14 ms·
Why Did My Patient Leave Me?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- z3t4 10y agoit can be more rewarding to ask happy customers what they like about you.
- jacquesm 10y agoI've done this, without feedback. The reason was that doctors seem to come in several varieties when it comes to bringing their ego to work and my doctor had a serious case of that. I was dehydrated after an operation and when he asked if he could do something for me I asked for some water, the doctor then ordered someone else not in the room to come and get me a glass of water. He couldn't be bothered to walk to the sink and do it for me because that sort of thing was beneath him, he was a doctor after all, not some lowly nurse. That would have been hard to argue as sufficient reason to switch but I figured that if his primary worry in a situation where a patient has clearly expressed a need is his perception then he shouldn't have become a doctor in the first place and likely that would get in the way of him providing care. I've talked this over with a nurse friend of mine and they totally confirmed that this is normal, doctors, especially in a hospital setting, are on top of a hierarchy that tends to self-reinforce their importance. And yes, they are important. But in the end what is most important is that they realize that the only reason they have a job is because someone else is in trouble and that some humility goes a very long way towards establishing real rapport. The one thing that stood out for me on this subject that I read about a while ago (not sure if it was in a book or online) was that actually being in the hospital as a patient immediately made doctors a much better doctor for their patients. Dogfooding works, even for doctors. Another reason why people don't leave feedback: they don't want to get into an argument, they just want to switch and they already have enough on their plates and fortunately in many places they have that right.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>the doctor then ordered someone else not in the room to come and get me a glass of water // It seems possible that was a hygiene issue. For example the doctor knew that he'd need then to wash his hands again (possibly twice, once before going to the cupboard, once after), or change his gloves, before continuing with your consultation?
- jacquesm 10y agoIt could have been but it wasn't. He wasn't in scrub and besides doctors are required to wash their hands between patients anyway and he'd touched other objects in the room already.
- QSIITurbo 10y agoAnother alternative that I've run into. Visiting a doctor friend of mine. She needed to deliver some papers to another room and summoned the nurse for that. I joked that why you can't do that yourself (omg) and she replied that the nurses start to complain if you do stuff that's earmarked to them. It might be that it's because they're in a union or it's a company policy. Who knows, I never asked. But the point was that the nurses wouldn't appreciate it if she did it herself.
- jacquesm 10y agoThat would still not trump patient comfort. It's ego all over again, now from a different angle.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThat's a very american thing. I remember reading about engineers from Germany who worked with NASA engineers on a project. The americans were surprised that when something was wrong the germans just took a wrench to fix it where for the americans it was policy to call a technician. From my own experience the US is a weird mix of "can do" attitude on the one hand with strict hierarchies and enforced policies on the other hand.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- danieltillett 10y agoI have luckily been very healthy in my life, but I have always believed that the relationship between a doctor and a patient is a collaboration with the aim being to help the patient make the most appropriate decision for their needs. Too many doctors seem to be of the opinion they know best and the patient should just do as they say - even if they are correct technically it is not their life that is on the line. The patient is always right.
- agumonkey 10y agoWell, I've been plunged into this very issue. Even for cancer care, I found no trace of collaboration. It was bureaucratic, sometimes cold, out of sync (no news, contradictory news). No team work possible. Also if you ever try to mention alternate ideas, you get dismissed right away. And for fallacious reasons. Mostly statistical and experience driven, which looked like myopia to me. I'm actually collecting evidence to back my ideas right now. I understand they're humans, have limits, budgets. But the overall "this (comfy death) or nothing" is maddenning to me.
- XorNot 10y agoPeople looking for alternatives for cancer care tend to look for things which literally do nothing (high profile example: Steve Jobs), or get fixated on experimental drugs which have a high likelihood of being ineffective or much more immediately fatal.
- agumonkey 10y agoFair point. I just think a bit like DeVita: delay death (in a moral manner, not at any cost); then treat with recent combinations/molecules. The regulations forbid combinational trials first and delay learning (according to him). There are potent tumor inhibitors like CBD that aren't accepted by most of the medical field, thus patients too (high trust in the doctors). They can alleviate symptoms and slow down metastasis (some academics have seen regression even). This gives time to plan for the rest. Instead you're sent home to die thinking it's hopeless. I guess it's better than dying at hospital, or being cut into pieces by resections... but it's far from acceptable IMO.
