10 ms·
Markets are such an essential tool for our society, but they're also easy to get wrong. Markets require regulation, whether it's in the form of contract enforce
by epistasis 10y ago
Markets are such an essential tool for our society, but they're also easy to get wrong. Markets require regulation, whether it's in the form of contract enforcement or setting standardized terms for communication in the market. Any time there's a power differential, we need regulation.
That's why I wish we could get past this mindless anti-regulation political trend into a "smart regulation" political trend. Whenever I see "regulations are bad" these days it's always associated with mindless deregulation; deregulation is a difficult thing that must be done carefully, and it has to be adjusted later on to adjust for all the unforeseen consequences. Regulations are not bad, it's needless regulations that are bad.
- YCode 10y agoThere's a degree of irony in that the reason air travel is so safe is because air travel safety is so heavily regulated.
- clarkmoody 10y agoOh, you know, because the quickest way to go out of business is to kill your customers...
- kartan 10y ago> Oh, you know, because the quickest way to go out of business is to kill your customers... Why use more fuel than needed in a flight, if you are going to get there anyway? Is that safety measure so important? Without regulations this will be more common: "Colombia's Civil Aeronautics agency concluded in its investigation that the plan for the flight operated by Bolivia-based charter company LaMia did not meet international standards." "Neither the company nor Bolivian authorities should have allowed the plane to take off with the flight plan submitted, said Freddy Bonilla, air safety secretary for Colombia's aviation authority." http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/international/chapecoense-plane-crash-cause-human-error-not-enough-fuel-colombia-a7497026.html http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/international/ch... Also, Tabaco happens. Kill your customers, get new ones.
- admax88q 10y agoKilling them slowly is fine. See tobacco or fast food. Killing them quickly and violently tends to go poorly.
- Mz 10y ago..quickly, violently and en masse in a manner in which you have no hope of plausible deniability. ("But, maybe it wasn't the crash that killed all 200+ passengers. Correlation does not prove causation.")
- clarkmoody 10y agoUmm, tobacco kills over a lifetime of product usage. Aircraft kill quickly, violently, and in headline-leading ways...
- ssambros 10y agoMarkets don't usually optimize for safety, or security, for that matter.
- marcosdumay 10y agoAir travel is so safe because people have a disproportionate amount of care towards it. The amount of regulation comes from that, as does the industry embracing safer procedures by itself.
- bogomipz 10y agoThere's many reasons why air travel is so safe - fly-by-wire, GPS, collision avoidance systems, improvements in aerospace engineering and design are all contributors. Regulation is only part of the reason it is not "the" reason.
- 1_2__3 10y agoI'm going to guess your unspoken assertion is that these things would have happened anyway - or even faster, natch! - had the government not gotten involved and mandated ever-stricter safety requirements. I do not agree.
- bogomipz 10y agoI don't have any "unspoken assertion", I really don't understand your comment. What is "natch"? The FAA's issuing of new safety regulations has historically been reactionary, they are generally enacted in response to an accident or specific incident. It is actually only very recently that they have shifted from a reactive event based system to a proactive form of risk management.
- stevenwoo 10y agonatch is American slang for naturally, phonetically matching the first syllable of the word.
- jessaustin 10y agoHas anyone besides Stan Lee actually used this word? Has he used it since the 1980s?
- shuntress 10y agoI think the point is that many of these technologies wouldn't be implemented or would be done so poorly were there no regulation.
- L_Rahman 10y agoSpecifically, regulation and deregulation are not inherently good or bad. They're about managing tradeoffs. Sometimes markets have incumbents with so much entrenched power that regulation can actually make the market more capitalist and create more choice for consumers. American politics however is poorly structured so that corporations who have economic incentive to game regulation/deregulation have concentrated power and the broader public or smaller competing interests do not. Corporatist regulatory capture and the status quo biases that come with it are the source of some of the biggest problems in our society - booming healthcare and education costs as well as entrenched oligopolies in infrastructure markets like telecom, internet and airlines.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tvanantwerp 10y agoThe trick here is defining "smart" versus "needless" regulations. It's not always an obvious difference. For example: lots of excessive state-level occupational licensing which effectively just creates cartels was passed with sensible arguments about protecting consumers from harm and poor quality. It's fairly easy to rationalize lots of regulations that don't work very well in practice. So just saying "it should be smart and not mindless" isn't really a solution to anything without a rigorous definition of what a "smart" regulation looks like.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoI think of regulations as capital projects. There's an up-front political cost to passing them, an up-front cost to establishing them and then an ongoing cost to feeding the bureaucracy. Minimising that ongoing cost, or at least ensuring it's paid out of the gains from the regulation, would appear to be a dividing line.
