14 ms·
There's nothing quite like trying to get fusion to work for a while to make you appreciate how awesome fission technology is. If we applied even half the cleve
by Robotbeat 10y ago
There's nothing quite like trying to get fusion to work for a while to make you appreciate how awesome fission technology is.
If we applied even half the cleverness needed for fusion to making better fission technology, we'd probably be way better off.
...and then there's solar. Why even bother with producing the energy, just capture it with a very thin solid state device! Just need to automate the planting of solar panels in the desert, and we could produce all of our electricity from the Sun. Using just a fifth to a tenth of the land (and much crappier land that nothing much can grow on) that we use for /ethanol/ production alone.
(Yes, storage is tough, but is getting cheaper, and we can just plant more solar panels so there's enough power even during cloudy days... Although this is mostly a thought exercise. The best plan for deep decarbonization by far is to operate with a mix of clean power sources optimized for high capacity factor, including at least our current nuclear fleet... They help provide a reliable baseline which drastically reduces the amount of storage and over-installation required. That last 20% of power produced by nuclear is worth its weight in gold and should be protected at least until all fossil power production is ended.)
- sjcsjc 10y agoRe solar: not just deserts (there aren't many in the UK) - https://www.fastcompany.com/3053998/these-sky-high-balloons-could-generate-more-power-than-solar-panels https://www.fastcompany.com/3053998/these-sky-high-balloons-...
- Robotbeat 10y agoYes, I was being US-centric. I know most about the energy situation in the US, and I happen to live here. :) Thinking deeper into the future, floating solar farms could also be a thing. The oceans are huge, and most nations are not land-locked. They'd have their own engineering challenges, for sure, but those challenges look like patty-cake compared to fusion power.
- mrfusion 10y agoNot just deserts. You could also float them in the ocean, no? We have 70% of our planet we're not using. Spread them far enough apart and add some movement and shadows wouldn't hurt wildlife much.
- OJFord 10y ago> You could also float them in the ocean, no? Yes, offshore wind and solar farms do exist.
- Recurecur 10y agoThe ocean environment isn't easy on equipment, plus storms are a major issue. Then there's cabling...
- Robotbeat 10y agoThat all looks trivial compared to the challenges of fusion power, though.
- Recurecur 10y agoTruthfully in the medium term next generation modular fission reactors seem like the way to go, as a complement to intermittent and variable solar/wind power. If the LPPFusion approach eventually works out, it will be a giant win compared to the Tokomak or implosion fusion reactors.
- spdionis 10y agoAre you sure? This is a recurring theme in your arguments but I don't necessarily agree with you. What are the reasons for you to think that?
- Robotbeat 10y agoRead the article that this conversation is attached to for a list of very good reasons. Getting fusion to work is most certainly possible, but incredibly hard. Engineering for salt water is way easier than engineering for neutron activation, achieving high neutron economy to breed the tritium, managing tritium, managing a high temperature reactor next to a very cold magnetic containment system, a high vacuum system, oh and the very basic problem that has yet to be solved (achieving even just breakeven fusion in a non-H-bomb) etc, etc. It really does look trivial to just properly seal stuff against saltwater. We'll probably need fusion to help reach the stars, so I think it's definitely something that should be pursued, but making it an economic power source for Earth seems very unlikely to me.
- KnightOfWords 10y agoTurns out those deserts may not be so useless after all I'm afraid, for example dust blown from the Sahara fertilizes the Amazon: https://www.nasa.gov/content/goddard/nasa-satellite-reveals-how-much-saharan-dust-feeds-amazon-s-plants https://www.nasa.gov/content/goddard/nasa-satellite-reveals-... Solar has become more efficient and economic in recent years but remains only a small part of the energy puzzle for various reasons.
- DigitalJack 10y agoI have to think there are major ecological concerns with blocking sunlight over large areas. They may not be negative impacts, but surely it isn't a no-impact situation.
- Robotbeat 10y agoThere is always some impact. There's a disease in our energy discussions where if something has ANY effect or can be measured at all, it is considered a big no-no. We lack a sense of proportion. Radiation is SUPER easy to measure even tiny amounts, for instance, since you can look for the signature of a certain decay tree, so people hear that you can measure radiation from Fukushima and lose their minds. Likewise, people make a big deal about solar using up a lot of land, but then forget that agriculture uses up on the order of 100 TIMES the land that solar would take up if we relied entirely on solar for electricity. The sense of scale is entirely lacking.
- VLM 10y ago"The sense of scale is entirely lacking." Agree and it extends to risks. Better to kill 100K people per year with coal, than possibly maybe hundreds might die (but almost certainly zero actually will) in a nuclear accident. Your diet and your car are far more likely to kill you than global warming.
