7 ms·
Rents aren't high because fat cats are charging more money. Rents are high because of supply and demand. That's literally all there is to it. Someone is going t
by jstanley 10y ago
Rents aren't high because fat cats are charging more money. Rents are high because of supply and demand. That's literally all there is to it. Someone is going to get the house and someone isn't, and the one who gets it will be the one offering more money. The only thing the fat cats change is what proportion of the money goes to which people. The amount of money comes from supply and demand.
- jondubois 10y agoAlso, this is mostly true for rent in big cities; big corporations are essentially forcing people to move to big cities where the quality of life is lower by promising them a better future. This increases house prices and makes everyone miserable (except wealthy shareholders and landlords).
- euyyn 10y ago> forcing people [...] by promising them a better future Something doesn't add up in your analysis.
- jondubois 10y agoForcing people to do things doesn't necessarily entail holding them at gunpoint. You can make anyone do anything you want if you can bend their perception of reality - They are completely ignorant and powerless. If you're holding someone at gunpoint, at least they have the power to beg for mercy.
- euyyn 10y agoSo your opinion is that big corporations are forcing people to move to big cities by manipulating their perception of reality? Like with ads that suburban or rural life is crap, or what?
- throwanem 10y agoMaybe, but if not, it isn't evident in what you quote of GP. I'll give you a million dollars tomorrow - I promise. See what I mean?
- euyyn 10y ago> I'll give you a million dollars tomorrow - I promise. How's that forcing me to do anything?
- nnfy 10y agoYou do realize that many people enjoy living in big cities, right?
- morgante 10y ago> big cities where the quality of life is lower by promising them a better future. Is there any place in your worldview for people different than you? This might boggle your mind, but I voluntarily choose to live in big cities even though my work is 100% remote. I could live in a super cheap rural area, but instead I choose to live here in NYC specifically because I think it's much higher quality of life here. Your comment seems incredibly self-centered. Not everyone considers large houses and empty spaces to be the epitome of "quality life."
- 1_2__3 10y agoNever have to look far in a thread like this to find the kid who thinks economies work like Econ 101. Here's a piece of advice: anytime you find yourself concluding with "it's that simple" you're probably not thinking critically about the issue.
- jstanley 10y agoOK, how about this. Buy a house, and offer it up for rent at twice the going rate. See how easy you find it to get a tenant.
- antisthenes 10y agoYou do realize the action you described reduces the aggregate supply of housing and drives up prices by itself, right?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mhermher 10y agoNow repeat that with not just one house, but let's say thousands of houses.
- maxsilver 10y ago> OK, how about this. Buy a house, and offer it up for rent at twice the going rate. See how easy you find it to get a tenant You say that as if it's ridiculous, but that is literally happening in many cities right now, word-for-word exactly as you described. "OK, how about this. Buy up the municipal water supply and offer it at twice the going rate. See how easy it is to get people to pay the water bill" -- it turns out everyone who can possibly pay, will still pay. Because water, like housing, is a basic human necessity.
- randomdata 10y agoSupply and demand really is that simple. Trying to understand everything that leads to a given supply and a given demand at a given point in time is where economics becomes incredibly complex, but supply and demand does not concern itself with those matters.
- jrs95 10y agoBut wealth distribution does affect who is willing to pay how much, and is going to have an impact on the outcome of supply & demand.
- maxsilver 10y ago> Rents are high because of supply and demand. That's literally all there is to it. Except that's literally not all there is to it, that's just one component of the problem. It turns out housing is just a tiny bit more complicated than your first day of Econ 101. The half dozen empty skyscrapers lots of us pass by each day seem to indicate that. "High Rent is just supply and demand" is the new "I could rebuild that whole app in one weekend".
- randomdata 10y ago> that's just one component of the problem. Which components influence the problem here without ending up only being an influencer on the supply or the demand? > It turns out housing is just a tiny bit more complicated than your first day of Econ 101. The half dozen empty skyscrapers lots of us pass by each day seem to indicate that. I do not see where your example indicates that. In this case, an owner is not required to make his property, even if vacant, available on the market. That affects the supply in the market. That still comes down to basic supply and demand.
- spdionis 10y ago> Which components influence the problem here without ending up only being an influencer on the supply or the demand? If all the relevant components "just" affect supply and demand then it's useless to analyze supply and demand. Take a step back and analyze those components.
- randomdata 10y agoThe only analysis I see in the original comment is what determines price, and the answer truly is supply and demand. I may be interesting to look at why the supply and the demand are what they are, but that seems to be outside of the scope of this discussion. From a practical perspective, I'm not sure further analysis is necessary either. Price, as determined by basic supply and demand principles, is a useful signalling mechanism even without understanding the underlying reasons.
- deleted 10y ago
- tunap 10y agoDo you remember the mass foreclosures? Do you see the sea of For Sale signs everywhere? Do you know who bought the lion's share of the defaults? It isn't the privates who fueled the housing/rental costs. You don't need to click ZeroHedge or formulate conspiracy theories, just visit the county assessor's site and try to unravel all the LLCs and "trusts" to determine who controls the market.
- losteric 10y agoRent is high because supply has been restricted by low-density zoning regulations, especially in San Francisco and Seattle. Policy-market mismatch is partially due to low participation in local politics, and partially due to high-income neighborhoods influencing local politics to keep their area low-density (raising their property value and the surrounding area's rent).
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoHuh? Seattle is dense. http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/data/seattle-density-doesnt-have-to-be-a-dirty-word/ http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/data/seattle-densit... Ok, so it is no Manila or Shanghai, but it is denser than low regulation "build baby build" Houston Texas. A lot of the low density places in Seattle are places that wouldn't support density very well anyways (i.e. hills); places that you don't see density at even in mega dense Hong Kong.
- losteric 10y agoSeattle is higher density than Houston, but it's not keeping up with demand in areas of high-demand. That's part of why so many people are getting priced out of their neighborhoods (especially around Capitol Hill)... an expanded and improved transportation network would help, but I understand the city is shackled by the county on that...
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoSeattle has a unique topography and is hemmed in even more than San Francisco is. Ya, you can save money by living in federal way, Everette or, in the past at least issaquah, but that means commuting.
- losteric 10y agoWe're not running up against those topological constraints yet. Consider Capitol Hill, rent is sky rocketing near Pike/Pine/Cal Anderson... yet there are blocks and blocks of single-family 2 story homes.