- epistasis 10y agoYes, that's exactly what I'm trying to point out! I'm not providing a solution, but merely saying that it's folly to treat all regulation as the enemy of free markets.
- ssambros 10y agoThe point of "mindless "anti-regulation" is that "no regulations" is the default position, and it's the proponents of regulation who should substantiate their claims that a specific regulation should exist; also that the lack of sufficient evidence in favor should automatically result in the default position being more favorable. In relation to the Chesterton’s Fence parable, a lot of people think that the fact that no one knows why it's there is in itself the reason to remove the fence, since the most common reason the fences are built in the first place it to provide someone particular the advantage over everyone else (limit access to the territory, markets, etc).
- rmxt 10y ago
- muninn_ 10y agoIdk - you can say that we're in a state of "anti-regulation" but I don't think that it's any worse than it has been for awhile. It basically amounts to who's looking out for who for regulation. Republicans are generally more about removing regulation (which can also be considered "smart regulation"), and Democrats less so, but the overall trend has been toward increasing regulation. It's very difficult to get rid of regulations once they are in place. One man/women's "smart regulation" is another man/woman's "overregulation/deregulation". For example, people say that regulating the coal industry should be done, and is common sense. I largely agree, but they say that without taking into account society's responsibility to provide for these people if we're going to essentially ban them from their jobs. If you spent 30 years working in the coal industry, you've built up expertise in that industry and regulation effectively destroys your ability to leverage that expertise to make a livelihood. We can say "oh they should retrain/relocate" but to me that's just abdicating responsibility for decisions. If we're going to do something that benefits society as a whole, we need to make sure that we're minimizing the harmful impact that will have on others. In other words, regulations can be very bad depending on who you are. Another example from a recent Planet Money podcast rerun. Because of state regulations she wasn't permitted to perform braiding hair in African style for profit unless she went to school for it. Businesses successfully had lobbied to create regulations that protected their interest. Fortunately (as far as I'm concerned) these laws were repealed. BUT at the same time, this regulation (let's say the whole thing was repealed) would have made the barrier to entry into that industry, as well as the time/money spent going to cosmetology school virtually worthless. Regulations are hard. It's incredibly difficult to get them right.
- hehheh 10y agoIn addition to contract enforcement and standardization, I'd add reducing and/or internalizing externalities. This is fundamentally a power differential issue but I think it's important enough to highlight independently. As for the assertion that "regulations are not bad, it's needless regulations that are bad" -- the argument sort of falls flat without specifics. The argument can be boiled down to "good things are good, bad things are bad."
- jwilliams 10y ago> Markets require regulation, whether it's in the form of contract enforcement or setting standardized terms for communication in the market. Any time there's a power differential, we need regulation. I don't disagree with this, but I strongly believe there are better paths to regulation than most of what we see today. In particular, you get a very long way by regulating founding principles -- Transparency, Access, Anti-Collusion. The problem with a lot of regulation and regulators is they become a party to the market. This creates a whole lot of issues. A lot of the regulation then is designed to protect the market as an entity, rather than the consumers.
- CalChris 10y ago> A lot of the regulation then is designed to protect the market as an entity, rather than the consumers. What you're describing isn't regulation; you're describing the results of regulatory capture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- jessaustin 10y agoI'm sure that in Scotland, regulators regularly avoid capture. In USA, the idea seems a bit fanciful... rather like non-crony capitalism.
- reckoner2 10y agoYou mention that needless regulations are bad. Matt Levine [1] has an interesting theory on regulations: (paraphrased) 1. There are two types of regulations: - Custom Regulations (smart, particular, specific) - Bulk Regulations (generic red tape, not reasoned or desired) 2. All regulations are custom regulations. 3. All discussion (like your point) is about bulk regulations, which do not exist. Regulation is tough. Everything that you believe to be needless, may actually serve a very specific and important purpose. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-01-24/metrics-fees-and-regulations https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-01-24/metrics-f...
- masklinn 10y ago> Everything that you believe to be needless, may actually serve a very specific and important purpose. It may or may not, and it may have served a purpose once upon a time but not anymore because the context has changed or because it's been superseded, it may have failed to achieve its goals or led to undesirable outcomes (either aside from its success or making the situation worse), it may have had a (now considered) horrendous purpose, … That one must be careful with regulations and understand why they exist is more or less GP's entire point: > deregulation is a difficult thing that must be done carefully I like this old quip/aphorism that you shouldn't be able to ask for a law's removal if you don't know why it exists, though I'm not sure it's always feasible, especially for the older texts. And of course the recorded purpose may not have been honest in the first place (see: many voting regulations in the US).
