39 ms·
Many famous scientists have something in common: they didn’t work long hours
- mannykannot 10y agoThe title is misleading - Darwin was pretty much always 'on the job', as we can see from his notes and correspondence.
- _of 10y agoIn his early life he was a neglectful student, an underachiever. He was a late bloomer.
- sova 10y agoAs a poet I must contend that no flower blooms late for its own rhythm. They're all right on time.
- joslin01 10y agoThough I admit I'm mused, this is Hacker News, so you're gonna have to specify time signature otherwise this is just conjecture.
- mannykannot 10y agoTrue - maybe he needed something to motivate himself, and he certainly found that!
- brlewis 10y agoAfter that, it was all downhill: The 60-plus-hour-a-week researchers were the least productive of all. Could causality be in the other direction? Researchers who aren't getting publication-worthy results spend more time in the lab desperately trying?
- 1propionyl 10y agoAt least anecdotally the opposite is true. Researchers who are getting publication worthy results are in general hustling to manage multiple projects, run experiments, write papers, apply for grants... The most talented researchers I know are without exception the ones who willingly live in their own lab. By their own admission they love it though. I don't sense burnout.
- dheera 10y agopublication worthy != famous Publication-worthy scientists try to manage multiple projects, work slave hours in the lab, interact with people 60+ hours a week, shaving themselves to fit perfectly into the mould of the scientific community. Sure-fire 50% improvements on existing results should be chased, because you'll get a paper in your name. Low-hanging fruit should be chased, because you'll get a paper in your name. Papers in your name gets you degrees, tenure, and more grants. Forget chasing 10-fold improvements. 10-fold improvements are dangerous because they're likely to fail -- too risky when you're trying to get grants, get tenure, or get your PhD. http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1436 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1436 Famous scientists didn't care about tenure, PhDs, papers, or any of that crap. They cared exclusively about 10-fold, 100-fold, 1000-fold improvements. Some published papers in peer-reviewed journals, but many had a hard time getting them reviewed because of their controversial ideas, especially if they were theoretical. Of course, for every famous scientist, there are hundreds of others that tried and failed hard, and you never heard about them.
- amelius 10y agoOf course, merely by statistics, there must be a few exceptions too, i.e. lab slaves becoming famous by accident. And the question then is if those exceptions are more abundant than those famous people going for the hard results.
- nickbauman 10y agoConsider the scientific method starts only after a hypothesis is made. A hypothesis is certainly informed by prior art, but even the most limited hypotheses have some kind of a leap they're trying to test; A hand extended in some direction in the darkness. It's not science there, it's intuition.
- j7ake 10y agoRichard Hammings anecdotes of famous scientists would suggest otherwise... They may not look like they were working but They were always thinking on their problem. Working on a problem doesn't need to be done sitting in your desk but it can be done while on hikes with your colleagues or locked in the attic of your room. Their minds were constantly thinking of their problems.
- bdavisx 10y agoI think about software development all the time too, but if I was in the office as often as I think about it, I would be so burnt out and depressed, I wouldn't get anything done.
- Asooka 10y agoOr otherwise said - "Your get your best ideas on the toilet/in the shower/walking around."
- biofox 10y agoLink to a transcript of Hamming's talk on the subject: http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html
- sova 10y agoYeah, just because it takes me 2 hours to physically type out the code does not mean I was not working on it mentally for weeks leading up to it. I think this is kind of the age-old question of "where does creativity happen" (replacing 'work' with 'creativity' in this context). Most physicists, philosophers, and mystics will maintain that time does not actually exist, but is a conceptual projection in a sphere of transformations, so trying to measure things like creativity and time may not lead to very useful correlates. However, the fact that one should focus ones effort in small, useful periods, is precisely what I take away from information such as this.
- SketchySeaBeast 10y agoI need to figure out a way to bill for time I've spent thinking about the problem rather than the time my butt was in the seat.
- misja111 10y agoThey also didn't have iPhones or televisions.
- YCode 10y ago> Scientists who spent 25 hours in the workplace were no more productive than those who spent five. Anecdotally this is a concept I've run into in many areas of life, the most overt one being school, I suppose because it's so easily quantified. You can do a moderately acceptable amount of work on any given assignment and get a C+, work hard for a B/A or work your hands to the bone for an A+, but at the end of the day all three students graduate. At a certain point you get diminishing returns for working harder. On the flip side being able to be productive for those few hours consistently without burning out nets you long term growth.
