11 ms·
Material Design Color Tool
- julius_set 10y agoImo Googles new material design is not impressive. It does however help developers who are not good designers build a cookie cutter app.
- blowski 10y agoAnd it makes much of the internet look like it belongs to Google.
- nsebban 10y agoNot sure why your comment gets downvoted. It's a fair point, especially since non-geek people don't have a clue who produces the apps they have installed on their smartphone.
- Dylan16807 10y ago> non-geek people don't have a clue who produces the apps Funny, that sounds to me like a counterargument to the idea that this makes things look like they come from google.
- infogulch 10y agoIn general people don't have a clue, but they obviously know the source of some Google apps like Gmail and search. But then they associate all apps with that design pattern with Google, since they do know Google apps.
- MikeAMartinez 10y agoI think this is the ultimate goal from Google's perspective at least
- Griffinsauce 10y agoThat's a very cynical view. I think their ultimate goal is getting nice looking and functioning apps on their platform. Material is an Interaction Design play first, a design play second and maaaaybe a branding play third but whatever. If it makes apps and the web a better place because every Joe Schmoe dev can focus on functionality instead of design (which a lot of people simply suck at) that's great.
- andrewingram 10y agoBut also not strictly on their platform. There's top-down "encouragement" from management to use Material Design in all their iOS apps too, which isn't really being a good citizen of the platform.
- blowski 10y agoI'm not convinced it's their ultimate goal, or even one of their goals at all, since poor implementations could water down their branding. But it is definitely a side effect.
- ehnto 10y agoIt's most impressive trait is that it is a holistic approach to UI and design. There aren't many "systems" out there for that. However I agree, there isn't much new and impressive in it and the evangelistic design chatter it created, much like the Flat Design trend, gets very stale and can stifle good conversation on the topic.
- Griffinsauce 10y agoWhat's sad is that people see it as an endpoint. While the thing is obviously meant to be a starting point, a baseline of "good design" that you can expand on if you wish, or stick to if you have better things to do. It moves the baseline from zero design to "good" .
- ehnto 10y agoWhich was the great thing about flat design too. It brought basic good design principles to the discussion. Whether you liked the asthetic or not, the core guiding principles were the real win. I feel like the creators of the Material Design site simply sought to formalize those principles and build upon them, which I think they have done a good job of.
- cyberferret 10y agoYou can look at it in much the same way that the early versions of Windows enabled programmers to build applications that looked exactly alike. In much the same vein, Material's "paper" concepts are designed to minimise confusion for lay users - i.e. "What does clicking the '+' button do?". Once you standardise the symbols and appearance of certain widgets, it removes the "have to think about it" barrier. You could argue that EVERYONE who uses a Windows computer knows what the [x] on the top right corner of every window does. And like Windows, I think you will eventually see developers modify and extend Material to make applications stand apart from each other while maintaining some sort of consistency of the UI. But like windows, you will eventually get to the stage that developers corrupt simple things like checkboxes to operate in non logical ways (e.g. as radio buttons), or you end up with a screen where every conceivable square millimetre of the window is a 'hot point' that does something when you touch/click on it! (I/m looking at you Excel etc.)
- Illniyar 10y agoWell, frankly there are tons of apps where I have no idea what the + button do until I click it. Many times, it's not what I would think it would do.
- Larrikin 10y agoHow down the button and it'll say what it does.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoAs someone who helps seniors use their computers, if Material is designed to minimize confusion for lay users, Material is a complete failure. I once tried to help someone through the new Material Google Contacts app, and eventually gave up and sent them back to Comcast.net. Simple is not necessarily better when making UI. A '+' symbol will always be worse than 'Add contact'.
- duiker101 10y agoI don't think it's as much a design for designers but a design for users. It's a guideline that all apps can follow so that the user doesn't have to relearn every single app and is more likely to know where to find stuff. As far as aesthetics go it's not the greatest yes, but it doesn't have to be. Having a good looking foundation on which to base your app is great. If you really want it can always be innovated. There's plenty of nice changes you can find in different apps and it's always evolving.
- maaaats 10y agoAs a user it's super un-intuitive, though. At least how gmail, calendar, maps and other google apps are on Android at the moment. I mostly click and pray.
- DanBC 10y agoIt's interesting that lots of people on HN say the same thing: I don't know how to perform an action; there are no affordances in the UI. But Google is a data driven company and they must, surely, have scads of data on this. They must know what their users are trying to do and how they're trying to do it, so why are Google interfaces so hard to use?
- stuaxo 10y agoThey can't get data on what goes through peoples heads before clicking an action, only if it was clicked or not.