- macintux 10y ago> Your diet and your car are far more likely to kill you than global warming. True for me. True for my (entirely hypothetical and never likely to exist) grandchildren? Less clear.
- mikeash 10y agoAn example of this which always gets me with nuclear power is the waste problem. The fact that the waste remains dangerous for tens of thousands of years is always held up as a huge problem, completely ignoring the vast quantities of extremely poisonous chemical waste produced by other industries which lasts forever. "This waste is dangerous." "OK, guess we'd better be careful with it." "This waste is dangerous for the next 10,000 years." "Holy shit! We need to build a high-tech underground fortress to contain it!"
- short_sells_poo 10y agoHow exactly do you propose to get that electricity from the desert to say Finland? Furthermore, you need to plaster a vast area in the desert with solar plants, which brings along all sorts of concentrated security risks. The alternative is to have many smaller plants dispersed, which results in a big loss of efficiency. I'm all for clean energy, but you seem to be handwaving away pretty huge issues as "thought exercise". Our inability to store energy is not just some side concern that will go away any time now. There is a reason carbon fuels are so prevalent - their energy density is far above what we can store in batteries. Without scalable and high density energy storage, unpredictable energy sources like solar or wind are much less useful because often there is no sun or wind at high demand and on the contrary there can be an overproduction during low demand. Germany already causes serious headaches for the European grid when it floods the network with electricity on sunny/windy days. They actually have to pay other countries to take over the extra capacity. Solar, wind, tidal etc... energy are all awesome and clean (if we disregard the land that they take up), but there are many difficult issues that remain to be solved before they can become a core part of the energy production.
- Robotbeat 10y agoHigh latitudes (above 50 degrees) have a big problem with solar power. Luckily, almost the only people who live that far from the equator are Northern Europeans, who tend to have access to hydro and nuclear. (this is why it's so stupid for Germany to shut down their nuclear power... they're replacing it with coal, brown coal, and gas!) The vast, VAST majority of the world's population lives FAR closer to the equator. Again, you seem to have ignored the part of my post where I mentioned installing enough solar to produce power even during cloudy days. Cost of utility solar is super cheap now. If it continues reducing in cost, it'll be plenty cheap enough to just install 3-5x as many panels as you need to provide power during cloudy days. Yes, solar CAN get cheap enough for that to be a good idea.
- short_sells_poo 10y agoI haven't ignored the part where you mentioned overprovisioning. Where do you propose to put the excess power during sunny days? Stable baseline sources like nuclear cannot just be shut down or spun up on a moment's notice to accomodate a vast number of solar energy entering or leaving the grid. At the same time, we don't have a capability to store electricity at sufficient scale so we do need the stable baseline to cover a high enough percentage of our production. The fact of the matter is, as long as we don't have a scalable storage solution, power sources where we can't regulate the power output cannot take up base load and can at best be a small overlay that can pick up load if the beneficial weather happens to coincide with higher load requirements.
- scriptkiddy 10y agoSpoken like someone who has never visited a desert. As a Southern California native, I am intimately familiar with the Mojave, Anza Borrego, and Sonora deserts. I will tell you that these deserts are far from "crappy land that nothing can grow on" as you put it. The North American deserts are areas of huge ecological and geological diversity. They are also some of the most beautiful and awe-inspiring landscapes that exist on this planet. We do utilize a lot of area in the Western Mojave for solar and wind power. For instance, there is a HUGE field of wind turbines in the San Gorgonio pass near Palm Springs at the intersection of the 10 and the 62. That said, I am no way in favor of scarring any more of our deserts by covering "a fifth to a tenth" of them in solar panels. However, I am not against concentrated solar facilities several square miles in area as long as they remain contained. I have thought about how we can "disperse" a solar panel network into a system of smaller panels and batteries and the best idea I can come up with is requiring all commercial buildings to cover their roofs in solar panels and maintain on-site battery banks. Also requiring all homes and apartment buildings to have at least one solar panel per household. These ideas come with their own trade-offs although.
- Robotbeat 10y agoI said a fifth or a tenth of the land in the US used for ethanol production. NOT a fifth or a tenth of our deserts. More like 1%. And my point is we can install solar on land that has no other use. Like land contaminated by industrial waste, etc.
- scriptkiddy 10y agoAh. My misunderstanding.
- dkirtley 10y ago1% of all deserts is only correct if you are talking about only today's electricity use. Even moderate growth and actually solving energy, not just the electricity subset drives these percentages much higher. To get US centric again, NREL published an optimistic 2016 report suggesting that the maximum rooftop solar capability could ever meet is 40% of electricity. That's 15% of today's energy use in an electricity heavy country.
