12 ms·
China Doesn't Understand the Concept of American Chinese Food (2014)
- boona 10y ago> China Doesn't Understand the Concept of American Chinese Food Fascinating! :O > vice.com Oh. :/
- azinman2 10y agoWhat's wrong with vice?
- rublev 10y agoVICE is corporate media with edgy branding. Murdoch's have a stake in vice too apparently.
- aioprisan 10y agoThat doesn't take away from the amazing reporting that Vice does.
- markdown 10y agoVice tells amazing stories, but not everything in those stories is factual and there is often significant embellishment. This is not obvious at all until they report on a topic you're very familiar with. I'm a big fan... it's great entertainment.
- kelukelugames 10y agoI think that's true of all papers/sites. “Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray's case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the "wet streets cause rain" stories. Paper's full of them. In any case, you read with exasperation or amusement the multiple errors in a story, and then turn the page to national or international affairs, and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read. You turn the page, and forget what you know.” ― Michael Crichton
- JBReefer 10y agoVice is owned by News Corp, which also brings us Fox News. To me, it looks like a generational hedge against declining cable viewership by a company that is very much opposed to what Vice supposedly represents. Also, I've met a ton of people that say that the pay is terrible, work conditions are awful, and everyone just accepts it because it's a good resume builder. It's also declined in quality a lot since the acquisition - compare old "Vice Kills" episodes with the dreck on HBO.
- vinchuco 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/over?points=100 https://news.ycombinator.com/over?points=100
- mrbill 10y agoShould say (2014), as that's when this was first published; the restaurant talked about closed in January 2016.
- mc32 10y agoI don't think I've ever had chop suey. I used to see canned "chop suey" in NY supermarkets. Never seen them in SF bay area --granted I have not sought it out. I may just have to try it out some day and see what the fuss is all about. Maybe it's the east coast version of Kung Pao chicken (i.e. a quintessential dish) Speaking of east coast dishes I don't see in the SF bay area are NY style calzones or knishes.
- anotheral 10y agoWow, you reminded me about real calzones. I miss 'em; what the Bay Area calls a calzone is a folded-over pizza cut into four pieces. SIgh....
- diego_moita 10y agoChop Suey is not a dish. It is basically "Cantonese people that were not very experienced cooks, trying to cook to North Americans". It means very different things in each state of US and province in Canada. See more here: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/food-and-wine/chop-suey-nation/article30539419/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/food-and-wine/chop-suey-...
- rinka_singh 10y ago:-p China would NEVER understand the concept of Indian Chinese food either. We've changed the traditional Chinese food so significantly that... And it is the second most popular "cuisine" in India after traditional Indian food.
- marak830 10y agoOh I hadn't heard of that. As a chef I'm definitely going to do some research on that! Any particular favourites?
- ninju 10y agoThe cuisine is called Indo-Chinese food...it's a fusion of Chinese dishes with Indian spices and vis-versa. It has come about because "close" border between China and India (in the north east) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Chinese_cuisine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Chinese_cuisine It is similar to the term Tex-Mex which a fusion of Mexican food with American tastes
- vbcr 10y agoHakka Noddles Chilli Chicken Gobi Manchurian and many more...
- draw_down 10y agoI've seen Gobi Manchurian a couple of times (I'm American), really delicious. Also check out Mauritian food if you can, it has those influences and more.
- echevil 10y agoYeah, American Chinese food is mostly Cantonese, which is only one of the eight major cuisines in China. Even if it were exactly the same as Cantonese food in China (it is not, apparently), it would still be unfamiliar to most Chinese people
- scruple 10y agoAnd, even then, there is an undeniable Western influence on quite a bit of "modern" Cantonese food, even in Hong Kong itself.
- treehau5 10y agoI think most countries are blown away by America's portions. They are just insanely huge some times. They are so big, even some places that do "small plates" or tapas are still too big.
- BurningFrog 10y agoAll Chinese regions have their own variation of the major Chinese cuisines. You can think of the different versions of it outside China as regional variations as well.
