18 ms·
United Broke Its Contract with Flyers
- UhUhUhUh 10y agoLet's just note that giving the guy a 1st class ticket or even a private jet to his destination would have been less expensive. And could even have enhanced UA's image and business.
- ScottBurson 10y agoThey could just as easily have flown their employees to Louisville on a private jet. I have even seen it suggested that the employees could even have gone by taxi, though I don't know if that was really practical. Anyway, seems to me the best solution would have been to simply keep raising their offer for compensation until they got enough volunteers. Whatever they had to pay would have been far less than the $1.6B hit they took to their stock price. (I actually like Delta's solution the best: they ask you when you check in how much you would accept to get bumped. It's fair and efficient.)
- gt565k 10y agoI had a flight get delayed twice for a few hours and then a smaller plane arrived, so people had to get bumped. I waited for a bit and then talked to the Delta rep at the counter, explaining that I really needed to get to my destination soon as my friend was waiting to pick me up, and if they had a flight available in the coming hour or two, I'd volunteer to be bumped. Received a $400 voucher, and got placed in 1st class on a flight which departed 30 minutes after my delayed flight. It was a win-win. I pounded 3 heinekens and had a jolly time.
- jenamety 10y ago>I have even seen it suggested that the employees could even have gone by taxi, though I don't know if that was really practical. I have a feeling the contract with the Pilot and FA unions squashes that idea rather quickly.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> I have a feeling the contract with the Pilot and FA unions squashes that idea rather quickly. Correct, the pilot and FA unions would both have forbidden using a taxi to deadhead in this scenario. Source: friends who are flight attendants, and I've actually also gotten bitten myself by this rule personally (though obviously with far less serious consequences than this doctor).
- Eric_WVGG 10y agore: Delta's solution, last week my mother effectively got her summer vacation flight to NYC paid for this way.
- Alupis 10y agoWell, if we're comparing their stock price hit vs. paying for alternative transportation for the 4 employees; United could have sent all 4 employees to the ISS and back for far less[1] than the $1.6 billion market cap loss. [1] http://www.space.com/20897-nasa-russia-astronaut-launches-2017.html http://www.space.com/20897-nasa-russia-astronaut-launches-20...
- maxerickson 10y agoAn unrealized change in the stock price doesn't really mean anything. Especially over the short term.
- Alupis 10y ago> An unrealized change in the stock price doesn't really mean anything I think we all understood that already. It's merely comparing, and accentuating, the market cap loss vs. options that would have been less costly, even if those losses aren't "real". To that endeavor, putting these employees on a rocket ship, launching them into space, docking with the ISS, then finally returning sometime later... just for fun... all would have "hurt" less than trying to evict customers from their seats in this case.
- maxerickson 10y ago"hurt" That's just the point. A short term stock move doesn't hurt (or help) a company much at all.
- adwi 10y agoNot to belabor this, but I believe it's a valid point to illustrate the scale of the potential financial repercussions for United. The damage to their brand could in fact cost far more than the short term $1.6B change in market cap.
- leopoldo 10y agoI actually agree that it is what they should have done. OR at least go up to the $1,350 that the regulation stipulates. However I find it difficult to believe that the Airline (or the flight attendants manager) would have allowed a $5,000 compensation for the seat. Because they had no way of knowing how this was gonna unravel. / > Why the hell did you give this customer $5,000 for his seat, are you CRAZY? >> M'am, I just prevented the biggest PR shitstorm in our company's history > You're fired, and we'll make you pay those 5 grand / :)
- ScottBurson 10y agoBy the point where they were about to have an airport police officer beat the crap out of the passenger (which they did, BTW -- he suffered a concussion and two lost teeth!) it should have become clear that this wasn't going to go well. So once it was clear that Dao wasn't going to leave his seat voluntarily, they should have brought in a higher-up with the authority to offer more compensation to get another volunteer -- or simply pick another person to involuntarily deplane. (They could also have publicly threatened Dao with a civil lawsuit, figuring that even if that didn't change his mind, it would deter the next person they picked from doing the same thing he did.)
- differentView 10y agoSaw on TV news this morning, those weren't even real cops. They were private security hired by United. They were even told to stop wearing jackets that said "POLICE" months ago, but kept wearing them.
