29 ms·
Rents in Megacities Can't Go Up Forever
- jandrese 10y agoWhat does it look like if a rent bubble pops? Can such a thing even happen? Rents tend to be difficult to change without moving. I guess rents can fall if demand considerably outstrips supply and the landlords get desperate, but most landlords I've seen are pretty stubborn and will hold out until the last second before they lower the rent a single penny.
- maxxxxx 10y agoIn 2008 rents didn't drop much. I think landlords will leave places empty before they will drop rents too much.
- AlexB138 10y agoI wouldn't expect rent to have fallen in 2008. Thousands of people were losing the homes they owned and becoming renters, sky-rocketing the demand for rental property.
- trapperkeeper79 10y agoThat's right. At the start of the crisis, I had landlords offer crazy incentives - 2 months rent free on a 13 month lease. They just wanted to lock people in. In a few months, when it was clear that people abandoning houses were moving into apartments, these deals disappeared and rents actually started to increase!
- refurb 10y agoThat wasn't my experience. I knew several renters who renegotiated their rent down around 2008. We're taking knocking off 10%+. With rent control in SF that's locked in inperpetuity.
- maxxxxx 10y ago10% down is not that much compared to the previous run-up.
- nosuchthing 10y agoApparently hedge funds scheme to always leave a a fraction of the units empty as a means of pushing against the market.
- Atheros 10y agoThat doesn't make sense.
- dcosson 10y agoThis is a pretty crazy macroeconomic view to take, that you've known some stubborn landlords therefore rents across a city will never come down. Look at the numbers of how many jobs have been created vs housing units created in a place like SF over the past decade. It's not some mystical force driving up rents, if you build enough housing it will become more affordable. There's no evidence that housing operates outside the principles of supply and demand, despite what some Nimby politicians will try to tell you.
- jandrese 10y agoI guess you're expecting the renters to survey the market every year and aggressively negotiate down their rents if the supply grows too large?
- refurb 10y agoWhen the choice is between getting $0 in rent a month and getting 10% less than last month, most will take the later option. Occupancy is a make-or-break issue in real estate. Dropping your rent by 7% is better than having a single month of non-occupancy.
- mcguire 10y agohttp://www.austinchronicle.com/news/2007-03-02/451609/ http://www.austinchronicle.com/news/2007-03-02/451609/
- rhino369 10y agoThey'd accept lower rents if they couldn't find other people to rent. They just don't have to in big cities. But this isn't a rental bubble. The rents aren't really too high, they just can't keep growing above inflation rates forever.
- psyc 10y agoNot literally forever, of course, but I think it's naive to say people's inability to have the lifestyle they want will deter increasing rents. Empirically, society on balance doesn't care one tiny bit how much hardship people endure, and people will endure the hardship. I'm not seeing what mechanism is assumed to counter that.
- orangecat 10y agoI'm not seeing what mechanism is assumed to counter that. Increasing supply. Which in this case is difficult due to the alliance of existing property owners and useful idiot "anti-gentrification" protestors.
- Bartweiss 10y agoIt's also difficult for the more fundamental reason that space is one of the harder goods to 'manufacture'. We're not running out of land, obviously, but for standards like "land within 3 miles of the city center and -100 to 500 feet of the surface", that's much tougher. Not full, but crowded and with exponentially-rising development costs (since construction gets more difficult and annoys more people). Of course, that's a problem I associate with NYC, LA, etc. SF (and probably London?) get blocked politically before they ever reach that point.
- stale2002 10y agoThere is lots of free space within 3 miles of these cities. It is just in the air.
- nosuchthing 10y ago1. Repeal prop 13. 2. Apply local or state taxes and penalties against empty lots and housing/retail units without real tenets. 3. Reevaluate property tax annually and apply land tax for dense urban cores to encourage mixed development and high density units.