- Cyph0n 10y agoExactly. I view school as an optimization problem where the goal is to find the minimum amount of work that will get you the maximum performance (grades, effective learning), while also minimizing the negative impact on other aspects of your life. I was a straight A student all though my major (EE), but I never hesitated to take a B+ if I felt the amount of work needed for an A wasn't worth it. In addition, I made sure to enjoy my free time and work on stuff that I love (software dev, for instance!). I think I was successful: IIRC, I pulled 1 all nighter in my 4.5 years as an undergrad. Obviously, I didn't graduate with a 4.0, but I got a high enough grade to get admitted to an excellent school for a PhD.
- vikiomega9 10y agoA point of note is finding that minimum amount without sacrificing future growth in terms of learning/skill set, ie. learning to learn or understanding a fundamental.
- Cyph0n 10y agoGood point, otherwise cheating would be a valid strategy (ethics aside).
- smokeyj 10y agoBut cheating is a valid strategy.. Colluding when everyone else is competing is exactly what intelligent people do. Not following the rules because they're stupid is what intelligent people do. It's not mutually exclusive to understand the fundamentals and cheat. The idea that we should compete with our peers for a chance at higher education is like a dystopian hunger games novel.
- laurentdc 10y agoYet Another Article With Initial Caps Telling Me How To Live My Life
- Veen 10y agoNo one is telling you how to live your life. This article merely points out that there's evidence that common assumptions about the relationship between the amount of time worked and productivity aren't accurate. What you choose to do with that information is entirely up to you. You may enjoy working 80-hour weeks and achieving as much as a person who works a 20-hour week. Others may differ.
- inputcoffee 10y agoI am as happy as the next person to accept that you can work less and achieve more. Ordinarily, I would protest that there is no data here, just some anecdotes. But in this case, I say, let's just accept this claim at face value.
- wainstead 10y agoFor some data I suggest the following books, if the subject interests you: "Peak: Secrets From The New Science of Expertise" "Deep Work" "A Mind for Numbers" All are pretty engaging reads!
- inputcoffee 10y agoOkay, before I read them, are you saying that these books contain evidence for the rather startling thesis that hours of labor are not required for achievement? Because if they are just laying out what you need to succeed (focused practice, immediate feedback, elemental skills or whatever the current theory might be) then, although valuable, it doesn't speak to the matter at hand.
- wainstead 10y ago> hours of labor are not required for achievement? Well, you need to put in something like 3-8 hours per day, certainly. But it's been documented over and over that 60+ hours a week does not increase your productivity. Each book does contain evidence for its claims based on research. Perhaps "Deep Work" is more anecdotal than the others, but Cal is up-front about this.
- z3t4 10y agoYour subconscious grinds away, even when you do not work. Then you see or hear something, a final piece in a puzzle, and an idea is born!
- DannyB2 10y agoIf their job was, say, picking cotton, then the hours they spent at work would directly correlate to their work output. So what is the difference? Maybe scientists are still thinking about difficult problems when they are away from work. Like when they are sitting in their porch swing with nobody else around to distract.
- itamarst 10y agoFor factory work at least this is not true. Multiple people and real-world experiments, from Henry Ford to German factories, have found that 40 hour workweek maximizes output: http://www.igda.org/?page=crunchsixlessons http://www.igda.org/?page=crunchsixlessons
- valarauca1 10y agoThe methods of testing employed by most manufactures of that time period are extremely flawed and considered blatantly unscientific today.
- itamarst 10y agoRobinson also points to studies in construction industry run in the 1980s.
- meow_mix 10y agoIf you pick cotton for 80/hr a week I promise you won't be picking cotton in the long run as long as the guy only doing it 20 hr/week (you will develop physical problems very quickly)
- pixl97 10y agoFrom a business perspective it is probably better to burn though many people at 80 hours a week, rather than fewer 20hr week employees (er, or slaves as history goes). Since it is a low skill job and anyone can do it the employee longevity likely doesn't matter. An employee that has picked cotton for 1 month isn't likely to be that much worse than an employee that has picked for 1 year. Of course this is my anecdote, and picking cotton is rather brutal by hand, hence we have machines that do it for us now.
- supergeek133 10y agoThere is being at work for long hours and actually being productive during that time. They are different things. There are still many jobs and/or management mentalities that see "butt in seat" as productive time. Especially in "brain labor" jobs versus physical labor jobs where your time working is inherently productive.
- itamarst 10y agoEvan Robinson has collected a whole bunch of evidence that long hours don't result in greater output (http://www.igda.org/?page=crunchsixlessons http://www.igda.org/?page=crunchsixlessons). This has been known for something like a century at this point.