- joezydeco 10y agoThey were Chicago Department of Aviation police. They're hired by the City Aviation department and usually have police training, but are not allowed to arrest citizens or carry guns (although they have been asking). http://www.chicagomag.com/city-life/April-2017/3-Things-to-Know-About-the-Officers-in-the-United-Airlines-Fiasco/ http://www.chicagomag.com/city-life/April-2017/3-Things-to-K... tldr: They're rent-a-cops hired by the airport, not United.
- gshulegaard 10y ago> I actually like Delta's solution the best: they ask you when you check in how much you would accept to get bumped. It's fair and efficient. This is kind of like a recruiter asking you what your current and expected salary is. I wouldn't call it fair and it is only efficient for the airline which can then use that information to bump customers with the lowest thresholds, maximizing producer (the airline) surplus.
- svachalek 10y agoThe typical way to do it is to more or less hold an auction, increasing the offer until enough people take it. Either way the people with the lowest thresholds end up getting bumped. These are the people with the least urgency and/or most need so I don't really see what's unfair about it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Qworg 10y agoHold a reverse auction instead - start high and lower it until you get just enough takers.
- mistermann 10y agoWhy would you start high, that's going to maximize your cost not minimize.
- koenigdavidmj 10y agoBecause people are selfish and might volunteer to get 800 for themselves rather than let some other guy get 1200 (even if 1200 is the legal maximum).
- FabHK 10y agoNo, if you start low, people might basically implicitly "conspire" to keep their hands down, and when the first "breaks" the cartel at some high price, all hands will shoot up. Better to reverse auction until only 4 hands are left. It should end up cheaper (and fairer, incidentally, as it will closer to true preferences)
- ufmace 10y ago> they ask you when you check in how much you would accept to get bumped I don't like the sound of that much - how many people actually know or are prepared to think straight about how much money they would accept to get bumped when they're checking in? I'd rather the system be that, if they need to bump someone, they start with a public offer of a modest amount, then keep increasing it until either somebody accepts or it gets so high that it's cheaper to do something else.
- ghobs91 10y agoKeep in mind many people check in at home the day before. I flew recently and Delta offered me the option and I declined because I had to arrive at a certain time.
- michaelt 10y agoI agree that would be a fair system as everyone, even the bumped passengers, would leave happy under that arrangement. It would certainly work well if all the passengers were already on the plane, as they'd all be there to participate in the auction. However, if people were being bumped at check-in, or between check-in and boarding,
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ScottBurson 10y agoThe other advantage of Delta's system is efficiency. These auctions take time, delaying flights. Delta knows when they start boarding who is getting bumped.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> I have even seen it suggested that the employees could even have gone by taxi, though I don't know if that was really practical. It would have taken five hours. By itself, that's fine. But according to FAA rules, what is their status during those five hours? If they're on duty, they either need eight hours off duty once they get to Louisville, or they have a limited amount of time they can be on duty once they get there. (If that time doesn't count as on duty, of course, no problem.)
- dingaling 10y agoAs I understand it the transfer time would count as duty time because they were being moved from their report-to-work location, Chicago, to an alternative work location due to the crewing contingency. Incidentally they were actually from another airline, Trans States Airlines of Missouri, which also flies for United and American. So they were using their status as to-become-United Express crew to make must-ride space on a Republic Airways aircraft.
- JshWright 10y agoAmerican Airlines once put me in a cab from Baltimore to Philadelphia after my flight out of Baltimore got cancelled (and the only viable alternative flight was later that day in Philly). Chicago -> Louisville is a little further than Baltimore -> Philly, but it still seems manageable. The only question is, would the crew have been "on the clock" (counting against their hourly limits).
- yardie 10y agoThat depends on what on the clock means. My spouse used to work for an airline and they had various clocks. * 1000hour flight time clock which they couldn't exceed (cosmic radiation or something). * They had the flight clock which is how they were compensated ie. 14 hour LHR-HKG. * They had the break clock in flight. So crew could sleep 1-2 hours during a 12-18 hour flight. * Rapid response standby (15 minute) was a 12 hour standby shift in the terminal. Because the work times are so extreme cabin crew is given certain latitude in off time. Like, they may work 3 12-hour shifts and then take 3-4 days off. Everything I've read so far has not been clear about why the crew needed to be there on a flight that was already closed (when the last seat is filled the gate is closed). There were many better options, including driving, that were available. Unloading a passenger is a logistical nightmare and most ground crew are reluctant to do it. It messes up their performance metrics but in an airline like United maybe they just don't care.
