21 ms·
Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the Young
- anovikov 10y agoWell, i couldn't read article because it's behind paywall, but PwC is surely a place for young people. It is a sweatshop where you get paid a pittance, worked till you drop, but learn fast and earn a good line in resume, as well as build industry contacts quickly. Great place to start but if you are stuck there for long, something is wrong. If you are over 40 and under the partner level, it makes no sense to stay there.
- seibelj 10y agoI think a lot of on-site consultant roles are for young recent graduates. My friend worked right out of college for Epic Software as a consultant managing their medical software integrations. He was supposed to fly home once a month for 3 days off (he had normal weekends off too, but stayed at the client's location in a hotel) but often deadlines would cause him to have to stay. He wound up drinking a lot, smoking way too much weed, and essentially had a nervous breakdown after a year of doing this. To add insult to injury, because he didn't make it long enough to fulfill his contractual obligations, Epic made him pay back his signing bonus and moving costs they reimbursed him for. He then moved back home with his parents, got his shit together, and a few months later got into IT project management at an eCommerce company. No travel, normal weekends, normal hours. He's back to himself again. The consultant life just seems so brutal, you don't make close friendships, you're never home, difficult to have a romantic relationship, difficult to eat healthy and exercise. No thanks!
- toyg 10y agoBut: very good money, and a lifestyle that can be pretty glamorous at times (if you want it, of course). I'm currently in the process of slowly moving away from it because of external forces, and to be honest I know I'll miss it. The first couple of years were as harsh as you describe, but then I learnt to pace myself (and VPNs got truly mainstream so traveling decreased dramatically). Is still a pretty good life, all considered; after all, any good career these days requires brutal hours and lots of flying.
- ghaff 10y agoA lot depends on the sort of consulting probably. There are some cannon fodder sort of jobs certainly. There are others, as you say, where you learn to create some semblance of balance even if you still live on planes. (Though I would dispute that all good careers require both brutal hours and lots of flying; some do some don't.) Out of school I was supervising projects on-site and it was a really good out of school job. Would I have been wanting to spend weeks in shipyards at 40 or 50? No way. I do a lot of flying these days but I'm in control of my schedule to at least a certain degree.
- ams6110 10y agoThe drinking and the weed probably had as much to do with his breakdown as the job.
- joezydeco 10y agohe had normal weekends off too, but stayed at the client's location in a hotel Long spans away from home, with no friends or family around, and a high-visibility deadline constantly hanging over your head...how would you relieve some of that stress? I've personally known people that did this kind of job right out of college, it's a hell of a meat grinder.
- Arizhel 10y agoPersonally, I wish I could find a job where I traveled for about 1 week per month, like to customer sites to do support work. I used to have a job like this, but it didn't last long for various reasons, and I haven't found another since. It's a lot of fun IMO: I get to travel someplace new, I can eat at nice restaurants on the company's dime, I get access to a nice swimming pool and gym at the hotel, and since the customer isn't generally going to stay late I get plenty of free time to explore the city or just hang out in my hotel room (or a coffee shop, or wherever) working on a personal project on my computer, etc. As long as it isn't more than 1-1.5 weeks/month, it doesn't feel like I'm "never home" or that I can't have a romantic relationship, and I actually eat better and get more exercise than when I'm at home where I don't have my own pool or gym. The only really big downside is the TSA, and sometimes the misery of flying (though it helps a lot to only fly with Southwest if possible).
- Spooky23 10y agoSome people prefer to exclusively hire blond women with D cups. Or white mainline protestant men. Both of those things may be a big part of how a hypothetical company works. Problem is, it's illegal.
- unabridged 10y agoI think this is a perfect example to test the theory they bring up about the gender pay gap. If so much value is being left on the table ignoring older workers, gather them all up into a company and beat the market.