- whistlerbrk 10y agoAnd then on the flipside there is Musk, Jobs, Gates and countless others who work(ed) all the time. All I'm saying is I see a lot of emulation-of-success articles posted here...
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>who work(ed) all the time. Except as executives, their work is different than a skill workers' work. I mean, they don't have a manager busting their ass about TPS reports, they made their life their work. So a two hour lunch meeting that is 50% bs'ing is 'work.' Leaving at three to go golfing with a few guys, one of whom who is vendor, is 'work.' Going to the birthday party of a partner's kid is 'work.' Staying late for a meeting where you sit quietly munching on a bagel and watch those below you sweat through a presentation is 'work.' They're human just like us and only have x amount of productive hours. Low key managerial tasks, networking, socializing, and sitting through meetings isn't exactly the same thing as sitting at the compiler agonizing over someone's legacy code and burning your brain out. If you're doing hard skill work that requires serious concentration, you simply can't do that for 8-12 hours a day. You can push 4-5 and then you're done and if you don't recognize your limits you're entering burn-out zone. Unlike a high level executive you can't take a 4 week 'working sabbatical' to a Greek island and work by answering emails on the beach when the stress catches up to you. You have your vacation days and that's it and you better hope its not crunch time when you do burn out. edit: grammar fixes
- wainstead 10y ago> Except as executives, their work is a little different than skill workers. This, which is addressed in the first chapter of "Deep Work" by Cal Newport. The concept of long periods of uninterrupted concentration and singular focus applies to researchers, programmers, artists, and other occupations. But an entrepreneur does not require "deep work" (though can certainly apply it).
- sjg007 10y agoThere is some deep work for the executive / entrepreneur which is to figure out what to build or where the market is going.
- senior_james 10y agoIt really depends on the situation. If you are getting a company started, you will need to work long hours until it's stable. But after this, it shouldn't be your normal schedule.
- mythrwy 10y agoThe guys on the article were walking about on huge familial estates and had servants. I on the other hand have a mortgage to pay. Out of the box creative thinking as the result of leisure is great. Sometimes it pays off. More often it doesn't. Sadly most of us don't have the luxury of finding out. At least for now.
- Fricken 10y agoI spent my early 20s working 2 shifts a week at a bar. It doesn't cost much to buy yourself the time and headspace needed to get from 0 to 1 as a creative worker. It was a rich life. It still is. All that's changed is that I travel more. Priorities, man.
- mythrwy 10y agoOh, fully agreed. It's not like it's 1874 and we pretty much all have a fair amount of leisure relatively speaking. It's just I've noticed a fair number of "great contributors" to human knowledge and civilization appear to have had a lot of trivial things in life taken care of out of the box. As opposed to those who come up scrabbling (who often wind up wealthy but aren't necessarily great contributors in an intellectual sense). The Greek philosophers, Buddha, people like Thomas Jefferson, the people in this article. All some degree of wealth and leisure and other people (initially at least) taking care of the small things for them. There are always the Ben Franklins though so I guess it's not a universal truth. Just kind of makes me wonder what humanity could be if so many people weren't born into a world that required a hustle or die mindset. Meh, probably just a lot more video game screencasts on YouTube:) But maybe not.
- DrNuke 10y agoI am not Einstein but in my 40s and definitely doing a lot with my time: on one side it was hard commitment and fierce hustling for 15-20 years in the past, on the other side hustling increases efficiency and high-level productivity dramatically, so that I can now do a lot (and well conceived / designed) in a very short time. Low-level implementation is invariantly slower though, be it by yourself or delegating. As an analogy with more talented people, I suspect scientists finding their Eureka! moments easier worked very hard for a long period in their past.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jackhammer2022 10y agoSo Survivorship Bias in play in this article?
- bbig3831 10y agoExactly what I thought. Lots of not-so-famous scientists didn't work long hours either. This is just another case of the "Halo Effect".[1] Let's select a group based on an outcome (i.e. being a famous scientist) and then work backwards to find similarities that fit a narrative. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Halo-Effect-Business-Delusions-Managers-ebook/dp/B000NY128M/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1490891896&sr=8-2&keywords=halo+effect https://www.amazon.com/Halo-Effect-Business-Delusions-Manage...
- officelineback 10y agoOne point about these guys is they were men of means. They were hyper-rich for the time, had vast properties and many servants and such.
