37 ms·
Trolls are winning the internet, technologists say
- alexkavon 10y agoTrolls were always winning the internet. From "RTFM" attitudes to anonymous user accounts. It's a troll playground. Don't get me wrong the internet was built to be/can be an incredible tool, but let's not misconstrue this is a new trend. EDIT: I find the issue with the candor on the internet is lack of context 90% of the time.
- M_Grey 10y agoTrolls, in a broad sense, win life in the same way. "This is why we can't have nice things," is a practically universal sentiment, and much of our human endeavor is geared to managing the activities of its edge cases. Technology only empowers people, it doesn't make them better people... so this is the result. The response will be a combination of social quarantine, and an upgraded intellectual immune system on the part of netizens. I think Trump's election and the damage his presidency is likely to inflict will be a bit of a turning point in the collective attitude to trolls in general.
- thinkmilitant 10y agoI agree. It seems to me that the biggest difference is the extent to which the average internet user gets his content from other internet users (reddit, facebook, twitter, etc) instead of designated content creators with reputations to uphold.
- clock_tower 10y agoIsn't this the applied form of the Global Village nonsense from back in the '90s? I'm sure I've seen positively-spun descriptions of the process you describe.
- BeetleB 10y ago>It seems to me that the biggest difference is the extent to which the average internet user gets his content from other internet users (reddit, facebook, twitter, etc) instead of designated content creators with reputations to uphold. This is as old as humanity, and has always been the case for the majority. See the chapter "Social Proof" in the book "Influence": https://www.amazon.com/Influence-Psychology-Persuasion-Robert-Cialdini/dp/006124189X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1490993840&sr=8-1&keywords=Influence https://www.amazon.com/Influence-Psychology-Persuasion-Rober...
- the_af 10y ago> From "RTFM" attitudes While agree some internet users are a bit too gung-ho with RTFM, I think it's unfair to lump them with trolls. While veterans can be harsh and unfriendly, the RTFM response is often warranted (though, again, it could be phrased more nicely -- and the default assumption should be that the person seeking help is well-intentioned). Otherwise, many online communities would be completely overrun by people demanding help with minimum effort on their part. "RTFM" is not trollish behavior, because trolls have a different goal: to disrupt communities, start flamewars and generally annoy the hell out of people. It's not merely being "unfriendly"; in fact some trolls fake cluelesness instead of anger.
- michaelchisari 10y agoI disagree. I think that hand-holding beginners can be one of the best services a community can provide, and it can go a long way to growing the community. That doesn't mean everybody needs to be teacher/mentor/educator. But the people who don't want to be can also just keep out of the conversation, instead of rudely pointing to some 300 page manual and telling someone with passion and interest to screw off.
- the_af 10y agoHmm, RTFM is not aimed at beginners (and note: I do agree with the sibling comment that the aggressiveness of the response leaves a bad taste. I do agree pointing to a 300 page manual, without any guidance at all, is unhelpful). RTFM is aimed at help vampires (recommended reading: http://www.skidmore.edu/~pdwyer/e/eoc/help_vampire.htm http://www.skidmore.edu/~pdwyer/e/eoc/help_vampire.htm). Help vampires do not grow a community; they destroy it. These are people you do not want in your community anyway. Unlike actual beginners, who learn and then proceed to become valuable contributors (unless of course they are treated harshly by veterans, in which case they simply leave), help vampires are never helpful. They ask the same question again and again, don't pay attention to any cues, don't read anything, and seldom provide context or follow-ups to their problem. And when you've wasted time with one (more often than not fruitlessly), the next one comes in. And they are legion. The end result, like the first article I mentioned claims, is that your community of well-intentioned volunteers is destroyed. So a polite RTFM is often the best response: if the person was an actual beginner, they'll read TFM -- and follow-up questions are often welcome, since they show the asker has actually made an effort. If not, they'll leave and you haven't wasted any valuable time. In fact, help vampires are often indistinguishable from trolls, in that they have the same community-disrupting effect. RTFM has always been part of the hacker culture (also see: How To Ask Questions The Smart Way, http://www.catb.org/esr/faqs/smart-questions.html http://www.catb.org/esr/faqs/smart-questions.html). It has nothing to do with trolls.
- ravenstine 10y agoLet's not forget that that '03 to '06 era of "Just F*ing Google It".
- Mendenhall 10y agoWhat I see is some people dont like foolish words on a screen so they want to clamp down on open discourse to control dialogue because in their opinion its fruitless or mean or whatever they feel. Some silly troll spamming idiotic statements is not nearly the threat that controlling dialogue on the net and deciding what is trolling and what isnt. Socrates would be labeled a troll these days if he was on social media.
- geofft 10y agoMy screen is of a fixed size; my days are of a fixed length. If you want to put foolish words on your screen more power to you, but if they're on my screen or taking my time, that impedes me doing whatever I want to do with my screen or my time. That is, the more dialogue that I'm uninterested in that I lack tools to filter, the more my dialogue is being controlled by DoS. That is the fundamental paradox of open discourse; I don't know what the right answer is, but naive open discourse isn't it.
- rjbwork 10y agoSo your solution is to be given tools to enforce your cognitive bias reinforcing filter bubble? That's not a solution, that's a technology provided lobotomy. A dialogue takes two - if you don't like the dialogue taking place, instead of attempting to quiet the other voices, perhaps just remove yourself from the dialogue.
- dbelchamber 10y agoAs a counterpoint, the biggest gripe of "trolling" that I have is that it prevents dialogue rather than adding to it. It's one thing to argue for say Nazi ideology in a relevant conversation with the purpose of expressing a genuine point (this would be a rare event indeed), but that is not what trolls are doing. Instead, they are invading a conversation with ad hominem attacks as well as distracting and attention-seeking behaviors. Preventing trolling does not inherently involve silencing points of view. All it should be doing is removing unhelpful, unsolicited, and off topic nonsense. Even the most evil views that I can think of should not be censored, under the condition that they are actually being discussed with the interest of discourse, for that truly is what "dialogue" is. But again, in that event it isn't really "trolling".
- KaiserPro 10y agoSigh The Trolls have been with the internet from the start. I would say that actually they are mostly contained (why? because its really fucking difficult to be anonymous. Plus you are more than likely to be prosecuted for whatever you've done) So whats changed? more people are on platforms like twitter, and seem to think that fake internet points are real. The vast majority of "trolling" is pretty low grade "die", "sexual slur", "lol rape", "exploitation of personal detail that you've shared" Thats not trolling, thats people just being arseholes. They are anonymous people, they have no impact on your life, ignore them. edit I should point out that yes swatting and doxxing still happens, and the impact is massive. but it is still rare. The advantage of a twitter profile is you can delete it, and start again. I wish I could have done that in real life. It would have helped me escape the daily torment of my bullies at high school.