- geff82 10y agoEspecially for information technology, I don't understand the rationale why it has to be concentrated at certain places. As long as there is a good net connection, it could be anywhere in the world. Let's concentrate on the US for a moment. Why can't a successful startup not be in Dallas, Amarillo, Miami or Des Moines? Talented people already move from one coast to the other, so they could as well move to any other place. The rest of the country's infrastructure is so good that you could connect venture capitalists, founders and customers in any arbitrary way. I also say to the main point of the articles: rents have a lot of room to grow under the current logic. City centers simply get voided of average earning people and replaced by high earning ones. As soon as they are the average earners, even more wealthy people move in. Also with the rents, salaries go up, so people have the possibility to pay for their accommodation again. While in Berlin you could easily live with 40.000 Dollar/year, you'll probably have to add another 60.000 so people are at least somehow able to move to work for your new shiny SV company.
- bpicolo 10y agoThere are certainly a lot of factors. People want to live in trendy cities. There's a lot to consider besides rent - culture, nightlife, etc. San Francisco sure does have some of the best food in the country (and with tech consuming most of spare time the way it is, eating out is really a huge part of culture). Rent definitely ends up being the deal breaker for many, but for others isn't. It's a lot harder for a company to hire top tech talent if they're in Miami / Des Moines, because the Bay Area has a much higher concentration of tech workers. Convincing people to move is hard, especially so for more experienced tech workers who have a life/family somewhere. You need to be getting an insane deal for it to be worth abandoning your friends and family/forcing your partner to find a new job (and I've yet to see tech companies trying to compete on comp vs SF/SV outside of them). Can't run off middle-road new grads alone (Edit: Good point below that top grad talent wants to hit the big cities too).
- amyjess 10y agoYou could always do what the founders of TI did: start your own university and grow your own talent. The University of Texas at Dallas, established explicitly for this reason, is probably the reason why Dallas is a tech hub.
- Finnucane 10y agoTo put it another way, the cost of real estate in a given area is proportional to the rate of money flowing through that area. Will ever larger flows go through New York and San Francisco, increasing without end? History suggests that is unlikely.
- elastic_church 10y agoWell the frothiness of the tech bubbles are purely a factor of a lack of liquidity of meaningful services to create. VC capital focused on tech is a tiny sliver of available capital given the sources VCs get their funding from, and an entire order of magnitude of greater flows could come through. So if you were using that as an excuse not to buy that costly condo on the island or peninsula, its not a great excuse.
- mcguire 10y ago“The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.”
- elastic_church 10y agoYes, much much longer or macroeconomic events can spook a few relatively large funds and dry up funding. Keep building! There's a very large ecosystem and a lot of continually generated capital that merely needs to be convinced that the tech sector is the place to park it.
- ozim 10y agoMarket growth is showing that you are not correct. Market is going up all time, S&P 500 even if bubble burst around 2008 and 2000, now we have prices almost twice as high. So it is true that more and more money will flow to those places.
- ClayM 10y ago<Megacities> Hold my beer.
- supergeek133 10y ago> Rents in Megacities Can't Go Up Forever Yes it can, College Tuition is a great example. Instead of finding the cause and treating it, we just increase the amount of aid people have access to.
- yladiz 10y agoBut college is not a necessity, whereas living somewhere is, and you can somewhat easily get money from the government (at least in the US) to support your degree, whereas you can't really get that for your housing.
- PlaceFan 10y ago> But college is not a necessity Ehhh, that isn't the narrative we've been pushing for the last 20+ years. > whereas living somewhere is I think the fact that it's a necessity only benefits the idea of providing people aid for housing. > you can't really get that for your housing. I mean, you absolutely can depending on your level of income. It won't make up for being poor, but that's what section 8 housing is. Even on the more middle-class scale, the government provides tax breaks for home owners (and especially for first-time home buyers) which is basically money from the government.
- supergeek133 10y agoExactly, from the point we think a child can understand it, society pushes a narrative that you need college to succeed.
- ceejayoz 10y agoThe rise in college tuition likely can't continue forever, either.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoThank goodness we are too smart to try that with Healthcare.