- kelnos 10y agoI read somewhere (unverified) that they couldn't send the crew to their destination via taxi/limo due to union regs. Wasn't aware of that feature of Delta's check-in; that's actually really smart. I'd be in favor of a system where involuntary bumps are banned, and the airline just takes (cash) bids for people who might volunteer, and is required to take the N lowest bids. I'd be ok with something like allowing the compensation to be vouchers if the airline is willing to make the voucher amount 2x (or something) of the cash amount.
- an_account 10y agoAt some point someone can't get on the plane. If there was no maximum amount then people could game the system and get tens of thousands of dollars. Maybe the legal maximum should be higher though.
- AdamJacobMuller 10y ago> keep raising their offer for compensation That's backwards from a psychological point of view, that will entice people to hold out for a larger offer later. How they should handle it is very simple. Pick a very large number, lets say 10k, tell everyone on the plane to raise their hand if they're willing to get off the plane for 10k. Obviously a lot (probably way more than half) will raise their hands. Now, tell everyone "keep your hand up if you're willing to get off for 7500," rinse, repeat until you get to only four people with their hands up. I bet united could have gotten four passengers off that plane for LESS than the $800/each that they offered at the beginning, probably a LOT less and the four passengers would have been happy about it, too.
- FabHK 10y agoThat "just as easy" option with a private jet or Uber is an assumption. There a crew resting hour regulations that might have prevented the crew from operating the next flight had they driven, and union contracts that stipulate how deadheading crew can be transported. Again, all of those might be renegotiated at some point, but that doesn't mean there is an easy obvious alternative at hand now every time a pax refuses to deplane.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yourapostasy 10y agoThe ceiling on compensation to pax is $10,850, based upon a quick quote I got from executivejetmanagement.com for booking a 7 pax small jet in the next 3 hours, ORD-SDF. They quoted me a range $7,590 - $10,850, so this is the worst-case scenario. So UA's policy is possibly based upon a "stay below some non-market-related amount" internal goal versus recognizing that they were throwing away perfectly useful pricing signals every time they enacted these kinds of policies. If they reached $2712.50 per seat for those four deadheading crew members in the auction with no takers (highly unlikely), then that is not just signaling it is cheaper to charter a private jet, but also signals pricing information to inform their route planning and marketing teams. I see this all the time in business when helping clients implement their policies into software. There are often policies set for what amounts to someone with policy making power within the organization trying to game the metrics they are compensated by, and it ends up blinding the company to valuable market information that they then turn around to spend a minor fortune upon obtaining a very low-fidelity equivalent in lengthy, futile sales and marketing efforts.
- koenigdavidmj 10y agoUp until a week ago, four times the fare plus your hotel if necessary was sufficient remedy for this sort of event. It's a new thing for grown adults to throw temper tantrums and then get nearly-universal public support for their cause. It's only now that companies need to be proactive in knowing how to handle this of all things.
- tigershark 10y agoAh ok. So let's say that you are getting married the next morning and you are removed from a flight that you boarded (that is illegal and in breach of the contract). I guess that you'll be happy to miss your wedding for 4 times the fare and a night in the hotel. As far as I remember this is the first time that I've seen such an abuse, with a company removing a boarded passenger on a whim. But apparently you can always find people that are ready to justify such abuses. I'd be curious to hear your opinion in case the hypothetical scenario that I presented happened to you.
- koenigdavidmj 10y agoFlights get canceled entirely for much more mundane reasons, such as storms or maintenance issues. If you truly need to be somewhere tomorrow, you need to plan for those cases, which are quite a bit more frequent than this one. As for your scenario, ask for a volunteer to get bumped instead, and incentivize them as necessary.
- s73ver 10y agoWhy should I have to do the airlines work for them?
- tigershark 10y agoAh so now it's up to the passenger to solve the problem for united finding a volunteer. I propose also that you should give them your a*se in case they ask for it. As for the cancellation if instead of the wedding there was a funeral you would ask the deceased to schedule better his own death I guess. It's really astonishing how there are people perfectly willing to give away all their rights while thanking for it with a smile.
- mbesto 10y agoExcept it's not. You've just set a precedent that would invariably become way more expensive in aggregate.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mkhpalm 10y agoLets also not forget to note that United's way of handling the situation after it went viral was to dig up dirt and defame Dao. I couldn't believe what I was hearing regarding unrelated personal past issues Dao had that were suddenly being broadcast by main stream media.