- JacksonGariety 10y agoI'd say it has a pretty profound impact on your life: share personal information online, get 'trolled', and then watch that encounter become permanently associated with your name.
- KaiserPro 10y agoI could have explained it better, but what people call trolling, and actual trolling are two different things. Apparently posting a link in reply to someone is now "trolling"
- accountface 10y agoOn the contrary... these trolls have SWATted, stalked, ddos'd, called, doxxed, and harassed normal people. They've spammed business, social media accounts, email... For some people the impact on their life is very real. I can't use my name publicly on the internet because of trolls. This impacts my life in a huge way.
- KaiserPro 10y agoYes, I should have made that clear. you were trolled, and it is clearly devastating. What most people think of trolling is just someone shouting WANKER at the screen.
- pcmaffey 10y agoTrolling is the new spam. Except trolls want your attention, not your money. People said the same thing about spam. And it's largely been defeated (or institutionalized, whichever way you want to look at). We're all still figuring out the dynamics of the attention economy... and I imagine that as we do, we'll find ways to minimize the impact of trolling. I'd venture to say that that's the big lesson we have to learn from the current presidential cycle (aka troll-in-chief).
- Edmond 10y agoThere are folks like us working on this: https://www.cipheredtrust.com/ https://www.cipheredtrust.com/ The trick is a scalable means to do identity verification on the internet...basically a way to do it that preserves user privacy and security and it is dirt cheap so everyone can leverage it.
- michaelchisari 10y agoI'm curious about something... I've seen reports that when places started using Facebook comments, they found that the lack of anonymity didn't prevent trolling, in fact, it made everyday people more hostile. Is it just about identity? Would that do anything more than just removing the occasional death threat, instead of actually addressing the more pervasive trolling?
- pcmaffey 10y agoGiven that identity is the basis for most trolling, I'd say identity is a poor proxy for trust. Despite what Facebook and the CIA / NSA may want us to believe, there's no evidence that a lack of anonymity/privacy leads to greater accountability.
- Edmond 10y agoIdentity can prevent abuse if it can be used as an effective way to keep the trolls out. In the real world if you know behaving badly can get you permanently banned from a place you'd like to have access to, that keeps you in check. Similarly if it was possible for service providers to effectively penalize (from suspension to permanent banning) abusers in a way that they can't easily circumvent (ie create a new account), that'll be effective.
- wvenable 10y agoThe real problem is that bytes are effectively free. Here I am, using up your bytes right now. Using up the bytes on Hacker news. The only limit is my own time, effort, and energy. You think this means that we're all equal; we all have equal access to sharing bytes. But the problem is that trolls have infinite time and energy to post bytes. They have significantly more power and influence than you do because of that simple fact. Trolls could, if they wanted, completely bring down hacker news with just endless content and it would be near impossible to stop. I've had to deal with real determined trolls on some of my own sites that simply have infinite time to post, to write code to post, to obfuscate themselves -- a single troll can shout out dozens to hundreds of other people. This is why the trolls are winning.
- czep 10y agoWhat are some good tips for controlling or at least mitigating trolling on sites that depend on user generated content? Moderation, flagging, downvoting, IP address rate limits, keyword blacklisting, are these effective?
- cf 10y agoAnil Dash actually wrote a great article about this. The short summary is you need real humans doing the moderating. All the tooling you create should be about enhancing those humans. http://anildash.com/2011/07/if-your-websites-full-of-assholes-its-your-fault.html http://anildash.com/2011/07/if-your-websites-full-of-asshole...
- wvenable 10y agoI banned an entire country once -- not the best way to go but after all other mitigations failed it was the last choice available. And it wasn't China or Russia. It's almost impossible to give everyone the same number of bytes of work with -- if you can solve that problem you've solved it all.
- kordless 10y agoIt is an irrational belief that trolls have infinite time and energy. This is, in fact, the very idea of irrationality, who's concept indicates additional work must be done to determine outcome of choice, either by individual or by group. Note that I did not disagree with your assertions here, but simply seek to restate them in slightly different terms so they may be visualized by others more effectively. Trolls may encapsulate irrational ideas, which may be visualized as memes, inside multiple illogical statements which may be designed to directly conflict with each other's truths. Evaluating one of these statements as a "truth" may cause the other statement to evaluate to false. Trolls may utilize statements in which evaluation of truth is not desirable to the entity visualizing the truth. Any attempt by the recipient to evaluate truth or non-truth of these statements may lead to additional work being conducted to achieve a desirable outcome, such as "winning an argument". Additionally, these "double bind" memes, or internal visualizations, may effectively spread the irrationality to other actors if they are constructed correctly. These viral memes take root and spread when the new irrational actor posts more irrationality in the form of similar or modified logic patterns. This process, manifests as a viral meme (or what I hypothesize as an entity): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc Trolls remove choice from individuals and groups by causing the individual and groups to work against each other. The only way to prevent this is to educate people on the concept of double bind statements, their use in removing choice for others, and the possibility that these concepts may spread virally, on their own accord, in a population which may or may not be conscious. My primary suggestion for combat trolls in a quick and easy way is to simply not visualize removal of choice for another in your own internal frame. In other words, visualize choice for yourself in the future if you must, but avoid visualizing the actions of others! Stating your refusal to be illogical, or irrational, is usually enough to send the trolls scurrying away. Note: A double bind and a double BLIND are two different concepts. Double binding someone has been likened to "crazy making" due to its effect of blocking decision making processes from occurring in a given entity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_bind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_bind
- alphonsegaston 10y agoIs this really a problem of technology though? Seems more the artifact of a modern culture so predicated on con-artistry and spectacle, that abuse and manipulation have become the dominant form of expression. Technology makes this easier for sure. But I think it's the futureless world of hucksterism being articulated to everyone that makes behaving this way attractive to so many people.
- moomin 10y agoYeah, it pretty much is. If you're going to credit the development of the web and related technologies with the economic benefits it has delivered, we need to take it on the chin for the damage it has caused to our society. Every time we disrupt an industry, especially media, we are by definition shaping society. It's about time we as technologists started being honest about that.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoThat's a fair observation. You break it, you bought it.