- amyjess 10y agoI disagree with the article's premise that urban growth is driven by creativity. For example, this doesn't explain Tokyo. Japan's capital of creativity is Osaka; Tokyo doesn't even come close.
- Bartweiss 10y agoDoesn't ubranization drive urbanization? I mean, people (myself included) treat living in cities as end in itself. People pay more of their income in rent just for the access and experience of urban life. So yeah, I think Cowen's justification is off. There is a second layer where I agree with Cowen more, which is that urban cash flows need some 'engine'. People can only pay based on their salaries, and some fraction of spending in a city flows out (to food, industry, etc). So yeah, having a major economic driver raises your price cap, but it doesn't have to be creative. It just has to be something you can effectively do in a city and get money from elsewhere. I don't know what it would be for Tokyo, but in my home town it was urban-friendly manufacturing not creativity.
- huffmsa 10y agoBut why not? There is no precedent to the contrary. Rent has always gone up, people are social animals. The needs of business are independent of people's desire to be with other people. Virtualization need to improve a lot before the experience of "group" is as good as real life.
- jseliger 10y agoRent has always gone up This is not true, see e.g. http://observationsandnotes.blogspot.com/2011/07/housing-prices-inflation-since-1900.html http://observationsandnotes.blogspot.com/2011/07/housing-pri..., http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/02/67635.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/02/676..., and http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/laissez-faire-in-tokyo.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/lai... . The housing sector is excellent at providing housing services but has not over long periods of time and a wide array of places shown supernormal investment returns, adjusting for inflation. Robert Schiller has written extensively on this. Here is on pop article on his work: http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/personalfinance/2014/05/10/why-your-home-is-not-a-good-investment/8900911 http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/personalfinance/2014/05/...
- startupdiscuss 10y agoI think all almost industries cluster in the sense they are talking about in the article. The corporations responsible for creating and distributing are clustered. For instance, Oil and Gas in Houston, Pharma in New Jersey and so on. I don't think the economic value of clustering will stop anytime soon. The trend may stop because people find better solutions to housing than simply building more of the same. (And software should not be thought of as an industry, but a tool that enables other industries, but this is not the place for that.)
- brilliantcode 10y agoThe article title is spot on. Vancouver is not a megacity, therefore our rent will go up forever. It's unbelievable how relatively expensive rent is to income. I'm beginning to wonder why I'm putting up with Vancouver. I'm thinking I will take the first train out of here but that doesn't seem to be coming.
- trapperkeeper79 10y agoFrom Toronto. We have it worse. We are actually thinking of moving to Vancouver and renting :-p The rents in both places seem the same, except Toronto has shitty traffic, very limited tech opportunities, bad weather, and bugs. I looked around at jobs in Vancouver and it seemed a bit surprising how many tech employers there were. Can you shed light on why you are fed up with V? Where else are you considering?
- Tiktaalik 10y ago>Can you shed light on why you are fed up with V? Where else are you considering? - Very expensive with relatively low wages (Vancouver has the lowest median income for someone with a bachelor degree among major Canadian cities) - Near zero possibility to afford to buy anything other than an extremely overpriced shoebox condo.
- mattm 10y agoIt's more disheartening when you think that just a few hours away in Seattle a developer could be making 50-100% more salary.
