29 ms·
“But ‘how are you going to make money long-term?’ has been a question mark” Bhatt says. Gold has answered that question.” A Gold subscription lets users borrow
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
“But ‘how are you going to make money long-term?’ has been a question mark” Bhatt says. Gold has answered that question.” A Gold subscription lets users borrow up to double the money in their account to trade on margin with leverage
Wow, so that's effectively opening up new easy to get credit vehicles for unsophisticated investors. How could that go wrong?
Even if you are a professional trader you'll take a bath on margin over the long run. They are incentivizing what is effectively borrowing for gambling and that is their long term revenue strategy? Might be a great money maker but it certainly is playing with some really big barrels of fire.
"Three things ruin people: drugs, liquor, and leverage - Charlie Munger"
edit: The point here is not that Margin is a new service, yes every brokerage has it, it's that it is irresponsible to use Margin if you are not a sophisticated investor. Its even more irresponsible to push leverage onto unsophisticated investors.
Not everyone is going to understand the risks of leverage and if Robinhood makes it as easy as candy crush to trade on leverage, enough gamified users are "playing" stock market with real money and a margin call happens during a huge downturn, it will be exceptionally nasty.
- lcfcjs 10y agoWhy do people that work in finance hate the idea of personal investing? Is it because you are losing out on somebody paying you for your market insight? Investment is always good. The only person losing out with apps like this are investment advisors like you.
- hammock 10y agoMight be questionable for investors (although trading on margin is extremely common) but gambling seems to make a ton of money for casinos, betting parlors and lottery boards, many of which have been around for "long term." Sounds more like you have moral/personal objection.
- azag0 10y agoCasinos do not make money on borrowing for gambling, but on gambling.
- brianwawok 10y agoIt is very very common for Casinos to loan you money. This is how people often end up in debt by thousands (100s of thousands) of dollars to casinos, which causes all kinds of problems. From the casino POV.. why limit their wins to what is in your pocket? Limit their win to what is in your pocket + what the risk model predicts they can make you pay back over time.
- user5994461 10y agoCasino have truly insane margin on the money you play with them (and equally truly insane revenues). When they lend you money, they know exactly how much of that will go back to their hands soon (and they have a ton of cash flow to cover). Robinhood is effectively lending money with little guarantee to take anything back and no source of income.
- koolba 10y agoThey don't charge commission. They do receive payments for order flow. If you don't pay back your margin they'll come after you like any other debt collector. There's nothing special about it.
- kcorbitt 10y agoActually, if your investments fall in value to the point where it looks like your account is in danger of becoming insolvent, they'll likely immediately sell as many of your assets as it takes to make up the difference, locking in your leveraged losses. This is known as a margin call, and it's very unpleasant to be on the receiving end of one. The actual risk to the broker is minimal -- they just have to make sure to trigger the sale at a point where the value of all of your holdings (not just what you purchased on margin) is still greater than what you owe them.
- kgwgk 10y agoI think you may end owing money to the broker, if the margin call cannot be executed in a clean way. That has to be even more unpleasant.
- tn135 10y agoNot to mention the whole concept of credit cards are based on that and here people do not even gamble. They spend the money with 100% certainty.
- omarforgotpwd 10y agoMargin trading is a pretty standard feature across all brokerages. Dangerous if used ignorantly, but greatly increases you returns if used effectively.
- AdamN 10y agoAnd regulated - you have to be approved for margin trading by the brokerage.
- ohstopitu 10y agoI thought it was based on the % you traded? So for example, if I was using an 100k account to trade, I had another 100k of leverage no?
- jerf 10y agoAt least often, yes, but you will also need approval to even get that far. Etrade for instance has several levels of approval. I note that Etrade at least implements it less as "margin approval" and more as "advanced mode"; to do any sort of options trades, even the ones that don't require margin themselves, requires you to activate the "margin feature" on your account.
- jonknee 10y agoRobinhood makes you accept a new agreement to be in Gold which sounds about the same as getting margin approval at a brokerage (agree to the risks and approval is automated). They don't have special powers to waive regulations.