- ljoshua 10y agoThis is a growing and very important aspect of value-based care, and really factors into the discussion of quality that will be more a part of reimbursement than it ever has been. The article focused mostly on the provider him or herself, but patients also take into account the entire experience, including office staff, scheduling and billing procedures, etc. Shameless self promotion: this is the exact problem my co-founder and I are working to address: https://www.perspexilabs.com/ https://www.perspexilabs.com/ (site currently looks broadly-focused, but we're targeting medical). We're finding patients are actually very happy to give feedback, especially when given a neutral medium to discuss their experiences and when doing so very quickly after an interaction. The super-tight feedback loop not only makes everyone more satisfied, but it also has the chance to improve quality of care too.
- Herodotus38 10y agoIt looks like your model uses immediate or nearly so text messaging after an interaction. Since a phone number is protected health information as per HIPAA, I'd be interested in how it's been setting a business associate contract? I imagine there is quite a bit of red tape. Are you able to set up one and use it for each clinical entity or does it require a bit of individualization?
- ljoshua 10y agoIndeed, you're right. It follows a similar model to services that do appointment reminders via text message, which is becoming very common. The permission check becomes vital: it's part of the patient authorization at, for example, a first visit, and is best when also followed by a verbal authorization upon checkout. It's one of the big hurdles we're trying to overcome obviously, but we believe there are proper ways to do it and make it work within the boundaries of regulation and privacy. No good problem worth solving is without difficulties, right? :)
- Herodotus38 10y agoI wish you luck. I think your approach is far better than the mailed sheets of paper surveys I inevitably toss in the recycling bin that arrive 1-2 weeks after my children's appointments. Do you guys use any sort of incentive to boost responses?
- known 10y agoA good doctor should always tell the patient how his disease could have been prevented.
- speeder 10y agoI don't bother explaining to doctors why I switched. Every time I did in the past they got personally offended and refused to address their flaws, so why bother? Also I am almost convinced good medics in certain fields (endocrinology for example) are almost nonexistent.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Also I am almost convinced good medics in certain fields (endocrinology for example) are almost nonexistent. Endocrinologists are legally all but required to have the presumption that their patients are criminals, and that the patient must prove otherwise. Because of the ban on "cosmetic" use of anabolic steroids and other hormones, which was passed under Bush Sr., endocrinologists are flooded with patients who concoct really elaborate stories explaining why they need hormones. The liability is so high for endocrinologists that they are incentivized not to be the most convenient provider around, lest they develop a reputation as the one who prescribes easily. The people who suffer the most from all of this are the people who need hormones the most: transgender people and people with serious hormone disorders, but the system is not designed to make their lives convenient.
- zer0tonin 10y agoMost endocrinologist only ever see diabetics and people with thyroid disorder. They are often quite lost when they get to see something else.
- speeder 10y agoI have thyroid problem... Endocrinologists even then failed to help for most part. I found only one willing to help, and only in an half-assed manner. I still go most for formality and legality reasons, but I am mostly treating myself as I want now.
- lmns 10y agoSo, in this sense, vaccination should be an individual choice? This is something which concerns the individual, but has consequences for society as a whole.
- rubatuga 10y agoIt has and always be the individual's choice, unless they are unconscious or unable to make a reasonable decision on their own. Vaccination has always been opt out, and it's a right to choose whether or not to accept medical treatment.
- dexterdog 10y agoNot related. Vaccination is for the population as a whole more so than the individual. Experimental treatments are a risk the individual should be able to choose to take.