- welcomebrand 10y agoThey still use their mighty data to show me ads for things I've literally just bought, I do sometimes wonder if all data is even.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoAs a tech enthusiast, I occasionally get surveys to possibly sign up to try out a new version of a Google UI. I've never actually done it because the time windows don't usually work out, but signing up for these user studies is definitely something I ended up in by being in the tech crowd. But I also have done a lot of tech support for senior citizens, who don't have the innate ability to stumble through bad UI like a lot of us millenial-types do. I feel like Google is talking to the wrong people. I suspect that if Google UI designers spent some time in senior citizen communities watching people use their email, almost everything about how Google designs web pages would be thrown away.
- sangnoir 10y ago> Imo Googles new material design is not impressive. Agreed. I will add that I have seen some impressive designs that used the material design framework.
- weego 10y agoThis is the thing. You need to invest not only in completely understanding how every aspect of material design works, you also have to understand that visual languages enforce strong opinion and aren't an expression of creative freedom. So if you understand it well enough and if you have enough weight to ensure what you are designing fits into it then it might work for you and your users. It seems to mostly be used like bootstrap thought and ends up being tedious and inconsistent. The worst kind of inconsistent as well, the one where you are mislead by familiarity that then doesn't turn out to be real.
- colmvp 10y agoI think what's interesting is they canonized the bottom navigation (https://material.io/guidelines/components/bottom-navigation.html https://material.io/guidelines/components/bottom-navigation....), a notable move given that many popular Android apps have historically opted to design the navigation of their app around the navigation drawer(https://material.io/guidelines/patterns/navigation-drawer.html https://material.io/guidelines/patterns/navigation-drawer.ht...), a philosophy that made the Android platform UI a bit distinct from iOS. Personally, I find a bottom navigation of primary functionality to be far more pleasing than having to tap twice. For example, on iOS Spotify was quite arduous to navigate when they tried simplifying the aesthetic by having all the navigation within side menus. Their later re-design to move content back into the bottom navigation was met with a lot of praise amongst users.
- mhd 10y agoI think that's the main issue: We're talking about"apps" here, where a unified HCI guide always was an important goal. Material design is basically using the Android's platform's UI in the browser. This application POV clashes with "web pages" being more a domain of print designers gone digital. Tschichold or Tognazzini...
- crashdown 10y agoI'm surprised it took them so long to do this. Someone else made one ages ago at https://www.materialpalette.com/ https://www.materialpalette.com/
- kensai 10y agoYes, but this is Google. Now it matters. You know when it will matter even more? When Apple does the same. And even more more?! When Elon does it! :D
- duiker101 10y agoUhm interesting. Seems like a good tool but either I'm using it wrong or it's very weird that it doesn't seem to provide an option for the accent color. here's some other similar tools that I collected over time https://www.sankk.in/material-mixer/ https://www.sankk.in/material-mixer/ http://flatuicolors.com http://flatuicolors.com https://www.materialpalette.com https://www.materialpalette.com
- jasonlfunk 10y agoI figured it out. You have to click the 'Primary', 'Secondary' boxes in the bottom right.
- duiker101 10y agoWow i totally missed that, thanks for pointing it out!
- zserge 10y agoShameless plug: http://0xrgb.com http://0xrgb.com (similar to flatuicolors, which was using Flash by that time), 0xrgb also includes ios, tango, solarized and material color schemes.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ecesena 10y agoDirect url: https://material.io/color/ https://material.io/color/
- jt2190 10y agoThis could also stand a title change. Should be: New Google tool helps developers make best use of color in Material Design.
- sctb 10y agoThanks, a moderator updated the submission link to this from https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/06/new-google-tool-helps-developers-pick-the-right-colors-for-their-apps/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/06/new-google-tool-helps-deve..., which didn't seem to add to the original site.
- foldr 10y ago"And the wheel," said the Captain, "What about this wheel thingy? It sounds a terribly interesting project." "Ah," said the marketing girl, "Well, we're having a little difficulty there." "Difficulty?" exclaimed Ford. "Difficulty? What do you mean, difficulty? It's the single simplest machine in the entire Universe!" The marketing girl soured him with a look. "Alright, Mr. Wiseguy," she said, "if you're so clever, you tell us what colour it should be."
- jacquesm 10y agoHHGTTG. Excellent reference, if you're going to spend time on picking the 'right' colors rather than just any set of half decent colors and then move on you might miss out on that important little thing called functionality without which it really doesn't matter what color it will be. Once you're established and you're tuning the last 0.3% of the market that you might catch if only you used the 'right' colors you can spend time on this. It's another nice example of premature optimization.
- dspillett 10y agoThe legibility tab is more generally applicable though. " tuning the 0.3%" could be significant then that 0.3% are people with significant vision problems. You still don't want to be spending more than a moment on that in early design, but with a tool like this covering the issue might only take that moment so you don't have to make alterations later when early design decisions/accidents are baked in and harder to change.
- jacquesm 10y agoYes, and it would be enough to have one set of styleguides to cover all apps. In fact, I would very much prefer that. All the 'cool' looking stuff can be extremely confusing because you need to re-learn at least that part of the UI over and over again. It's a kind of mental form of lock-in.