- pervycreeper 10y agoIf we define "troll" as anyone who posts inflammatory, bad faith, needlessly aggressive, insulting, false, or otherwise unproductive content, then the entire class of authors of the genre of news article decrying trolling and harassment are themselves trolls. >Of course, this is already happening, just out of sight of most of us Why would they consider that to be such a big problem, if it's not bothering those who are wont to be bothered? The true motivation for these comments is clear, but remains unsaid: what "trolls" are posting is outside the control of these would-be authorities. The technology community must pick between enabling universal surveillance and censorship, or protecting the privacy of the vulnerable, including those who hold minority opinions and express themselves in ways that could be deemed "unpleasant".
- Goronmon 10y agoIf we define "troll" as anyone who posts inflammatory, bad faith, needlessly aggressive, insulting, false, or otherwise unproductive content, then the entire class of authors of the genre of news article decrying trolling and harassment are themselves trolls. Isn't that a bit of a tautology? "If I expand the definition of the word 'troll' to include 'authors decrying trolling' then authors who decry trolling become 'trolls' themselves." It's not an exceedingly convincing statement to me personally. Though you've used one of the adjectives I think best describes the nature of 'trolling' and that's "bad faith". Personally, I feel the most useful definition of 'troll' is someone who argues/antagonizes/insults others not because they are trying to make a point or start a conversation, but merely to provoke a negative response.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 10y ago>Isn't that a bit of a tautology? "If I expand the definition of the word 'troll' to include 'authors decrying trolling' then authors who decry trolling become 'trolls' themselves." No, it's not tautological. The parent doesn't propose to "expand the definition of the word 'troll' to include 'authors decrying trolling'". He proposes defining trolls as "as anyone who posts inflammatory, bad faith, needlessly aggressive, insulting, false, or otherwise unproductive content". Which is as (or close) to how it has always been defined, and how the authors of TFA use it. So what the parent suggests is not some "expansion of the definition of trolling", much less one to include "those who complain about trolling", and in no sense a tautology.
- ElatedOwl 10y agoI'm surprised at the concern over trolling compared to shilling. If someone wants to be an ass whatever, but CTR and similar seems like a much more serious problem to me.
- michaelchisari 10y agoHow is CTR on your radar, but Russia employing thousands of online trolls isn't?
- ElatedOwl 10y agoIt is; but they're employing shills, not trolls. It doesn't even have to be political, I'm sure we've all seen the forced corporate memes that totally aren't an advertisement.
- michaelchisari 10y agothey're employing shills, not trolls. I disagree. CTR was known for promotion, shilling, just as advertisers are, but people in Russian employ were known for disruption. They aren't pushing the merits of Donald Trump, Marine LePen, etc., as much as they're fomenting discord through fake news and aggressive bias.
- ElatedOwl 10y agoLinguistics aside I think we're in agreement. :) The article doesn't outright define trolling, but gets pretty close with: >humans like trolling. It’s easy for people to stay anonymous while they harass, pester, and bully other people online All I'm getting at is, people being assholes on the internet isn't a real problem compared to the astroturfing and forum sliding that goes on.
- michaelchisari 10y agoI guess where we're in disagreement, though, and this is something that was in discussion at the senate hearings in terms of "unwitting agents" or put less delicately, "useful idiots" that will follow along with dangerous patterns that might have their source in extremely negative astroturfing/forum-sliding/shilling, but which take on a life of their own. We have clear evidence that disinformation campaigns and active measures are being used, but the reason they work isn't because initially a bunch of Russian teenagers are employed to push false and dangerous narratives. They work because they get picked up by totally sincere people who have an emotional reason for perpetuating them, but which reject any kind of rational discussion around them. As a use case: An army of (shills/trolls) pushes a completely fake story titled, "Police Find 19 White Female Bodies In Freezers With ‘Black Lives Matter’ Carved Into Skin." (this was an actual, viral fake news headline), and times it properly to get it to certain key environments. Once it's there, it gets perpetuated by people who are sincere, who are continuing the narrative for emotional, irrational reasons ("this fits my world view, it angers me, it makes me feel good to bring it to light"). When people respond that it is a fake story, those people are responded to with hostility, name-calling and anger. At this point, you have a shift from shilling to trolling, but the original source hits a particular emotional note that posting things like, "Hillary Clinton is the most experienced and qualified candidate for president EVER" or "Hey guys! I just learned about this great new product, totally randomly! Let's talk about it!" Both are problems. The latter are annoying, and with a little bit of savvy, easily identified and ignored. The former is outright dangerous and attacks one of the foundations of a democratic, free society.
- return0 10y agoIf you give people a big wall and free spray paint, of course they 'll fill it with dicks. Unlike real life, there is nobody to paint over them. Trolling is a natural part of the internet, its the price for having relative freedom, i dont have a problem with it. If that puts off people who don't have the capacity to tune it out, all the better.
- koolba 10y ago> Unlike real life, there is nobody to paint over them. In the real world having your tagging painted over is one of the saddest feelings. I wonder if there's a way to digitize that sensation but I think people are desensitized to things being deleted. It would have to be beyond that.
- dredmorbius 10y agoI've seen people respond similarly or analagously to having their posts or comments removed. Which makes me cautious about invoking that particular remedy in any but particularly eggregious or blatent cases. If I think there's any reasonable option for remediation, I'll try to avoid it. Spam and blatent trollery, not so much.
- defined 10y agoSure, but if the big wall is a map, and you're trying to find something on that map, all the dicks make it so much harder to find it that giving up in despair is often the reaction. It's hard to tune out a cubic mile of dicks when you're looking for a pearl.
- skylan_q 10y agoThat's a terrible analogy because you can refine your search nowadays.
- ashark 10y agoWell, in that case the Internet "map"'s problem is less the dicks drawn here and there than its being covered on every square centimeter by ads. Oh wait, I think I see the part of the map I needed... oh, no, just another ad designed to make me think it was part of the map.
- syphilis2 10y agoI don't like the loose language used in this article and others that uses "trolling" as a catch-all for online harassment, violence, privacy violations, and more. It's misleading and gets people riled up as they talk past each other. Conflating 'baiting someone into looking stupid online' with 'sending threats to their family members' muddles the conversation. Worse, it erodes the meaning of the term. I'd call it cultural appropriation but that'd be too obvious.
- wott 10y agoUnfortunately (because I agree with you), that's the common meaning of the word nowadays. I guess we have to deal with it, and speak of oldschool troll for the original meaning from now on.