- jorasta 10y agoDarwin was thinking during his walks. During his writing tasks much of the activity was mechanical or the consolidation of notions arrived at during leisure. What society regards as 'work' largely comprises the application of existing knowledge and the running of errands. >He was passionate and driven, so much so that he was given to anxiety attacks over his ideas and their implications. Emotions driving emotions? No, he was right to be anxious about the consequences of his work. Though marvellous and important and interesting, not to mention true, it set up a huge conflict in the psyche of the West due to the competing claims of science and religion. Which still hasn't been resolved.
- cableshaft 10y agoI'd be perfectly happy if the takeaway companies got from this is to let people get away from the desk and do some thinking about work during work hours. Let me take an extended walk and think about where I'm stuck on a problem during the work day, instead of forcing my butt in a seat for 8+ hours, and interrogating me if the time-tracker at my computer drops down below that.
- intrasight 10y agoMaybe they are famous due to serendipity and luck. I don't believe there is a correlation between long hours and luck.
- finid 10y agoThe rest of the time, they were hiking mountains, taking naps, going on walks with friends, or just sitting and thinking. Their creativity and productivity, in other words, were not the result of endless hours of toil. Their towering creative achievements result from modest “working” hours. If Darwin spent most of his time "hiking mountains... or just sitting and thinking", guess what he was actually doing? Yep, he was studying, and working. Just because he was not hunched over a table or a microscope does not mean he was not studying.
- arcanus 10y ago^ this. My best cited paper came to me while summiting a 14er in Colorado. Did actually generating the results take long hours and serious work? Of course. But the idea required freeform thought and subconscious mulling.
- kamaal 10y agoTeslas and Edisons did insane work hours most people would consider suicide these days. In my experience these are largely a function of volume, quantity and relationship with your work. Most managers I know can get by even 2-3 hours of work/day. This is true because the work is largely meta- Delegating, tracking things et al. If you are involved in your work at a lot more micro level, then the speed of the project is the function of your involvement with the project. This fantasy of achieving extra ordinary things doing just 5 hours of work/day is largely a millennial thing. As a Indian millennial myself, I find this attitude sick. Our fathers used to largely look these things as 'opportunity'.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jfv 10y agoMaybe I missed it in this story, but this anecdote about Poincare himself is apropos: "The famous French mathematician Henri Poincaré was very interested in mathematical creativity. He describes a period of hard and seemingly fruitless effort to solve a problem, from which he took a break to join a geological expedition. As he was stepping on a bus, he made one of the most important breakthroughs of his life. The solution came to him out of nowhere, and was accompanied by a perfect certainty as to its correctness" (from this blog: https://kjosic.wordpress.com/2012/06/19/creativity-and-wasted-time/ https://kjosic.wordpress.com/2012/06/19/creativity-and-waste...)
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoSimilar to what Gelman said about what he called the Feynman method: "Step one: write down the problem statement. Step 2: think real hard. Step 3: write down the problem solution." His point was, I think, that not every scientist can work that way. Some are real treasures, come along one in a generation.
- galdosdi 10y agoThat's not the most useful lesson I'd take from that. (That's not a very useful lesson, because I guess if you're not already a Feynman level genius, too bad) The more useful lesson, useful for anyone, is that sometimes sleeping on it (literally, or just doing a very different activity) helps.
- gwern 10y agoThere's a better Feynman method: http://alumni.media.mit.edu/~cahn/life/gian-carlo-rota-10-lessons.html http://alumni.media.mit.edu/~cahn/life/gian-carlo-rota-10-le... > Richard Feynman was fond of giving the following advice on how to be a genius. You have to keep a dozen of your favorite problems constantly present in your mind, although by and large they will lay in a dormant state. Every time you hear or read a new trick or a new result, test it against each of your twelve problems to see whether it helps. Every once in a while there will be a hit, and people will say: "How did he do it? He must be a genius!"
- 10y ago
- lkrubner 10y ago" or just sitting and thinking. " Put another way, these people worked long hours, so long as you recognize what kind of work they were doing. I mean, they were not shoveling coal. I think humans have some bias such that we don't recognize thinking hard as hard work.
- importantbrian 10y agoThere was a poll on HN a couple of years ago that asked how many productive hours each reader had in a given day, and if I remember correctly there was a large plurality that picked 4-6 and a rather large group that picked 2-4. Which seems to square fairly well with my personal experience and that of the scientists in the piece. I often wonder how much actual work people who spend 80 hours in the office are actually getting done.
- agarden 10y agoAre you referring to this? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7900741 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7900741
- importantbrian 10y agoNo, I looked, but couldn't find the exact one I was looking for. It had a lot of responses and was in a purer poll form.
- danohu 10y agomaybe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=493152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=493152 ?