- dsacco 10y agoIt depends on the brokerage. There is Reg T. margin and then there is portfolio margin (the latter has significantly higher capital deposit requirements). It also is not a straight 1:1 ratio. You generally can't go absolutely nuclear with leverage unless you have portfolio margin. Typically, brokerages will require collateral in the account equal to the risk (for defined risk strategies) and you will need a higher trading clearance on your account for unlimited risk. Your buying power is a function of how long the trade will be held as well as the risk profile.
- supster 10y agoTrue, but all major retail brokers allow investors to trade on margin (and charge you interest on it), so this is nothing new.
- scurvy 10y agoAnd that interest is tax deductible
- kakarot 10y ago"Three things ruin people: drugs, liquor, and leverage - Charlie Munger" - ???
- problems 10y agoDepends what you want to do, I'm about 98% in plain old, boring index-tracking ETFs. But sometimes I want to take a bit of money to make some stupid bet. Yes, to gamble. And for that purpose, often having the leverage is a good thing. The way I see it, the bets are much more entertaining than those at casinos and with better odds. Maybe it's just me, but I find casinos incredibly boring, but gambling on the market can be quite interesting.
- cjslep 10y agoI think the bigger problem is the erosion of the distinction between "investor" and "speculator", which is often unclear for novices entering the market (for whom Robinhood is significantly lowering the barrier for). Robinhood provides the firing range and a gun but no safety instructions. So I'm willing to bet you view this app very differently than someone who finds it on the App Store in a spur of the moment enticed-by-Wall-Street feeling, where it can be mistakenly thought as a get-rich-quick scheme. There's no education component to Robinhood (This conflation between speculator/investor has been happening for a while, see "The Intelligent Investor" by Benjamin Graham.)
- SEJeff 10y agoBut even if you pay the $9-$15 for their Gold account, you still can only get on margin the amount of capital you have in the account max ie: if you deposit $5 and have $5 of cash on hand in your robinhood, but own ~$1200 of stocks, you can use < $1200 of "Gold" which is what they call margin money. It is explained quite well here: https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/213262686-Robinhood-Gold-Buying-Power https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/213262686-Ro... Note that I am a robinhood user and do not use gold or any margin investing. I use it for speculation for long term stuff and have the rest in boring index ETFs / funds primarily. I think the entire idea of investing on margin as playing with fire when you lack fireproof gloves.
- JakeAl 10y agoInvesting or trading on margin is intended to allow you to trade while you are waiting for previous trades to settle. It's not meant to be a loan, but it is exploited that way by both banks and traders at their own risk. It's simple enough to fix, only allow margin to cover the amount of money waiting to be settled. In other words if a trade hasn't settled then the funds are not available for trading.
- rl3 10y ago>Even if you are a professional trader you'll take a bath on margin over the long run. Huh? It would be difficult to find a professional trader that doesn't trade equities on margin. They pretty much have to due to the way the settlement process works. The returns of a professional trader depend on many factors, including available capital and the capacity or manner in which the trader operates. That said, they're enough that the employment of margin and the leverage it affords is simply mundane and considered a cost of doing business.
- dsacco 10y ago> Professional traders presumably make their living trading, so their returns far exceed 5%. In theory, sure. But most do not "far exceed 5%", and instead have the fees of their employing funds to subsidize their strategies. For traders who are working independently, or in prop shops, I suppose it might be true by definition (if they last in the market they are either re-upping and gambling, or at least profitable). But that's still not the rule. More importantly, retail investors are not professionals, and Robinhood is basically catering to /r/wallstreetbets with this sort of product offered to them.
- rl3 10y ago>More importantly, retail investors are not professionals, and Robinhood is basically catering to /r/wallstreetbets with this sort of product offered to them. I agree with this and never asserted anything to the contrary. The scope of my reply was addressing a single point concerning margin in context of professional traders. Also, the statment that most returns "far exceed 5%" probably wasn't the best choice of words. I've edited my original post accordingly.
- scott00 10y agoTypical margin rates for professional traders are far below 5%. See https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=1595 https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=1595. And IB is basically the most expensive professionally focused brokerage. If you've got a million bucks you can probably get Fed Funds + 50 basis points.
- huac 10y agoRobinhood knows that people can just buy index funds and sit (which is what I do). But this doesn't make money, so they encourage people to buy individual stocks, "whatever new Elon Musk stock is out there", and trade on leverage. To some extent they want to make Robinhood a game, rather than an investment platform.