- primitivesuave 10y agoI stopped reading after the third paragraph when I realized the entire basis for this article is a survey given to 1500 "technologists" with a loaded question that basically equates to "is trolling getting better or worse?". First of all, not everyone who could be described as a "technologist" is qualified to answer that question, and people are naturally biased to say things are getting worse. I have seen non-opinionated ways to research trolling, e.g. at a hackathon I saw a couple high schoolers use IBM Watson's sentiment analysis API with Twitter feeds. In a sense this article is just a more educated form of trolling - someone with an opinion grasps at fallacies and bad statistics to back it up, and uses the Internet to disseminate it.
- generic_user 10y agoI think online journalism as a whole has turned into a form of trolling. Or maybe we are in a post Journalist world now. The value of a story is based on how many clicks it gets. Thats what makes these sites money. It does not matter if you click because the story makes you angry or you think its insulting just so long as you click and you get the advertising. And as far as standards go there are none. Just make up some stuff that riles people and come up with a click bait headline and on to the next story.
- houst0n_ 10y agoI think that depends on your sources. TheIntercept doesn't fit into that bracket to me. Bias? Maybe, but bias isn't a problem if you read a diverse set of sources. Bias isn't a problem, opinion isn't a problem; reading one source and complaining its 'fake news' because it's bias isn't the same as yours is.
- generic_user 10y agoI agree that there is still a spectrum of quality. And certain Journalists and publications can still establish a reputation for reliability and quality. But the problem is the business model. No one has been able to come up with a solution to make money on quality. Its all volume advertising. NYT is competing with BuzzFeed for eyeballs. Its a competition to come up with the most clever hook and target peoples emotions to drive traffic. In the print days there was a small number of publications and it was very expensive to start one. The more serious publications published monthly. Its totally different now. Think about that up until just a few years ago serious Journalists had to produce about one piece a month and they had supporting staff and a budget. There is very little now that comes close to the quality and analysis that there use to be.
- paulpauper 10y agoI think it's the opposite: I hardly see any truly malicious trolling these days, especially since 2013. What the author attributes to trolling may just be someone expressing a view that goes against the grain, but is not deliberately intended to provoke a negative reaction and or in 'bad faith', which is a closer definition of what trolling is. The reason why there is less trolling is because many forum communities and social networks have filters and much stricter moderation and much less tolerance for trolls, than a decade or longer ago. From anecdotal experience, in 2004, trolling was much more prevalent on forums, but now admins and users have much less tolerance for it.
- ergothus 10y agoI'll agree the tolerance for extreme trolling is down, but I envy you your shelter: From trash talk to insults to casual "I'll drop this outrageous-but-believable statement and quietly leave", I see non-extreme trolling as mainstream anymore. And I define "trolling" as "taking actions or communication with the sole goal of gaining pleasure from someone's misery and/or outrage"
- jumpkickhit 10y agoIt think the problem is now too many people are on the internet. Back in the 90's, it was a great place to hang out. In the 2000's, you had fun sites with great user commentary like Fark, Digg, Slashdot, and Reddit. Now everybody and their kid has a cellphone with internet access. Your average person is an asshole, so that's reflected online because of how saturated it all is now.
- yumaikas 10y agoThe internet can still be a great place to hang out. It's just a matter of finding a community, rather than on of the big sites. https://lobste.rs https://lobste.rs is one example that I've found (mostly, anyway), I'm sure there are various fora as well.
- defined 10y agoThis is a good point. You know Sturgeon's Law? Something along the lines of "90% of science fiction is crap, because 90% of everything is crap?" Well, if you more or less agree with that, there is just so much more of everything that there is so much more crap. Another commenter expressed this as a signal-to-noise ratio problem. It is that, but it is also that O(N) is bad news for very large values of N.
- adrienne 10y ago*Sturgeon's Revelation. Sturgeon's Law was actually something else Ted said: "Nothing is always absolutely so."
- dredmorbius 10y agoSurgeon's Law is poorly behaved at Web Scale: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1yzvh3/refutation_of_metcalfes_law_revisited_network/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1yzvh3/refutat...
- ergothus 10y agoIt's just an extension of the Eternal September. Any community that comes in contact with a larger community that does not respect their customs has problems, but it Usenet, email conventions, Burning Man, victims of imperialism, or a local book club. We have lots of evidence of this. The unfortunate thing is that I can't come up with examples of anything positive coming about as a result: The smaller community is either destroyed or weakened, and the larger community rarely replicates the strengths of the smaller ones. We can talk about the strength of diversity, and I'm all for it! But this isn't a melding to create something new, this is tearing apart the "other" and continuing on barely altered. Humans are poorly built to handle large communities, and we've not really come up with an artificial means to deal with such situations.
- kartan 10y agoIf I understand correctly what has happened recently, state-sponsored media disruption is the problem. While the Internet was a place for nerds, it was uninteresting for mainstream powers. Nowadays is a good target for states wanting to influence elections, for companies that want to sell their products and for organized religion. Old tricks in a "new" medium. If a power can mobilize millions of troops, or expend millions on discrediting climate change. Why should they respect the Internet?
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt's the paradox of epistemic systems: as they become larger (or the audience more attractive), they attrack those who would use them for manipulation. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5wg0hp/when_epistemic_systems_gain_social_and_political/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5wg0hp/when_ep...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jknoepfler 10y agoI don't understand this article at all. I participate in two large professional forums (one for poker, one for development). The professionals are winning the internet there. There are dedicated subforums for trolls and random bs, which are pretty funny sometimes, but serve as an outlet for the garbage. I browse hacker news... It is what it is, I'm happy with it as a content sharing platform. My biggest gripe is the obvious advertorial/astroturfing that I think is probably something hn offers as a service, but I'm not stupid, so I ignore it. I get news through economist.com and npr.org and scattered other sources. I don't feel overwhelmed by trolls, except when I read yet another fucking headline about gluten. My social media is so boring and predictable I'll probably delete it all shortly. I've never had a problem there, but I respect that some people do. I shop on the internet frequently. I get trolled by counterfeit goods sometimes! Also by fake reviews, but that's what professional forums are for in the post cluetrain world. I get scholarly articles on the internet every other day as part of a professional masters program. Sometimes open comments on academic articles read like troll fests, but not really. I participate in open source on github, that's not being trolled to death (Although big os project maintainers may disagree). And on and on... The internet (as I know it) isn't being won by trolls at all. So what is the article actually about? Twitter? Comments on news sites (lol)? The pessimistic attitudes of "technologists"?