- importantbrian 10y agoYep, that's it! Thanks for the find. So, basically, ~56% of respondents actually worked between 3-6 hours a day, what I wish the poll also gave was how many hours they spend at work. So we could really get a sense for how many hours at work are actually productive hours.
- charlieflowers 10y agoI used to spend 80 hours in the office. Most of it was waiting around for everyone to go home so I could get some programming done. Now I'm much more balanced. I realized I want to have work I'm passionate about, and go at it with all the gusto I have, but also limit it to a timebox so it doesn't take over my life. Everything that involves reaching "as far as you can" needs to also be boxed. Otherwise, it's like a cancer cell that "grows as much as it can" until it destroys you. So, define a box for how much you want to work. Inside that box, work like a single-minded barbarian. But outside the box, enjoy life, smell the roses, and participate in hobbies. That's my formula now.
- SmellTheGlove 10y agoReminds me of this: http://www.theonion.com/blogpost/if-i-had-one-piece-of-advice-for-todays-youth-it-w-18438 http://www.theonion.com/blogpost/if-i-had-one-piece-of-advic... I know it's The Onion, but irony being that Roy Halladay probably worked harder than any other pitcher in the same span. Natural talent still helps, though!
- jhonatan08 10y agoAnother something in common: they are famous.
- kensai 10y agoOK, forwarded this to my PI... will let you know tomorrow. :D
- paulcole 10y agoRoger Bannister found time to break the 4 minute mile while in med school!
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoThey take a very constrained example and claim that "You should be a slacker too". This is at best an irresponsible piece of writing that's clearly targeting discussions like what's happening here. This is the 1000th time I've seen a post on this topic on HN, and every time it's posted here it's like groundhog day, same comments. Well this is what publications like these want, they want more traffic. There are many famous athletes who worked long hours. Ask Michael Jordan. There are many famous entrepreneurs (actually I don't know of a single extremely successful entrepreneur who didn't work extremely hard) who worked long hours. Ask Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, and really any successful entrepreneur who's changed how the world works. Just don't ask some nobody writer who writes for a blog who just needs to get more page views. They don't know what they are talking about. In fact, you know what? MOST successful people work very hard. Surprising right? Duh. It's your freedom to choose how to live your life, but don't tell others what to do based on your idiotic research clearly aimed at generating page views. That's irresponsible. Also, if you want to succeed, don't listen to these idiots. Statistically those who work harder succeed more. Period. That said, if your life goal is NOT about being successful but more about living a balanced life with happiness, then go live your life whatever way you want. In fact that's how 99% of the world live their lives. But again, if you want to have huge success and achieve more than you ever wanted in life, work hard. Don't let these people ruin your life. You will really regret later.
- TheCowboy 10y agoThere is so much aggression here. Relax. Working longer hours isn't equivalent to working harder. Plenty of unsuccessful entrepreneurs worked long hours and worked hard, and there are examples of people/businesses doing productive work with more balanced workdays. 99% of the people in the world live in a way to not be successful, but to have a balanced life with happiness? It should be obvious that for 99% of people, that isn't a choice they get to make. It's also a grotesque separation of success from balance/happiness that shows a profound lack of insight. The word "slacker" is only present in the title of the article itself. It's normal that the writer, who you railed against, doesn't get to pick their title. So it's important to read the actual content for the premise. The writer doesn't argue against putting in time. There is the idea that quality of working hours is also important.
- tzs 10y agoNote that work hours mostly means hours spent at one's job site (e.g., at their university in the case of an academic scientist). My experience observing people when I was at Caltech, and observing a few top software and hardware engineers in industry, is that the most productive people do work the way Bruce Banner handled anger in the Marvel movie "The Avengers": Steve Rogers: Doctor Banner, now might be a good time for you to get angry. Bruce Banner: That's my secret, Captain. I'm always angry.
- mod 10y agoI often remember a blog post or something that I read by a programmer--I'm sure I discovered it here. Anyway, he said that his wife was conditioned to not interrupt him no matter what activity he was doing, because he might be 'programming' while doing something like tending his garden. I think all of us programmers have experienced the phenomenon where we get stuck, then stand up and walk away and within 5 minutes we have 5 new possible solutions in mind.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bencollier49 10y agoThis is stupid. The article completely misinterprets its source evidence: Darwin, from the article: 8am - 12pm: Work; 1pm - 3pm: Work; 4pm - 5.30pm: Work That's a 7.5 hour, day which is pretty standard in the UK at the moment. The fact that he fitted a one-hour walk into his lunch break doesn't make him a slacker, and neither does the fact that some of that work happened to involve answering letters in an aviary.