- bostonpete 10y agoThe article isn't claiming that united broke its contract with frequent flyers -- it's discussing the contract included in every ticket. The Bloomberg (and therefore HN) title got this wrong.
- dang 10y agoGood point. s/Frequent//.
- mvpu 10y agoIn the social era airlines (or any company for that matter) shouldn't be worried about breaching or keeping their contracts on paper... they should be worried about 1-click brand damage from a frustrated customer screaming on Twitter or Facebook. Social media is unforgiving, customer experience is everything.
- cortesoft 10y agoYou say social media is unforgiving, but is it really? In the short term, sure, but you think this will have a lasting impact on United? Social media is fickle, if nothing else. It will move on to something else soon enough, and completely forget about this incident.
- maxerickson 10y agoThey've said they aren't going to call police just to remove passengers anymore. I bet they stick with that for quite some time.
- Chaebixi 10y agoYeah. Maybe people will forget about the incident soon if nothing happens, but they're now primed to think United is even scummier if it ever does something similar in the foreseeable future.
- mvpu 10y agoSocial media is more than fickle.. it amplifies the breadth (spreads to lots of people fast) and depth (make it look worse) of incidents. Millions of people have now seen that brutal United video, and remembered that it's all United's fault. Tomorrow when there's another United incident, albeit minor, regular and social media will amplify it - one more hit for the consumer. Each incident in isolation will be forgotten, but the bad taste remains. Look at what's happening with Uber, Bill Oreilly, etc.
- component 10y ago[1] Pepsi: That was the biggest PR blunder of the week, year maybe. United: Hold my beer. Sean Spicer: LEEEEEEEEEERROOOOOOOY JEEEENNNNNNKINS! Fickle indeed. Hopefully United learns from this incident, tho I think it's unlikely There's also an episode of It's Always sunny in Philadelphia (S12E04) where they talk about the 24 hour news cycle - which pretty much sums up social media unforgiving nature [1] https://mobile.twitter.com/lance_bradley/status/851864862426890240 https://mobile.twitter.com/lance_bradley/status/851864862426...
- jnwatson 10y agoThe biggest issue was that United made clear that the implicit agreement between itself and its customers is void. Their policies and procedures reflect a certain attitude that many potential fliers didn't realize were part of the deal. And there's no walking that back.
- 13of40 10y ago> no walking that back I don't think it's as dire as you make it sound. The reason is that the real implicit agreement most of us have with our society is that everyone is as helpful and congenial as possible as long as it keeps the wheels turning. Once you run afoul of the airline, or the sheriff, or the HR department, you can be stomped down in the blink of an eye, and even if you successfully challenge it legally, at the end of the day you've still lost some amount of money, time, or health fighting it. Someone in that mindset is going to look at their Expedia search and still sort by price, because they realize that every airline is playing the same game, and the one in a million chance of being forcibly removed from the plane over a technicality is just one of those gambles that everyone takes whenever they step outside their house. (That said, if I sort by price and Delta and United come up the same, I'm picking Delta.)
- hartator 10y ago> (That said, if I sort by price and Delta and United come up the same, I'm picking Delta.) Except that the Delta will probably just be the United sold via Delta!
- mcv 10y agoIs that possible? That you actively try to avoid United and still end up in a United plane?
- jdeibele 10y agoIf you're not paying attention, yes. I checked flights on Kayak from SF to Vancouver and a lot of the results look like this: Tue, May 2 Air Canada logo 10:45a – 1:01p Air Canada• Operated by United 2h 16m SFO – YVR nonstop Flight details That's because United and Air Canada "codeshare", meaning you can book with United or Air Canada but that flight is on a United plane. Of course, it goes the other way: you can book an Air Canada plane but use a United flight number. https://www.united.com/CMS/en-US/Marketing/CustComm/Promotions/Pages/AirlinePartners.aspx https://www.united.com/CMS/en-US/Marketing/CustComm/Promotio... https://www.kayak.com/flights/SFO-YVR/2017-05-02/2017-05-07?fs=specificleg=SFOYVR1493719200000AC51151;providers=-AA https://www.kayak.com/flights/SFO-YVR/2017-05-02/2017-05-07?...
