cases where that applies? In cases where no response is prompted and I need to cancel, then I'll call (or email if that's available).
- jaxn 10y agoMost people don't like making phone calls, but you should be able to dial the number you just received the text from.
- Animats 10y agoYes. There are even companies which provide only outbound SMS. Their customers are usually spammers, broadly defined.
- kamilszybalski 10y agoCustomer concentration risk is a real thing.
- hendzen 10y agoHow much of Twilio's revenue comes from unprofitable VC-funded companies?
- zachsnow 10y agoI have no idea, but profitable companies use it regularly. The larger question is whether enough smaller, profitable companies exist to backstop losses from larger, (unprofitable) companies abandoning ship to continue their growth.
- eggie5 10y agowhat is Uber going to use instead of Twillio?
- phamilton 10y agoOnce you get to the 1 billion sms per month range, you can actually just become your own carrier / MVNO.
- venture_lol 10y agoWhat is the number one Twilio differentiation? The price or its APIs?
- gkoberger 10y agoAt this point, marketing/mindshare is #1. (That being said: they are priced competitively, do have a great API, can do things may others can't (ie MMS), and have great deliverability across carriers.)
- jorangreef 10y ago"That being said: they are priced competitively" Twilio is perhaps one of the most expensive of all SMS gateways. Twilio's achilles heel is their value-added approach to pricing what should instead be priced as a commodity, i.e. cost-plus pricing supported by vertical integration and economies of scale.
- phamilton 10y agoOne of the big barriers to entry in the space is spam whitelisting. Every time you send an SMS message, there's a chance the carrier flags it as spam and doesn't deliver it. Twilio and others try to give customers a higher chance of successful delivery. That comes with direct carrier relationships and stuff.
- fujipadam 10y agoAs a hobby, I have been studying "oversold" stocks for the past month and am starting to see that the market is prone to over reactions. AMD and RTTR for example are stocks that were drastically punished for no good reason. I am assuming here is where Warren Buffet like folks buy. That said Twilio does seem to have a reason to tumble. The risk of losing WhatsApp also is too high for this valuation
- sokoloff 10y agoI think there's maybe something tradable from over-reactions to short-term news, but buying on an "over-reaction dip" is fraught with peril that it's just the beginning of a prolonged fall. I bought a bunch of UAL after the UA3411 incident came out and sold the last of it today for a tidy profit. Now, if their earnings had been lackluster or worse, that trade could have gone poorly. I have also made money in aggregate on 3x oil ETFs, but the swings can be long and deep.
- mholmes680 10y agoI think your assumption on Buffett is wrong. Buffett finds companies that have a significant competitive advantage (moat) and prefers stable, blue chip, traditional brand names, preferably with dividends, that are most likely to just keep growing. And then from that group, he finds the best pricing in industries he understands to be good businesses. Buffett wouldn't touch a company like AMD, punished or not. When Buffett does it right, he's specifically mitigated the risk of a stock getting punished well ahead of earnings. I'm interested to learn what you've found on oversold stocks though - have anything written up?
- lpage 10y agoThe TC article is light on details compared to the actual call and 10-K. Uber was 12% of total rev at the start of 2016, and 17% later on. WhatsApp was the next largest at 9% for the year. Concentration falls off from there, with the 3rd largest customer at 2%. Twilio's initial (unamended) S-1 filing uses Uber as a customer case study [1]. They called out WhatsApp as a business risk given that they were and are a variable account (15% of their business at the time). Uber was not, potentially because they're a Base Customer Account, but as noted in in the 10-K [2]: "its usage historically has significantly exceeded the minimum revenue commitment in its contract, and it could significantly reduce its usage of our products without notice or penalty." [1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1447669/000104746916013448/a2227414zs-1.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1447669/000104746916... [2] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1447669/000104746917000800/a2230935z10-k.htm#dq43801_item_4._mine_safety_disclosures https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1447669/000104746917...
- Neliquat 10y agoTo me, that seems like an excelent risk profile, and no reason to sell. Uber seems to have a stench to it lately, and to be free of that large customer influncing your growth is a net positive. But stocks react in real time.
- cyberferret 10y agoI seem to have missed it in the article and from reading the comments here, but what exactly is Uber's reason for moving away from Twilio? Are they building their own comms & SMS infrastructure in house? Are they big enough now to work out bulk deals with Telcos in each country? Are they spreading their load across multiple comms providers? In any case, I would have thought the move would have been planned well ahead, giving Twilio time and notice to try and entice other huge customers, possibly even Uber's rivals to step in and take up the capacity?
- busterarm 10y agoEx-phone company employee and someone who set up his own personal voip service (Asterix server) with DID & Termination for dirtcheap "cell phone" service here: It's such an easy thing to do, but requires a lot of coordinated effort to do correctly. A company of Uber's size definitely should be in-housing this kind of operation and so should anyone with budget to hire engineers and a competent ops team. Heck, the hedge fund I worked at had a dedicated telephony team. It's not sexy technology, so nobody wants to do it and that's where Twilio makes all of their money. Expensive, but convenient.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 10y agoI would disagree. Twilio should be able to do it better and less expensively than Uber. The only think I can think of is Twilio refused to lower its prices or there's a glaring deficiency that Twilio is unable or unwilling to fix.
- busterarm 10y agoReally? Twilio pulled in ~$277 million last year. Uber was supposedly 12% of that. You're saying it would have cost Uber more than $33 million and change to do their telephony? I strongly doubt that. Uber doesn't need all of Twilio's features. They can build out just what they need much cheaper. This is the same situation people find themselves in with AWS, etc. It's less expensive _initially_. There's a point where this becomes not the case.
- uladzislau 10y agoAs far as I know Uber goal is to replace all of the 3rd parties APIs/products they're using with built in-house. So I guess any company having Uber as a major customer should be concerned.
- nodesocket 10y agoWhere did you hear this? Have a source?
- venture_lol 10y agoAll large enough companies would consider this. Why pay someone else when you are the driver for economies of scale?
- derefr 10y agoWhat are the margins on Twilio's business model, anyway? People are always saying that at medium-scale with a non-spiky workload, IaaS is way more expensive than your own servers. So, in the same sense: at medium scale, is Twilio "more expensive than" a PBX + business SIP line + custom glue programming?
- animex 10y agoI'm surprised Facebook hasn't absorbed / internalized WhatsApp's SMS requirements.
- staticautomatic 10y ago"What at first glance appeared to be a positive story very quickly divulged into a financial nightmare." Just wanted to point out that the author is a bit of an idiot.
- thogenhaven 10y agoIMO, the market is vastly overreacting. It's only natural that the customers that grow very big (e.g. Uber) eventually build a proprietary alternative to cut costs. That doesnt mean that the need for the service is generally declining
- bluetwo 10y agoFor the record, working with a company because they fill a need in which you lack expertise and then creating your own version that reduces your need on them is called a switchback.
- sitkack 10y agoWhich totally makes sense from a game theoretic standpoint. I rent a car while mine is getting fixed. I stay in a hotel for a week while a renovation is done. I rent to own while I look for the right thing to buy. The cloud is literally rent-a-wreck or rent-to-own furniture. As a cloud provider you constantly have to be adding more features and "value", otherwise the customer will build in house. And not just to cost reduce but to get transparency of ops. Clouds are opaque, companies are wise to launch on cloud then bring in house for lots of reasons. From the cloud providers side, view each individual customer as ephemeral. When you have a single huge customer, you aren't a business anymore, you're a contractor.
- _pmf_ 10y agoTwilio's business model is not having to call a telco account manager.