- Lagged2Death 10y ago[Darwin] was passionate and driven, so much so that he was given to anxiety attacks over his ideas and their implications. He many not have spent that many hours sitting at a desk, but he had to be directing a tremendous amount of mental effort and attention to his work to have this sort of reaction. The article describes his not-sitting-at-a-desk time as "downtime," and maybe that's half-defensible. But that "downtime" probably isn't something I'd recognize as leisure time, either. Here's something else that many successful 19th/20th century artists, scholars, writers, and scientists turn out to have had in common, the other side of the same coin, perhaps: sufficient economic prosperity (often familial) to employ servants. They could devote great swaths of time and attention to their work, even when away from a desk, because they were not fretting about the grocery shopping, not wondering if they should be pushing the kids harder on their ABCs, etc. The class structure and sexism that made such arrangements common also surely squandered enormous amounts of human potential.
- raygelogic 10y agothis is such a typical HN discussion; misleading headline provokes reaction to the headline rather than the content of the article. nowhere in the article are entrepreneurs discussed, or doctors, or anyone else whose work requires many hours of clocked-in work. the fundamental claim of the article is that deliberate focus in a creative field cannot happen without deliberate rest. you can't always be on if you want to achieve the types of breakthroughs which underpin the most significant steps forward in science, literature, and music. that's it. he never discussed Gates' work habits, except in context with Gladwell's 10k hours for expertise thesis. he then goes on to say that those 10k hours do not exist in a vacuum, and that this number is often misinterpreted; those 10k hours of focus also require a commensurate amount of leisure and rest. he even specifically says that "[scientists'] legacies are often easier to determine than those of business leaders or famous figures", which to me says that those individuals are outside the scope of his discussion. how so many people here are projecting that conclusion is a mystery to me.
- jordanmoconnor 10y agoI'm just spitballing my opinion here. One of my favorite quotes is: "Most people overestimate what they can do in one year and underestimate what they can do in ten years." - Bill Gates Working long hard inefficient hours might get you short term gains, but consistent effective work over years will bring long-term success. Typically (for me) putting short time constraints on projects amplifies my focus and cuts down on wasted time. The best way to cut down time is to have a well planned path of execution (know what you're doing before you sit down and don't do anything else). That's how you can be successful without necessarily working long hours. I'm not successful in terms of my own standards, but I think this makes sense.
- schintan 10y agoThey also had another thing in common; they didn't care much about money
- coss 10y agoNo desire to be famous but I can't see myself getting to where I am without working hard. I'm just not smart enough.
- blizkreeg 10y agoWhat did Darwin do to pay his bills?
- overgard 10y agoMixed feelings on this -- I don't think sitting at a desk for 12 hours is useful for anything other than social signalling, but, there's a Stephen King quote I love: "Amateurs sit and wait for inspiration, the rest of us just get up and go to work." Sometimes you just have to grind. Some of my most productive days have been when I really really didn't want to work, but I had to, and somehow the inspiration came out of that.
- nerfhammer 10y agoI bet famous scientists spend almost every waking hour actively thinking about their subject of study, even if they're not necessarily sitting around pushing a pencil at their desk.
- pebblexe 10y agoThe best book I know about research is "Apprentice to Genius: The Making of a Scientific Dynasty": https://www.amazon.com/dp/0801847575 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0801847575 It's a fantastic book.
- merraksh 10y agoI wonder if the maximum aspiration of any scientist is to be famous, or even "successful", for whatever definition of success is out there. I would imagine a scientist as someone who wants to make a positive impact on the life of his fellow human beings by investigating a field of science, or maybe is just curious about said field and just works to find out what intrigues her. Whether she becomes famous in the act is only a side effect, and maybe not even a necessary condition to fulfill her desire. I have the impression that just aspiring to fame is not conducive to "good" science. This said, I'd like to see articles comparing the working days of people who accomplish something important in science, regardless of their fame (or lack thereof).
- linkmotif 10y agoI'm just going to drop this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10882202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10882202 You can listen to the guy who wrote this article. Or you can listen to John Carmack. 0_0.
- adarsh_p 10y agoThis may have been true during Darwin's time, but it simply does not apply in today'a academic world. The level of competition for grants, publications, etc. is way, way higher than before. Not that I've conducted a survey, but I'm pretty sure every professor at an R1 university works at least 60 hours a week, if not more. Source: Am finishing up my PhD in theoretical high energy physics.