- ghaff 10y agoSo many armchair lawyers who have suddenly become so expert in the fine print of contracts of carriage. Yes, United should have done anything reasonable to get a volunteer to get out of their seat and leave the flight. But this fine parsing around when an airline is allowed to deplane someone is pretty silly. What if the captain determined that he needed to take some weight off the flight? Would the airline be allowed to involuntarily deplane someone in that case? And guess what. I have been bumped off a flight after I was sitting down for unknown reasons. (It was quite a while ago.) And I managed to avoid getting into a tussle with airport security over it.
- pm90 10y agoWhile you complied and everything worked out for you, it doesn't mean that everyone should do the same. I just don't understand this line of reasoning at all. Yes, its well within their legal rights to request a passenger to deplane, but if he refuses, while they do have the right to forcibly deplane the person, they would have done much better if they had found alternatives.
- ghaff 10y agoAs I said "United should have done anything reasonable to get a volunteer to get out of their seat and leave the flight." However, once the flight crew directly asked him to leave, they had three choices. What they did, sit at the gate until he changes his mind, or cancel the flight. If I'm flight crew and there's someone on board who is not following crew instructions, I'm not flying with them on board.
- mnm1 10y ago"There’s nothing illegal about breaching a contract." No there isn't. But there is something illegal about lying to police, filing false police reports, and using such false pretenses to assault and batter someone by proxy. There is no question United did this, it's illegal, and it's criminal. They should be charged by the prosecutor as should the cops who did the actual beating. They are equally responsible as United. The police failed to investigate and beat up an innocent person because of their failure to understand the situation. They should lose their jobs and pensions; ideally they should go to jail.
- cortesoft 10y agoWait, how did they file a false police report? Even if they are breaking the contract, they are allowed to ask the passenger to leave the plane (as the article points out). Once he refuses to leave, he is trespassing (again, doesn't matter that the airline broke its contract by asking him to leave). The airline called the cops and asked them to remove the passenger. Where did they lie or file a false police report?
- mnm1 10y agoBy saying or implying it is within their rights to remove the passenger when it clearly wasn't.
- jdoliner 10y agoThey are within their rights to remove the passenger though, it's just a breach of contract to do so. But they are within their rights to breach the contract, it just gives the other party the right to recoup damages.
- cortesoft 10y agoWhat makes you think it ISN'T within their rights to remove the passenger? The plane is their property, they can ask someone to leave (even if they previously allowed them in). What law did they break? As the article says, they broke the contract, but that is a completely separate issue from being able to ask someone to leave.
- slapshot 10y ago[Deleted]
- ghaff 10y agoIf this hadn't hit social media, I'd be willing to bet good money that he'd have been arrested and facing felony charges.
- TillE 10y agoFunny how cops and corporations have difficulty lying and/or abusing their power when there's video evidence, huh?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nebabyte 10y agoGood thing we're laying the groundwork for "controlled information", such as not recording your experiences to play back for others (say, if it involves a police officer [or 'voting officials' at voting booths, as we tell them they're called - snort snort guffaw]) or being able to share things that happen to you under an NDA or gag order Phew!
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y ago>The only person who should go to jail is the person who thought he was so much more important than everyone else on his plane that he was the only one who refused to leave when asked, legally, by a police officer. Not only did he think he was more important than everyone on HIS plane, he thought he was more important than the people on the plane that was going to get cancelled because it didn't have a flight crew. Running back onto a plane, screaming, after being removed by law enforcement is a crime. He should go to jail. This is such a crazy level of corporate apology that it's got to be sarcastic. United was not in the right to remove him. He stood up to that. If United really wanted to make room they should go for the market-based solution of just continuing to increase the price they were willing to pay for you to vacate your seat.
- in_cahoots 10y agoCouldn't United claim that there were four fewer 'available seats' than normal on this flight and thus it was oversold? It doesn't resolve the question of whether he was denied boarding or involuntarily removed but it does seem to be a reasonable interpretation of the first part of the contract.
- jeltz 10y agoMaybe they could, but it seems like a weak argument to me given that they let everyone get seated.
- ubernostrum 10y agoUnited's contract of carriage appears not to be super clear on when such a situation is in effect, or what they consider to be "denied boarding". Which means this one's going to need a court to sort it out, though I believe the general principle, when the terms are ambiguous or have multiple interpretations, is to prefer the interpretation least favorable to the side that wrote the contract.