- aantix 10y agoOh man, have you ever tried to have a political discussion on Facebook? Even citing sources, trying to be diligent... And then, the only response you get is... "that's not right!". And that response is somehow given equal weighting? I actually wish Facebook, the place where a majority of Internet discussion probably occurs, WOULD institute a dislike button and suppress those comments that get down voted too much (like Hackers News or Reddit). Right now, it's either a "thumbs up" or a neutral stance, and that's just not enough to accurately describe the level of discourse occurring.
- jknoepfler 10y agoI mean, I can hop on the gripe-train about Facebook, but the only way I've found to have meaningful political conversations is over a very narrow topic with the expectation that parties come well-researched and willing to continue researching. Politics is excruciatingly complicated, trying to have a cogent conversation about it on Facebook is like trying to have a deep talk about religion while riding bumper cars.
- doktrin 10y agorelated : http://nymag.com/selectall/2016/09/how-internet-trolls-won-the-2016-presidential-election.html http://nymag.com/selectall/2016/09/how-internet-trolls-won-t... http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/03/memes-4chan-trump-supporters-trolls-internet-214856 http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/03/memes-4chan-t...
- RidingQwerty 10y agoTHEY SEE ME TROLLIN THEY HATIN AND HOPING THAT THEY GONE CATCH ME RIDING QWERTY Look bruh, when we got on this internet, we could be whoever we wanted. It didn't matter what flesh machine was punching on the keyboard, if I said I was a white Nigerian female quantum physicist, it's on you to either accept my identity or challenge it. That's how it was for decades. Then social media came and incentivized personal identifiers like photos and videos and audio. Once personal identifiers became cheap to transmit, then old world political conflict, racial conflict, gender conflict, and the rest of the identity politics shit show quickly followed in its wake. People refused to challenge self-identification for the sake of being polite and "revolutionary" (Yeah, okay). In fact, they were attacked if they DIDN'T accept a self-identification. So, here we are, hacking your stupid addiction to identity politics because the reason we ended up on the internet to begin with WAS to get away from that insanity as it chased us across real-life institutions, cultures, and social programs. Maybe I want to be more than the person I was genetically and socioeconomically destined to be. Maybe I want off of this postmodern circle-jerk where humans are supposed to be ambivalent balls of energy that can be shaped however the powerful desire. The internet was essential in exploring those potentials. You call it trolling, I call it liberation. EDIT: Downvotes only prove my point.
- bittercynic 10y agoMaybe they're downvoting because of the belligerent tone, even though the thrust of your argument has some validity. I believe the downfall of the weird wide web has been greatly exaggerated. There are still plenty of interesting corners of the internet. Don't let Facebook and its kind prevent you from finding the interesting parts of the web.
- giardini 10y agoI used to laugh reading about politics in Abraham Lincoln's time: distribution of news was, at best, iffy and journalists made up stories to suit their political/social viewpoint. Remarkably like today. The Internet is indeed wondrous. Thanks to the trolls, we're back to where we were in 1860 again. "Fake news isn’t a recent problem in the US — it almost destroyed Abraham Lincoln": https://qz.com/842816/fake-news-almost-destroyed-abraham-lincoln/ https://qz.com/842816/fake-news-almost-destroyed-abraham-lin...
- mybrid 10y agoI think the scope of this trolling concern needs to be expanded to include the latest science on confirmation bias and cognitive dissonance. The fake news of Hillary running a child prostitution ring out of a pizza parlor is an example of where people are creating protected spaces for confirmation bias online. Such a story is ludicrous. After Trump won the alt-right created a coded language where common words are substituted for slurs. It is human nature for birds of a feather to flock together and part of this includes creating a negative environment to weed out all but the most dedicated. This human behavior can be found at executive levels at Fortune 500 companies where cussing and swearing not allowed at the employee level represent barriers for people, most notably women, who don't appreciate the troll, obnoxious behavior. It is well known that climbing the corporate ladder requires an ever increasing capacity to put up with caustic trolling behavior.
- snickerbockers 10y agoThere have always been mean people on the internet, grow the fuck up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sebringj 10y agoI don't think we can cut off trolls because of free speech. Its not even a good idea as some trolls aren't even trolls, they are just loud. Instead, if personal filters were controlled via browser settings or something independent of the actual provider, you could maintain privacy yet have nice content as well. An AI filter would be a good candidate for that.
- st3v3r 10y agoWrong. Most internet forums are privately owned, and thus the concept doesn't apply. Plus, trolling and harassment isn't free speech. Conflating the two is insulting to those who are fighting for actual free speech, in places where they will be arrested for advocating that.
- sebringj 10y agoI have a hard time knowing who is a troll as there are times when people become one but not in their normal behavior. I remember recently there was a study on that listed here which was interesting. Also, your negative tone for example could be interpreted as trolling if you put lots of those types of responses, not saying you are of course, but some AI might give you a false positive on extreme opinions. What I meant was not the person trolling but the person viewing content, just being able to have their own filter, where the filter is not controlled by some 3rd party but under your own so let's say the 3rd party couldn't suddenly remove the option. More about control than privacy in that case.
- anjc 10y agoIdiotic article.
- DictumExNihilo 10y agoWhat if most of them aren't "trolls" at all, but rather people who have something to say that is important to them and they choose a method to say it that upsets some people? The base assumption is that many of them are old-school variety: they seek disruption for its own sake. Suppose for a moment that this base assumption should not be taken as axiomatic. What else might motivate such a person? Some of you are quick to jump to the conclusion that money is the only other motivation. But money isn't what motivates everyone. Lots of people create art, for example, and receive little to no money for what they do. What if some people are trying to motivate others to think about the things they believe, say, and do? Their medium need not be literature, paintings, music, sculpture, and so forth. A sarcastic tongue can teach too. It can spread ideas and challenge assumptions. Writing a lengthy essay that nobody will read may be a counterproductive use of time. People roll their eyes if one brings up philosophy in a casual setting. I see a lot of things people call "trolling" as small performances of philosophy. Not all of them are effective, virtuous, or well-informed. But some are. The ones that really get under our skin are the ones who actually understand us the best, they know our weaknesses and exploit them. There is too much focus on who they are and whether or not they're getting paid (because they probably aren't) and not enough on what is being said. In a lot of cases, what isn't said is just as important. If the "troll" wants you to think about your own positions, he may just omit several critical details on purpose and let you fill in the blanks. Diogenes didn't make people happy when he walked about in broad daylight with a lantern looking for "an honest man", he made some of them laugh, and made others angry. Socrates made enemies by arguing with people and showing them that they didn't really know why they believed as they did. I've had more productive conversations with people in my life when I took an adversarial position to them under the veil of anonymity, even though I agreed with their position. If I can argue a position I don't agree with and hold my own, the other guy comes out of it with new ammunition to defeat it too (or more ambition to find some), and they often teach me a few tricks along the way. It is entirely too easy to dismiss a person if all you think they want is to make you mad with what they've said.
