6 ms·
>The guy poured his heart and soul into the project and was vested way beyond a paycheck, yet he was literally replaced like a cog the minute a spreadsheet call
by BeetleB 10y ago
>The guy poured his heart and soul into the project and was vested way beyond a paycheck, yet he was literally replaced like a cog the minute a spreadsheet called for it.
This is one reason why "follow your passion" is a bad career strategy.
It's not unique to this industry. Look at all the folks who get PhDs and waste their 30's doing low paid postdocs ($50K is higher end).
- radarsat1 10y agoAm in my 30s doing a postdoc getting paid $50K. Can confirm. ;) That said, I do enjoy doing research. It's frustrating working with researchers sometimes though. :P Sure, everyone push to master without testing, no problem! I'll just spend my afternoon making things compile again..
- inetknght 10y agoJust create a new branch in git, call it 'production', and... literally throw piles of shit at people who push to that branch. Then they'll get the hint. /s
- radarsat1 10y agoLol.. just venting ;) But thanks, I take your point. And actually good idea regarding the production branch, I might just do that.
- philipov 10y agoI don't know if it's the git way or not, but I learned with subversion, so I treat master as unstable and make a new maintenance branch for each release. So what I'm saying is: more than just one production branch. That way you can test the next release on its own branch without freezing trunk and without affecting the current production branch (suppose you want to roll back to the previous release?)
- Muuuchem 10y agoJust wondering but why are you still in a postdoc position? My previous field was Medicinal Chemistry and had I continued with my Ph.D, I would have gotten it by 26/27. Post docs are usually for 2 years in Med Chem I believe.
- quantum_magpie 10y agoWell, you can look at age timeline: Start school at 7; Start university at 19; Start PhD at 25 [4-year bachelors + 2-year masters] if you can do that immediately after masters, or 26; Finish PhD at 28, or 29 (if it's a 3-year PhD, otherwise older); Finish first post-doc at 31, second one at 33/34. By mid-30s you are just starting your tenure-track (assuming you get some semi-permanent position at a university or research institute) I'm currently doing a PhD [quantum chemistry] and this is basically my expectation for the future.
- branchless 10y agoIs it a waste? Our system does not map monetary reward to value created. Better to assume someone not making big money is doing something worthwhile. If salary were a function of social value added why is the Pepsi CEO so well paid? So many industries just appropriate wealth from real work. If people don't yield to the flawed system I say hats off to them.
- BeetleB 10y ago>Is it a waste? It's up to them to decide. I, for one, have seen far too many people go the route of academia, stick to it, and then regret it because they either didn't get a tenure track position, or because they were so old when they got one. It depends on the discipline. Engineering/CS is soft on academics. When I was doing my PhD, it was not unusual for a graduate to get a TT position without doing a postdoc. But if you're in the sciences or math: Good luck. You are responsible for taking care of your needs. If all you care about is research, and not enough money to pay for your kids' college (the situation of a number of career post docs I know), then I'm the last one to tell you to reconsider.
- branchless 10y agoWhere does it end? Your kids get their college money so they can do what? Do a phd? Throw their interests in the bin in the name of consumerism and so their kids can ... what? This is why a system that fails to associate value added with reward gained is so utterly damaging.
- specialist 10y agoPassion is fine. Whatever works for you. I'd advise against making someone else rich, at your own expense. Been there, been done like that.
- BatFastard 10y agoSo you are saying get rid of SV? Greed and desire for the pot of gold are illusions.
- BeetleB 10y agoHaving a passion is fine. Following your passion is fine. Complaining about low pay because you are following your passion is not. If they're complaining, they care about more than their passions, and they (not their employers) are responsible for satisfying their needs. You can get lucky and follow your passion as well as take care of material needs, but those are the exceptions. Not the norm.
- justicezyx 10y agoNo, passion and money usually aligned. That's the whole undernote of any startup pitch. If there were not aligned, then we should strive to change the market and society to make them align. Without a proper incentive mechanism, no innovation can be done optimally.
