17 ms·
Velodyne Announces a Solid-State Lidar
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoAnyone know what the deal is with Quanergy [1]? [1] http://quanergy.com http://quanergy.com
- sohkamyung 10y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "what the deal is with Qaunergy". Does this article [1] answer your query? [1] "Quanergy Announces $250 Solid-State LIDAR for Cars, Robots, and More" (Jan 2016) [ http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sensors/quanergy-solid-state-lidar http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sens... ]
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoHow does this news bode for Quanergy?
- matheweis 10y agoQuanergy gave me an early quote on a dev kit last year that was an order of magnitude higher than that. So unless they've reached that price point from their press release, probably not good...
- nojvek 10y agoQuanergy gave me a quote too. It seems they won't sell until you buy thousands of units. They use old school contact seller techniques and just seemed very scamy in the whole process.
- throwaway6556 10y agoAre you really basing your share buying/selling decisions off HN comments?
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoCute, but no. I've heard of Quanergy's solid-state technology and am curious to hear more from someone with expertise.
- MrBuddyCasino 10y agoFinally! Anyone has a guess as to what those might cost? (Edit: whoops, embarassing : totally missed the "hundreds of dollars." Sorry!)
- andreapaiola 10y agoWhy you don't read? The estimated price per unit is in the hundreds of dollars.
- sctb 10y agoThe guidelines ask you to please leave out things like “Why you don't read?”: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kirillkh 10y agoThe article mentions the angles (120 horizontal, 35 vertical), but not the distance covered. This might explain why the interviewee does not believe the solid-state lidar will replace the current tech.
- sohkamyung 10y agoThat's answered in the Velodyne press release [1] linked from the article: "The new Velarray LiDAR sensor uses Velodyne’s proprietary ASICs (Application Specific Integrated Circuits) to achieve superior performance metrics in a small package size of 125mm x 50mm x 55mm that can be embedded into the front, sides, and corners of vehicles. It provides up to a 120-degree horizontal and 35-degree vertical field-of-view, with a 200-meter range even for low-reflectivity objects. With an automotive integrity safety level rating of ASIL B, Velarray will not only ensure safe operation in L4 and L5 autonomous vehicles but also in ADAS-enabled cars. It has a target price in the hundreds of dollars when produced in mass volumes." [1] [ http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20170419005516/en/Velodyne-LiDAR-Announces-%E2%80%9CVelarray%E2%80%9D-LiDAR-Sensor http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20170419005516/en/Velo... ]
- kirillkh 10y agoThen why do you think will the current technology still be useful, given an order of magnitude higher price?
- sohkamyung 10y agoI'm not the writer of that piece. But my guess would be that automotive technology tends to change slowly and gets gradually replaced. Car companies are getting used to reading data from standard Lidar. Getting them to suddenly dump it for Solid-State Lidar may be a step too fast and they would rather go through a transition period first (standard + solid-state) until they are happy with the performance of solid-state lidar. You are referring to this in the article, right? “I don’t necessarily believe that [the solid-state lidar] will obviate or replace the 360-degree units—it will be a complement,” Marty Neese, chief operating officer of Velodyne, told IEEE Spectrum earlier this month. “There’s a lot of learning yet to go by carmakers to incorporate lidar in a thoughtful way.”
- ec109685 10y agoIs lidar still necessary if computer vision advances far enough? We drive just fine without radar.
- sohkamyung 10y agoAt the current stage, depending on computer vision may be dangerous. See this BBC article about how it can be fooled [1] [1] http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20170410-how-to-fool-artificial-intelligence http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20170410-how-to-fool-artific...
- threeseed 10y agoCouple of issues with this point: 1) We don't just rely on our vision when driving but also on sound (nearby cars) and touch (feel of the road). I actually haven't seen any self driving car projects talk about this aspect which is interesting. 2) Self driving cars can't be just as good as humans they need to be effectively perfect. Quite a lot of people think they are amazing drivers i.e. infallible so mistakes from a self driving car aren't going to go down well.
- mikeash 10y agoThere are deaf drivers, and I'd wager the vast majority of human drivers pay no attention to the feel of the road.
- fudged71 10y agoI haven't really seen many people talking about "Human sensor fusion" regarding sound/touch/etc, and I think it's a very important point. Are driverless cars even measuring sound, vibration, and G-Forces? I'd like to better understand how those play into the whole sensor fusion of these systems.
- willvarfar 10y agoYou deserve some up-votes. Tesla famously doesn't use LIDAR, saying cameras (possibly with parking radar) are good enough. Here's a nice summary: https://cleantechnica.com/2016/07/29/tesla-google-disagree-lidar-right/ https://cleantechnica.com/2016/07/29/tesla-google-disagree-l...