- inopinatus 10y agoI'm married to a first-generation offspring of Chinese parents, a source of regular and scathing remarks on how what is served in the US as "Chinese food" is often a many-generations-removed facsimile thereof. Three items in particular (Chop Suey, Chow Mein and General Tso Chicken) receive very special ridicule and their appearance on a menu can effectively disqualify any restaurant from further consideration. As the spouse of the above-mentioned I consider it essential that I can avert any incipient noodle deficiency crisis; there are a very few joints - so few I can count them on two fingers - between SFO and San Jose that have received grudging consent and pre-approval for takeout. (It probably doesn't help that we generally reach SFO or LAX via a layover in HKG or SIN)
- dlwdlw 10y agoI actually really like general tsaos chicken and often seeek it out as it's a dish you can't get in China. It only appeals to more people more from the south though or have sweeter cuisines like Shanghai. Many chinese people in the bay area who can't stand it don't like sweet dishes in general. If they're more from the west, they often complain about not being to find authentically spicy food.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kobeya 10y agoThere's plenty of good, authentic Chinese food in Cupertino.
- cbhl 10y agoConsidering how big the Chinese population is in Fremont, Cupertino, San Mateo, and Daly City, I'm surprised there aren't more approved restaurants on your list. But then again, rents are outrageous, so maybe it's just impossible to open a restaurant as an immigrant who is good at cooking.
- deleted 10y ago
- candiodari 10y agoFunny thing about international food. It's not very international at all. French food is great ... except in France it's very different (and outside of the center of Paris sucks pretty bad) Turkish fast food, specifically Kebab, is as far as I know a German invention taken up by Turks, rather than something that historically existed in Turkey. Now you might say shaved roasted meat existed there, and you'd be right, but that existed pretty much anywhere, and was prepared very differently. Shish kabob are sticks with goat meat. Sucks that I can't find the typical bread they serve Kebab in in Western Europe anywhere here in Asia. Chinese food in Asia is SO much better than Chinese food in Europe. Cheap Chinese food in Hong Kong is edible to great (esp. the vegetarian stuff is nice). Cheap Chinese food in Paris ... you'll be sick for days. But there's very little French about French cuisine in SE Asia. Their idea of traditional French cooking: a steak, with a fat edge attached to it, medium rare, with "edges" (really thick fries thickly covered in spices). No sauce. Great French food in France: a clean steak (no fat or nerves or sinews), one of a few sauces made with cream, meat juice and pepper, bearnaise. Thinly cut (not mcdonalds thin, but still far thinner) fries, a good portion of mixed salad, and some cooked vegetable preparation.
- santoriv 10y agoI think you are generally correct but there are also some exceptions. You can get authentic "international" food if you know where to go. The most authentic and best tasting Vietnamese restaurant in my area is also incidentally the least successful one because they don't know how to cater effectively American tastes. There is a menu for the Americans and a secret one for Vietnamese people. The Vietnamese one has the really authentic stuff (coagulated pork blood, pork and chicken with bones, REALLY spicy dishes) etc. The other two Vietnamese restaurants in town do a lot more business (nice decor, lighting, menu, everything is somewhat Americanized etc.) but they get lazy and put the wrong kind of broths in different soups because only Vietnamese people will notice. Anyway, the best way I've found to get "authentic" food in the US is to try to find an urban center with a LOT of one kind of ethnic population and then just go wherever they go.
- jaredklewis 10y agoMy favorite example of this is Japanese sushi. In Japan, where totally fresh fish is abundant and easy to purchase, the focus is entirely on the fish and rice. Most every dish is just raw fish and rice. There are simple rolls which wrap, fish and rice in seaweed. Sometimes wa few, sparse other ingredients like shallots or cucumbers make there way into the roll. Then, Sushi gets taken to America, and what I can only assume was a creative solution to the problem of limited access to fresh fish, sushi was transformed into the decadent "maki" rolls that dominate sushi menus in the US. Cheese, fruits, vegetables, fish, meats. US maki rolls that have nearly a dozen ingredients are not uncommon. Both styles of sushi are amazing, though very different. More like cousins than the same type of cuisine. Reminds me of how cocktails were invented during prohibition to mask the bad taste of moonshine. Japanese shushi is to American maki what wine is to martinis. I think when cuisines get transported to foreign counties, they get changed to adapt to their new environment.
- bingomad123 10y agoChina does not understand American Chinese Food ? Wait till they find the monstrosity called "Chinese Bhel" an Indian Chinese food.
