22 ms·
What makes gambling wrong but insurance right?
- MR4D 10y agoArticle gives a good background, but doesn't clearly answer it's own question. The simple answer (although not followed as closely as it should be in regulation): Gambling involves the creation of risk where none previously existed, while insurance is solely about the transfer of risk from one party to another (or more than one).
- lotharbot 10y agoThe way I phrase the simple answer: both gambling and insurance are slightly-negative-expectation plays with occasional large payoffs. With gambling the payoff is random, but with insurance the payoff is coupled predictably to an external negative event.
- hliyan 10y agoI see it this way: insurance is risk sharing. Gambling is competition. Insurance is about risks to yourself and your property. In betting, you are not compensated for your own loss, but some event that may be a loss or a gain or even neutral. I'd say taking out an insurance against a random person's life would still be betting.
- Mz 10y agoTaking out insurance on a random person's life is also illegal. I worked in insurance. I am not a fan of it. But you need insurable interest in someone to take out life insurance on them. Otherwise, people would just insure random strangers and then kill them. This is not hypothetical. One of the forms of insurable interest is key employee life insurance. There have been cases where a business decided to call entry level employees "key employees" so as to take out life insurance, and then these "key employees" kept dying." There have also been historical cases where female serial killers were offing relatives for the insurance money.
- ucaetano 10y ago"both gambling and insurance are slightly-negative-expectation plays with occasional large payoffs" When you take in account that personal utility functions aren't linear, insurance and gambling are no longer slightly-negative-expectation, but usually positive. In other words, if U() is your utility function, U($1M) != 1MU($1). For most people, U($1M) > 1MU($1) and U(-$1M) < 1M*U(-$1).
- abtinf 10y ago> usually positive Is there an example of a voluntary transaction where the expectation is negative?
- ucaetano 10y agoYes, gambling for small wins can be negative, if you don't include the "excitement" or "entertainment" in the utility function. But then you're not talking about a pure monetary transaction. More like a trade. Which goes back to your point: nobody makes a voluntary transaction where they get less value than they provide. Take charity donations, for example: people value the warm feeling from helping others and a clear consciousness more than the money they are giving.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- anonymoushn 10y agoSure, for example buying heroin. You have to get through a few steps to agree though! You could disagree by saying that people's "revealed preferences" are their "actual preferences", or by saying that people's utility function after accounting for hyperbolic discounting is their "actual utility function."
- baddox 10y agoOf course in the case of heroin addiction it's easy to poke fun at the notion of time-discounted utility functions, but you can't really shrug off the idea, since it's vital to explaining why people do all sorts of immediately neutral or unpleasant things like brushing their teeth, saving money, or exercising.
- briandear 10y agoMore accurately, insurance isn't about a 'payoff' it's about being made whole after a covered loss. You don't profit from insurance payoffs. Insurance is designed to mitigate risk as opposed to profiting from it. Insurance is defensive while gambling is offensive.
- simonbyrne 10y agoNot quite: one of the usual characteristics of insurance is the existence of an insurable interest[1]: you must personally have exposure to the risk before you can take out insurance against it. So insurance is really changing a large occasional negative payoff into a smaller more consistent one. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insurable_interest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insurable_interest
- wpietri 10y agoWell put. And I'd add that insurance is specifically about transferring risk from people who can't handle it to those who can. (Financial derivatives can easily be used to do it the other way.) You could also say that gambling is net negative sum, while insurance is net positive sum. The positive part being the long-term economic benefit of people not having their lives harmed or ended by low-frequency, high-expense events.
- abtinf 10y agoMaking value judgements on transactions between consenting parties is a fraught endeavor.
- wpietri 10y agoAnd yet as voters we must make these value judgments. Gambling for many is a dangerous addiction, one with significant societal costs. You could look at the financial crash of 2007-8 as being mainly about gambling at the institutional scale. When transactions are truly consenting (which is not the case with addicts) and have no negative externalities, sure, we should default to letting people do their thing. But when that's not true, voters, who are the real insurers of last resort for societal risks, end up having to make value judgments.