- pasbesoin 10y agoOk, here it is, basically, as I heard it in some reasoned reporting the other day: The contract allows them to reschedule you. Period. You can be at the gate -- or even boarded -- with your "normal" fare, and a passenger can show up and pay full fare -- say a grand or two versus your $200 ticket. It's economically advantageous for the airline to bump you and give your seat to the last-minute, full fare passenger. Even after comping you say $400 (and that's often in their script, not in actually, fungible dollars) for your inconvenience. And, per the report, they will! Big surprise. In short (in my words), you don't really have a ride until the plane is in the air. If you think this is "unfair", might I suggest... gasp, some regulation?
- tyingq 10y agoIt's not that simple, as is usually the case when law and contracts are involved. I suspect this will take some actual legal proceeding for there to be broad agreement. Things that make it complex: - Airlines are "common carriers". So they are subject to laws above and beyond a mom-and-pop restaurant on issues like refusal of service. - They publish a "contract of carriage". - Overbooking didn't happen, so those laws don't offer any protection - They can't have multiple meanings of the term "boarded" and switch meanings to use it to their advantage depending on the sitation. Denied boarding has to happen before boarding. - The door wasn't shut, and the passenger did not assault or intimidate the crew. So "interfering with a flight crew" isn't on the table.
- pasbesoin 10y agoWell, then, looks like I have to pay attention to this again and update my understanding. At the same time, this sounds like... regulation! Some form of restriction on how the terms may be interpreted and executed. I am not entirely happy with the situation. I want to know that when I purchase a ticket to go somewhere, I'm going -- absent equipment failure or some act of God. (Or, the occasional drunken pilot...) But, it is what it is. And I get a bit tired of all the outcry when much of such is basically coming from the people who made it this way -- through the governments they've voted for, or not voted for, as the case may be.
- vivekd 10y agoThis is one of the cases in law where everyone wants to argue about the contract but no one wants to sit down and read the thing. Here contract of carriage https://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/contract-of-carriage.aspx#sec25 https://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/contract-of-carriag... We can read the definitions section of the contract where it defines oversold >Oversold Flight means a flight where there are more Passengers holding valid confirmed Tickets that check-in for the flight within the prescribed check-in time than there are available seats. So does this apply to this case - yes, even though this individual was removed to accommodate UA employees the fact was there were more passengers holding valid tickets than there were available seats Now scroll down to Rule 25 which gives the provisions for what would happen in the case of oversold flights - one of which allows for involuntarily denying passengers >Boarding Priorities - If a flight is Oversold, no one may be denied boarding against his/her will until UA or other carrier personnel first ask for volunteers who will give up their reservations willingly in exchange for compensation as determined by UA. If there are not enough volunteers, other Passengers may be denied boarding involuntarily in accordance with UA’s boarding priority The article may have one valid argument - that the language of the contract says "boarding" not "leaving once already seated" but I don't know how much of a difference that would make in legal terms. Is there really a world of difference between not being let on the plane and being asked to leave once you've taken your seat. I don't think there is. It's possible that you might get this in front of a sympathetic jury and get an award. But as a lawyer, under the law it's pretty clear that United did not breach any contract. And This remains true no matter what talking heads on TV are saying.
- tyingq 10y agoThe counter argument would be that the Dr Dao incident was "refusal of transport": https://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/contract-of-carriage.aspx#sec21 https://www.united.com/web/en-US/content/contract-of-carriag... because no oversell happened. You'll see none of the reasons to invoke rule 21 are valid in this case. Or, you can argue that laws and regulations outside of the contract of carriage apply. I don't think this is a case where just the United contract of carriage settles it. There are actual aviation lawyers saying things like "this is very gray".
- nebabyte 10y agoTitle just gave me an epiphany. Could members of that flight sue as a class for trauma/emotional distress?
- CamperBob2 10y agoThey certainly can. That will be why everyone on the aircraft has been issued a refund.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mankash666 10y agoWhere's the fine print on "excessive force"? The officer(s) involved in manhandling Dr. Dao need to be brought to justice as well!
- danderino 10y agoHow was he manhandled? They used enough force to pull him out of the seat and stopped.