- z3t4 10y agotake a look at the drink buisness. the look of the bottle is very important. you can argue its actually more important then whats in it.
- agd 10y ago> (though anybody who has ever had to read a lot of dark gray text on a light gray background knows that this is an issue) On techcrunch which has...yep, dark gray text on a light gray background!
- johnfn 10y agoAnd then I read your comment on HN. It's dark gray on light gray all the way down!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tmatthewj 10y agoNice to see that Google picked up a specific use-case, material design on mobile apps, and built a guide tool. For color guide on more generic design requirements, https://color.adobe.com/create/color-wheel/ https://color.adobe.com/create/color-wheel/ is something you might want to look at.
- xook 10y agoOh, good. Now I can figure out which shade of blue I should use.
- marknote 10y agoGood. I am also using 2 tools: http://designspiration.net/ http://designspiration.net/ http://paletton.com/ http://paletton.com/
- AlphaWeaver 10y agoPaletton is really good. It also allows you to simulate Color Blindness of various types so you can plan for those users in your color selection as well.
- marknote 10y agoYes, it is really helpful, especially useful to match the secondary color when primary color is defined.
- daedlanth 10y agoStudy color and quit being so lazy.
- daedlanth 10y agoStudy color and quit being so lazy.
- kuro-kuris 10y agoI think the accessibility tab is useful though I wish it highlighted which combinations are accessible.
- nkkollaw 10y agoReally cool. The only problem I have with material design is that lots of apps just look the same, and some people _do_ confuse Google stuff with apps that use material design, thinking they're from Google. Much better than all apps looking like Bootstrap's default theme, though, which is a popular alternative to loading a material design theme with a palette you picked.
- GBKS 10y agoThe other side of this is that it helps usability when things look and feel familiar. It's interesting how it's accepted that desktop applications generally look the same, but mobile apps are supposed to be more unique. Maybe just the nature of mobile being generally more consumer oriented?
- nkkollaw 10y agoI don't agree that desktop apps look the same, but it depends on the platform I think. Apps that use native controls will definitely look the same, but the apps I've been using in the past few months—and yes some are Electron-based—all look very different on macOS. Not sure, though.
- numbsafari 10y agoI think it's that (consumer oriented), but also the more "personal" nature of mobile apps.
- tptacek 10y agoIsn't it weird that when it comes to desktop apps and particularly UI toolkits, we freak out when things don't match the OS style perfectly, but with applications on the web --- many of which are more UI-intensive than native apps --- we're constantly looking for the CSS Zen Garden?
- mc32 10y agoSo long as desktop apps don't mimic kai's power tool interface, I think a little variety on the desktop side is nice, so long as it fits function to a meaningful degree. So an audio mixing applic might do something in a different way than office's ribbon ui.
- alc90 10y agoReally nice tool. Great work mate!
- alc90 10y agoReally nice tool. Great work mate!
- WA 10y agoWhat's the "A 100, A 200 etc." on the right-hand side? And the 50-900, what's this about? From the docs, I read: "pick 500 as primary color". But what does the number refer to?
- yathern 10y agoThose are accent colors - A for accent. The number refers to the darkness level of the color variant. Not sure what better way to describe it, but it goes from: Low Saturation Light (50) --> Very Saturated (500) --> Low Saturation Dark (900)
- owly 10y agoVery nicely done.
- dbg31415 10y agoThis is cool, adding it to my list of colors tools. * Paletton - The Color Scheme Designer || http://paletton.com/ http://paletton.com/ * Material Design Color Palette Generator - Material Palette || https://www.materialpalette.com/ https://www.materialpalette.com/ * Flat UI Colors - Color Pallette from Flat UI Theme || http://flatuicolors.com/ http://flatuicolors.com/ * Coolors.co - The super fast color schemes generator || https://coolors.co/ https://coolors.co/ * Spectrum - Chrome Web Store || https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/spectrum/ofclemegkcmilinpcimpjkfhjfgmhieb https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/spectrum/ofclemegk...
- H1Supreme 10y agoGreat tool. Especially for people without a lot of design or color theory experience. As someone with both, I find the palette a bit too saturated for my tastes. I've tried to only use the colors listed in the material design docs, but usually make my own palettes in the long run.
- karmajunkie 10y agoAre there some good resources you could recommend for color theory? I've come across lots of palette tools but little indication of what makes colors work, aside from contrast indications. I feel very much like someone in a workshop with every tool imaginable and no idea of how to use them.
- andreygrehov 10y agoI'm not a color expert, but is there a color tool which would narrow down available color options for the Secondary color palette? Primary palette is cool, but I can still make it all look ugly by choosing random colors for the Secondary palette, which is exactly what I would want to avoid.
- theptip 10y agoThere are a few, https://color.adobe.com/create/color-wheel/ https://color.adobe.com/create/color-wheel/ is one I was recommended many years ago. Interested to see what the new hotness is though.