- mirimir 10y ago> Before the international banking crisis broke in 2007, the total face value of outstanding derivatives contracts was many times larger than the world economy itself. Really? I had no clue that it was that bad.
- hueving 10y agoIt sounds bad, but it's not particularly hard to get into that position. If everyone just insures their home, the value out outstanding derivates on peoples is already 1x. Now add in everyone that has mortgage insurance that is protecting lenders on home defaults, and you're already beyond 1x for total outstanding derivatives.
- abtinf 10y agoYour statement clearly states the essential distinction. A more concrete way of stating this is: the purpose of gambling is to try to earn an outsized return, while the purpose of insurance is to make you whole in case of loss.
- narrator 10y agoNo. Insurance is to pay for an outcome that the insured did not want. A person with car insurance does not want to get into an accident. A person with health insurance does not want to get sick. A person with home insurance does not want their house to get flooded. A gambler, on the other hand, is indifferent to the outcome of the roulette wheel except for the monetary payout. Same goes for buying options unless there is ownership of the underlying security. A gambler had an incentive to cheat to make the transaction go their way. An insurer has an incentive to help make the event the insured does not want to happen not happen.
- geon 10y agoInsurance is not transfer of risk. Having many ensurees takes the risk away. It becomes inevitable and predictable. Simply a cost.
- baddox 10y agoThe cost is the risk. Many people will pay more into insurance than they get out of it (that's obviously a mathematical inevitability), so those people viewed in isolation would be better off self-insuring. Of course, no one knows ahead of time if they're the ones who will be healthy.
- geon 10y agoIm talking about the insurance companies. They dont take any risks, since they know in advance how many accidents that will happen. To them it is just a forseeable cost. The risk of each client is not transferred, but eliminated.
- colomon 10y agoThat's simply not true. They work very hard to understand and control the risks they take. But there is an entire field of reinsurance[1], which is insurance for insurance companies against the times they get it wrong, such as major disasters. And even then I suspect you'd find a big enough disaster would break the reinsurance companies too. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinsurance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinsurance
- tankenmate 10y agoWhich is why reinsurance companies take out so called "super cat" (super catastrophe) insurance. Some of the world's bigger super cat insurers are Berkshire Hathaway subsidiaries; National Indemnity is probably the best known one.
- greenshackle2 10y agoIt's still a risk. If everyone's houses burn down at once the insurance company will be SOL unless they insured themselves against catastrophes (which they probably do). Also, arguing by definition is pointless, put since we're already debating pointless semantics, google 'risk transfer' and see what comes up.
- noway421 10y agoAnother way to put it is that the lack of insurance in its turn is indeed gambling. You are imposing a risk onto yourself in order to achieve cash gains, while you could walk away without the risk but with less reward.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sametmax 10y agoAnd liability. Gambling is your risk. Driving is a risk we take together.
- hvidgaard 10y agoInsurance is pooling the risk, such that incidents become cheaper but more common (here being insurance cost).
- raverbashing 10y agoThat's a nice TL;DR Pooling risks makes things more predictable (not sure what's the avg. profit of insurance companies) A small correction, it's: "its own question"
- ghaff 10y ago>not sure what's the avg. profit of insurance companies It varies by company and type of insurance but profit margin seems to be in 5% range or so.
- tuna-piano 10y agoDriving a motorcycle also involves the creation of risk where none previously existed. But people seem to make a rational choice to get on their motorcycle. The risk of losing money gambling to me seems less relevant than the risk of getting addicted to gambling and making irrational decisions. There's a 100% chance that when I buy a BMW that I'll lose money, but of course no one believes there's a problem with car addicts that the government needs to solve. There is, however, a real problem of gambling addicts, not too different from heroin addicts. That said, solving the problem with prohibition creates the normal prohibition problems (rational adult gamblers lose their rights, black markets are setup, etc). I tend to like the self banning programs that many states have set up. If you feel you are addicted, you can sign a form banning yourself from casinos for a period of time / life. If you go back, you can be arrested for trespassing. And of course, the governments do-gooder motivations seem suspect when the government makes lotteries illegal, but then sets up their own lottery monopoly with absurdly low payout rates.