- AngeloAnolin 10y ago"The rest of the time, they were hiking mountains, taking naps, going on walks with friends, or just sitting and thinking" I think in most likelihood that the creative mindset of these people ticked when they were doing these stuff, hence, once they get back to work, their focus is so sharp and intent on finishing.
- plg 10y agological fallacy - these people are famous/successful - they also have characteristic X - therefore if I want to be famous/successful I should aspire to characteristic X it's a logical fallacy
- CamperBob2 10y agoThat's because a lot of people we think of as famous scientists were really politicians. Rest assured the people who did the actual research weren't working 40-hour weeks.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoSince so many people here are talking about how "in science it's different, you need to just chill out. Science is all about creativity and you shouldn't work hard if you're in a "creative business"", let me just leave this link here: https://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/work-hard/ https://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/work-hard/ If one of the best mathematicians of our time is saying "Work hard", it probably means more than some rando who writes for some blog. If you want to just "chill out" and live a fun life, feel free to do so, the world would suck if everybody worked hard. It's actually great that you guys decide to believe working less is good for achieving what you want, because the ones who actually know what's up have higher chance of success.
- taocoyote 10y agoI would argue that "working hard" and "working long hours" are not the same thing.
- zymhan 10y agoYes, merely staying late to work every day won't lead to a breakthrough. Being so absorbed in your work that you forget to stop working is a by-product of really enjoying your work and wanting to learn more. You can't force enjoyment of (or a breakthrough in) a subject just by slaving away for hours after the office closes.
- amag 10y agoBreathing is not just inhaling, you also need to exhale.
- antognini 10y agoI think Terry Tao's advice is consistent with the original article: > There is an important distinction between “working hard” and “maximising the number of hours during which one works” ... Generally speaking, it is better to try to arrange a few hours of high-quality working time, when one is motivated, energetic, prepared, and free from distraction, than to try to cram into one’s schedule a large number of hours of low-quality working time when one or more of the above four factors are not present.
- loup-vaillant 10y agoThat seems to be in direct contradiction with what Hamming said on the matter: http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html http://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html Maybe some people thrive by slacking, and others by working their ass off?
- martingoodson 10y agoAs a counterexample, Hans Geiger was a workaholic. Rutherford said he "works like a slave… [He] is a demon at the work and could count at intervals for a whole night without disturbing his equanimity" [1] He eventually discovered the atomic nucleus, so I guess it paid off. [1] http://www.encyclopedia.com/people/science-and-technology/physics-biographies/johannes-wilhelm-geiger http://www.encyclopedia.com/people/science-and-technology/ph...
- unabst 10y agoI suspect if you counted the hours they were thinking about their work, the conclusion would be the exact opposite. Granted, we are talking about "thinkers" here. We can think sitting on the toilet or taking a shower, and maybe even better than staring at a book. Walking to get your juices flowing surrounded by clean air and a soothing environment would make any hiking trail a great office for any scientist or philosopher. "It's not that I'm so smart, it's just that I stay with problems longer. " ― Albert Einstein "Richard Feynman was fond of giving the following advice on how to be a genius. You have to keep a dozen of your favorite problems constantly present in your mind, although by and large they will lay in a dormant state. Every time you hear or read a new trick or a new result, test it against each of your twelve problems to see whether it helps. Every once in a while there will be a hit, and people will say, 'How did he do it? He must be a genius!" - Gian-Carlo Rota, Indiscrete Thoughts
- glangdale 10y agoYes indeed! From TFA: "Yet when you look closely at their daily lives, they only spent a few hours a day doing what we would recognize as their most important work. The rest of the time, they were hiking mountains, taking naps, going on walks with friends, or just sitting and thinking." "Just sitting and thinking" sounds like part of their work, and the article deploys a sleight of hand to define this as "not really work" so that it can discover that these guys didn't work very hard.
- laughfactory 10y agoBut I still think the articles conclusions are meaningful: namely that, in our overly hurried world, we need to make space to breathe, to think, and to rest. If we're constantly racing off to the next thing, or sitting at our desks trying to force a solution, or sucked into TV or our various devices, we leave no room for our minds to percolate on problems, explore solutions, etc. And we tend to worship those who sleep as little as possible. How radical would it be if we started admiring people who take naps, who go on long walks, who sit and leave space for thinking without pulling out their smartphone or turning on the TV? Before smartphones came along I did some of my best thinking on the toilet. Now it's become time consumed with reading drivel on my news feed. And I don't sleep enough, and personally can see how my productivity and emotional health is impacted. Tough times which require greater self discipline, I think, than times past.