- BeetleB 10y ago>No, passion and money usually aligned. That's the whole undernote of any startup pitch. I would beg to differ. The aligned ones are the exceptions. Unless your passion is to make money, that is. The whole point is that if your passion is something other than to get rich, you are more inclined than the average person to take lower pay to pursue your passions. "Wow, it's awesome employer X is willing to pay me to do passion Y. I never thought I could make a living doing this!" "Those who use their skills to do boring work (code/CAD monkey) to make more money are sellouts!" Most startups are in it for the money. As pg himself wrote: It's not at all unusual in the early phases for a startup to completely change direction because they didn't find a market for their "passion". The goal is to get rich, not to solve business problem Z. >Without a proper incentive mechanism, no innovation can be done optimally. I agree with the caveat that the incentive need not be "get rich". Making a lot of money often lowers innovation by constraining it.
- sleepybrett 10y agoThere is, in fact, a ton of money in boring ass software.
- mungoid 10y agoThere is, but the problem with that is people get drained doing boring software over and over for years. No passion, no motivation, etc. Believe it or not, most people dont care about making a ton of money. Making a good income doing something you enjoy is worth more than making 3x that income doing something that makes you feel bored and crappy all the time.
- s73ver 10y agoYeah, but usually, that 3x income also comes with normal, 9-5 working hours. So you slog through the day, and have plenty of time to do the passion stuff at home. Plus, if we're talking about games, you have the money to pay people for quality art, sound, etc. So when you are ready to make that step, you can really give it some polish.
- EthanHeilman 10y agoThe problem with the above story is that the engineer lost all connection to the project. It would be like allowing an artist to finish a painting 90% and then firing the artist and giving the painting to someone else. It is heartbreaking to hear. Those are years of someones life. > Look at all the folks who get PhDs and waste their 30's doing low paid postdocs ($50K is higher end). Research is different. You are certainly losing out on income, however in my experience you have an immense amount of ownership and autonomy over the project. If you get the boot you can take your project with you. You can publish your code as free software or open source and your papers on open access pre-print services. Academic researchers are often far less alienated from their labor than video game engineers. Consider two orthogonal vectors: one is income earned and the other is your accomplishments. Ideally you want to maximize both, but failing that different people express different priorities over which one to maximize in a career.
- BeetleB 10y ago>The problem with the above story is that the engineer lost all connection to the project. It would be like allowing an artist to finish a painting 90% and then firing the artist and giving the painting to someone else. It's heartbreaking to hear. It's heartbreaking the first time I hear it. After the 100th time, the sentiment transforms to "Why did you allow yourself in this predicament?" And the answer is always "Passion". This story has been repeated over and over for the last 15 years. You can take this exact story to aspiring game developers and they'll say "I don't care. It's not about the money. I just want to make games. Even if I play a small role in the project I'll be satisfied" >You are certainly losing out on income, however in my experience have an immense amount of ownership and autonomy over the project. Many postdocs don't. They do the bidding of some faculty member. Many faculty members don't. Sure, on paper they do. But they'll all tell you about the work they cannot pursue because they can't get grant money for it. >If you get the boot you can take your project with you. Not true for some postdoc work. >You can publish code as free software or open source and your papers on open access pre-print services. Not true as a post doc. My advisor certainly forbade it. >Consider two orthogonal vectors: one is income earned and the other is your accomplishments. Ideally you want to maximize both, but failing that, different personalities often express different priorities over which one to maximize in a career. I completely agree with this, which is why I'm not sympathetic to the game developer, or with postdocs who regret spending so long in academia. They picked their priorities - it was not imposed on to them. And for many, later in their life, they feel they picked the "wrong" priorities.
- infinite8s 10y agoNot only your 30's, you also waste your 20's getting the PhD (which if you are lucky pays only slightly less than a postdoc). Two decades of lost opportunity costs really adds up.
- BeetleB 10y agoAs others have said, it's a personal judgment call. I wasted my 20's that way, and have no regrets. The PhD did not help my career one iota. But the journey was worth it, and I accept the price I paid (which is entering the job market a little older, and thus retiring a little older). If someone wants to keep that up with postdocs, more power to them. I just observe that there are a lot more postdocs who regret their journey than those who stopped at PhD.