- coldtea 10y ago>Driving a motorcycle also involves the creation of risk where none previously existed. But people seem to make a rational choice to get on their motorcycle. That's because there are concrete benefits from doing so (going from one place to another). And even with that, there are all sorts of regulations for getting a license to drive a motorcycle, where and how to drive one, what to wear while riding one (a helmet is mandatory in many countries), etc. And even so, if motorcycle related accidents where that many that it would matter, driving one would have been outlawed altogether probably. >There's a 100% chance that when I buy a BMW that I'll lose money Yeah, but you also get a BMW. With gambling you on average just get nothing.
- averagewall 10y agoI think he means that he gets the pleasure of having/using a BMW compared to a gambler who also gets the pleasure of gambling. Both are forms of entertainment and both cause you to lose money.
- 10y ago
- orblivion 10y agoThere are further benefits to insurance once it gets more advanced. Actuaries, along with experts studying the domain being insured, find an appropriate price for insuring various different options (ex: living by the shoreline vs however many meters inland) which provides a sort of regulation. It gives consumers a well informed number for any given risk. Even more advanced, they'll start to research new ways to make the activity safer. See: Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Granted, gambling does give you betting markets which may help predict the future as well. But I would guess for broader topics only. Perhaps someone could enlighten me otherwise.
- bluetwo 10y agoI would add that insurance is also for the purpose of facilitating business and society advancement, while gambling is purely for pleasure.
- mikeash 10y agoI'd say the fundamental difference is that gambling sometimes provides a huge payout after a small loss, whereas insurance provides a payout roughly equal to the loss. Insurance isn't supposed to have big paydays, it's just supposed to make you whole. Your house insurance might pay out a million dollars, but only if that's what it actually costs to rebuild your house. It's telling that when insurance starts to get away from this model, like people insuring stuff for far more than it's worth, or taking out life insurance policies on strangers, both the law and morality start to frown it.
- massysett 10y agoLife insurance can have huge paydays. The size of the payout is tied only to the premiums paid, not to the size of the loss.
- CocaKoala 10y agoYeah, but somebody needs to die in order to collect it. Again, the goal is to make a party whole after a loss.
- gricardo99 10y agoBut the premiums are tied to the size of the loss, which is what the payout is supposed to cover. The loss you're supposed to be covering is your lost income and other less tangible but quantifiable benefits to your family. Although I'm no expert, I'm guessing underwriting becomes more difficult for policies that are completely out-of-line with your income. There has to be some justification for the payout to meet underwriting standards, which in essence is considering the size of the loss. If you're asking for a policy that is very unusual, it will be much more expensive, if you can get one at all.
- SilasX 10y agoI think I would refine that a bit as, insurance [1] involves payout on an event the insured doesn't want to happen [even given the payout], while a gamble is where the insured does want it to happen [because of the payout]. This matches the historical and in-practice role of the insurer: they try to keep you from overinsuring things, or insuring things you don't have an interest in preventing from happening ("insurable interest"). Both of these create a so-called "moral hazard", the same category that make gambling bad, and vastly increases the fraud they have to deal with. [1] or rather "the kinds of risk transfer we want to allow" vs those we don't
- valuearb 10y agoYour definition is good, but you should add that gambling is done for entertainment purposes.
- test6554 10y agoRisk aggregated among a large pool is lower than the sum of all the individual risks. Systemically, it makes sense to pool risk.
- lucisferre 10y agoIn a word. Math.
- colorincorrect 10y agowhat do you mean? in both cases the odds are against you.
- lucisferre 10y agoDon't be ridiculous. Insurance companies exchange a guaranteed coverage of some risk at a calculated cost by pooling risk. Gambling is a repeated game tilted the house's favour where the players can lose big with every turn of the wheel. There is nothing guaranteed to the players other than the fact that over a long enough time frame they will certainly lose and over short times they may also lose. It should be noted of course that gambling is generally not illegal as long as the government (read: the people) is benefiting. Whether one agrees with gambling as a tax or not is another discussion. Unregulated gambling is typically illegal because it benefits no one.