- stevenwoo 10y agoThe study referenced in this article hypothesizes gender pay gap exists because companies are willing to pay more to people who are willing to spend more hours at the office. (They looked at more careers than programming.) https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/24/upshot/the-pay-gap-is-because-of-gender-not-jobs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/24/upshot/the-pay-gap-is-bec... On the one hand this seems fair, on the other hand, the escalating arms race to spend all your time at the office doesn't seem like a great way to live for the ordinary employee without some ownership stake. The careers with the most gender parity were the ones without excessive time in the office associated with success. If the time spent in office theory is true, it also makes that theory about gathering all the employees of a certain class to start a company not relevant.
- greenyoda 10y agoWell, I've seen lots of studies over the years that claim that extra time spent in the office (beyond 40 hours per week) doesn't translate into extra productivity. Some reasons mentioned include: - Tired employees make more errors, which then take time to fix. And if you've been working for 12 hours, you'll be mentally tired even if you're not physically tired. - If you spend 12 hours a day at the office, lots of things you need to do in your life (e.g., arranging your social life, running errands, going to the gym, eating meals) will get done while you're at the office. - A lot of programmers (myself included) get their best thinking done when they're relaxing away from the office.
- Asooka 10y agoMaybe not extra actual productivity, but extra imagined productivity and when it comes time to raises, it's not reality, or what could have been, but your boss's imagination that counts.
- zipwitch 10y agoThe big problem with hiring older workers is that they're better at knowing what they're actually worth. They also tend to avoid personal sacrifices (mainly time and health) that are of net benefit to the company but not to themselves.
- Thrillington 10y agoThat sounds more like a systemic problem where companies profitability is put forward as an excuse for anti-social behavior.
- lj3 10y ago> anti-social behavior You say anti-social behavior. The courts say 'maximizing shareholder value'.
- branchless 10y agoIt just amazes me people can't see this. Workers produce value, their labour is the product. The difference between the value produced and the cost of labour is the profit. Paying labour as little as possible is capitalism. Competition between companies means there is no choice other than to seek to maximize this.
- anigbrowl 10y agoNo. I hate capitalism but this is not how economics works. Please, get a textbook or two (Barron's publishes some excellent revision guides that are well-written and cheap on a variety of business subjects, including economics), and study it for a year or two.
- branchless 10y agoI disagree.
- capisce 10y ago
- sxp 10y agohttps://www.propublica.org/article/is-it-age-discrimination-if-you-dont-know-youre-being-discriminated-against https://www.propublica.org/article/is-it-age-discrimination-... covers the same set of discrimination lawsuits as this WSJ article without the paywall. It also goes into more depth about the legal precedents involved. The tl;dr: the companies argue that the discrimination laws only apply to current employees and not applicants so it's OK for them to intentionally discriminate against older applicants.
- lkrubner 10y agoI recently had an idea for a startup, related to the mis-use of the old. I have been working with startups that are using a hybrid approach to data gathering, using both Natural Language Processing (NLP) and also humans. The NLP works best as a lead-generator for the humans, the NLP can pick out sentences that we are 95% sure have the information we need. Then we have humans read over the data to look for bits that should actually go in the database. One evening I watched a fellow on the data team as he read through a dozen newspapers, looking for any clues that we might have missed. He is part of an 8 person team, and they are all in their 20s. That weekend I went to visit my mom, who has been retired for more than 15 years. As is normal for her, she was reading over The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and a few business magazines. She majored in history, at Hunter College, back in the 1950s, then she did her masters degree in economics. The week before last, Hunter College had its reunion for alumni. More than 2,000 women showed up. I met my mom outside as the event was ending. I saw the thousands of smart, retired women, and it occurred to me: why don't we use these women to read through all the data fetched by the NLP scripts? Why do we rely on people in their 20s? These women are smart, well trained, highly educated, many of them are looking for part-time work with flexible hours, something they could do from home. Most of them have the life long habit of looking through newspapers for interesting data. Most are willing to work very cheap. Most are eager to be in the workforce, most are sad about being out of the workforce. There is, in fact, a whole category of startups that are opening in this area, using the hybrid approach of both NLP and also humans. And it would be an ideal place to use retired people. Only stupid bias keeps startups from pursuing this.