- jacquesm 10y ago> So, in this sense, vaccination should be an individual choice? Emphatically: YES. Bodily integrity is something that is very high on the list of things that a person should have a say over. Whether they do it because they are mis-informed, dumb, irrational or religious doesn't matter, they still should have the final say over whether or not they get a specific injection or not. There are many things that concern the individual that have consequences for society as a whole, in fact, it is very hard to point at a single thing that concerns an individual that has absolutely no consequence for society. And many of those things are regulated to benefit society. But your body is yours and yours alone and that's a good thing even if there are negative consequences for society. Fortunately the anti-vaxxers are a small minority instead of a large majority so the risk is somewhat controllable and fortunately the only people at risk are those that have not been vaccinated yet (a risk that for many diseases is extremely small) so the consequences for society as a whole are manageable. If that should change dramatically then this should be revisited but for now I'm pretty happy to support this even though I would never apply it to myself or my children (who, ironically, don't get to chose because the argument isn't really framed right, it's not an individual choice but in almost all cases a choice for a parent about their child...). This also ties in with religious freedom, and as an atheist you might find it surprising that I'm a big proponent of that, I don't believe in any of this but I will definitely defend the right of others to believe in whatever they want, including in things that may make them make sub-optimal choices when it comes to their own health or the health of their kids. If you start to take away those rights you will end up with a very unhealthy society, far more unhealthy (and unhealthy on a different plane) than the society that has to deal with some actual health issues in a small part of their population.
- tomohawk 10y agoYears ago, I had a truly great primary care doctor. She had her own practice, which was typical at that time. She was caring, but above all, extremely competent. After she retired, I've yet to come across a situation remotely as good. I think she was so good because she was allowed to be directly engaged with her patients and that resulted in some sort of feedback loop where she was always striving to stay on top of the state-of-the-art. These days, those sorts of practices are hard to find. There's the doc-in-a-box places that dominate, and they seem surprised if you want to see the same doc rather than whoever can just see you. There's also someone else in the room these days - the government and (practically the same thing) insurance company. The doctor / patient relationship is now more like the doctor stooge snooping on the patient relationship. Just look at how many doctors no longer will prescribe medicine for pain due to the war on drugs. They're scared of losing their license. The collateral damage is the poor people who need strong pain management but find it increasingly hard to get it.
- DanBC 10y ago> Just look at how many doctors no longer will prescribe medicine for pain due to the war on drugs. They're scared of losing their license. The collateral damage is the poor people who need strong pain management but find it increasingly hard to get it. Doctors haven't stopped prescribing opioids because of the war on drugs. They've changed prescribing because opioid meds are not effective to treat long term pain, and certainly not effective in the way they were being prescribed. People with long term pain given opioids will quickly develop tolerance to those meds, and need to increase the dose. They quickly reach dangerous levels of opioid use, often with multiple meds, and they're still not getting relief from their pain. So now they're still in pain, and they have an opioid addiction. People with long term pain need rapid access to specialist pain clinics, with a full range of treatment including physiotherapy and prescribing, and -if needed- carefully prescribed opioids.
- nullstyle 10y ago> Doctors haven't stopped prescribing opioids because of the war on drugs. They've changed prescribing because opioid meds are not effective to treat long term pain, and certainly not effective in the way they were being prescribed. Watch the documentary "Dr. Feelgood" (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5192362/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5192362/) for a couple of very extreme, living and breathing refutations of that claim. It's not nearly cut and dried one way or the other.
- josephorjoe 10y agoThe primary reason I have left healthcare providers has been the poor quality of their administrative staff. There are too many qualified doctors in the major metro area I live in to put up with ones where I can't quickly and efficiently make an appointment, can't get an appointment in a timeframe that is useful to me, and where their staff can't seem to successfully process routine insurance claims with major insurance providers. Also, randomly billing me for stuff weeks or months after an appointment with cryptic explanations thoroughly pisses me off -- even it if is only $15.00 (going to get a new podiatrist over that one...). As for actual "doctor specific" reasons for leaving a doctor, not explaining the reasoning behind his/her recommendations for me to get certain medical tests or procedures done will get me to look for another doctor. I don't actually need to fully understand the reasoning (I'm not, afterall, a doctor), but I need to know there is a reason beyond "hey, you said your elbow hurt and I think I can get the insurance company to pay for an MRI!".