- brilliantcode 10y agoIt's around $126,000 USD /year in Seattle. [1] They didn't bother listing Vancouver because the salary here is so painfully low with entry level software engineering positions regularly listing $40,000 CAD /year or $30,000 USD /year, which is what a Starbucks barista in Seattle clears. As your experience goes up, so should your salary right? Not in Vancouver. It's around a couple hundred dollars per month in after-tax pay bump provided you've slaved at a company for 5 years minimum. Pretty fucking hard to build a competitive tech company in Vancouver, when people are unmotivated due to depressed wage, high cost of living with no upward mobility. Almost everybody I talk to, housing is a big issue. Everyone is working, commuting on congested public transit, house poor but the image of living in Monaco, coupled with good ol' Canadian Ohwellism, people really don't give a shit about career mobility as long as they have a regular job that will let them sustain a roof over their heads. There is a large brain drain happening here, in 15 years, this city is going to be a very different place. I don't know what the impact of losing long time middle class residents who comprise of the economy. You will be poor but working in Vancouver, and that alone serves as a novelty for newcomers. There's really nothing special in Vancouver, to justify a 100%~300% pay cut (factoring in exchange rate and low Vancouver salary). Vancouver might be multicultural but it's also a ethnically silo'd and very tough to meet people in general as they are very cliquey and stick with their own skin color. Lot of broken dreams and disappointed Canadians/Americans from other provinces/states who tell me these things, which is why I'm writing this long comment to warn those who have a romantic attachment to Vancouver. Fuck Vancouver. [1] : http://wonderfulengineering.com/much-software-engineers-around-world-make/ http://wonderfulengineering.com/much-software-engineers-arou...
- aljones 10y agoForever is a long time. As a famous economist once noted, in the long run we're all dead.
- clock_tower 10y agoObviously not forever -- eventually the sun will become a red giant and consume San Francisco, at which point all rents there fall to $0 -- but I heard "forever" in that article as "the foreseeable future and its foreseeable future". Maybe 100-200 years; maybe longer than that... How do you read it?
- aljones 10y agoIt is unclear. I prefer clarity. I don't know what to think of it really.
- carsongross 10y agoFor those interested, rentier classes appropriating all surplus value in an economy has been dealt with outside the typical marxist context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism Georgism was wildly popular in the United States, but was memory holed after WW2 (along with distributism and Texas-style populist banking).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 10y agoIt has to at least track inflation, which varies between 2-4% a year, so yes they can go up 'forever'
- fred_is_fred 10y agoRents in fact do not have to at least track inflation. With increasing housing supply or loss of jobs, rents in will in fact go down.
- mcguire 10y agoWait. Bloomberg is saying that the price of something can't go up forever?
- davidf18 10y agoThe author of the article is a professor of economics but doesn't state the true cause of rising housing costs: Market inefficiencies (or market failures) caused by politically induced market scarcity restrictions called "rent-seeking" which benefits landowners such as President Trump over people who rent or are purchasing housing. Rent-seeking was first illustrated by David Ricardo in the mid-19th century (IIRC) and surprising that the author did not cite the true reasons for the rising housing costs. Harvard Economist Edward Glaeser and Economist and Financial Times writer Tim Harford among many others writes about this. Remember, rising prices come from scarcity. Eliminate the scarcity and your eliminate the high prices. Reverse the zoning density restrictions and you get lower prices.
- frebord 10y agoI like how you managed to throw in a blow on Trump there, nice!
- davidf18 10y agoI love how many of the very people who claim to be critical of Trump and his wealth are the very people who help support zoning density restrictions that have made him far, far wealthier than he would otherwise be. If they started caring for regular people instead of wealthy people like President Trump then there would be more, affordable housing, and President Trump would not benefit from "rent-seeking".
- differentView 10y agoIt's one thing to support laws and regulations that happen to benefit Trump, it's another to want him to be the leader of your country.
- davidf18 10y ago> "It's one thing to support laws and regulations that happen to benefit Trump," But these left-leaning people claim they want to help the working class and others and are worried about inequality, yet they are the major cause of the inequality by making housing unaffordable through rent-seeking which benefits President Trump instead. In other words, they say one thing that they are for addressing the ills of inequality and instead support a policy that creates more inequality and benefits the very wealthy whom, in words only but not in deeds, criticize. If they truly cared about inequality as they claim, they would reverse the unfair rent-seeking zoning density restriction laws.
- seppin 10y agoIn theory, can't the drop in rental prices be in small cities and the more "desirable" ones keep going up?
