12 ms·
How police found Twitter user accused of sending seizure-triggering GIF
- robk 10y agoThat seems like a very reasonable process. Nothing unusual anyways.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoAgreed. This appears to be the ordinary process. Can anyone point out what might be of interest here.
- MBCook 10y agoThe only thing I can point to us this is one of the few cases where some piece of atrocious online harassment actually ended up with someone being held accountable in anyway. There have been plenty of cases of death threats and bomb threats and other such things that didn't seem to trigger any kind of real response.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoGood point. Maybe there are many other cases but they go under- / un-reported?
- a_bonobo 10y agoIsn't it way easier now to find harassers on Twitter because Twitter made a telephone number linked to the account mandatory in some (all?) cases?
- just2n 10y agoThey typically don't qualify as criminal threats in those cases. The FBI does investigate quite a few of these and I've seen more than a few from FOIAs that don't result in arrests because they fall short of being criminal. I'm still surprised at just how often nothing is done about swatting. I find this case interesting. While it's far beyond acceptable or fair play even in good fun and trolling to do something like sending someone who suffers from epilepsy a gif known to trigger a seizure, it's being classed as stalking in this case. I'm curious to see the evidence and what precedent this sets, because it seems like a stretch to call it stalking from what I understand of this case, which is admittedly not too much. A good side effect of this is that hopefully it prompts companies to provide better protections against this, because it's rather unique in terms of medical conditions interacting with technology and has a lot of potential to cause harm.
- danso 10y agoIt was interesting to me because of how ordinary it was. I just assumed the user would be doing this from a regular computer, and that the police tracked down the IP. Not that the suspected troll would be dumb enough to use his own phone number to register for Twitter. And be someone who is "Clever" enough to use a pre-paid account but then dumb enough to sync data to iCloud. But I guess it's easy to erroneously conflate Apple's device security with iCloud security.
- bleachedsleet 10y agoThese are common mistakes of cyber criminals. Usually people get caught because they miss a point of data leaking. A commom one is people using a VPN and then accidentally opening their browser that's still logged into Google...All of a sudden that IP is now linked to you personally. If you're going to commit crimes online keep everything separated and use a VM or better yet a different device altogether.
- trprog 10y ago>But I guess it's easy to erroneously conflate Apple's device security with iCloud security. You might be overthinking it. I get the feeling that many people think of "online" as some sort of magical place where they are shielded from the consequences of their own behavior.
- cookiecaper 10y agoI think it serves as a good reminder that it's quite easy for law enforcement to access anything that you have stored in your cloud accounts. We tend to get casual and think of these as our personal backup pods that can't be accessed without our knowledge. It's good to remember that Google holds the keys and that they are used according to legal procedure (as in this case), and at times, according to Google's fancy (as in PRISM and I'm sure many incidents of unauthorized employee spying). Pay attention to what you upload, and pay attention to what you're using. It's very easy to cross-contaminate or leak information, and these things can have a very long tail. "The internet never forgets". Dread Pirate Roberts aka Ross Ulbrecht was eventually tracked down because early on in the Silk Road's lifecycle, he made a post on a btc talk account linked to his personal email account asking if "[anyone had heard about this new marketplace called Silk Road]". Since that was the first mention found online, agents began to investigate Ulbrecht. It may seem obvious in hindsight, but that was a single long-forgotten post made years before anyone had an inkling of what Silk Road would become. Strict opsec is very important.
- Stratoscope 10y agoIt doesn't have to be something unusual or extraordinary to be interesting. Personally I found it pretty interesting simply to see how the wheels of justice turn, just like I used to watch detective shows when I was a kid. One odd little thing that caught my eye: the way they used archive.org to establish some history of the victim's Wikipedia page. I would have expected that they would have used Wikipedia's own edit history for that. It made me wonder if the FBI agent just didn't know about the Wikipedia edit history, or if they thought archive.org was a more reliable source.