- r00fus 10y agoDoes Matt address the industry-sponsored regulations (ie, ones promoting barriers to entry to protect existing players)?
- Analemma_ 10y agoThe problem is, it's not clear which ones those are. Regulations don't come with labels saying "this is industry-sponsored to protect incumbents", and reasonable people can disagree on whether a barrier-promoting regulation has legitimate reasons.
- rubatuga 10y agoYou see that mentality engrained in the US government with net neutrality rules. Companies such as T-Mobile are offering unlimited data on their curated list of specific video streaming sites, and companies such as AT&T are throttling Netflix streams so as not to compete with their own video sharing service. What used to be a super-highway is becoming a mess of toll roads, and this is slowly being done under the guise of an attempt to create more competition. Facebook also has no qualms on encroaching on net neutrality rules in developing countries, and they have set up services in cellular networks all around the world where they provide customers with free access to only their own social network. Many citizens are under the impression that Facebook == internet. Some countries such as Chile have banned this practice quoting their own net-neutrality laws. However, currently the US seems to be taking a big step backwards for little economic or political gain.
- webnrrd2k 10y agoI agree - good regulation is worth a lot. Good regulations prevent potentially catastrophic situations. For example, good fire regulations help prevent whole cities from burning down. It's also hard to sell people on prevention when they haven't been through disasters themselves. Unless they have direct experience then, in general, people have trouble understanding just how bad things can get. I'd love to see, as an experiment, having laws written with a preamble explaining the context and goals of that particular law, with the intent of qualifying the purpose of the law. Then there would be something stating how to quantify that law... in other words. That way there are clear statements of the intended purpose and intended effect of the law. Finally, the law would be set with a re-evaluation date, or maybe an expiration date, and, if the goals were not met, then the law would be up for debate again. Then the cycle repeats, maybe with a longer delay each time, until the law just gets passed without debate every time. I know it's unrealistic. It would be a difficult way to get anything passed, but a culture would build up around this system, just like the current U.S. system, and every other major political system, and it would eventually work. And, the important thing, it would make a lot of the current system much more explicit, bring a lot of stuff to light, and I think we'd end up with much better laws and regulations in general.
- maxvu 10y agoThat data takes such a backseat to ineptitude and greed in policy debate is so tragically true. I agree with you 100% and, even if naming metrics is unrealistic, I'd pursue it given any power to influence the conversation. That I spend more time and effort in policy discussion describing the role and mechanics of the federal government than outcome causality or weighing moral questions is the absolute first reason I've never seriously considered government work.
- rayiner 10y agoWe are in the age of "smart regulation," and have been for about 40 years. Prior to the 1970s and 1980s, you had government regulation that tried to micromanage markets (as the article explains, regulating "prices and routes"). Airline regulation was representative: the airline told you what you could charge, where you could fly, what your customer experience had to be, how much profits you could make, etc. The problem is that the government was terrible at making these sorts of decisions. In the late 1970s through the 1990s, we rolled back that sort of regulation all across the economy. Instead of micromanaging prices and routes, we refocused the government on regulations like safety and maintenance standards. And it was a huge success: http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/AirlineDeregulation.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/AirlineDeregulation.html. So much so that Europe copied it: http://www.economist.com/node/146627 http://www.economist.com/node/146627. It's not just because ticket prices are way cheaper than they used to be (though it's partly that). Carriers like FedEx and UPS (and companies that depend on them, like Amazon) wouldn't have been able to exist under the previous model where bureaucrats micromanaged the air cargo industry. The article isn't espousing "smart regulation." It's asking for the government to get back into the business of micromanaging prices and service: > There should also be rules on how many passengers an airline can cram into a plane, and what extras it can charge for. And there should be limits on price gouging. It makes no sense to allow airlines to charge an astronomical fare just because a flight is nearly full, and a dirt-cheap fare for an advance booking. There is no economic rationale for the government to tell airlines what extras they can and cannot charge for, any more than there is for the government to tell app or game developers what kinds of DLC they can charge for. Airline service is crappy for the same reason pop music and fast food are crappy. People are willing to give up almost everything in the way of amenities in return for saving a few bucks on the ticket price. It's not the government's place to tell them they shouldn't do that.
- Animats 10y agoFrom the article: An industry that is not naturally competitive went from being a regulated cartel, to a brief period of ruinous competition, and then to an unregulated cartel — with predictable effects on the quality of service. That also happened with the long-distance phone industry. Remember MCI Long Distance, Sprint Long Distance, etc. Also banking, where the US is down to four big banks.[1] [1] http://www.motherjones.com/files/images/big-bank-theory-chart-large.jpg http://www.motherjones.com/files/images/big-bank-theory-char...