- trapperkeeper79 10y agoThis article crystalizes a point that was vague in my mind: "megacities have a problem making it affordable to raise large or even medium-size families. How many of us could live in San Francisco, London or New York City and bring up three children in a decent neighborhood with good schools? Only the already well-to-do can manage such a feat.". As a mid-30s person with a new baby, I don't see how the numbers work for new entrants to the housing market - unless you were a gambler. Your gamble would be that (a) you don't ever take a hit on your income, and (b) property prices continue to rise. We've been unable to take that gamble .. and homes have increase 40% in the blink of an eye. In Canada, we have a lot of family in the GTA. We're basically priced out of areas as far away as Mississauga and Milton (Milton went up 20% since Nov 2016). An option we are considering is to move to BC and just rent for a few years in Vancouver. At least we get a better city out of it. For any Canucks, are there any other decent places with tech jobs, and somewhat affordable housing?
- Arizhel 10y ago>How many of us could live in San Francisco, London or New York City and bring up three children in a decent neighborhood with good schools? The simple solution is to not have any children. Leave that to extremely rich people and very poor people. Society obviously does not support child-rearing, given the cost of housing and the lack of support from employers, so why fight it?
- jamiek88 10y agoThat is a logical but dystopian conclusion to make. It disturbs me deeply and I wonder why. Maybe it was your matter of fact, emotionless delivery of it that caught my attention. I can't really dispute what you have said other than it is not an inevitability. Societies can choose to change this, Sweden being a current example, Finland too. But people need to organise and want it enough, maybe they don't. Time will tell.
- Arizhel 10y ago>It disturbs me deeply and I wonder why. I'm very glad about this; it means I must have gotten something right. :-) >I can't really dispute what you have said other than it is not an inevitability. Societies can choose to change this, Exactly, but that's the problem: societies can choose to change this, but will they? As a pessimist, I say no, other than a few very small countries like those you cite (and even there those are just attempts at change so far; the birthrates in those nations are extremely low). Humans are remarkably bad at seeing impending large problems and collectively working together to change things to avoid them.
- sgron 10y agoSure they can. That there is a natural bound relative to other fundamentals in no way means that the absolute price cannot unboundedly increase. Any in any case, the most thorough spatial equilibrium analysis suggests that there is natural agglomeration of high skill/wage (locally positive feedback). The reference is Diamond (AER 2016), but the working version of her job market paper is a bit more complete: http://web.stanford.edu/~diamondr/jmp_final_all_files.pdf http://web.stanford.edu/~diamondr/jmp_final_all_files.pdf
- andrewprock 10y agoThe author is of course strictly correct, and practically wrong. Eventually our civilization will collapse, and the sun will go supernova. But for the foreseeable future, fiscal policy will be managed by inflation, and economic policy will be managed by economies of scale. The surprising thing is the author, doesn't mention either inflation or scalability once. When information technology no longer scales, and we achieve full saturation for jobs that support scaled services, the prices will plateau. Until then, I expect them to rise at a rate faster than the rest of world. I don't expect that trend to end in my lifetime.
- pklausler 10y ago> and the sun will go supernova Nope. Not massive enough.
- ctdonath 10y agoSupply and demand. So long as people want a limited resource enough to pay $X+1 for it, prices will rise. There's a limit to the inherent value of living in a megacity (adjusting for floorspace, quality, etc), so once insufficient customers are found, prices will flatten or drop. Being able to work from anywhere, there's no reason for me to stay anywhere near a megacity (which I find expensive and distasteful). As employers discover the cost savings of telecommuting, employees will discover the cost savings of moving out of megacities ... and prices will slow, flatten, and perhaps even drop.
- humanrebar 10y agoI agree. The only challenge for me is the lack of dining table economics on the part of employers outside of places like NYC and the Bay Area. What I mean is that they almost exclusively look at local market prices for developers. They don't generally factor in what developers can make in the big cities. Now, some do, but generally they just apply the inverse of a cost-of-living multiplier and make that offer. That's problematic because then our savings rate, something that should be measured in absolute terms, is being reduced. Anyway, point being, if I add up my benefits, savings rate, and cost-of-living adjusted expenses, I end up with a big number for most non-coastal-U.S. employers. I then have the risk of branding myself as an overpriced prima donna, especially if I'm seen as a cost center instead of as a strategic resource.