- imglorp 10y agoThe only part I take exception to is the hyperbolic kill portion of, "intent to kill, injure, harass..." of the complaint. Seizures are unpleasant, inconvenient, and you might get injured on the way to the ground but they are rarely fatal, and if the victim was known to be at risk of such, he would be in an ICU somewhere. Did the perpetrator intend to kill? That might be hard to prove.
- jacquesm 10y ago> “Spammed this at [victim] let’s see if he dies,” Seizures can kill and this is widely known, so widely that we got instruction in high school on how to deal with a seizure victim to make sure they don't die. Surely someone sending a seizure inducing picture to someone they know is prone to seizures is well aware of the risk they are taking, they are definitely not doing it to give them a monitor induced suntan. See perps quote above, definitely a slam dunk for intent. Griefers don't care about the damage they cause, the more the merrier.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoThat quote sounds like common smack-talk rather than a genuine statement of intent. I think you could hang "intent to do the victim harm" on the combination of that and the actions here. But, actual intent to cause death? I'd want to see much more than mention of dying - "do that and I'll kill you" or "I hope you die", or similar, must have been said a trillion times in situations where actual death was _not_ intended.
- antingate2 10y agoWhy is tweeting a GIF illegal?
- omgitstom 10y agoTL;DR Twitter gave the police information about the phone number which registered the account that sent the seizure-triggering gif AT&T gave the police information that is was a Tracfone prepaid account with an associated toll record that was an iphone Apple gave them access to his cloud account which had all the incriminating details needed including email / picture of him with his drivers license and data about the victim
- colmvp 10y agoIt should be noted that in the document, Twitter and Apple were provided search warrants whereas AT&T received a "request."
- tyingq 10y agoDesktop browsers allow you to disable auto-playing animated images. I'm surprised mobile browsers don't seem to have this. If I suffered from this, I'd want some sort of reasonable protection from asshats.
- rjeli 10y agoTwitter's native app allows the user to disable autoplay.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoThat's a good place point. I see Apple's disability servies praised on a regular basis. One would have thought this scenario would have been thought of. Is it possible on iOS to disable animations / autoplay within an app?
- richdougherty 10y agoIt seems like it would be useful to do this at the OS level too, not just per application. I.e. detect and filter out combinations of pixels sent to the screen that could cause a seizure. That would make the whole device a lot safer. I wonder if (a) this is possible and (b) whether it would interfere too much with desirable animations. Edit: There is (offline) software to check if a video could cause a seizure: https://trace.umd.edu/peat https://trace.umd.edu/peat.
- wapz 10y agoIt's probably possible on an OS level but I'm guessing it's an expensive task. If you're playing a 3d game that's resource intensive and you want to check 'every' frame you'll surely take a performance hit. I think disabling gif/movies/etc from playing automatically would be almost as effective and not as much overhead (toggle option of course)
- 824ueirwfjd 10y ago> reasonable protection from asshats Is there a strong argument that distinguishes this case of being "asshat on the internet" vs "homicidal with intent to kill"?
- danso 10y agoDumb question, but what is the meaning of AT&T "toll records" used to link the user to an iPhone 6? > "AT&T responded and a review of the subscriber information showed the telephone number was associated with a Tracfone prepaid account with no subscriber information. However, a review of the AT&T toll records showed an associated Apple iPhone 6A Model 1586" That is, if you are a Tracfone user and Tracfone uses AT&T to provide service, AT&T effectively sees the Tracfone user information? Also, Twitter tracks the type of client used to send a tweet and reveals it in the metadata accessible to the public API -- the `source` attribute [0], e.g. "Twitter for iPhone", "Twitter Web Client", "TweetDeck". And Twitter probably captures more about the device/client that isn't publicly revealed, such as the browser agent for when a tweet is sent via the web client. If the suspect had tweeted using the iPhone client, or via the iPhone Safari browser, would the police have enough info to subpoena Apple for Apple Account tied to that specific phone number? In other words, skipping the process of subpoenaing AT&T/Tracfone because the suspect was dumb enough to register the Twitter account using that phone number? [0] https://dev.twitter.com/rest/reference/post/statuses/update https://dev.twitter.com/rest/reference/post/statuses/update
- cxseven 10y agoI think AT&T just logged the IMEI of the phone that used their towers, which I believe is sent as a standard part of the authentication packets the phone sends to the towers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- guiambros 10y agoMy understanding is that "toll records" simply means the metadata that AT&T keeps to charge Tracfone the usage of their customers. At minimum they need to keep track of the ICCID for your sim card and the IMEI for your phone [1]. Once you have the IMEI and know that this is an iPhone, it is trivial to ask Apple for the records of who bought that device, or which iTunes account is associated with that SN. edit: corrected per comment below. [1] https://www.cnet.com/news/on-call-how-does-my-carrier-know-which-phone-im-using/ https://www.cnet.com/news/on-call-how-does-my-carrier-know-w...