- csydas 10y ago> Also, randomly billing me for stuff weeks or months after an appointment with cryptic explanations thoroughly pisses me off -- even it if is only $15.00 (going to get a new podiatrist over that one...). This part gets me a lot as well, and having experienced other pay-for healthcare systems, it's extremely frustrating remembering just how much I would pay in the US even when I had fair insurance through my employer. Getting a simple biopsy done on my leg resulted in a $250 upfront new patient fee, $2300 for the biopsy, then an additional $400 for lab fees some months later. Aside from the new patient fee, I had no idea or indication about any of the other fees until a bill arrived in the mail, despite asking and persisting about it throughout the visit, and since I had to take time off of work to get an appointment, I was at a loss as to how to "make a stand" to get such information. Compared to where I've been abroad where it's been an upfront fee for walk-in visits. Appointments were needed, but it was a day or two in advance. And when I got insurance through my workplace, it was equally simple.
- theoneone 10y agoSo 3000$ for a biopsy: ticket to Greece and back to USA : let's say 1000€. Biopsy procedure if it's ultrasound guided around 300€. Lab fee for examining the biopsy:around 200€ max, maybe less. Hotel room for 2-4 days in Thessaloniki 120€-150€ in a decent hotel. Total:1500€ or even less. All these can be done by highly and well educate medical doctors, treatment in private clinics is very good(since you are paying in cash you always get vip treatment) and o course you can enjoy a good vacation. I always said that medical tourism is the future
- stinkytaco 10y agoI don't know if my doctor would notice. She sees so many patients it's hard to get in when I need to, so I end up seeing whoever is available anyway. That seems increasingly common,large systems with overworked generals and huge administrative headaches. And it's not like we can switch, we've got insurance.
- builtinbuffalo 10y agoWe've created a patient feedback software (http://www.repcheckup.com http://www.repcheckup.com) that allows doctors to automate their patient feedback by sending email and text rating/review solicitations. On average, less than 5% of all patients seen will leave feedback. When prompted, we've seen this jump to 10-15% of patients seen, although we do have a few who have much higher conversion ratios. (This is likely due to the doctor introducing the feedback concept at the end of the consult.) What has been most interesting to see, contrary to the story, is that most doctors and healthcare professionals are still on the fence about implementing these sorts of feedback loops. We find often times that buy-in does not occur until the professionals can see "comparisons" as to how others are doing. There are also a ton of hurdles to implementation of these types of feedback loops, due to HIPAA and other requirements that often makes things near impossible. This makes the whole thought of introducing this into a practice daunting for some and that's why usage of feedback loops like these are not already widespread. Hopefully, as legacy practitioners give way to a new generation of medical and Heath professionals, patient feedback will be more widely solicited and used.
- giardini 10y agoIn my case, - reluctance to diagnose and treat the ailment instead of the symptoms and - simply refusing to hear what the patient says. I had an oozing rash break out behind my knees. The dermatologist said "That'll go away easily if you put some OTC corticosteroid cream on it." Wrong! The rash flared up within hours and nearly ate the flesh off the back of my knees. I happen to know that this indicates a fungal infection so I stopped the steroids and applied an OTC antifungal regularly. Slowly it began to heal. A week later I had a minor bout with detergent dermatitis around my jeans pockets (happens every winter if I use a strong detergent). Next time the dermatologist sees the residue of my scarred legs behind the knees and the "jeans-pocket" rash, I tell her that her steroid recommendation was absolutely a wrong call, what happened and how I treated the problem. Rather than take a culture from the back of my legs (and later possibly prescribing an antifungal), she then prescribes not a tube, but a 1-pound _tub_ of corticosteroid cream and tells me to put it on all rashes (behind knees and on "pocket" rashes) for six weeks! So I figure either she's deaf, has a serious learning disorder or flatter myself that she is trying to kill me. In any case I won't see that dermatologist again. On the upside: I have an unopened pound jar of steroid skin cream in my refrigerator.
- madengr 10y agoDermatologists have a cream for everything. Once in a while I have a horrible itch breakout on the top of my feat; so bad I'll scratch it bloody. In this case, the one pound tub he prescribed does work. Works well for chiggers too.