- ralfd 10y agoWhat does "solid state" here mean? If i am not blind the aryicle doesn't explain that, only that it is cheaper.
- coryrc 10y agoBy 'lidar' they mean '2d depth imager using lasers', which has historically been done with a fixed laser and a physically moving galvanometer. Solid state is to get rid of the moving galvanometer.
- mrfusion 10y agoReplacing it with what? It seems like something would have to be moving.
- gallamine 10y agoThere are many techniques for optical beam steering. It some cases you can use MEMs devices (like DLPs) or you can apply a voltage across a optically clear material that changes its properties under the electric field. This is used to bend the light in certain directions (think of an electrically controllable prism.)
- ethagknight 10y agoMEMs (as in a DLP tv) seems less than an ideal for the abuse a vehicle takes. Curious if the other option you mention is similar to a cathode ray tube?
- web007 10y agoIt depends on the implementation, the concept seems fragile but they can be amazingly resilient. There are a bunch of MEMS accelerometers that support ranges in the 10s to 100s of Gs.
- hwillis 10y agoSquare cube law. The mass (cube) of microscopic features is very small compared to their surface area (square), which dictates how thick their connections are. That means they have very little inertia and as long as they aren't scratched or wet they're very resilient. Electro-optic materials are more like LCDs. Light interacts with the material and the material interacts with electricity. In a cathode ray tube there are electrons, not light, and they interact directly with the electric and magnetic fields. CRTs also need a dozen-odd fields to form a good beam, or 30+ for things like electron microscopes.
- grondilu 10y agoNaïve question : why is Lidar so important for driverless cars? We human drive cars with only visual and audio information. We don't need lidars. Why couldn't cars do the same?
- balazsdavid987 10y agoThe goal is to collect as many information about the environment as possible so you the software can make better decisions than human drivers.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoWhile I'm no expert, it's obvious right away that humans do a lot of sorts of visual processing that AIs don't on a conceptual, categorizing, and general-knowledge level, and we use these capabilities to interpret visual scenes and draw object boundaries and therefore place objects in modeled 3d space. Example, http://www.optical-illusionist.com/imagefiles/dalmation.jpg http://www.optical-illusionist.com/imagefiles/dalmation.jpg - to see the dog, you really do have to know rather a lot about dogs, sunlight and shadows.
- felipemnoa 10y ago>>Example, http://www.optical-illusionist.com/imagefiles/dalmation.jpg http://www.optical-illusionist.com/imagefiles/dalmation.jpg - to see the dog, you really do have to know rather a lot about dogs (Disclaimer: Cynical Plug) This is exactly the sort of AI project that I'm working on: being able to recognize patterns even with lots of noise or incomplete information. I tried a show HN submission [1] but there was absolutely no interest. :( Question: Does anybody know if google is yet at this level? Would google's AI be able to recognize the dalmatian? I think my AI algorithm would be able to recognize the dog but I'm still not at that stage yet. Really need to get more computer power before that. Thanks for the image though, you've given me some really good testing ideas. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14057043 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14057043
- runako 10y ago
- andor436 10y agoHm, this is not Velodyne's first announcement of a solid state lidar breakthrough. http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sensors/velodyne-announces-breakthrough-in-solid-state-lidar-design http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sens... Several other companies are working on these (Quanergy, Blackmore) too, but so far they seem to be just press releases. Hopefully we'll see some real ones soon; the current state of the art for wide field lidar are many thousands of dollars and (imo) too fragile for use in production vehicles.
- runeks 10y agoThis article doesn't mention a breakthrough in solid state LIDAR design, as article you link to does, but rather that they have an actual product ready-ish: > Velodyne today announced a solid-state automotive lidar ranging system that the company will demonstrate in a few months, release in test kits later this year, and mass produce at its new megafactory in San Jose, Calif., in 2018. The estimated price per unit is in the hundreds of dollars.
- Animats 10y agoNot much info here from Velodyne. What's the range? Is this a flash or MEMS device? Resolution? Advanced Scientific Concepts has had good flash LIDAR units for sale for years. They just cost too much. They sold them to DoD and Space-X. Continental, the German auto parts maker (a very big company, not a startup) has purchased the ASC technology and expects to ship in volume in 2020. Here's a Continental prototype mounted on a Mercedes.[1] This is mounted at bumper height and has a 120 degree field of view, and has only 30m range. So this is for city driving or slow driving in tight spots. Continental says they intend to ship in volume in 2020. Nobody is yet interested in ordering enough units in the kind of volume a major auto parts manufacturer needs. Google uses a high-mounted LIDAR with longer range as well as the bumper height sensors. This doesn't address that market. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pxqFX94zBPI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pxqFX94zBPI
- moondistance 10y agoFrom the image at the top of the article: "up to 200m range" and "35 degree vertical field of view".