- jacquesm 10y agoThis is as close to a real life 'snowcrash' as you could get and whoever did this (and the copycats) should be thrown the book at. 50K people die in the USA alone each year due to seizures, this is really no joking matter.
- partiallypro 10y agoThe problem is that it's easy to say someone gave you a seizure, since -most- are not fatal, even if they didn't have a seizure. There's not much evidence against or supporting that you had a seizure from a gif. This really opens the door for abuse on both ends. So, I am skeptical of "throw the book at them" as a solution, because it would be so easy to fake and ruin someone. The solution should be with browser makers and social media companies to not have autoplay and be more cautious for photosensitive people. I mean, what if you accidentally give someone a seizure? Should you be held liable? I say this being a skeptic of this particular person's story, given his history.
- rtpg 10y agoSo I'm not responsible for throwing a rock at your car because the windshield stopped it and didn't crack? There's documented evidence of intent here. The guy was trying to give their victim a seizure. There's nothing accidental here. Of course if someone accidentally gave someone else a seizure, there should be different standards applied. Of course! Also, yes, we need to make sure photosensitive people can browse more safely (for the same reason we put airbags in cars). The book you throw at them isn't "giving someone a seizure", it's "attempting to harm someone intentionally with super malicious intent".
- throwaway7767 10y ago> Also, yes, we need to make sure photosensitive people can browse more safely (for the same reason we put airbags in cars). I'm kind of surprised that we don't have "epilepsy mode" in a browser somewhere. Just limit the redraw speed. It'd mess with the browsing experience but much less than a seizure. Same for TVs, for an epileptic user it's much better for a highly dynamic scene to look washed out or just blur to a whitish color than to show it accurately and potentially cause a seizure.
- vmarsy 10y agoFrom an article related to the case [1]: > charged with criminal cyberstalking with the intent to kill or cause bodily harm and faces a maximum sentence of 10 years in prison if convicted, What is even more sad: > More than 40 Twitter users sent similar strobes to Mr. Eichenwald after they realized they could trigger seizures, he tweeted Friday. The agent went through these steps to identify the suspect: - Asked Twitter about account information. (w/ search warrant) - Got phone number - Phone number was Tracfone prepaid but asked AT&T for information about phone number. AT&T could map [phone number] -> [specific iPhone model] ("DPD sent a request to AT&T") - Asked apple about iCloud account related to [phone number] (w/ search warrant) - Find selfie of accused with his DL in hand in iCloud pictures, and also a screenshot of the seizure-triggering GIF, and many other incriminating/stalking behavior items. [1] http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/mar/18/twitter-user-charged-cyberstalking-over-seizure-in/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/mar/18/twitter-user... EDIT: Added (w/ warrant search) to clarify what "Asked" meant in my summary.
- rjeli 10y agoWow, did not realize Apple is so gung-ho about sharing iCloud data with LE. I love the Apple ecosystem but when I have to start fracturing out my services it's going to suck. edit: should have read the post. Thought "ask" meant they handed it over willingly. Apple was served a search warrant, AT&T was not.