- st3v3r 10y ago"What if most of them aren't "trolls" at all, but rather people who have something to say that is important to them and they choose a method to say it that upsets some people?" If the only way you can express your dislike of a black actress is to compare her to an ape, maybe just shut the fuck up. "It is entirely too easy to dismiss a person if all you think they want is to make you mad with what they've said." And it's entirely too easy to ignore the problem of real trolling and harassment if you think it's just people with "differing opinions".
- Chathamization 10y agoI would be interested in seeing more places try posting limits. It's easy for someone to shoot off hundreds of thoughtless messages, but it takes time and effort to make a single thoughtful post. A minority trying to do the former is going to inundate those doing the latter. And for those (probably most of us) who do a bit of both, it's likely that our less thoughtful and more rapid fire output is going to dwarf our thoughtful output (just because the latter requires so much more time and effort). Even in the cases where someone provides a lot of thoughtful output, a minority of active users can often drown out the majority of visitors. It would be interesting to see what kinds of communities would develop if there were efforts to encourage more even output.
- BeetleB 10y ago>I would be interested in seeing more places try posting limits. This was proposed years ago on Reddit: Limit # of votes/posts per user per day. Never implemented...
- dredmorbius 10y agoI like the concept, though I very strongly suspect it would be gamed. Creating a system for imposing a cost on persistent identity -- not "real name" identity, but some form of valued persistence -- and then imposing rate-limiting, could be useful. Reddit does put posting limits on new and unverified accounts, by subreddit. To the point of only one post every 5-10 minutes, if I recall (I've tripped that filter a few times). Or as I've said a few times: "Who are you?" is the most expensive question in information technology. No matter how you get it wrong, you're screwed.
- CM30 10y agoThe problem there is that it is certainly possible to legitimately post hundreds of times a day. I mean yes, someone who posts or votes too much could be a troll. Or they could be a perfectly good, yet exceedingly dedicated community member with a bit much too much free time and a lot of passion for a subject. Limits like those tend to screw over more active users in general.
- Para2016 10y agoYou're helping prove his point. I would consider you a troll. You are aggressive, insulting, inflammatory, and you do it with regularity. I'm not sure why it has to be funny to you or anyone else.
- leereeves 10y agoOnce upon a time, "troll" meant someone trying to provoke a reaction for fun, from a type of fishing called "trolling", which involves dragging baited hooks through the water. Lately, as in this article, the term seems to be expanding into a general purpose insult for anyone whose posts annoy someone, sometimes only because they express a different opinion. Under the old definition, bad faith was a requirement. Having an honest argument or even being an honest jerk wasn't the same as being a troll. That seems to be changing.
- mirimir 10y agoA quick scan indicates plain-spoken and incisive, but good-natured. Maybe funny sometimes, but not in a mean way.
- dang 10y agoThat's a personal attack, and those are not allowed here. If you have concerns about other users breaking the site guidelines, flag their comments or email hn@ycombinator.com. Breaking the guidelines yourself just makes the site worse for everyone. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14007347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14007347 and marked it off-topic.
- zxcvvcxz 10y agoWhat's that, we're not marching smoothly towards the left wing socialist worker's paradise? Must be trolls.
- skylan_q 10y agoThe new owner of the Atlantic is a hardcore globalist. That means that if you disagree with him or his agenda on the Internet it's because you're just a troll.
- dustingetz 10y agoA troll is anyone with an incompatible worldview. That's why when /r/democrats starts posting in /r/republicans everyone says everyone else is trolling.
- houst0n_ 10y agoIf I'm having a rational discussion with someone who disagrees with me then I'm automatically a troll? I tend to feel the trolls are the hordes of people calling for me to be executed or using nothing but insults instead of contributing meaningfully. Everyone is free to their own worldview, shutting down discussions with "I hope you get raped in hell n*" isn't what I call a different worldview, it's what I call an arsehole.
- cbhl 10y agoThe ability to have a rational discussion comes from a place of [typically white, male] privilege, though. If you are being sexually harassed, racially discriminated against, or are otherwise in a psychologically unsafe position, you're not going to be in a position to "back up your opinion with facts" or "explain why you feel the way you do" or even listen to someone who calmly, rationally explains that "he's never made me feel uncomfortable", or "why didn't you report [being raped to the police] / [being discriminated against to HR]" or "I don't see race".
- houst0n_ 10y agoWell I'm just taking about Not being spammed with loads of shite instead of genuine prejudices as you point out. I have a hard time really understand the race thing as a Brit thigh. I think the colour thing is a predominantly American problem; while I'm sure there is discrimination in the UK Ive never witnessed black folks here getting a hard time any worse than anyone else and Ive lived loved and employed people of different colour to me most of my life and it's not something I've ever had to really even contemplate.
- pdeuchler 10y agoThe internet is as it always was, the only difference is more people, and more importantly more people without technological prowess and forum/bbs/irc experience, are accessing it and moving increasingly larger chunks of their life to the internet. As someone who fell in love with the internet when I was young because nobody knew I was young, it constantly surprises me when people put intimate details online and then become outraged that they are targeted or harassed. The internet didn't magically make everyone equal, it made everyone equally anonymous (to at least their fellow users, privacy down the stack notwithstanding)... that's why it was/seemed like an egalitarian paradise. Everyone was equal, including the trolls, because nobody knew who you were. Is it that surprising that once people started telling others who they truly were discrimination, harassment, and invective started showing up again? The internet doesn't magically make social, political, religious, and ideological rifts magically disappear, it just seemed like it did because nobody could associate users with their backgrounds. Now that we know who everyone is, the internet just makes you encounter more of these rifts due to it's global nature. But when your first experience with the internet is twitter, facebook, or any other social media this lesson is not only dismissed, but outright refuted. The internet is synonymous with identity to those people. They come completely unprepared and completely open, expecting the internet of the 90's. Obviously things are going to go sideways. In my ever so humble opinion this is the disconnect that is causing a lot of fervor around "trolls" and "harassment". Those that have been battle hardened by the early internet saw how to treat trolls: you ignore them ("don't feed the trolls") because they didn't actually have any ammo. We've given them ammo now, so here are the consequences.