- logfromblammo 10y agoIn gambling, you are concentrating risk. In insurance, you are diffusing risk. Both rely on the expected value calculation. If you own an object that has a 10% chance in any given year to spontaneously self-annihilate (and a 90% chance to continue existing as usual), then you would expect that its value next year will be ( 0.1 * 0 + 0.9 * v = ) 0.9 times its value right now. Gambling is to watch it for a year. If it continues to exist, you still have it, and it is worth the same. You beat the odds. But if it vanishes, you lost everything. Insurance is to accept the reality that you can't keep winning that game forever. You can spread the risk of loss over multiple years, while abandoning any gambling windfalls you might have enjoyed. You pay 10% of the value of the object every year to your [mathematically simplified] insurer, who agrees to pay 100% of its value in the event it is lost. In any year it still exists, you "lost" 0.1 of the value you "won" by still having it. In the year it vanishes, you lost 1.0 the value of the item itself, but got a net 0.9 of the value of the item in non-self-destructing cash, "losing" 0.1 total. From your end, you get exactly the value you expect mathematically from owning the item, year after year, with zero risk to you. The non-simplified math is a bit more complex, but ensures that while you will always eventually lose the self-destructing object itself, you will never lose all of its value all at once. It also means your insurer is essentially investing the gains you would have otherwise realized by gambling. Once their bet is closed by disappearance of your object, they pay you off from their investment portfolio and pocket the difference or absorb the loss. The smart play for you would be to neither gamble nor insure, sell the self-destructing asset right away, and invest the proceeds normally, in something that has a positive expected value. Eliminating the risk is always worth more than managing it.
- colinmegill 10y agoUh... the downside isn't inevitable?
- diab0lic 10y agoI'm not sure this answers the question outlined in the title. Gambling is wrong because the downside isn't inevitable but insurance is okay because the downside is? If anything I imagine gambling to be introducing risk of ruin while insurance is protecting against it.
- Buge 10y agoBoth have possible upsides. And both have negative expected value.
- coralreef 10y agoHow do you figure that gambling or insurance have negative expected value?
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> [Why do] gambling or insurance have negative expected value[s]? The house sets the rules and the house has to make money. Occasionally the house sets bad rules [1] [2]. Those houses go out of business, leaving a greater fraction of the surviving shops demonstrating the rule. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2012/04/the-man-who-broke-atlantic-city/308900/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2012/04/the-man... [2] http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-the-untold-story-of-how-aig-destroyed-itself-2010-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-the-untold-story-of-how...
- Buge 10y agoIf you multiply the gambling reward with the probability of winning, it will be less than the cost to play. This is the house edge. It's how the casino makes money. It's the same thing with insurance. If you multiply the size of the payout with the probability of getting a payout, it will be less that your insurance premiums. It's how the insurance company makes money. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expected_value https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expected_value E[x] = prize*winning_probability - cost < 0
- tabeth 10y agoThis raises an interesting question: is there a way to perfectly insure yourself? Or rather, a company that you pay to insure you for everything? My understanding of insurance is that if there's say 1/100 chance of some event costing you 100 dollars, then you might pay $5 at some rate for some period of time to protect you in the case that the event occurs, costing you 100 bucks. However, if you knew the odds of certain somewhat expected events in your life were, how could you capitalize on that? You could save, but generally people don't make enough for that to be worthwhile.
- closeparen 10y agoInsurance is useful for low-probability high-consequence events, where the payout could be many years of salary. It's true that in aggregate, insurance buyers lose, but no specific insurance buyer lives in aggregate. Either you have that $500,000 claim, or you don't. The only way to self-insure is to have $500,000 on hand. >if you knew the odds of certain somewhat expected events in your life were, how could you capitalize on that If you know that something has a 50% chance of happening across 100,000 people, you write insurance policies such that you can deal with it happening about 50,000 times. If an event has a 50% chance of happening for you, preparing by saving 25% of its cost isn't going to help much. Expected value calculations don't make sense for N=1.
- patio11 10y ago(If you look at loss ratios in the insurance industry -- payouts and claim expenses over premiums collected -- it is closer to ~$1.20 in most fields, and coming down over time. Yay capitalism!)