- hatsunearu 10y agoPage 11-12, Weird how he takes screenshots of random shit like his research on how to trigger epilepsy. Who researches shit and takes screenshots?
- beering 10y agoIt's an easy way to send information to others. Maybe he was brainstorming ways to attack the victim with others and sent them screenshots of his research?
- Andrenid 10y agoMy SO is a specialist nurse. She takes screenshots of everything under the sun. She finds it easier to quickly look up screenshots than load a bookmark or even find her own research notes. When I asked about it, she said all the other nurses and doctors do it too and that's where she picked it up.
- traviscj 10y agoYeah, makes sense. Bookmark == pointer to bytes, Screenshot == bytes. If the bytes could save someone's life (or N doctor visits, or even 5 saved minutes), quite worthwhile to keep a copy. Same principal as pinboard.in's archiving, except comes stock on nearly every phone.
- arjie 10y agoInteresting, though, because screenshots aren't searchable.
- traviscj 10y agoIndeed, but not surprising when `O(n)` beats `Maybe<?>`.
- stuaxo 10y agoPrinting to PDF on google drive is my equivalent. Useful when arriving in foreign countries where you don't have internet setup - download them all first and have names of destinations, maps, tickets and bookings - especially good in Asian where a taxi driver may not read or speak English.
- cottsak 10y agoMore https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/17/technology/social-media-attack-that-set-off-a-seizure-leads-to-an-arrest.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/17/technology/social-media-a...
- compsciphd 10y agoI'm wondering if they asked AT&T if the IMEI was ever used on any other phone numbers/sims. its possibly he always used the tracfone sim, but I'd guess that its highly likely he might have used it with others a well that might have tied to his identity. perhaps its too broad a request?
- 69mlgsniperdad 10y agoWhat happens if some 10 year old in say Russia, for example (lol), used Bitcoin he made from a few minutes of mining in the very early days of Bitcoin, to purchase a black hat SEO campaign, spamming social networks like Twitter, Tumblr, and Reddit with a click-baity title and purchased upvotes/likes/retweets, spreading a gif like this across US social networks. Would our law enforcement convince, or manually penetrate the networks of the black hat SEO service spending possibly millions of dollars to maybe track down this 10 year old, to find out they have no jurisdiction over him? What if someone had an unsecured hotspot on their phone and local LE accused the person who owned the phone of this? Are local LE's capable of deciphering the possibly extremely technical misdirections one could easily employ? What if someone reads WikiLeaks, and used one of the exposed zero day exploits to frame a mobile phone user of this. What if someone's friend knows their WiFi password and does the same thing, spoofing the owners Mac address? What prevents a 10 year old kid from sending anyone they dislike to court for who knows how long, requiring them to amass legal fees to defend themselves. What happens if one of the enormous number of people who have RAT's from malware on their computer from being set up in this manner? What if someone creates their own image hosting server, and they swap all the images hosted, out for this gif? What happens if someone hacks said img hoster and does the same? What if it is a massive free, fast image hoster, and they are hacked and this happens? If the precident dictates that this could potentially kill people, what standards of security should image hosters be held to? Should they be required to pay for the same annual audits companies who handle credit card info do? Or should they be held to the standards of government contractors? Seems like they are effectively claiming the security of image hosters is an order of magnitude more vital than any other company. What if a kid uses the WikiLeaks zerodays which were purposely not exposed by the CIA, provided the entry for this 'prankster'? Can any potential victims sue the government. Since we've established that feelings matter, how is a gif like this different then offending someone to an absurd degree? I've seen several articles from multiple news sources from different countries, detailing the enforcement of hate speech crimes; for example, Western countries making it illegal to speak out against islam? Are offenses of those nature subject to similar accountibility? Are law enforcement agencies equipped well enough to be certain that no misdirection or projection of the actions onto another was utilized? Obviously one could go on for eternity like this. Making it simple for anyone with Google to lock someone up who they dislike. Seems to me that a person who is susceptible to these triggers, should find a solution on their end to somehow inhibit the effectiveness of such weapons. If all jurisdictions were to take this seriously, whether it's a 'meme' charge or attempted murder, one could backlog an entire countries legal system for years for a small sum of money. Tbh, this is the dumbest thing I've ever heard of, and the few comments I read, are equally ignorant. What if, the defendant in op's story denies the accusations. What if his friend did it from his phone while he was sleeping, and never told a soul? Good luck using the internet, everyone. Hide your kids, hide your wife.