- metalliqaz 10y agoWall street did that a loooong time ago
- stuffedBelly 10y agoRobinwood's target audience seems to be younger generation, most of whom are not hot about investment, not to mention whether they know what Wall Street did a long time ago (aside from 2008's financial crisis).
- webninja 10y agoRobinhood makes money off of uninvested capital and margin accounts, not trade commissions. So why would they care what we buy or whether we make purchases rarely or not?
- huac 10y agoSomeone who trades frequently is more likely to upgrade to Robinhood Gold than somebody who buys an index fund once and forgets.
- usefulcat 10y agoAccording to TFA they also make money off of rebates, which are proportional to the number of shares traded.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoSo then they make money of both.
- austenallred 10y agoEh I don't consider it a new credit vehicle, margin trading is available in every trading platform. It doesn't make a huge difference for Robinhood; they'll issue a margin call if you're undercapitalized, so the likelihood you would lose any of Robinhood's money is very low. As for the investors, the percentage rate is very reasonable; given standard market conditions you'd make good money using robinhood gold and putting it in SPY. It's a pretty smart move to charge for it IMO.
- eugeniub 10y agoYes margin trading is available elsewhere but only on Robinhood is it so easy. Setting it up on Scottrade or what have you is difficult and has a lot of hoops to run through. On your phone it really feels like "not a big deal", so a lot more young, inexperienced ordinary people can get sucked into it.
- austenallred 10y ago> margin trading is available elsewhere but only on Robinhood is it so easy What part of it is hard on eTrade or ThinkOrSwim? It's almost literally the same process. The only difference is RobinHood is scooping up all of the people who are new to stock trading and the others aren't. Those same people would be offered the same margin on any other platform.
- mywittyname 10y agoMargin trading is not any easier on Robinhood than any other major brokerage platform. They all make it pretty trivial to trade on margin. Scottrade makes you sign a form saying you understand what you're doing, that's about it (I'm sure Robinhood has the same requirement).
- pfarnsworth 10y agoYou sound like someone who has never set up a margin account. General margin accounts are almost no questions, and varying levels of options trading only ask you questions like "how many years have you traded options", with no verification. There's basically 0 barrier to entry except for having money to trade. The only difference is that Robinhood is charging a subscription for access to margin whereas other brokerages do it for free.
- hectorr 10y agoThis is a lot of finance works. You offer a consumer product full of awesome features and freebies that is a loss-leader, and make up for it on interest. Cash back when you finance a car, credit card miles, discount stock and RE brokerages, etc.
- jsudhams 10y agoDoesn't most brokers already provide up to 7 to 10 time leverage for intraday and 2 to 3 times for future? Atleast in india every broker provides that.
- scott00 10y agoIn the US, most retail investors are limited to 2x leverage for new positions, and 4x leverage for existing positions. This is the "Reg T" margin system. If you qualify for the "Portfolio Margin" system (usually offered to customers with account values greater than 100k or 250k), you can do up to 6.66x leverage in a stock-only position.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- brilliantcode 10y ago> Wow, so that's effectively opening up new easy to get credit vehicles for unsophisticated investors. How could that go wrong? This is the hallmark of modern day capitalism. By issuing loans knowing full well they will never pay back, you can collude with banks to threaten to kill the economy when the government hesitates about cutting them a cheque.
- lend000 10y agoWouldn't want to enable people to make their own decisions with their money, would we? The fact that you have to make a paid account to use leverage (whereas you can trade indefinitely for free) is deterrent enough for most people who do not already actively manage their investments. I think Robinhood is doing a great service -- I just wish they would expose a better API.
- theseatoms 10y agoOn the flip side, we do a terrible job of educating young people about even the basics of personal finance (in the US). I was lucky enough to have a father who ran a small business, so I got an early education in these matters. But that's the exception to the rule.
- nolok 10y agoUnless I misunderstood him, he's not complaining that people can make their own decisions with their money, aka that anyone can use this service even if they're not well versed in that field, he's complaining that Robinhood entire business model is based on pushing the very users who don't know how to use it in a sane way, to do it anyway. That will be the company's lifeline, as its way to make money. I can see the benefit in making it easier for people to get access to things that are often hidden behind layer of complexity and "need an in", but I can also see the perversity of building a business where your money making system is "put debt on people who don't quite know what they're getting into". The point is not that they allow it, it's that they have a direct incentive to make it happen as much as possible.