- jtrtoo 10y agoI have a idea. Well, several. 1. Let's stop overbooking in the airline industry. The seats are already prepaid for. Who cares if a passenger shows or not? (It'd be different if they were losing revenue when a passenger doesn't show up; they aren't). 2. Let's take responsibility (the airline) if we fuck up (or an act of gawd enables) a situation where our own staff can't get where to a destination they need to be in per our own scheduling. This means we don't bump customers involuntarily for our fuck-up. If not enough paying customers volunteer so be it: We'll eat the impact of our fuck-up of not properly planning how to get our own staff from point B to point B (whether that means finding an alternative for them to get there, delaying some other flight, whatever). The crux is this entire situation seems to be four distinct matters: - Overbooking (unnecessary) - Staff logistics (contingency plans, accepting consequences) - Involuntary bumping (goes away with addressing the former two matters) - Security / policing efforts for matters that aren't being handled amicably in the moment by a disagreeing party (standard police matter I presume, which has a body of knowledge and skill associated with it which may have been lacking here or needs to be adopted to plane boarding situations)
- cgag 10y agoI might be ok with overbooking if they got rid of involuntary bumping and had to auction off being bumped until someone accepted the price.
- adamson 10y agoImagine the game theory analyses on frequent flyer sites
- markdown 10y agohttp://www.cbsnews.com/news/delta-offer-10000-to-flyers-give-up-seats/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/delta-offer-10000-to-flyers-give...
- fshaun 10y agoI don't think introducing an unbounded liability is the solution to this (or perhaps any) problem. Would this work for 99% of flights? Sure. But it's just asking to be gamed.
- wnevets 10y ago>The contract allows the airline to deny boarding involuntarily in case of overbooking. But that’s not what happened; the airplane wasn’t oversold. And Dao wasn’t denied boarding. Every article about this story needs to repeat this line.
- zdean 10y agoThe article also goes on to say (in essence) that even if you assume that United was in the wrong on this point, it constitutes a breach of contract on United's part. At that point, Dao is free to sue for breach of contract...but United is free to ask him to leave. I'm not justifying United's actions (or that of the police)...just saying that Dao unfortunately probably wouldn't have a legal argument against being asked to leave.
- gyc 10y agoI don't think that is true. If you had a valid lease with a landlord for your apartment, your landlord can't just kick you out of your apartment before the end of the lease if you haven't violated any of the contractual terms of the lease.
- aidenn0 10y agoWe have renter protection laws because people used to do just that.
- greensoap 10y agoThat is because tenancy has a depth of laws surrounding them. The only way to kick a tenant out of his house if with an order from the Court and action by the sheriff (at least in most states). But your right to stay on the property of another person, outside of tenancy arrangements, do not have that body of law.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- williamle8300 10y agoLet's also remember that David Dao was physically assaulted, which is a separate matter and that cop should be charged for the crime of using excessive force.
- danderino 10y agoHow was he physically assaulted? He was told he'd be removed forcefully and the man said he didn't care. He was removed forcefully with adequate force.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoyou can find the answer to your question here: https://www.google.com/search?q=united+dao https://www.google.com/search?q=united+dao
- danderino 10y agoI seen the video. They literally just pull him from his seat. I don't know how else you would forcibly remove someone whose resisting getting out of their seat.
- maym86 10y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/assault https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/assault
- danderino 10y agoOh cmon. Going by literal definitions, an officer tackling a man out of the way of a bus would technically be a "physical assault". But if your headline was "Officer physically assaults man", people are going to have a much different impression. Tell me whats wrong with pulling a man out of his seat when you are ordered to remove someone from a seat and that person refuses to leave peacefully.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoThere is a bill in the works with a simple rule: you cannot remove seated passengers for non-safety reasons [1]. If you care about this issue, please call your U.S. Senators and ask them to prioritize it. [1] http://thehill.com/policy/transportation/328497-dem-plans-bill-to-prohibit-airlines-from-forcibly-removing-passengers http://thehill.com/policy/transportation/328497-dem-plans-bi...
- kelnos 10y agoI don't think this is necessary, or even desired. United's Contract of Carriage specifies conditions for removing someone from a plane (all of which I think are reasonable). If they violated that contract (which it seems they have), then they're legally liable, and Dao (and the other three passengers) have grounds to sue. That's how it's supposed to work, and I think that's sufficient. Successful suits (or out of court settlements) and negative PR will make it unpalatable for airlines to do this as a matter of habit.
- hugodahl 10y agoAm I the only one who interpreted the title as breaking a contract with the Philadelphia Flyers hockey team?
- rurban 10y agoIt's stronger than just "Broke Its Contract with Flyers". United explicitly broke FAA rules, in both incidents in the last week. Both were already seated, when someone more important to them arrived (too late). Both of them violated not any of the FAA rules by denying to leave the plane or change seats.
- stuaxo 10y agoAh, the old implicit contract of don't beat your customers.