- c517402 10y agoAnyone have a link to the GIF?
- tunocina 10y agoIf I remember correctly, this was the one: https://img.4plebs.org/boards/pol/image/1482/29/1482295481983.gif https://img.4plebs.org/boards/pol/image/1482/29/148229548198... (beware, it blinks ;P)
- i336_ 10y agoYIKES, that's using like the minimum frame delay! [Unsafe] Here's a mirror in case it goes down: http://i.imgur.com/Qi6tSit.gif http://i.imgur.com/Qi6tSit.gif [Safe] And here are the two frames extracted to two separate images. Anyone with epilepsy should be able to view this without issues. http://imgur.com/a/kQTQc http://imgur.com/a/kQTQc
- tunocina 10y agoIt won't blink as fast when played in the Twitter website or app. Twitter automatically converts it to a video when you post it, and there's a bit of a delay between every loop when you loop a video, as compared to a GIF.
- i336_ 10y agoAh, right, good point. (It's mildly amusing that the affidavit went to such lengths to describe GIFs, when nowadays it's really a webm or mp4.) It seems that either twitter has vacuumed up any copies of the gif from their website, or google reverse image search has removed all/has no indexed copies of it on site:twitter.com. (I don't exactly want to upload the gif to twitter to test it...)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- amingilani 10y agoIf you're curious about the actual gif, I found it here[1]. Funny how something this simple can be so harmful. WARNING, THIS IS THE ACTUAL GIF AND INDUCED A SEIZURE IN ATLEAST ONE INSTANCE THAT WE KNOW OF. DON'T OPEN IF YOU'RE EPILEPTIC! [1]: https://giphy.com/gifs/acid-SDdgL8VFPq4ec https://giphy.com/gifs/acid-SDdgL8VFPq4ec
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoSome people find much later in life they are epileptic. Not sure if that's true of photo-induced epilepsy too? Perhaps sit down first before viewing?
- amerkhalid 10y agoI feel a little nauseated after watching this for a few seconds. I don't think I am epileptic but could this mean I might be?
- lledargo 10y agoI would look up other symptoms of epilepsy. If that does not quell your concerns, consult with a doctor. As a person with epilepsy I viewed the image (FOR SCIENCE!) and almost immediately had a headache. which is on par with what I was expecting from previous experiences with flashing lights. That being said, EEG testing has reveled that my thresh hold for Photosensitive seizures is much higher than other triggers making me feel safe viewing the image.
- jackvalentine 10y agoYou're an insane person and I regret engaging with you.
- dang 10y agoPersonal attacks will get your account banned from Hacker News. Please don't do this again, regardless of how wrong someone is or how bad some comments are. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13920864 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13920864 and marked it off-topic.
- Sciencehaters 10y agoCan you stop doing everything you can to make people hate science. Stop being elitist maybe?
- tunocina 10y agoThe guy was charged with "aggravated assault w/ deadly weapon": https://twitter.com/Lauren_Southern/status/844214058635223045 https://twitter.com/Lauren_Southern/status/84421405863522304...
- taternuts 10y agoIs there some extension or piece of software that could potentially detect this kind of thing and mute it? Like download gifs, look through the frames and calculate some kind of score and if it hits a threshold, auto-pause the gif?
- jlgaddis 10y agoOn the bottom right of this page, a link entitled "Related Article" takes you to a US Department of Justice Press Release [0], although it doesn't really say anything new other than that the guy was arrested and had an initial court appearance last Friday. [0]: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/maryland-man-arrested-cyberstalking https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/maryland-man-arrested-cyberst...