- weberc2 10y agoI'm economically illiterate. Could you explain why markrts require regulation? What happens in unregulated markets? What variable does "appropriate regulation" optimize for? GDP?
- MagnumOpus 10y agoThe main reason why regulation needs to exist: - Unregulated markets often become oligopolies or monopolies, see the 19th century US robber barons (the reason for existence of FTC, antitrust laws, price dumping regulation etc) - Unregulated markets can pose massive health and safety hazards, because operators pursue cost cutting at the price of safety - see the accident rate Chinatown buses between Boston and NYC, or see the regular food scandals in any developing country of your choice (reason for existence of OSHA, FDA etc) - Unregulated markets can pose big fraud risks - particularly unregulated securities markets (reason for existence of SEC, NASD, etc) - Unregulated markets will ignore externalities like pollution, public health, damage to commons both environmental and infrastructural [roads, buildings, trash, spectrum interference]. Regulation is needed to avoid the externalities or to internalise the costs into the market which causes these costs (reason for existence of EPA, FCC)
- losvedir 10y agoI think you might get some mileage out of skimming the wikipedia article on "Perfect Competition".[0] While "free markets" are a bit of an ill-defined, political term, "perfect competition" is well-defined, in a mathematical sense, well-studied in Economics, and generally regarded as a good thing. But (as you'll read in the wikipedia article) there are a number of required conditions for it. So good regulations could help ensure those conditions are met. For example, one of the conditions is "no externalities", which are things that affect 3rd parties not involved in the buying/selling decision. Pollution could be relevant to airlines; perhaps one airline can offer cheaper tickets by burning dirty and dumping soot all along the way. That's not perfect competition because it affects all the people who suffer from the pollution, but not the person buying the ticket (who naturally would be incentivized to buy the cheaper ticket). But if the government mandated pollution standards that protects all the non-flyers, and that all the airlines are subject to, then it's a fair competition on price again. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition
- isoskeles 10y agoShould contract enforcement pervade every industry? Or in other words, why would enforcing contracts be a "regulation" specific to airlines? As far as I know, regulations would mean a set of rules spelled out by the executive branch of the government, imposed upon businesses that qualify by existing in some industry. Contracts seem to be way broader than that. But I am not a lawyer. I agree that some form of standardized terms for communication should exist in the market. And I don't know enough about airline regulations to say they don't already exist. I assume the article in question would not tell me if such regulations exist, as it does not advance the "deregulation is bad" narrative.
- stevenwoo 10y agoWhat if it's not regulation at all but financialization as this topical Atlantic article describes - https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/04/how-wall-street-killed-the-solar-industry/523245/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/04/how-w... To paraphrase - he went looking for government regulation causing a problem and didn't find it. "But I found that—though that was a part of it—what was more important was the difference between how the Japanese corporations and the American corporations were organized and who controlled the corporations."
- Consultant32452 10y ago>Any time there's a power differential, we need regulation. The biggest power differential is between the government and "everything else." Far too many people think regulation is the right answer, right up until the "other party" gets their hands on it. People say regulations are bad because they see the results of the bought and paid for regulations that our governments are writing. One need only recall the Princeton study which demonstrated there's a near zero correlation between what voters want and what gets enacted into law.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's why you have bureaucracy. So you can have people who know wtf they are talking about make rules that make sense. Unfortunately, you have one party that has been able to systematically defund and break the executive branch for about 30 years. So stuff doesn't work as well. You have an airline cartel because the government allowed it. For example, obvious anti-competitive, anti-consumer mergers like Delta/Northwest (monopolizing traffic to Minneapolis) are allowed to go through. At the fare level, the airlines are allowed to rollout the circus carnival pricing scheme where nobody pays the same price, and nobody has a way to actually compare prices at an apples/oranges level.
- drawkbox 10y agoWhen people think of free markets they think of open competition, but some free markets are not competitive and more fixed markets by the big fish. We need fair free markets that encourage competition. Not a free market that is blocked by the biggest fish, we should be anti-monopoly and all regulations need to encourage competition. Markets should be free but fair, by fair I mean encourage competition. Regulations should make it easy for competition to happen not harder needlessly. Regulation is important for a healthy fair market. AT&T breakup was big and did encourage competition, though they may be back soon. Microsoft 90s ordeal really did shake them up and in the early 2000s competition happened again. Dark side of monopolies are AT&T created modern software/C++ and wired the US up first, Microsoft got everyone on the internet and a computer on every desk. Sometimes there are benefits to big fish but you can still create competition. It may also create other important growth areas when big fish are broken up. We only need regulation that creates markets that are fair competitively but otherwise free, net neutrality is an example of a fair competitive regulation.