- giardini 10y agoI asked two friends about my itching woes. Both are gardeners so have dealt with maddening itches. Their response: "I ask my doctor and he gives me a prednisone pill. The itching disappears; 3 days later I'm OK." In the case of the fungus, prednisone would have been a mistake, but I nonetheless sometimes feel I am a target for a form of alternative medicine. Why didn't _I_ get a prednisone pill instead of a tub of corticosteroid lard? As for chiggers: in college I got a serious case of chiggers from a romantic blanket evening in the Texas desert. We two were apparently the only mammals within miles as every chigger available mobilized to fulfill its Darwinian destiny. Next morning I awoke up with a maddening itch everywhere (and I do mean _everywhere_) that lasted until the chiggers died (~3 days IIRC). Best treatment was to take as hot a shower as possible [The only thing better than sex is steaming hot water on chigger bites - it's like the Scratch of God]. Rest 30 minutes and repeat. I've heard a hair dryer works too. Thanks to your recommendation I'll keep the tub of steroid cream around just in case.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThis is an interesting read. It seems doctors really believe they have a conversation with their patient whereas most patients feel that the doctor just rushes in and gives his standard recommendation without deeper thought and generally doesn't listen to them. Do doctors go to other doctors when they have a problem? Do they get more respect by other doctors? If they went to a doctor and got the same treatment as their patients typically they should see that something is going wrong.
- kbutler 10y agoThis is definitely more at the specialist, chronic care level. Like anything else, if you have a weekly contact with them, you are much more significant than a once or twice a year visit.
- maxxxxx 10y agoProbably correct. My girlfriend just had a few surgeries. I was shocked how little time these specialists gave their patients. I bet most of them spent less than an hour thinking about the whole case. There are exceptions but we had several surgeons who stopped by a few minutes before the surgery and didn't remember anything about the case or confused cases. Then they took 3 minutes to get up to speed. They also often don't look for feedback after the surgery. Some don't even call and when you tell them that it didn't work they disappear. Also, they rarely talk to each other. So every procedure starts from scratch and the patient has to explain the case history. I can't imagine how bad software development would be if we acted like the medical system.
- magnetic 10y agoI was following you until... > I can't imagine how bad software development would be if we acted like the medical system. ...which made me laugh. Until I realized you weren't sarcastic (I think).
- bayouborne 10y ago
- ziikutv 10y agoIt ain't perfect in Canada either. I remember losing my hairs and getting patches of super smooth bald spots. Super embarrassing for a kid in a bad neighbourhood and bad school. Went to the doctor she looked at my charts and said I was super low on iron so low that I might even die if it continues to lower. I was given iron pills. Two months after I went to the doctor again and said my hair patches are not fixed. She looks at my chart again and said... hey you don't have low iron you have perfect iron and I never told you to take any pills. Then upon investigation it was noted that the staff gave her wrong chart; of a pregnant woman who had a similar "feminized" version of my name. Edit: Addendum: finally I was sent to a skin specialist who injected me with steroids for months until my patches were fixed. They said I had alopecia. I was furious what if the said person had cancer and they started chemo on me? Same doctor once injected my mom with the wrong fluid. To this day we don't know. We filed a complaint but she then resorted to personal attacks in her report and the "college of medicine" or whatever it's called didn't do anything. Till this day my mom has a red/purple bump on her arms. Finlly, most other docs don't even check me out they listen to symptoms and say it's nothing, it will go away, etc while looking miserable (no doctor should watch House MD lol). Other times they solve the symptoms by tossing prescriptions at me. Said symptoms always keep coming back and I keep getting more of the same prescriptions. Thanks for the free health"care" Canada.
- dleslie 10y agoBureaucratic mishaps and mediocre care providers are bound to occur in any sufficiently complex system.
- waqf 10y agoHave you looked at the work in the 2000s on preventing medical errors, e.g. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/31/health/31safe.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/31/health/31safe.html?
- ziikutv 10y agoI agree and the skeptic in me wonders if we can ever replace the "humans" in these roles with computers that crunch a bunch of numbers. However, just like computers, many doctors base their decision on statistics.
- dabbledash 10y agoI think it's great for doctors to solicit feedback from departing patients to see if there is anything they could be doing better. But on a related note: I'm not sure about the value of using patient satisfaction surveys to evaluate physician performance generally. Patients will love doctors who tell them what they want to hear, over-prescribe antibiotics, over-prescribe powerful pain killers, go along with non-vaccination, prescribe homeopathic remedies or similar nonsense.... I think most people are not in a good position to evaluate the quality of care they're getting outside of things like bedside manner, so I wouldn't pay much attention to reviews for doctors.
