4 ms·
I'm surprised more libertarians aren't worried about the blowback when it becomes common knowledge that they were lying for the benefit of large corporations. I
by ZeroGravitas 10y ago
I'm surprised more libertarians aren't worried about the blowback when it becomes common knowledge that they were lying for the benefit of large corporations. I can easily imagine a swing towards nationalisation, confiscation of property etc. when things become visibly messed up.
- Edmond 10y agoIn the future when the effect of climate change is fully realized and there is no more denying it I do hope retro-active action can be taken perhaps in the form of lawsuits that would lead to the seizure of assets of any business entity that willfully engaged in misinformation on the subject...think fossil fuel industry and assorted politicians who helped them.
- nikanj 10y agoLike we did with e.g. the tobacco industry?
- Edmond 10y agoYes but likely much more economically costly...Philip Morris is still around and quite healthy...if whole city waterfronts end up under water around the world, the liabilities could be enough to make Exxon et al disappear.
- gonzo41 10y agoi don't see this happening. Right now exxon can explore for gas in the Great Australian Bite and if there is an oil spill as a result of this drilling, its on the taxpayers because it exploratory drilling!
- sgift 10y agoOne can hope that we wise up in the future and don't repeat our mistakes. It's naive, but sometimes hope is all we have left.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoLying for profit - and "PR" which uses that MO - should be criminalised. They're effectively another form of corporate pollution.
- skummetmaelk 10y agoIn the past being honorable was important because of unwritten social rules. Today those rules have to be written down because there is no longer any consequence for exploiting people as long as you are within the letter (not the spirit) of the law.
- dhimes 10y agoNot only that but we have accepted this lying into our society. When a businessman lies about something or does something shady, we say "he said what he had to say" or "he did what he had to do." Lawyers likewise are socially excused. And by socially excused I'm referring particularly to the neighborhoods and communities and clubs in which they live and recreate. Not everybody gives them a pass of course, but many do. I'm curious about something: were any of those bankers from the 2007/8 crisis and scandal booted out of their country clubs?
- throwaway7312 10y agoAnd that is indeed what it's always been about, back to the days of Margaret Thatcher, when the British government first incentivized researchers to produce evidence showing carbon caused global warming, and not the reverse[1]. It's always been about taking out Thatcher's political enemies in the fossil fuel industry. AGW is a terrific example of how political campaigns can go viral and become their own self-sustaining anti-fill-in-the-blank movements, given the right mix of ingredients. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-m09lKtYT4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-m09lKtYT4
- samiru 10y agoExactly. Somehow we humans are built in a way it is very easy to plant ideologies and make them spread in the society. If you somehow get a group to feel collective guilt for something, you are already halfway of achieving your goals. Groupthink takes care of the rest. I suppose it is the same mechanism in work as for religions in general.
- ratboy666 10y agoEdmund -- that would be a "climate change denier" position. Since climate is always changing, the effect of climate change cannot be, and will never be, fully realized. The question then becomes "when will that retro-active action be allowed"? What triggers that certainty?
- Edmond 10y agoYou are right, except clearly the effects of human caused change is still being denied by many. I am guessing/hoping there would come a time when such people will lose their influence.
- breatheoften 10y agoLibertarians believe the almighty market will eventually suss out these liars and punish them in the market going forward, that no liars will ever arise capable of deceiving the market for any length of time, and that any action taken to clawback profits made by deceiving the market is socialism because (1) there could never have been market deceit since the market is almighty and/or (2) socialism is the only thing that can distort the market from almightiness and in fact is therefore always the cause of situations where the market is capable of making mistakes anyway, so the cure can't be more socialism. Libertarians are not capable of acting rationally because their ideology is a word soup of contradictory ideas and circular logic.
- bsbechtel 10y agoIs that like advocating for net neutrality because everyone should pay the same rate for Internet access, but those who can pay more, should pay more when it comes to paying taxes?
- skummetmaelk 10y agoWealthy pay the same price per kWh as people who are poor. They also pay the same rate for water and other utilities. If you frame the net neutrality issue as a tax, then sure, set up some rules and make wealthy corps pay more. I can't believe you don't see it being abused by telecompanies within days though.
- bsbechtel 10y agoMy point was more in response to the OP's comment about contradictory ideas and circular logic.
- breatheoften 10y agoThe parent was expressing surprise that libertarians are not worried about "blowback" against market players who actively mislead society about the negative externalities of their business activities. My comment was about how libertarians are never worried about such things -- that in fact the idea of a market player paying for a negative externality is explicitly against their convoluted philosophical perspective. I was arguing that it's wrong to have an expectation for a libertarian to behave rationally when a negative externality is involved. Nothing about your comment seems to be related -- I'm gathering you are trying to use some kind of slippery slope analogy to show that my thinking when expanded to some imaginary limit actually yields some sort of undesirable result. Thanks I guess -- I suppose next time I make a comment about how environmental damage is mispriced by the market that I will consider the implications of my words when they are reinterpreted randomly as a somehow specific comment about net neutrality ... On the other hand -- thank you for demonstrating very well the exact experience of having a discussion with a libertarian -- I often find it to be an exercise in being confronted with random analogies designed to separate the topic from any arena of specific facts.
- pizza234 10y agoIt's perfectly possible that the conditions will be [significantly] messed up only in the long term (same as oil predictions)¹. If this is going to be case, denial in the present times would be a malicious but winning strategy - as a matter of fact, some theorize that Trump's denial policy has a the core the belief that the planet is screwed up, but in the relatively distant future, therefore it's a better strategy to capitalize on the adequacy of the present condition. [¹] of course, this is just a possibility.
- TellMeWhoToBan 10y agoI'm not surprised liberals embraced social strategies to reinforce a new technological dark age to appeal to supernatural magics to justify technological backwardness to save forests that only exist for paper farming. "GLOBAL WARMING/COOLING/CHANGE" AKA We need to regulate human behavior at the genetic level because trees might revolt against us, and as we all know, trees have been the most important voting bloc in modern democracy since 1950s white girls were trained to hate their dad. Downvote me until you get a Silicon Valley boner. Go fuck things that hardly resemble yourself.
- orf 10y agoThat comment is incredibly confused, angry and borderline deranged. That is why people are downvoting you. If you want a discussion about whatever it is you are talking about then put some effort into straightening out your thoughts and writing them down.
- pottersbasilisk 10y agoIts a sign of increasing desperate and polarized america. Very worrisome.
- Neliquat 10y agoSeems more like an attempt to make sense of a noncongruent world. We do the best with the info we have, and boy has that info been bad recently.
- TellMeWhoToBan 10y agoAll political discussions are stream of conscious. It is no accident I selected that format.
- louithethrid 10y agoI for once bet on torch and fork-futures!