- waterhouse 10y ago(You must mean premiums collected divided by payouts and claim expenses. Otherwise, if the inverse ratio were 1.20, that would imply that insurance companies were losing money.)
- patio11 10y ago
- teslaberry 10y agoit's funny how westerners in general have been completely brainwashed to think insurance is always good and useful and that insurance fraud by insurers against massive pools of those they ensure is just a small problem that is the necessary cost of 'doing business'. if insurance is so useful and good why can't it be profiteable without massive tax subsidies that it has succesfully lobbied for from government? perhaps you can ask warren buffet....
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoInsurance guarantees that you pay the expected value of the cost (plus some premium and buffer), dropping variance in exchange for a fee. Gambling does the reverse, turning a fixed amount of money in to bursty payouts in exchange for a premium, adding variance. One is basically the opposite of the other. You can even use roulette as an event randomizer to make your trips to Vegas more exciting. (Games with probabilistic loot are more "fun" than predictable loot.)
- kirykl 10y agoI think the right/wrong is in the apparatus. Gambling is usually repetitive and involves operative conditioning, which can be addictive. Insurance is too but to a much lesser degree. If I buy fire insurance and my house burns down, I get rewarded (as in operant conditioning). But only punished when my house lasts until I die or sell it.
- smallnamespace 10y agoThere's another, more direct reason: insurance is only supposed to allow you to 'hedge out' risks that you already have, whereas gambling or speculation is unrestricted. In the case where your house burns down, you're 'rewarded' in the insurance contract, but you should be close to net indifferent (after insurance) over whether your house burned down or not. That's why we don't let people buy insurance on other people's houses -- it creates a perverse incentive for the insurance purchaser to force a certain outcome.
- draw_down 10y agoInsurance doesn't ever really "reward", it just makes whole.
- gpm 10y agoMoney doesn't have a linear utility function. The more money you have, the less the next $X are worth. This means, even for "0 sum" games where there isn't a house taking a cut, gambling will typically have an average net utility loss. You make as much money as you lose, but that's money worth more when you lose it then when you make it (past the first $epsilon). Insurance on the other hand will typically have a net utility gain despite being a net dollar loss. When you "win", you would otherwise have very little money, so the money is worth a lot of utility. When you lose, you have lots of money so it only costs you a small amount of utility.
- iambateman 10y agoThe answer to the headline question is in the book "how to lose a million dollars", which I recommend. The author describes four classes of financial risk-taking 1. Investing 2. Speculating 3. Market making (I think) 4. Gambling Investing is risking capital with a strong probability of maintaining the principle while receiving a reasonable return. Gambling is when you have a negative-sum chance at keeping your principle. As a result, one person with limited information and portfolio diversity could "gamble" on apple stock while another person with more diversity is "investing." Fundamentally, they're more about information and risk than anything else.
- ucaetano 10y agoYou can look at gambling and insurance from a portfolio theory perspective. You want to hold the portfolio that maximizes return for the level of risk (variability) you're willing to take. Both insurance and gambling lower your returns, but the change in variability for insurance has a -1 correlation with a risk you currently have (canceling it out), therefore significantly reducing the overall variability of your portfolio. Gambling isn't related to any other risk you already have, therefore introducing more variability into your portfolio. So insurance is just a form of gambling where the payout is correlated with a risk you currently carry, instead of being "random".
- pmoriarty 10y agoCould "betting" with insurance be made as fun as gambling?
- dest 10y agoI have been dreaming for years of a casino where gambling results are tied to insured events. Risk averse people would meet people looking for risk. I am not sure it is a good idea thought. One difficulty is the discrepancy in the probabilities of outcome. Insured events are rare and cost a lot. Gambling often cost you a little bit but sometimes you earn a lot.
- ryhamz 10y agoSounds like you want to start an insurance company or a VC firm.
- dest 10y agoI am not sure I want that. When you go to a casino to gamble, your gains expectancy is negative because of the house's cut. You pay to have more risk. When you go to your insurance company, your gains expectancy is negative as well, because the insurance company is profitable. You pay to have less risk. So people pay to have more risk, and other people pay to have less. I'd like to know if those two groups can meet.