- notahacker 10y agoOr get served Aeropuerto (a wonton sitting on top of an enormous pile of rice, noodles, and potato chips) in a Peruvian Chinese restaurant
- nostrademons 10y agoMy dad's a Chinese immigrant, and I've been to China and had Chinese food there. There are two types of Chinese food you can get in America (well, more given all the regional variations, but I'm making a point...). If you went to a strip mall, walked into a P.F. Chang's, and had General Tso's Chicken, that's not Chinese food. But if you walked into an unmarked doorway in Chinatown, walked down a flight of stairs to a very dingy basement, held up a few fingers to tell the hostess how many people were in your party, and then ordered off a menu where nothing was in English and everything either had tendons or organ meat - you're probably getting something pretty close to what you would get in China. You can get the latter experience in most major metropolitan areas in the U.S. and Canada, but you have to know where to look. Restaurants like that don't send out coupons with the normal advertising circular - basically anything that advertises in an English-language publication is American Chinese food.
- bane 10y ago> walked into a P.F. Chang's, and had General Tso's Chicken To be a touch contrarian, I'd even argue that the kind of food served in some of the newer chain restaurants isn't even proper traditional American-Chinese food (which seems to have shown up sometime in the late 19th, early 20th century). One of the things I've come to appreciate after lots of travel and lots of <insertcountry>-Chinese food is how well developed and embedded American-Chinese food is as an American cuisine. There's rough variants of it in Western Europe when you can find it, but it's a little different. But you can find an American-Chinese restaurant in almost every po-dunk country town across the entirety of America. I've been to places where the only places around to get prepared foods was a local gas station and a Chinese takeout. And the menu is both incredibly standardized, but quintessentially American. P.F. Chang, Ka Pao, and a couple other of the new food places seem to be putting an effort to "de-ethnic" the food and make the preparation and presentation of it shift a bit more into familiar American diets. It's actually kind of hard to talk about without ending up confused with the words, but the nearest I can think of is a spectrum from: <food somebody from China would recognize> - to - <food an American would routinely make for themselves> These new Chinese dining places seem to shift a bit more to the American side, and lose some of that scrappy mom&pop Chinese takeout joint charm and replace it with fresh faced, often Caucasian college kids serving healthy optioned brown rice and not too spicy or oily (and not too tasty) variants of American-Chinese favorites. America has a lot of very interesting quasi-ethnic cuisines that are no longer recognizable by the people from their origins, but also don't really exist outside of the U.S. in any meaningful way. Some day, perhaps, we'll just think of it as "food" and it'll be solidly on the right of that weird spectrum, much in the way Ramen is thought of as "food" in Japan even though it's also Chinese-Japanese cuisine. P.F. Chang's is a step towards Ramenizing American-Chinese food, but it still makes me feel a bit sad. My only hope is the more recent trend of more "authentic" regional and modern Chinese cuisine finally starting to show up as a new wave in the U.S. Non-scary (for Americans), high quality, and tasty Chinese foods are starting to appear in American cities, often with an American-Chinese section on the menu.
- Svekax 10y agoAs offensive as saying the Spanish don't understand the concept of burritos.
- VLM 10y agoA far better comparison would be the Taco Bell Chalupa which shares the name with a Mexican dish but has nothing in common with the Mexican dish. Taco Bell, much like American-Chinese food, or McDonalds, accelerated past cultural escape velocity a long time ago. See also the concept of American Lite-Beer-like-beverage vs German Beer. The concept of cultural escape velocity applies to more aspects of culture than just food.
- draw_down 10y agoHmm... how offensive is that, actually?
- diego_moita 10y agoFor a wonderful story of Chop Suey (North American "Chinese" food) in Canada: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/food-and-wine/chop-suey-nation/article30539419/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/food-and-wine/chop-suey-...
- tuna-piano 10y agoIn the reverse, this is what I got when I ordered a burger at a basketball game in China. I think of this burger when I try and empathize with how other cultures feel when America adapts their cuisine: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5dDMxJP_n1aVWFmby0ydlJfbW8/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5dDMxJP_n1aVWFmby0ydlJfbW8... Also, here's a video of Chinese people trying Panda Express (American Chinese fast food) for the first time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fo59LlkTDe4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fo59LlkTDe4
- zhemao 10y agoThat "burger" actually looks pretty good though. I think that was just a case of lost in translation. Chinese people know what Western hamburgers look like. There are McDonalds all over China.