- henrikschroder 10y agoI saw a study of patient satisfaction across the entire healthcare field which showed that overall patient satisfaction was the highest for massage therapists, and the lowest for oncologists. The former deliver no bad news ever, and treat to make you feel good and relaxed, the latter deliver nothing but bad news, but they probably save your life. So what happens is that people mistake their subjective feelings for the objective quality of care, and discount the value of being alive immensely.
- Waterluvian 10y agoDoes it spread well on toast?
- giardini 10y agoThe fungus or the steroid cream?
- salesguy222 10y agoWhich have you tried? :) p.s: anyone that downvotes this, you should really allow HN to be a place with a small dosage of humor sometimes!!
- jjordan 10y agoIf I want to scroll through pages and pages of joke threads, I'll go to reddit. HN is special in its high signal to noise ratio.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoThere is as much noise here as any other place on the internet, we are not special here.
- salesguy222 10y agoSome of the most profound observations in this world were made by accident, or through jokes. Some of the most effective speakers routinely incorporate humor into their presentations, including John Carmack. If you really feel this site needs more technical manuals, nobody will stop you. But if you think humor is less important than the debate about Italian vs French bread that is on the front page right now, then I wish you luck in your very dull life
- rhizome 10y agoRight, without you there would be zero humor on this site.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI abandoned an orthopedist last year because I felt that he was using hard-sell tactics on me to get me to agree to surgery for my broken ankle. Basically, he had a surgery slot open in a few days and it seemed like he wanted to book it, with increasing discounts (including exploding offers!) on the surgery as I kept demurring. He was a referral from the urgent care clinic that I went to immediately following the accident, and I think they recommended him solely because he was in the same doctor/hospital network (although he did not take my insurance!). So I spent several hours doing research on orthopedic surgeons and went to visit one of the best ones at the best hospital in the city (who also happened to be in-network). He looked at my X-rays and recommended against surgery, saying that the break wasn't that bad and that it would heal fine with just the cast I was already in! He was not as personable and a bit more robotic than the other guy who was giving off the salesman vibes, but I trusted him because of my research rather than the first doc who was essentially just some random referral through happenstance. A year has gone by now and I'm glad that I didn't get the surgery, because my ankle healed perfectly without it (the second doc was right). I would've been walking faster with the surgery, it's true, but I also would've had permanently implanted metal hardware (which can cause lifelong irritation issues), and which could have necessitated a second surgery for later removal. In hindsight I regret nothing, and of course not having the surgery was also much, much cheaper. So if that first doctor were to ask me why I'd leave him, I'd just say that it seemed like he was placing profits above the best interests of the patient, or, more charitably, that since he's a surgeon he thinks of surgery as the solution to every problem, even when it's not necessary.
- HillaryBriss 10y agomaybe it goes without saying, but you also avoided the infection risks which come with surgery.
- CydeWeys 10y agoYeah, and the risk of spontaneous anesthesia death (it's rare, but some people simply don't ever wake up). There's always plenty of reasons not to get surgery, and the only reason to get it is if the outcome for the injury is better, which it wasn't in this case! The default should be to not get surgery unless it has a clearly better expected outcome, whereas the orthopedist seemed to default to surgery for any injury.
- amelius 10y ago> "Why Did My Patient Leave Me?" I'm seriously wondering how many doctors will ask themselves this question, or even notice that their patient is gone.
- losteverything 10y agoI'd say in a bar to this author dr 1. Kittens die 2. You have a unique position to help people. 1. If you have ever cared for 4-7 week kittens then you know sometimes they just die. Don't be surprised when they do. They simply do. One moment they seem healthy and the next-they are gone. Your patients will not come back. They just won't. Don't be surprised when they don't come back. It happens. You will not know why. It's part of life like kittens dying. 2. You help people. You give them their life back. You are One of the few people who can make someone better. You improve. You prolong happiness. You give hope. It's often invisible to you. Yet it is real. It's real when your patients can travel, cook, walk, earn a living, hug grandchildren, breathe another breath. I can't do that. Most people can't do that. But you do. Every day. So who gives a ### that you don't know why the kitten left your practice. It never changed all the good you did and all the good you can and will do. So... Forget the kitten.