- brlewis 10y agoNot really, since something bad has to happen to you for you to be a "winner".
- id122015 10y agoSometimes dealing with HR departments is like gambling. The house always win and you loose. With insurance you might win exactly when you need it.
- sverige 10y agoAfter working in or for the insurance industry for 15 years, I came to the conclusion that it is not right, and that it is the moral equivalent of gambling. I understand that the vast majority of people rationalize insurance as a good thing because the cost is relatively low when compared to catastrophic loss, and even have a couple of personal anecdotes to add to those of the advocates of insurance that demonstrate the wondrous utility of insurance, but I am convinced that it is wrong. I quit the insurance business and moved to a completely different career. I only buy the insurance that is required by law (what a ridiculous concept! does the government have to mandate that you also buy food?) and have paid the tax penalty for foregoing Obamacare. I know this will likely not be well received here, but I thought I'd share my position for any who read this and wonder if they're the only ones who understand it this way.
- truetraveller 10y agoUpvoted for strong morals.
- sverige 10y agoOr at least the willingness to live out what I believe to the best of my ability. Such behavior is often labeled as insanity by those closest to you, incidentally.
- IanCal 10y agoCan you explain why it's morally wrong in the case you bring up, small costs for catastrophic loss?
- H4CK3RM4N 10y agoBecause the viability of the industry is predicated on the vast majority of consumers losing money on their premiums. Insurance isn't a bad idea intrinsically, but it's a bad thing when the industry is turning billions of dollars worth of profits
- 10y ago
- milkers 10y agoASAP(as simple as possible), for the first you consider to pay money expecting that you are lucky, for the letter you pay money expecting that you are unlucky.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoDifference is in the intent.
- Nomentatus 10y agoNot mentioned is that life insurance began as a form of gambling during the Civil War; but the original form was the reverse of the modern idea of insurance: soldiers formed a pool and the last man alive (long after the war, presumably) would inherit it all.
- kriro 10y ago“Inn-sewer-ants,” repeated Rincewind. “Tha’s a funny word. Wossit mean?” “Well, suppose you have a ship loaded with, say, gold bars. It might run into storms or, or be taken by pirates. You don’t want that to happen, so you take out an inn-sewer-ants-polly-sea. I work out the odds against the cargo being lost, based on weather reports and piracy records for the last twenty years, then I add a bit, then you pay me some money based on those odds—“ Color of Magic, Terry Pratchett, page 45 That's the passage I found googling. It actually goes on and compares insurance and gambling. Highly recommended book (as is almost everything by the author of course)
- zhengiszen 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Takaful https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Takaful The purpose of this system is not profits, but to uphold the principle of "bear ye one another's burden". The principles of takaful are as follows: - Policyholders cooperate among themselves for their common good. - Policyholders contributions are considered as donations to the fund (pool) - Every policyholder pays his subscription to help those who need assistance. - Losses are divided and liabilities spread according to the community pooling system. - Uncertainty is eliminated concerning subscription and compensation. - It does not derive advantage at the cost of others. ...
- JetSpiegel 10y agoAnd yet the insurance companies are for-profit corporations. Does not compute.
- PaulRobinson 10y agoI spent a year back in the 2000s living as a professional gambler. I know professional poker players. I write and operate "bots" that gamble on betting exchanges automatically (effectively the sports/games version of algotrading) as my main hobby - 20+ hours/week, sometimes - and my accounts are net positive to my advantage (a feat accomplished by less than 0.5% of gamblers). Whilst I enjoy a good old punt on a horse like many a Brit or Irish racing fan, and enjoy the odd bet on a football game or cricket match, I believe that I - and fellow gamblers I know who make a profit - do not actually gamble the way most people do. We treat it more like insurers see the issuance of insurance. First, we'll look at data. Second, we realise money management - and liability exposure vs. income - is critical to success. We look for situations where there is an edge in our favour which we call "value". When we see an edge we can quantify, we'll exploit that using Kelly or Maximal Exponential Growth strategies. Genuinely, I look at some sports events using techniques and strategies that would not look alien to a statistician who has trained to become an actuary. They have more data with stronger statistical significance, and their thinking may be more rigorous, but they are my inspiration: with the right numbers, you can model risk, and identify what odds you're prepared to accept and what odds you're not. I will play in casino games for recreational fun, not for profit. Same with slots/fruit machines, lotteries, and so on. Tiny amounts of money. It is impossible to beat these beyond the medium term without some form of luck. In the long run, games with house advantage will only ever be won by the house who has the advantage. Sport though? Something where I can do some data analysis and start finding informational arbitrage over others in the market? That's potentially investment. And so far, it's done me well. And so the honest answer is, nothing much is different, it's just that most gamblers and most people who buy insurance are people who do so without thinking and without understanding mathematics and liability, etc. A few of us though, a small number on Betfair or perhaps inside the sacred walls of Lloyds of London, see the World a little differently and play a game with maths at our side that few others are interested in playing.