- pdelbarba 10y agoHonest question: how would you reconcile privacy-centric communities like Reddit and definitely-not-privacy-centric communities like Facebook? They both have the same patterns of information bubbles generally feed content in similar ways (broadly speaking) and they both have strong troll subgroups. If anything, Facebook might have a lower overall incidence of trolling because you run the risk of having your profile picture on the evening news.
- nradov 10y ago
- ivanhoe 10y agoNo, Internet was always like this (even worse), just there was much less people on it, and expectations were different. Back in the days of USENET there was a lot of quite unpleasant people you'd run into occasionally, but we've seen it as a part of the scene. Like going on a punk concert and someone spills a beer on you or a fight breaks out. It's not nice experience, but it's the part of the show, partially it's what makes it what it is. In my view it's not trolls who are destroying the Internet, but those who are trying to regulate every single aspect of it, instead of teaching people to more self respect and defiance as a way to deal with assholes. And author is right about that one, it will turn all human interaction into a superficial social equivalent of Potemkin villages where we'll be afraid to speak up without 2 pages of legal disclaimers first.
- sp332 10y agoIt's not true that nothing has changed. Facebook and Twitter will show you posts that they think you're likely to interact with, and hide other stories. That didn't happen on Usenet. Those services will also recommend that you follow/friend other users with similar interests, which automatically builds up mobs. That's not how the Internet used to work.
- houst0n_ 10y agoRight but if people are never going to click on stories they're not interested in then does it really matter? Can we really blame increasing silo-mind on certain demographics not seeing links that they demonstratively wouldn't have opened anyway?
- sp332 10y agoYes, I would say that just browsing a table of contents gives you an idea of what's being talked about and what's getting the most attention, even if you never click through anything. And I don't think the algorithms are that good. It's probably just sorting people into a few discrete buckets.
- woodandsteel 10y agoI think the only way that trolling can be defeated is if people are educated in productive discussion, including why it is beneficial and how to carry it out, and also in how to respond to trolls without simply attacking back.
- dredmorbius 10y agoAcculturation is a component, hence Netiquette, the September Effect, and then of course, the Eternal September. Acculturation only scales so far.
- bingomad123 10y agoWhen you define anyone who does not agree with you as a Troll that phrase kind of gets meaningless. I meet regularly main stream journalists who complain about Trolls winning on internet but talking longer makes me realize that these people actually hate the fact that their "card carrying journalism" is actually made totally worthless by ordinary individuals on street writing a blog from their bedroom. I am from India and I know specific examples of media personalities trying to shut down totally legitimate blogs by calling them "trolls". Example: http://mediacrooks.com/ http://mediacrooks.com/ Bunch of them even came to silicon valley and tried to lobby with social media giants that their opinion must get more visibility than other internet user. Personally I dont think bad guys are winning, I think Internet has truly helped marginalized people express themselves without being judgemental about their opinions and without giving more importance to any authority.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- baobabKoodaa 10y agoTroll used to mean someone who just tries to provoke reactions online. Nowadays almost every time I hear the word, it's actually used to describe a person who expresses an unpopular opinion. It's an easy way to ignore criticism and disagreement: anyone who disagrees with you is just a troll.
- greggman 10y agoI find there's just in general a huge tragedy of the commons issue. Not just trolls but bad incentives in general One example is people actively mis-tagging things. Go on soundcloud.com, look at the charts. Pick Techno, notice at least 5 of the top 50 songs are not techno in any way shape or form. Instead the artists just wanted to try to get on any chart possible and so tagged with as many tags as they could dream up. I've seen a similar thing on other sites. I have no idea how to solve that. I suspect soundcloud is not interest in hiring people to police and some how negatively incentivising the behavior. They aren't the only site that has this problem. Stack overflow solves it with their point system and above a certain level you can edit/change tags but it requires volunteers to do the editing and finding a way to incentivise those volunteers to do a good job. (and I know many people are not happy with those volunteer's judgments)
- LeoNatan25 10y agoIt seems that trolls are also winning leadership positions across the world, so why wouldn't they win the internet as well?
- dredmorbius 10y agoPerhaps there's a related sociological or psychological dynamic?
- steauengeglase 10y agoReally it all boils down to a lack of community. Yeah I know, it sounds like something the dad from Leave it to Beaver would say. My favorite example goes back to the days of Quake(World). It was a surprisingly bright and sunny place. You'd pop on to a few community run servers to say "hi". Maybe play a few rounds of whatever mod you were into. When bad actors showed up, they were punted. If they came back they were literally gunned down (whoever had admin access would put them on a team by themselves and everyone would finish them off). As a result of having access to self-policing the number of bad actors were generally low in a healthy community. As time wore on the goal became customer retention. I can remember publishers selling this as "curated team building" around the time the first X-Box came out. It all went downhill from there. You weren't a member of a community anymore, you were a license holder and a subscriber, and soon the very concept of community largely dissolved. A likely "better" internet isn't a world of several thousand descending on a single comment thread. It's a hundred at most aimed at the goal of useful interaction. The internet as it stands doesn't need more pan-continental megalopolises, it needs neighborhoods of people seeking common interaction.
- anant90 10y agoHey steauengeglase! >> A likely "better" internet isn't a world of several thousand descending on a single comment thread. I cannot agree with you more! We have been thinking about this problem for a while, and recently started https://www.commonlounge.com/ https://www.commonlounge.com/ because we genuinely believe a community-based approach is the right way to win the battle against trolls. Most people don't realize how much care a community moderator needs to put in a community to keep it a healthy place, and building tools to make their job easier usually takes a back seat at most "community platforms".
- nebabyte 10y agothe "community" solution only works at small scale/for niches. Given any degree of mainstream attention, 'just gunning them down' is like fighting the hydra. Niche sites thus chug along fine, but any generalized effort to form communities falls victim to this. For niche communities on reddit, this has basically become a repeatable lifecycle (not including the countable-on-one-hand subreddits with leadership large and dedicated enough to wrangle their topics into submission.)
- dominotw 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Co5jTvGlt6Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Co5jTvGlt6Y Whenever I hear troll I think of this video from kitchen nightmares. Puts picture in perspective.