- orblivion 10y agoI think that young guy was just showing off how authentic he was to the two ladies sitting next to him. The old people liked it.
- ralfd 10y agoYa, the young people were overly picky because they wanted to.
- lvturner 10y agoThat burger to me looks like it's actually a 肉夹馍 (rou jia mo) - which is often mistranslated as a burger or a "Chinese Burger" if done right they are really tasty... unfortunately this particular example looks a little stomach churning Edit: wife has corrected me, it's a 馅饼 (xian bing) - roughly translated as a minced meat pancake/pie!
- Markoff 10y agoroujiamo is always open (sliced and filled with meat) if it's completely sealed it's gonna be some of million kinds of bing personally i consider everything inferior to donkey sandwich
- hindsightbias 10y agoCantonese in the US didn't get Hunan themselves until Henry Chung brought it: http://www.sfchronicle.com/restaurants/article/Henry-Chung-Hunanese-culinary-pioneer-dies-at-99-11098119.php http://www.sfchronicle.com/restaurants/article/Henry-Chung-H...
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoEven crazier when you look at the map and see Hunan is just north of Guangdong.
- 5555624 10y agoAlthough her TED talk is linked, there is no mention of Jennifer8. Lee's book, "The Fortune Cookie Chronicles." The point of the book is that American-Chinese food and Chinese food in China are different. (The book was published the same year as her talk, 2008; which is six years before this article originally appeared.)
- orblivion 10y agoWhat doesn't add up to me is the idea that American Chinese food evolved from the 1800s, yet every legit Chinese restaurant has owners who have a heavy Chinese accent, clearly from China themselves. Did they come here and so quickly adapt to what was expected from "Chinese" food?
- smallnamespace 10y agoBasically yes. They're here to make a buck, not to do haute cuisine, and it's much safer to serve food that your customers already know rather than something totally foreign. Restaurants change hands frequently in cities. Actual family owned restaurants that have passed through generations are a small minority.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoMy experience has been that very few Chinese restaurants are owned by Chinese immigrants, most are from some other country. There are a handful of "Chinese" food distributors in the US that provide for most restaurants. It's more akin to opening a McDonald's.
- sdiupIGPWEfh 10y agoHaving never eaten at two Chinese restaurants with even remotely the same food, I find that hard to swallow. At least in my part of the eastern US, Chinese food quality varies wildly.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoEasiest to tell with the chicken dishes, and even with the same food source the quality varies wildly. Chefs, amounts of ingredients, freshness and other things still influence things, similar to fast food. Distribution still doesn't have the greatest online presence, but here's one of the east coast distributors. http://nywtc.com http://nywtc.com
- wluu 10y agoNot really a surprise. It's the same story elsewhere around the world. They had to adapt to survive. They firstly adapted local ingredients with techniques and flavours of home to cater to their fellow migrants, then they'd start adding some new dishes based on what they perceived as local tastes to try to attract the "native" population when just catering to their fellow migrants wasn't enough to survive. How close a restaurants' dishes are to "authentic" ones depends largely on how many generations removed the chef is from their homeland. Anyway, I'm of Chinese descent. First generation in my family born in Australia, but several more removed from China. So while the food that my family cooks retains Chineseness it also contains influences from the countries that my parents grew up in mixed in with ingredients that were sourceble in Melbourne, Australia in the 80s. That said, due to the relative distance of Australia to Asia during the mid to late 90s, more ingredients came in as the post-Vietnam war migrants settled here and had become further established in the community (so had capital to spend on luxuries like imported ingredients). Some links that may be of interest: - http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-02-21/humble-chinese-diner-mapped-by-food-historians/7187218 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-02-21/humble-chinese-diner-m... - http://www.chia.chinesemuseum.com.au/biogs/CH01148b.htm http://www.chia.chinesemuseum.com.au/biogs/CH01148b.htm - Chifa (Chinese Peruvian Cuisine) https://immigrationtalk.org/2013/07/17/chifa-the-story-behind-authentic-peruvian-chinese-food/ https://immigrationtalk.org/2013/07/17/chifa-the-story-behin... - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caribbean_Chinese_cuisine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caribbean_Chinese_cuisine
- alkonaut 10y agoThis is exactly the same with Italian food: even though the US is full of people of Italian descent, that doesn't change the fact that the Olive Garden menu baffles Italians. Italian-American is a different kitchen. Just like British-Indian food. Or Tex-Mex. Sometimes these adaptations are pretty good (the British Indian food, which is what everyone outside india thinks of as "Indian food" is pretty good!) but for some reason the US-chinese, US-Italian and US-Mexican (Tex-Mex) cuisine is an embarrassment to the originals.