- sumedh 10y agoWhat if a new born baby has condition which needs an expensive surgery, how will parents pay for it, how does that fit in your everyone dies model?
- 4ad 10y agoNot the grandparent, and slightly offtopic, but I think it is inhumane to raise children with problems that would affect their quality of life. Preferably this should be detected before birth, but if it's not possible but becomes obvious just after birth I would prefer to euthanise my baby than a life in pain.
- Sephiroth87 10y agoA condition that requires surgery doesn't necessarily means a life in pain...
- 4ad 10y agoNo, it doesn't, and obviously every situation is different and needs a different analysis. Personally, I would err towards having healthy children that do not require invasive medical procedure to survive at the expense of simply making another child. Of course this is all theoretical as baby euthanasia is illegal.
- pertymcpert 10y agoDid you read the person you replied to carefully?
- Marazan 10y agoGambling is an adversarial relationship. Insurance is co-operative. When I insure my house against fire neither I nor the insurance agent want my house to burn down. When I gamble on Man Utd to win 2-0 with Pogba to score the bookie doesn't want that to happen and I do. Anything that is co-operative is insurance, anything that is adversarial is gambling.
- humanrebar 10y agoIt's cooperative before an event happens, then adversarial while deciding whether an event is covered by the policy. Nobody wants a house to blow down in a hurricane, but they don't necessarily agree on the value of the property or how much of the damage was caused in which ways (wind, water, acts of God, etc.).
- jkulubya 10y agoJust as a side note; A bookmaker isn't actually your adversary in the way you mean it here. A bookmaker (as defined) in a normal? environment shouldn't care for a particular result in a gamble. All they care for is the profit they make from squeezing the odds on both ends of a gamble. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematics_of_bookmaking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematics_of_bookmaking
- Marazan 10y agoI went for a relatively specialised market in the scorecast for my example as the bookmaker won't have a balanced booked as there are just too many options to cover.
- peternilson 10y agoMy opinion is that insurance is vastly misunderstood, just as gambling is vastly misunderstood. In insurance, it's the low premiums on high valued assets that obscure peoples thinking and in gambling it's often small wagers offered in return for potentially large payoffs. I know of people who could afford to replace a phone if it was stolen, but still take insurance on it because the small premium on the insurance seems like a good deal. There is just no way that these type of insurance contracts have a positive expected value to the individual. However, if you're a single Mom making ends meet, who needs to drop her kids at school every morning, please insure your car. The utility of losing the car and not being able to get to work etc. is just too negative.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jlebrech 10y agoyes it's gambling, and so is a pension.
- k__ 10y agoInsurance is betting on your bad luck and gambling is betting on the bad luck of others.
- Spooky23 10y agoIt's pretty obvious. Gambling by its nature creates a situation where the "game" is there to induce a biological response where you're either rewarded or punished asked on your performance. Insurance is different -- its there to pool and quantify risk. That's why we don't have people hopelessly addicted to buying car insurance. It's not there to give you a rush.
- kemonocode 10y agoUnlike with betting though, it is seen as acceptable for insurance companies to weasel out of their obligations when paying out insurance.