- greenyoda 10y ago"These women are smart, well trained, highly educated, many of them are looking for part-time work with flexible hours, something they could do from home. Most of them have the life long habit of looking through newspapers for interesting data. Most are willing to work very cheap. Most are eager to be in the workforce, most are sad about being out of the workforce." If they actually need the money to survive, why would they work very cheap if they're well trained and highly educated? There's freelance work out there that pays better than "very cheap", e.g., editing or translation. Retired professionals such as lawyers or CPAs can also probably find freelance work in their fields. If they don't need the money (they have enough savings for retirement) and are just looking for something to do, they'd have the option of doing volunteer work for charitable organizations that are probably more fulfilling to work for than some random startup.
- dghughes 10y agoAfter 33 years in my trade over 14 years at the most recent place I was let go. Not fired not laid off just quietly let go. I suspect it is due to my age I'm 48 and was told I wasn't being considered since I am " not the right fit".
- WrtCdEvrydy 10y ago> over 14 years at the most recent place That's the issue. You made a mistake believing there is such a thing as "loyalty". Move every 2-3 years to get "raises" and fuck everyone else, no company has any loyalty to you.
- sramkrishna 10y agoagreed. I was at my last job for 20 years. From here on in, I'll try to not stay so long in one place. But I stayed mostly because I was friends with everyone. I was paid well enough, but work was fun.
- santaclaus 10y ago> Not fired not laid off just quietly let go. How does that work, logistically?
- toomuchtodo 10y ago"Your last day will be X."
- slededit 10y agoIsn't that getting fired?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoGetting fired usually involves cause being shown.
- 10y ago
- sjg007 10y agoI mean it is a pyramid scheme in that you have a few partners at the top and the bottom are the young PowerPoint analysts who grind out the work. Law is/was the same way. Software can be as well. Grad school as well. The whole thing is setup this way by design. Same with startups as well if you don't guard against it.
- mistermann 10y agoThere are so many professions where you study/work extremely hard for say 10 to 15 years, and then just pump out the big bucks executing (aka "putting in time") on what you've learned. Are there many professions other than software where you have to work so hard continuously (because everything is always new and you are competing with people with a fifth your experience) to make a good income?
- biztos 10y agoSerious question: Is any interesting software written in places like PWC?
- houst0n_ 10y agoNot really. Mostly (when I was pimped out to them) they did almost exclusively "business constantly" work (read: outsourcing blame and repaying favours, greasing the revolving door, putting projects on a project code with an existing vendor instead of hiring staff who come out of the overall budget etc etc), they made tech stuff something to "throw in" as a bonus to some deals. Started out with reporting (remember crystal reports and oracle appex?) but that grows with kickbacks until they're subcontracting Fujitsu or CapGemini to manage desktops as part of a deal. After a while the tech bit ended up being one of the biggest money makers they had, thanks to clever/corrupt SLA's which enabled them to have terrible staff who got paid nothing, and pocket the difference. They had an nice/huge domino setup in the 2000's though(sol/sparc), and some of the excel macros the audit folks wrote and used allowed me to grow up from thinking that working ksh perl and c made me "better" than the windows folks. They would share these 10mb+ packages of excel macros which were all compressed text, they extremely complicated and also controlled by various regulatory bodies, it was harder than most of the code we were writing for their backends... Tl;dr -- nope, but if you ever see how some serious financial auditors code, you might stop dismissing the MS crowd so readily.
- biztos 10y agoI never have dismissed the MS crowd, in fact I was part of it for years. Interestingly enough there's a lot of Excel-Macro wizardry in aerospace too. Thanks for sharing your memories. Having known some people on the business side of PWC I'm not surprised, but I am amused.
- sjg007 10y agoPwC's primary business is audits, assurance, and tax per wikipedia. So you might get software in those areas or in business valuation. I don't believe they do IT integrations. Accenture may do more interesting work on the consulting and software side.