- marcgcombi 10y agoBump to Robotbeat. Fission reactor designs, with many clever advances in safety, have never been tested because of the lack of support from U.S. DoE. Pilot-scale reactors are expensive, but would really help to advance our working knowledge of these new technologies. Overall, nuclear fission has gotten a bad wrap. As for the cost of storage, that was worked out 20-30 years ago via the Yuca Mountain facility. If one of the local managers hadn't shifted to a "organic-based storage medium', that was not pre-approved for that application, the fire wouldn't have happened and everything would be fine.
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoBut that is kinda how everything goes with nuclear. You can't plan for the "if everything goes right" scenario. Shit happens. Humans are very prone to errors. But nuclear proponents always want to pretend that isn't the case and explain away very real things that have happened as being anomalous- when in reality, errors and mistakes are the way the universe works.
- novalis78 10y agoThorconpower is a case in point. They tried very hard to get their experimental reactor off the ground in the US but their pilot project seems to have moved to Indonesia instead now. That's a shame - Thorium and molten salt reactor experience and technological mastery would be extremely useful for solar system space colonization efforts past the orbit of Earth (insolation levels fall dramatically and a lot of basic industrial chemical engineering off planet will encounter abundant raw materials but will also need easy access to enormous quantities of energy). Fissiln is so worthwhile pursuing and it's reputation so bad it will probably need an Elon Musk type persona to tackle it.
- kahrkunne 10y agoMore power to desert people! What a great idea!
- scythe 10y agoEnergy storage is easier than fission or fusion. We've just been working on the other two problems for ten times as long. Grid energy storage became financially viable maybe five years ago and there are already startups in compressed air and sodium-ion batteries (which can be potentially much larger/cheaper than lithium-ion at the cost of being less space-efficient). Nuclear energy has been financially viable forever and it took an existential crisis for the richest nation in the world to devote all of its resources to it for years to make it happen.
- Robotbeat 10y agoEnergy storage for a few hours is easier than fission. Seasonal energy storage, on the other hand, is much more difficult. This is why I think a mix of clean power sources (including some nuclear) is going to be optimal. I am of the firm belief that there are MULTIPLE feasible ways to solve the clean energy problem that we, as a society, could probably do if we put as much effort into it as we did a world war. Examples: <>nuclear France (ultimately using breeders of uranium or thorium) <>hydro/geothermal Iceland <>over-built intermittent renewables buffered with grid storage and perhaps either a little hydrogen seasonal storage or a mega-grid connecting north to south even exotic solutions like <>inertial or magnetic confinement fusion <>space-based solar power (which is easier than fusion) But the optimal (both in time and money) solution is to use a mix of clean energy sources (solar, wind, hydro, geothermal, nuclear) and some storage and some demand-response (smart meters are a pretty obvious solution, here) and some increased geographical grid interconnection (UHVDC power lines).
- ChuckMcM 10y agoReally the only reasonable world wide solar plan I've ever seen is solar power satellites. There has been a lot of work done there and they beam the energy back to the planet as microwaves where it is needed into the existing grid system. But so far the cost of getting all of that material into orbit to build them is something of a deal breaker.
- sbierwagen 10y agohttps://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/ >At this level, our 3.6 km diameter collecting area would generate about 40 GWh of energy in a day, at an assumed reception/conversion efficiency of 70%. By comparison, a flat array of 15%-efficient PV panels occupying the same area in the Mojave Desert would generate about a fourth as much energy averaged over the year. So these beaming hotspots are not terribly more concentrated than what the sunlight provides already. Again, I find myself scratching my head as to why we should go to so much trouble.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoGrid delivery. You cannot easily move power from the desert into urban centers.
- sbierwagen 10y agoWell, you sure can't point the power delivery beam at downtown LA either. And the footprint of the rectenna array is enormous-- Tom assumes a 100GHz transmit antenna 30m wide, which means the downlink antenna has to be 3.6km wide! And this is the minor axis-- the solar array has to be geosynchronous orbit, which means any receiving antenna not on the equator has be an ellipse.
- DennisP 10y agoLots of people are trying to apply that cleverness to fission. The problem is that governments make life much harder for fission projects than for fusion projects. There's some justification for that; fission done well is great, but fission done badly can cause much more serious accidents than fusion done badly, and proliferation is much less of a concern with fusion. Even so, the regulation is more of a problem than it needs to be. The NRC currently requires a near-complete design up front, costing several hundred million dollars, before they even hint at whether they'll approve your project. If they turn you down, you're done. If they approve, you've still just got paper; it's only then that you get to start experiments with nuclear material. If they just had a more incremental process it'd be a big help. Meanwhile, people build deuterium fusion reactors in their basements and nobody bats an eye.