- dnautics 10y ago100% agree that depending on people going into margin for monetization is a poor alignment of incentives. The humorous thing to me, is that being aligned with forcing people into leverage is an apt description of the economy at large.
- rtx 10y agoMost lifestyle business have similar revenue models. We shouldn't just object against one company.
- linuxkerneldev 10y ago> so that's effectively opening up new easy to get credit vehicles for unsophisticated investors. How could that go wrong? Not really different than what's currently available and which by the way, is heavily regulated as is the service that Robinhood appears to be offering. From their FAQ https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/213262686-Robinhood-Gold-Buying-Power https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/213262686-Ro... : You can use your full Gold buying power when buying stocks, though sometimes you can’t invest it all in one, single stock. Let’s explain. This is because US federal laws require all brokerages, including Robinhood, to have common-sense safeguards to prevent customers from losing too much money on a single, high-risk investment. Some examples where you can’t use your full Gold buying power on a single stock include leveraged ETFs (which are already leveraged) and newly-IPOed stocks (which can go up and down in price very quickly), stocks priced at less than $3.00 per share (these securities are at greater risk of getting de-listed), and others.
- lr4444lr 10y agoBut what's the added systemic risk outside of RobinHood's own capital?
- kyleblarson 10y agoI came here to write pretty much exactly this.
- ojr 10y ago"Always invest what you cant afford to lose" is a very common investing advice given to beginners. You don't need and an Economics PhD to understand this concept
- TallGuyShort 10y agoReally? Because that sounds like stupid, stupid advice and searching for that advice[1] yields results for the opposite. [1] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=always+invest+what+you+can%27t+afford+to+lose&t=ffab&ia=products https://duckduckgo.com/?q=always+invest+what+you+can%27t+aff...
- vitaminbandit 10y ago>"Always invest what you cant afford to lose" Is this a typo?
- volkk 10y agoI don't think so. Investing (i.e long term investing where you believe in a company) is usually a legitimately safe strategy, whereas speculation is more or less gambling.
- tekromancr 10y agoWonderful advice, right up there with "Buy High, Sell Low"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- appetizer 10y agoUnsophisticated investors already have access to 4:1 leverage in every stock broker out there, which is quadruple the money, so you don't know what you are talking about? Surprise! Robinhood is going to make revenues like a normal broker, who at this point already have mobile apps that are just as intuitive and more fully featured.
- j2bax 10y agoI have accounts with traditional brokers and with Robinhood. I assure you the barrier to entry with Robinhood is far lower than traditional brokers. I could definitely see this being a major concern with the potential to ruin some unsuspecting innocently curious "investors" lives.
- appetizer 10y agofinancially naive speculators blow up their account with partially featured financial company straight out of the onion folks. Robinhood's gold account is still 100% less margin than other brokers and the regulations themselves allow! Yet they are getting people to pay for it! Have a laugh because it is hilarious, paying for the privilege to pay interest is the bigger article here.
- Infernal 10y agoAs someone who has looked into but not actively used Robinhood - the main benefit of the Gold subscription is for day traders. With a free account, if I decide I want to sell AAPL and buy GOOG, I have to wait 3+ days before I get the money from selling AAPL credited to my account. With Gold, they basically let you float, so you can immediately get into a new position after getting out of the previous one, without having to wait for your previous position to settle. I believe that is far and away the primary use case for Gold.
- matwood 10y agoIf you're actually day trading you will still end up under SEC pattern day trading rules which require > $25k in the account. At that point, just get a real account with real tools. http://www.finra.org/investors/day-trading-margin-requirements-know-rules http://www.finra.org/investors/day-trading-margin-requiremen...
- JakeAl 10y agoWhat you said. Why would anyone not set up a real account and use their app? I think Scottrade, which is the entry-level broker, only has a $500 minimum balance and they provide real tools as well as educational resources.
- bcohen5055 10y agoI'm a current robinhood non-gold user and they actually eliminated this restriction around 6 months ago. Now as soon as I sell a position I can buy my next with the funds from the sale.
- tekromancr 10y agoWhich they have branded the loan they give you until deposits and sales settle "Robinhood Instant". Since you are trading without settled cash in the account, I believe the SEC considers this a margin account.