- waqf 10y agoYou are correct to forget this kitten, but that doesn't in any way mean you shouldn't research ways to stop kittens dying.
- JimXugle 10y agoIn my case it was because we weren't making progress towards turning a long list of symptoms into a diagnosis, compounded with some rather ill-informed and slightly offensive remarks about LGBT people and HIV/Aids.
- mhneu 10y agoOk, now this is just being obtuse. Parent post said single payer encourages checkups. You said "but there are still people that don't get checkups in Denmark". Those two points are completely orthogonal. Single payer encourages checkups, yes. Still some people won't get them, yes. Drop the sophistry.
- ThomPete 10y agoI said that in a system like that Danish which has single payer, that's not the case. I.e. the claim that single payer encourages that isn't true if you look at Denmark. Make of that what you want.
- dang 10y agoThis breaks the HN guidelines against being uncivil and calling names in arguments. Please don't do that, regardless of how wrong someone else is. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14120716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14120716 and marked it off-topic.
- bayouborne 10y agoThe author of this article is living in the some 'It's a Wonderful Life' twilight zone. Medical professionals now, generally speaking, don't care about you. Actually they care about you moderately for the time you are positioned directly in front of them, so if you've got an easily treatable malady there's hope for you. But if you are frightened and have an abdominal issue you know is not normal, then you're cast out into the Wilderness of Specialists who put you through a series of diagnostics and if these tests don't flash positive for something, you are on your own. Doctors don't care and are not your friend; a majority are goobs with no troubleshooting skills at all. They know to prescribe the blue powder for this condition, and the red powder for the other thing. They do not understand, nor do they care to. The Chinese physician of 600 years ago may well have served you better. Marcus Welby is dead; actually he's a fiction, he never was.
- bayouborne 10y agoIn my field when a customer has an environment with a problem, he or she files a ticket describing the problem to the best of their ability. Some of these customers are quite expert in accurately framing the issue, what they've done thus far, and they frequently provide addt'l information answering what would have been my next questions. Other customers are inexpert in stating the problem. Regardless of the customer's level of understanding of the issue, once we take a case (yes, we call them that) we understand it is our responsibility to resolve the issue. Doctors today are literally too busy to care. They never 'Hold the Paper' to the issue. It isn't enough for a patient to manage to have the proper insurance and reach out to a primary care physician; it's now incumbent on you to continually identify the specialist areas which may be germane to your issue and make the appointments and interpret the resulting data. You, are the integral component to saving your own life, as no doctor or other medical professional is there now to provide continuity, or put any of what's happening to you into context. I honestly think there is an opportunity for yet another layer to be inserted into American medicine - that of the patient's advocate, who is smart enough the carry the day, and who simply gives a shit.
- Ultramax 10y agoAs someone who deals with chronic joint pain, getting opiod pain relief right now is a fiasco. It is funny: prescribe pain relief, then act like I'm an addict? Give me a break. Who is selling the opiod epidemic story ad nauseum?
- propman 10y agoI have had severe chronic pain for many years as well. I use opioids but for a very short duration. It is a huge pain to get off them when you take them for a while. Max dosage of medical marijuana (cbd and indica not sativa) and synthetic opioids like tramadol not used daily works best for me. Current political climate is a no no to all opiates which is why it's so hard to get them now and it is awful for those with lots of pain, but doctors really did prescribe them too much.
- aladoc99 10y agoNot that the author of the linked piece will see this thread, but my experience has been that those patients who leave for personal reasons, as opposed to logistical reasons, e.g., changed insurance, moved away, etc. are usually not missed. My office staff will say, "We sent Ms. So-and-so's records over to Dr. Xyz" I'll say, "Gee, that's too bad." Almost invariably the reply comes back, "No, he can have her. She's impossible." (Of course, they're nice to me, but the office staff gets a more realistic picture.) So it tends to be that people who appreciate my style and personality hang around.