- analog31 10y agoI wonder if an alternative to moral and economic analysis would be empirical: Look at how gambling and insurance affect people and communities. How many lives are ruined by gambling? How many lives are ruined by insurance? There must already be known issues with both gambling and insurance, because both are heavily regulated.
- chillacy 10y agoYes, I think the answer to the headline is entirely that. The reason gambling is regulated is that it's fun and tends to draw the "wrong" type of crowd. It's like asking why we regulate alcoholic drinks but still use ethanol (albeit denatured) in fuel and medicine. Just look at what they're used for.
- analog31 10y agoPerhaps another reason is that gambling devastates people who don't understand it and can ill afford it, whereas anybody who loses money in the insurance industry is presumably a "qualified" investor who knows how much they can afford to bet.
- brilliantcode 10y agobecause the world is corrupt and created after men who seemingly look to exploit and take, like their forefathers did.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jknoepfler 10y agoI honestly don't understand why insurance is seen as a private affair. Everyone who is not very wealthy requires risk management, because otherwise they run a constant, non trivial risk of complete personal ruin (not just financial ruin, but inability to pay for medical care). Humans are not capable of correctly computing the acceptability of small amounts of risk of ruin. The straightforward solution is to pool risk so that everyone pays a fraction of each catastrophe, which should just be a federal tax. At a minimum, if you have children, lack of insurance should not be an option. Then again, I'm also in favor of decreasing U.S. freeway/highway speed lilims and enforcing them strictly (like Japan) for risk reduction reasons... I suspect that my antipathy to American libertarian machismo is far from universal ;)
- seanp2k2 10y agoIt's a private affair because it's a great racket. Collect money from everyone for doing nothing, then try hard not to pay when people need it. There's a reason that many insurance companies have been around for many decades and are in the Fortune 500. Look up who underwrites your policies and you'll see what I mean.
- antisthenes 10y agoLike many industries, it's a great jobs program for those who would be unable to do anything else (think middle aged insurance peddlers with no technical skills and poor enough health to be unable to do manual labor jobs). The entire car insurance industry, for example, could easily function with a fraction of its current workforce. We have the statistics on car crashes, we have the statistics on driver demographics. All that's required is to aggregate the data and target some number to achieve, say, 3% economic profit. You could eliminate the jobs of many risk analysts and sales and have the entire industry function without the overhead of having to pay 90% of useless workforce. Is it a cruel way to look at it? Absolutely. Killing jobs is political suicide. But could it be done? The risks are known.
- jperras 10y agoYour throwaway comment about freeway speeds is a bit odd, since there are verifiable instances that show that absolute speed is not the deciding factor in road fatalities. The most famous example, of course, is the German Autobahn: "The autobahn fatality rate of 1.6 deaths per billion-travel-kilometers compared favorably with the 4.6 rate on urban streets and 6.5 rate on rural roads." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autobahn#Safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autobahn#Safety
- kazinator 10y ago> What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? Is this serious? In insurance, I cannot say, "I want to quintuple-down on having a car accident this year; let me pay a $5000 premium instead of $1000 for a 5X payout!" Insurance typically covers specified perils. When they occur, the payout is in proportion to the actual damages, not to the rarity of the odds. If insurance were like gambling: "Oh man, I won the insurance jackpot! My house was leveled by a rare meteor---500:1 payout---not just your everyday 4:1 fire." Also, there is the obvious general observation: insurance compensates for losses. You don't win; you lose stuff and are compensated. You don't get compensated unless you lose first. People don't always feel adequately compensated by money. Money won't bring back the memorabilia you lost that got burned up in the fire. It won't grow back a severed arm, or replace people who died. In gambling you don't lose anything to win; just your time and the bets, which loosely correspond to insurance premiums. The win is a pure win, not a compensation for loss. `Nuff said.
- jaclaz 10y agoAdd what about tontines? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tontine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tontine They are not mentioned in the article, but they are (were) IMHO the missing link between life insurance and gambling.
- Chris2048 10y agoInsurance places don't have shiny bells and whistles encouraging you to take risks, if anything the red tape actively discourages your success in transferring risk to them. It's hard to sell insurance based on the promise of riches, the best you could do is fear-mongering risks of not having insurance.