- slackingoff2017 10y agoTexmex is good if you get it in Texas. Texas was once a part of Mexico. There's a large number of multi generational Mexican-US citizens and plenty of time for American and Mexican food to blend. What most places call texmex is just low quality imitations of Mexican food.
- barry-cotter 10y agoIndian food in Malaysia/Indonesia/Singapore is Southern Indian, mostly Tamil, not Bengali but spicier like British Indian food. Japanese Indian food is Bengali by way of Britain with no hint of spiciness. Tex-Mex for food snobs is called Southwest cuisine. American pizza is very different from Italian and good enough to have a small niche in Italy itself. I'm not really familiar with US-Chinese but you're wrong about Tex-Mex and at least one kind of Italian-American food. I'd be surprised if you were wrong about US-Chinese food because UK, DE and IE Chinese food are all awful. In English an ethnie's way of cooking is a cuisine not a kitchen.
- bonzini 10y ago"Tall" NY-style pizza can be found in Italy as a kind of fast food, especially around Milan, but it developed independently. Cuisine in Italy is extremely regionalized. Pizza has only been a "national" food for perhaps 50 years. At home we cook pizza perhaps once every week or two, but when my grandparents were young, it wasn't even a word here in the North. 30 years ago pizza was never in my school's menu, while nowadays they have it. On the other hand, I have never tried Chicago-style pizza, because it's just not a thing here. I am actually really curious about it, and would like to taste it---perhaps unlike most of my fellow countrymen.
- mozumder 10y agoWhat's the process of starting a company in China as a foreigner? Is it something the government there encourages? Are visas for those easy to get? What about incorporating?
- whack 10y agoI never understood this fascination with food-authenticity. When it comes to food, there are only 2 things that matter: - Is it healthy? - Does it taste good to me? If something is healthy and delights your taste buds, then why bother trying to find out whether it's authentic? Conversely, why force yourself to eat something you enjoy less, just because it happens to be "authentic" or because "other people like it"? Who cares if the stuff you're eating is highly evolved/bastardized from the original, as long as you like it?
- dTal 10y agoBecause eating is a social activity. We eat with each other and cook for each other. Sharing experiences is important. Because food reflects culture, and is an interesting and often pleasurable way to connect with it. Exploring other cultures is important. Because some tastes are acquired, and take effort. Diversity in experience is important. Taken to its extreme, your attitude would have us all drinking flavored Soylent.
- jclos 10y agoMaybe it's the inner Frenchman in me talking (food is very important here), but food doesn't have to just be fuel for your body, it's also a door to the local culture and a social ritual. Tasting different things and eating in an authentic setting can help open your mind, much like learning a foreign language or living abroad in a different culture. And besides, by educating your palate with tastes that do not exist in your country you can discover things that you would never have thought you would like.
- whack 10y agoI agree completely with trying out different cuisines and recipes. You'd have to be a very boring/close-minded person if you refuse to try new dishes. But that doesn't mean that you should force yourself to eat dishes that you've tried and disliked, just because it's "authentic". Or that you should stop eating something you enjoy just because it isn't "authentic". Ironically enough, this very obsession with authenticity stunts the evolution, innovation and diversity of cuisines. As a foodie, I consider this to be the real tragedy.
- wrp 10y agoI'm curious as to why American-Chinese food changed between the 1970s and 1990s. In my area, I started noticing the change in the late 1980s. Egg foo young largely disappeared and egg rolls were replaced by spring rolls. My impression of the newer style dishes was that they had less meat, were greasier, and were generally more well-done. The last time I had good egg foo young or egg rolls was almost 30 years ago. I had assumed the change was due to a massive wave of immigration in the 1980s. But if all of the food was a deliberate creation for the American market, why didn't they stick with what was already popular?