- phreeza 10y agoDoes anyone know if this or any lidars used for self-driving cars is capable of doing Doppler lidar?
- seandavidfisher 10y agoWould these be able to be used on drones?
- tyingq 10y agoIt mentions "The Velodyne package measures 125 millimeters by 50 mm by 55 mm", so pretty small. But, as I understand it, to do something useful with that, you need to be pulling in a lot of data in real time and processing it. So it may not be the Lidar unit itself that's the weight constraint.
- samlittlewood 10y agoMIT/DARPA also have a combined solid state steerable beam transmitter and sensor using phased arrays: http://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/semiconductors/optoelectronics/mit-lidar-on-a-chip http://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/semiconductors/optoelectr...
- deepnotderp 10y agoThe MIT lidar has really bad resolution and range iirc
- deepnotderp 10y agoLuminar has announced an interesting lidar as well, but no word on how the cost will come down since it's a 1500nm lidar, requiring indium gallium arsenide and other expensive and exotic metals.
- cjhanks 10y agoI would suspect any solid state lidar design at this point would be GaN (Galium Nitride) unless somebody has made a very secret breakthrough.
- deepnotderp 10y agoThe current generation of solid state lidar uses silicon, because of the different wavelength.
- kylehotchkiss 10y agoVelodyne hopes to win the new phase of this game by being first to market. “The first mover sets the standard,” Neese said. “Software is 60 percent of the effort, so if you show up [later] with a new piece of hardware, it may not fit in.” Garmin has one on the market for $150 https://www.sparkfun.com/products/14032?gclid=CIzZ86-fs9MCFQ-HswodxFsLSA https://www.sparkfun.com/products/14032?gclid=CIzZ86-fs9MCFQ...
- pdehaan 10y agoThat thing is basically just a laser range finder, it doesn't produce a 2D "image" of distances (unless you pair it with something to spin it around, at which point you just have a bad version of existing lidars).
- infocollector 10y agoGarmin's (or Lidarlite acquired) is a single point reader which is very restrictive for many applications. Sometime back Quanergy made the same splash that Velodyne is making now. When you talk to them, their price points are very high, compared to what they were talking about in their press release. I am still waiting for a decent Lidar unit that is dependable, and costs < $500 (with > 1k points per second spread across the sphere).
- maxerickson 10y agoThat looks to be a rangefinder, mapping the distance to a single point in front of the optics. The device in the article maps a much larger field of view.
- rcv 10y ago> [The new Velodyne unit] provides up to a 120-degree horizontal and 35-degree vertical field-of-view That LIDAR-Lite is only a single "pixel". The Velodyne press release doesn't specify the resolution, but I'm certain it's > 1x1.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- atomical 10y agoIs there any chance Lidar could be used in consumer drones in the future?
- blhack 10y agoAbsolutely yes there is. Even the single point laser rangefinders like what are linked in the top comment here now are useful for consumer drones. The hack people used to do (maybe still do?) was to combine a laser pointer and a webcam, and infer the distance based on where in the Y axis the laser appeared in the image that the webcam received. This, which is many points in many directions, is much, much better, and it sounds like it will be cheap (at least much cheaper than these devices have been).
- ThatGeoGuy 10y agoOne counter objection: LiDAR on drone will be a whole lot less useful if they all 1) collect the same frequency of EM, and 2) have any way of picking up scattered signals from other drones (because it was pointed at other drones, or from scattered reflections). Right now there's not much in the way of LiDAR on anything, but once there is, we will need to find ways to stop other active sensors from interfering with our own.
- Fricken 10y agoCheap, small solid state Lidar will have applications across vehicles, robotics, augmented reality, surveillance, mapping and 3D scanning and who knows what else. In theory SSL could be as cheap as phone cameras, and will open up a whole range of possibilities.
- mlonkibjuyhv 10y agoSure, Leddartech vu8 is targeting that in some of it's marketing material at least.
- blhack 10y agoI wonder if we're going to start seeing 3D barcodes that robots use to read each other's ID and relative orientation.
- nukenuke 10y agoThis is mostly hype until they can actually deliver. I ordered several of their current lidars 5 months ago and now it looks like the total delivery time will be about a year after the order. And they're mostly unresponsive about what is going on.
- mcmoose75 10y agoI was at SPAR 3D in Houston a couple weeks ago (trade show for laser scanning/ surveying industry), and there was some rumor-mill type chatter about what the hell was going on with Velodyne. Apparently some folks have heard that they're having some sort of supplier issue that they're not doing a good job of working through/ finding a replacement for.