- mighty_atomic_c 10y ago
- icedchai 10y agoBrokerages have been doing this for ages. What's new? There's no test for "sophisticated investor." You fill out a paper form and margin is enabled. Oh, you want options, too? You check another box.
- webninja 10y agoI use Robinhood and NO ONE should use margin if they don't know what a Margin Call is. Having understood that, the effective yearly simple interest rate on my particular Robinhood margin (extra buying power) is only 5%/year so all I have to do is earn higher than a 6% return each year. This last year, my return rate was 14%, so that margin was worthwhile. If new to investing and you aren't sure what to invest in, I suggest investing in: VTI, VYM, or QYLD depending on your risk tolerance. I'm invested in all three.
- mrtron 10y agoIt is probably helpful to explain individual investment vehicles and why it is sane for someone new to invest. VTI is an ETF that is basically representative of the entire US market. It is somewhat like holding a little bit of everything in the US market. If you have a bunch of cash sitting in a savings account, and instead want that cash tethered to the swings of equities market, VTI is a reasonable choice.
- kfrzcode 10y agoThanks for this, can you explain the others the parent mentions?
- bradleyjg 10y agoVYM is an index fund that tracks the FTSE High Dividend Yield Index invests in global equities (excluding REITs) with high dividend yields. About 1/3 of the current index is in 10 stocks all US: Microsoft Corp., Exxon Mobil Corp., Johnson & Johnson, JPMorgan Chase & Co., Wells Fargo & Co., General Electric Co., AT&T Inc., Procter & Gamble Co., Pfizer Inc. and Chevron Corp. QYLD is even more exotic. It seeks to track the CBOE NASDAQ-100 BuyWrite Index. That index in turn seeks to track the performance of a theoretical portfolio of the 100 largest NASDAQ stocks on which covered calls are written with a certain formula. Covered calls are a type of options strategy. I'm just another rando on the internet, but I would recommend neither VYM nor QYLD to people new to investing who aren't sure what to buy. VTI is a far more appropriate suggestion. As would be VT (like VTI but looking at all stock markets), BND (index fund for US investment grade bonds), and maybe BNDX (ex-US investment-grade bonds with currency hedges)
- tn135 10y agoFew things to note: - Robinhood Gold is not just about margin trading. It is also about instant money transfers. What truly prevents me otherwise from frequent investing is this long delay (upto 2 days) where I sell something and wait for money to be available for next purchase. - I will happily pay Robinhood say $10 per month anyways for the kind of service they provide. Getting $2K credit for that is not really a big deal.
- hueving 10y agoBanks get by on a long term strategy of supporting gambling. A loan to invest is the same whether it's in a small business, a house, or stocks. In fact, the first two are even riskier because they aren't liquid so they can't get out in turbulent times like they can with a margin call.
- MistaEd 10y agoencouraging retail investors to trade frequently and on a margin sounds like a terrible idea. Basically creating more suckers for the high frequency traders to trade against. Should rebrand the app and call it Robber-in-a-hood
- blazespin 10y agoThey make their money from bad routing rules. No such thing as zero fee.
- Gustomaximus 10y ago> Even if you are a professional trader you'll take a bath on margin over the long run. Id say not. Say your borrowing at 7%, markets tend to average around 10-14% return a year. So if you were doing some passive investing on margin you'd be likely to increase earning. The issue is it heightens risk and the speed of losses for those that invest badly, but being margin it should largely avoid losses greater than the principle invested which is better than other speculative investments so not all that bad.
- socmag 10y agoI worked in risk management in the mid 90's with Bond to Swap hedging. You have it right.
- whack 10y agoConsider the fact that every time you buy a house with a 10% downpayment mortgage, you're taking on 9x leverage. The fact that banks are willing to lend you ~$500k at a ~4% interest rate, on a piece of real estate that can produce >5% returns (including rent), is often what makes it such a fantastic investment. The same principle can be applied as well to stock investments. Obviously a 9x leverage would be too risky for stocks, but a 1x leverage is reasonable and can easily lead to win-win outcomes for both lenders and investors. If you're worried that unsophisticated investors can misuse this feature - there's nothing stopping such investors from putting all their money into a single penny stock either.