- nfriedly 10y ago> there's no reason for me to stay anywhere near a megacity (which I find expensive and distasteful) Yes! I lived in SF for a year, but then moved back home to Ohio and went back to working remotely. I occasionally travel to bigger cities to work with colleagues (maybe 3-5 trips a year), and this feels like a much nicer balance. I also earn enough that I could live like a king around here... or live on a more "normal" income, save the extra, and retire at ~45.
- diogenescynic 10y agoI work for a tech company in San Francisco and would gladly relocate to a cheaper city if the company allowed us to work remotely or had other satellite offices. Unfortunately, the satellite offices we do have seem to be dedicated towards specific departments, which doesn't help me.
- verulito 10y agoWhy not get a new job then? My neighbors will murder me for saying this but Austin is wonderful. Move here!!
- diogenescynic 10y agoI work in fintech and not in an engineering role, so the jobs that are available are mostly located in other high cost of living areas. I would definitely consider Austin if given the option to move there. The income taxes and housing costs make me salivate.
- cheriot 10y agoIs wealth inequality bounded? As long as there are people that can afford to pay more, some will.
- ssivark 10y agoThe article is mistaken about one thing: the size of the financial sector is not limited by the total wealth of the world. Eg: there could be derivative contracts (insurance or derived bets) for cumulative values much more than the value of the underlying asset (arbitrarily high, in principle). This is a big factor in what makes the global financial system so fragile. If the finance industry keeps skimming a fraction of all the money flowing through it then financial hubs like New York city and London could keep becoming more expensive.
- dba7dba 10y agoThe way I see it, to renters rent will forever seem to be going up forever. Because when general pay level goes up, rent goes up to match it.
- cletus 10y agoI've said it many times: this is one area where NYC is so much better off than, say, the Bay Area. In NYC you have an ultra-wealthy enclave around Central Park and pretty much the rest of Manhattan really requires winning an affordable housing lottery, being an incumbent or being in the top 10%. That might seem like a problem but it's not. Or at least not a huge one. Why? Because there are affordable options within reasonable distance with public transit (eg NJ, Queens, the Bronx). Compare this to the Bay Area where there's really nowhere affordable to live. So rents here are a proxy for property values. The author is right that property values have a natural ceiling but that's in the macro sense. There can be (and are) enclaves that are only the domain of the rich (eg lower CPW, CPS, 5th on the Park). This sort of thing tends to have a flow on effect which is why gentrification tends to radiate outwards. So you end up with a situation where you can buy an apartment on 57th for $100m and 30 minutes away you can buy one in Queens for $150k. That's actually a pretty healthy situation (IMHO). It also means that property values in Manhattan, for example, still potentially have a huge amount of upside.
- tutufan 10y agoI lived this out a few years ago when I had (great) offers in hand from TechCo in the Bay Area and FinCo in NYC. Running the numbers, the former was simply impossible without a four-hour daily commute, whereas the latter worked pretty well with a commute half that long.
- fallingfrog 10y agoWell, of course, no number that represents a physical quantity can go up forever.. neither electric charge, nor information, nor energy, or mass, nor money. Yeah I'm being a bit nitpicky I guess.
- prewett 10y agoWell, since I'm good at contrarian nitpickiness, I'm going to argue that it can. Mass can increase forever in a black hole, and if you keep accelerating, you get heavier and heavier so that you can never actually reach the speed of light. I guess you could argue that black holes will eventually run out of matter, and you would run out of accelerant, though. Conductivity is infinite in super-conductors (i.e. resistance=0). I don't see any reason why energy has any limit to how much it can be concentrated. I think people have argued that irrational numbers like Pi contain all possible strings (that is, of the characters [0-9]), although you may have to look pretty far out. So that would mean that the digits of Pi have infinite information. Writing this makes me think the world is a stranger place than I thought. I would have said that a physical quantity cannot go up forever, but I've talked myself out of that.