- raz32dust 10y agoDepends on whether whatever you are doing is something with a finite goal and has clear steps (e.g, deliver a prototype, complete testing, complete a presentation, prepare for a test etc.) or something that is more exploratory and you are not really sure what you are looking for. Most of the work we do is of the first kind. In that case, the amount of work accomplished is directly proportional to time spent*focus. For the second type of work, there is no correlation. You just have to train your neurons to try all combinations until something clicks. People who are not doing research or art (i.e, most of us, despite what we'd like to believe) can and will see more results if they spend more time. You need to be able to recognize whether you are doing type 1 or type 2 work and plan accordingly. Time and focus is not going to help in type 2 work beyond a minimum. If you are doing type 1 work and stretching yourself, recognize the trade-offs you are making and don't burn out.
- JeffR1992 10y agoThis article resonates with me in so many ways. I barely managed to get into any university in my home country, but once I was accepted to one, I set up a strict and timed schedule of 5 hours of concentrated work each day, outside of classes and other mandatory requirements, and left each evening for recovery. A few years later the structured work payed off and I am now completing grad school at Stanford. I honestly thought I would be working in a video rental store in my tiny hometown for the rest of my life. Let's home the structured approach continues to help into the future.
- femto 10y agoThe thing I want to know is how did they achieve the independence, whereby they could focus on their problem of choice and not have to continuously context switch to problems of other people's choosing?
- samirillian 10y agoPoincare is an interesting example, because he seemed to have a process of rotating between subjects of thought. I am also reminded of Guy Debord, who espoused the implicitly Marxist dictum, "to never work."
- itisalex 10y agoSo much of our "work" these days are only paid by the works ur in the office, where as most of the answers come to us at other hours of the day. Number of times I've emailed code snips to work....
- Safety1stClyde 10y agoIs this article really worthy of so many votes?
- ljw1001 10y agoI will add a personal anecdote from software development. On one project I had a difficult objective (to write a database that met certain criteria). I had never done database work before. For the first year, I worked with almost no supervision and developed a routine where I would select an area to work on, give it a week, and if I could find no good solution, would switch to something else. All the while I read many related technical papers. Often after a couple weeks of "not working on the problem" I would think of a clean solution and implement it fairly quickly. After that year, I got a new boss who insisted that I schedule my work using agile techniques, which meant that when I started something I had to focus on it until it was delivered, while trying to meet my estimates, planned to at most a two-day delivery cycle. My productivity in the second year was terrible and much of the coding I did then sucked, as it was full of hacks designed to make my first, sloppy approach work quickly. For me, downtime, and reading papers that were indirectly related to my problem area, vastly increased the quality and quantity of work done.
- fuzzfactor 10y agoYou've got it right, it works that way in computer science similarly to how it does in natural science. If you require balance relative to the mainstream, maximum scientific creativity is probably not for you. In expensive unique laboratories which often require years of assembly before productive creation of technologies can begin, it is easier to appreciate why the higher-performing individuals do not pursue much idleness. Seeking eminence is also a major productivity drain for someone who would otherwise be the most capable of breakthroughs at the bench. Anecdotally over a lifetime, seeking recognition for a million dollar breakthrough consumes the time & resources needed for more than one equivalent breakthrough that could have been.
- prginthebox 10y agoWhat a load of bullshit. Most of the scientists have spent a long time actually working, especially in the modern era. None of the successful physicist/mathematicians of those whom I have seen slackers. Each one of them (without exception) have worked extremely hard. Also, more importantly, I have seen level insight into solving difficult problems being directly and causally proportional to the amount of work people have put in trying stuff that hasn't worked till now.
- anoplus 10y agoI am quite interested in "how" the working hours are spent, rather than how many. Personally, it's when I forget about time, that I am more efficient, engaged and satisfied. Today I cleaned my house for 5 hours and almost forgot it suppose to be daunting. Did the same trick, imagining I have plenty of time. Just taking my time...
- erikb 10y agoI think there is a sweet spot of 30h a week. 60 hours and you are tired as hell and don't get the rest of your life managed. 20 or less and you don't really focus on it and take forever to get a little step ahead.
- erikb 10y agoActually what I can read in the article is that they have in common to work long hours. The very first example about Darwin already mentions that he gets 3x 1.5h stretches of dedicated work in, every f'n day. That's way more what the common 80h/week employee gets in with all the meetings, cross-office talk, and water-cooler waits. Even if you don't consider that "every day" probably also includes weekends. Famous scientists apparently didn't just work a lot, they worked very efficiently to achieve something like that.