16 ms·
The Future of Energy Isn't Fossil Fuels or Renewables, It's Nuclear Fusion
- zomg 10y agocorrection: nucular
- rini17 10y agoCompare and ponder "Fusion reactors: Not what they’re cracked up to be": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14202488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14202488
- sidcool 10y agoWould be great if we could harness fusion energy. But in present and near future, renewables are the saviours.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoRenewables are simply fusion capture at a distance ;)
- mrchucklepants 10y agoThat's actually true of non-renewable energy as well.
- autokad 10y agotechnically coal power is solar, coal is just the fuel cells / batteries
- marssaxman 10y agoI like the joke that my house is fusion-powered; the reactor is of course located in a remote industrial area, for safety, and I rely on an array of roof-mounted receivers for long-range wireless power transfer. Conveniently enough, this reactor happens to be a deregulated and tragically undersubscribed public utility service...
- toomuchtodo 10y agoLove your comment. Reminds me of something I'd read in a Douglas Adams book.
- mcguire 10y agoIs there some name for the argument that "The future is not [a technology that currently works, if not perfectly], it's [an open research problem if it can be made to work at all]"? Fusion, hydrogen fuel cells,...
- sidcool 10y agoPipe Dream? /s
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dzdt 10y agoThe future of energy is nuclear fusion -- carried out in a tremendously massive reactor at a safe distance of 150 million km from the nearest civilian population. Technology to convert radiation from that reactor directly to electricity is already cost-competitive with other energy sources and the price is still declining rapidly. Together with secondary capture techniques that drive turbines based on air or water flows driven by the energy of that reactor, the majority of humanity's energy needs will be met by that one source in a few decades. Smaller reactors will never reach a cost scale to be competitive, even if they can eventually be made to function.
- kristopolous 10y agoRenewables decentralize energy. The whole point is to make it not a commodity you have to constantly buy and transport, but something everyone at all levels of infrastructure could make themselves locally. There's a Moore's law of solar called Swanson's law which is on track for what in today's terms we'd effectively call "free energy" sometime in the nest few decades. Another big idea is that these don't require any manual capturing, transport, and feeding of fuel. You install them, make sure they are clean and essentially that's it. Nothing more to mine or constantly load into the machine. A robust, fault tolerant, dynamic system of community and family power is the actual future and only dramatically decentralized things like that will ultimately be politically viable and sustainable. They will more likely survive wars and infrastructure collapse; something that a model reliant on a few multibillion dollar plants will never be able to do. Sustainability is not only about ecology but also about decomodifying energy and not having to be constantly reliant on some large group of people maintaining an infrastructure to keep the lights on.
- grecy 10y agoMy off-grid friends struggle to get house insurance, because without "grid electricity" insurance companies don't consider a house worthwhile (it's actually a really, really nice house, worth close on a million dollars now). Anyway, my friend asks the insurance assessor how often he has a power failure at his house "Oh, only a couple of times a year" says the man. In 10 years living off grid, my friends have never had a single outage.
- mrfusion 10y agoSo what did he end up doing for insurance?
- grecy 10y agoHe has spent years and years hunting out the one or two companies that will actually cover him. Unfortunately, he pays something like $1900/month, because he is distant from the nearest fire station, and again, city-based insurance companies see that as a big problem. The house is in the Yukon, far out there.
- mrfusion 10y agoI was just reading about bubble fusion. From the info I found it seemed like the whole reason it won't work is because the researcher that discovered it was dishonest. (And it couldn't be replicated) But it seems like one experimental design failing shouldn't rule out the entire concept? It seems like it's physically possible, no? Ie nothing in physics rules it out.
- FiatLuxDave 10y agoTaleyarkhan's failures alone shouldn't rule out a concept, agreed. A bigger problem is that although sonofusion does appear capable of creating small plasmas which in theory could be hot and dense enough for fusion, the amount of time during which the plasma remains at that temperature and density seems to be too small. In other words, there seems to be insufficient containment. A common misconception about fusion is that containment is all about keeping the particles from leaving. But often, it is more about keeping the energy from leaving. A momentum-based containment design like sonofusion uses is subject to Rayleigh instabilities which carry the energy away in fast moving particles.
- mrfusion 10y agoInteresting point. Is that basically the same problem NIF has albeit in a different medium?
- FiatLuxDave 10y agoBasically.
- viggity 10y agoDotNetRocks (a popular .net podcast) does "geek outs" every so often on science/technology. They've done a couple on Nuclear Fusion. It gives a great overview of all the different companies and their approaches to nuclear fusion. Highly recommended. https://www.dotnetrocks.com/?show=1415 https://www.dotnetrocks.com/?show=1415
- anovikov 10y agoI am getting to feel that fusion runs out of time. They already barely have enough time for large-scale rollout before renewables overtake everything. In 10 years from now, if someone achieves net energy positive fusion, it will be solution in search of a problem - cheap and abundant electricity will be a reality.
- kwhitefoot 10y agoA large amount of very cheap energy could have uses that we haven't thought of yet. Sometimes you need a supply of ingredients before inspiration strikes. Just think what could have happened if the British government had not been so short sighted and if Babbage had not been so difficult to deal with. But then although Ada Lovelace did make some remarkably prescient suggestions no one had any real idea what really cheap computing could do. Remember "Quantity has a quality all its own", but what that quality is isn't always easy to tell before you have it.
- tedsanders 10y agoThat is a bizarre claim to make. Energy will not be far cheaper and more abundant in 10 years. Trillions of dollars are invested in infrastructure that has lifetimes of 50+ years. It is not economically or technologically feasible to undergo an energy revolution that quickly. Even if we gathered the political and financial will, our production facilities and supply chains could not feasibly handle the load of rebuilding the world's energy infrastructure in a single decade. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5guXaWwQpe4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5guXaWwQpe4
- Nomentatus 10y agoInfrastructure becomes obsolete and is scrapped all the time, disappointing investors. Newcomen steam engines didn't get to their end of life or anywhere near it, they were mostly scrapped when Watt's revolution happened no matter how new they were. You're saying that investors have been caught short by present trends. I think that's true.
- 10y ago
- bcaulfield 10y agoFusion is the future of energy... and always will be.
- Semiapies 10y agoAlways just 20-30 years away, always lots of new and promising experiments results that are just about to pay off.
- bcaulfield 10y agozactly.
- arca_vorago 10y agoThe main issue I see with fusion is a chart I saw (that I'm not sure how accurate it was though), that showed the amount of funding needed to achieve breakthroughs over time. All funding for fusion was far below the level needed for breakthroughs to be made, so until the motivation and funding are at the level needed, I think we will probably not get fusion as soon as we need it. Eg 20 years from now instead of 10
- isoprophlex 10y agoIsn't the power production inside the sun on the order of 300 W/m3? Is it at all reasonable to think we could scale this process to 0.1-100 MW/m3, to become economically viable?