- ccvannorman 10y agoWe should build and implement TrollTrace.com to use tracking and metadata to expose trolls on the Internet. Don't worry, it would only be used for trolls, not for regular "good" people.
- dataduck 10y agoThe content of this article, and the reason for such articles, has been covered before: http://web.archive.org/web/20140625080831/http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2014/05/cyberbll.html http://web.archive.org/web/20140625080831/http://thelastpsyc... As ever, trolls are not who you should be worried about.
- kebman 10y agoThat fact is, there are no more trolls than before. No really. There aren't. Not even since the time of Socrates, and we all know what happened to him. There are however a lot of people who'd like to silence pesky individuals and organizations who have recently started winning even more pesky debates, such as all those anti-establishment rednecks, patriots, anti-immigrationitsts and right wingers who got Trump into power. Can't have that. Must put pressure on Google and Facebook to censor (wait, I'm trying to come up with something suitable - hm... Yes, let's call it...) "hate speech" and "fake news". Yeah, that's it! Now we have the means to shut them up once and for all. Let's softly censor all people saying bad words on YouTube with things like (hm find new ideas here) demonetization and restricted mode, and let's cow these people once and for all so our narrative can win. Meanwhile let's use our corporate power for, let's say on behalf of the people, to put pressure on the governments to back down on the things that they were voted in for in the first place. There's only one problem. When you make peaceful dissent impossible, you make violent opposition inevitable. Not my words. JFK's. We absolutely must have democracy and freedom of speech. One doesn't work without the other. If you can't win an argument, then accept it and move on. Or try to find another angle. Limiting free speech to win debates is not the answer.
- fao_ 10y ago> We absolutely must have democracy and freedom of speech. You're conflating "Freedom of speech" with "The right to be listened to" and "The right to have a platform". The government isn't going to hunt these people down because they have expressed Foo views, nor is, for example, Google. Google, YouTube, Facebook, etc. as private companies are allowed to decide what they do and do not want on their platform (Excluding certain illegal materials, of course). When they do this, they are not violating the freedom of speech of the individuals whose views they remove. EDIT: "anti-establishment rednecks, patriots, anti-immigrationitsts and right wingers who got Trump into power." Would you really call those people anti-establishment? They voted in favour of the corruption of the political system and the succumbing of the tattered remains of it to the forces of lobbying and large businesses. That certainly doesn't sound "anti-establishment" to me. Usually the term "anti-establishment" is used to refer to people who are opposed to large corporations, rather than the demographic who voted the CEO of several of them into office.
- jwtadvice 10y agoI remember when the internet was primarily shock videos and Newgrounds flash animations, and really crappy expages raw HTML webpages with flaming GIF animations. That internet was horrible. It was filled with goatse, tubgirl, lemonparty, crush videos and much more. The internet today doesn't have that. But it is politicized. And just like mainstream media control of the politics has created a race to control platforms and communities. The internet has fracturous communities that break down into camps of people who are collectively gas-lighting one another. And in spaces where there is an established groupthink - anything that questions that groupthink is immediately a threat to the entire ecosystem of that space. And so the term "troll" has come to mean "anyone that doesn't agree with the groupthink." Yesterday someone suggested that I was a traitor to my country and would be hunted down because I fact checked a group hysteria. I've been called everything under the sun and have received all sorts of threats. But in that community I'm the one who is labeled a troll. (I've been criticized, and even temporarily banned from HN on the premise that I was a troll. In that case, I had been explaining and defending the Chinese case for their sovereignty over territory in the South China Sea. It was not bearable on this forum.)
- houst0n_ 10y agoI'm getting pretty worried about all this stuff. When did we lose the ability to discuss things with people who have a different stance?
- shomyo 10y ago> People who i don't agree with are winning the internet fixed
- igivanov 10y agoI think many of those trolls are actually bots or human-bot combinations.
- thomastjeffery 10y agoIf you walk in a room, and a bunch of teenagers are being noisy, do you leave, or call the cops? If your favorite social network doesn't give you enough privacy to avoid trolls, or even abuse, go somewhere else. People complain that trolls have the advantage of privacy, and recommend a police state as a solution. Privacy is a tool. Use it. Don't let anyone take it away.
- mrmrcoleman 10y agoThe internet is a reflection of the people using it.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoI'd argue that bots and the ad-driven revenue model are more destructive. It's responsible for clickbait articles like this.
- tehabe 10y agoIn my opinion we saw troll too much as a technical problem and looked for technical answers. It had to fail.
- dschiptsov 10y agoIt is called mainstream or wast majority or slightly below average IQ (think of Trump supporters). Mainstream ruins everything, including itself (by ruining it's habitat). It the biological law.
- Kequc 10y agoThe reason why trolls do what they do is because of people with the mindset of this author. Trolls cannot enjoy the internet because they are browbeaten by someone willing to type an entire article about their own thoughts. It's a deluge of terrible opinions and people with too much time to type them all out. The weapon to defeat that is to give them something ridiculous to rail against, so that their efforts are wasted. The fact this has worked for such a long time and that just about nobody seemingly has caught on. Means that yes, now there is an entire community of people who do it. It's just part of the internet now and it's growing and it'll continue to get bigger. Sorry people. I'm not a troll myself, I largely just get off the internet now. But the reason it's bad is because of this author, not trolls.
- jessaustin 10y agoWell the Atlantic trolled HN, so it's possible...
- coliveira 10y agoThey say this after years of study of FB and Twitter, but anyone who participated actively of USENET already knows that this is the inevitable outcome.
- dredmorbius 10y agoOr early days of The WELL. From its own admins.
- yazbo_mcclure 10y agoBack in 1992 we had to take a class to get a user id just to get a shell account
- Khaine 10y agoThe term troll is meaningless these days. The term is an umbrella for a number of different things, from traditional trolling, harassment and posting stuff other people disagree with. With the rise of reddit and facebook, its possible to live in a bubble, an echo chamber and anything that takes you out of that bubble is considered trolling. I remember in the late 90s everyone thought that the openness of the internet was going to tear down walls, as you got to expand your bubble. All its done is re-enforce the bubbles people live in. I think this post outlines what is happening http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything...
- EJTH 10y agoWelp, rather have trolls "winning the internet" whatever that means, than have mainstream journalism "win the internet". All this autistic screeching from journalists, these days, because they are loosing their foothold, lying didn't help win the election and it won't "win the internet" either.