- fallingfrog 10y agook, so there are certain functions that keep rising forever but are still bounded above. So what I mean is that physical extensive quantities are all bounded above. Black holes will run out of matter, and there is only so much accelerant in the universe. Like you said. Conductivity is not an extensive physical quantity like mass or energy.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Well, of course, no number that represents a physical quantity can go up forever.. Money isn't a physical quantity, though it can be represented by physical tokens; and, yes, a measure of a physical quantity can go up forever if the physical quantity is continuously (rather than quantum) valued. It may even be able to go up without bound whether it is quantized or not (which is different than going up forever), depending on the exact measure used. In any case, nominal rents absolutely can go up both forever and without bound, and real (inflation-adjusted) rents probably can, too. And rent in any particular city can go up forever and without boubd much more easily than overall rents.
- bdrool 10y agoMaybe they can't, but that won't stop the people who benefit from high rents[1] from trying! [1] (And the people they have somehow brainwashed into being on backing them up, despite it being against their best interests.)
- legulere 10y ago> Many more economic sectors tend to be spread out geographically -- such as higher education, caring for the elderly, installation of smart-home equipment, fracking, restaurants -- and if more economic activity takes these forms, to some extent rents will equalize across different cities. I do not buy this. In the countryside the economy is backed by the local resources (forestry, agriculture, if it applies fracking etc.). The rest of the economy in the countryside lives off the money brought in by those, and especially off the wages of the workers. The more automatisation you have, the less you need people spread out. The trend is that things get cheaper and need less work that is more centralized. What you need to be able to do is creating new things, and that is easier in centralized megacities.
- sanj 10y ago" In the early years of smartphones, a big part of the gain goes to Apple. As cheap imitators enter the market, prices fall and more of the gains go to consumers, or business users of the product, who are scattered across the country." I believe Apple still take 90% of the profit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- user5994461 10y ago> Will New York, San Francisco and London become unstoppable juggernauts, soaking up more talent and becoming more expensive each year? London rent and properties took a 10% hit since the Brexit event.
- cylinder 10y agoNo they didn't. Some high end billionaire properties did, that's all.
- pascalxus 10y agoI hope he's right. But, here's how he might not be: If cities like SF continue to maintain excess building regulations and "affordability" requirements that actually make it less affordable for most people. Zoning and land use policies are causing huge problems. Anyways, a smaller and smaller percentage of people will continue to prop up these insane housing prices, while a few others either gets free housing from gov subsidies or price ceilings, locking out any new entrants.
- shostack 10y agoNot just that, but CA is unique with Prop 13. That is an artificial pressure cooker factor that other markets do not have. The best time to buy in CA was as close to when Prop 13 was implemented as possible.
- pasbesoin 10y agoI found housing prices to be harbingers of what turned out to be the "Great Recession". Looking around my metropolitan area, wages and income just weren't keeping pace (and we didn't have a localized influx of foreign investment, like in Vancouver, BC). I suspect that escalating rents, tuition, and perhaps some other things, are similar signs of change, although it may prove to be less sudden and dramatic. Sooner or later, the "slop" in consumers' budgets that can accommodate these runs out. Also, the U.S. is becoming a less friendly place to foreigners. Although I don't know whether that applies -- or will be made to apply, by this 'embrace the "winners"' Administration and Congress -- to the global 1% buying in to e.g. U.S. real estate. (The U.S. currently being the center of my perspective.)
- tzakrajs 10y agoIt's easier to move to the bay than to move the bay to you.
- throw2016 10y agoThere has been a massive debt fueled asset bubble since the late 1990's in surprisingly nearly all major world cities. And financial policy in most countries has been not only fueling this but also protecting the banks. Any asset price drops will most likely devastate them. Unless these policies change asset prices will continue to rise.
- Ericson2314 10y agoClassic example of trends vs facts in journalism. SF chronical article today (like any of you read that hah!) talks about recession-level net migration in the Bay Area last year. Meanwhile in NY prices have supposedly declined (can only site annecdotes and others claims unfortunately). The predicted future is already here.