8 ms·
Update for Customers with Bitcoin Stored on GDAX
- eigenvalue 10y agoThis seems suicidal, what a terrible idea to change things in this way just when the idea was getting some traction. It will set a precedent that there is a lot more uncertainty in cryptocurrencies and hold back adoption.
- zik 10y agoThere's a lot of back story behind this. The story as I see it is this - a bank which opposes bitcoin in its current form funded a company called Blockstream to kick the lead developer off the Bitcoin development team and take control of it. They want to change the protocol away from a decentralized blockchain which they can't control to a payment channel system which provides a potential financial services marketplace for banks. Now they're following an agenda to deliberately prevent the blockchain from scaling in the way it was originally designed to. Why? To make the blockchain look ineffective - and now we have high fees and slow confirmations as a result. Bitcoin is badly affected by the congestion and so people are becoming desperate and clamouring for Blockstream's forthcoming off-blockchain scaling solution. This would have worked out pretty well for them except that there has inevitably been opposition to these political games. A couple of other development teams have sprung up with forks which are more closely aligned to Satoshi Nakomoto's original scaling vision. These groups have been vociferously attacked by Blockstream and Blockstream has generated terribly misleading FUD about them in order to try to retain their control of the ecosystem. Blockstream has failed. One of the alternate implementations "Bitcoin Unlimited" has all but won the war because the majority of miners are worried that the ecosystem is being damaged by Blockstream. Miners care about the value of their bitcoins and that's being eroded by the Blockstream-imposed congestion. The miners appear to be moving to Unlimited and it will most likely take over as the standard "Bitcoin" implementation at some point. The whole "chain split" thing is mostly more FUD. A hard fork isn't a big deal if handled sensibly. The minority chain will quickly die off naturally because it'll be uneconomic to mine on it. This is just as it was designed to work by Satoshi Nakomoto. No doubt people from the other side of this debate will see things differently but that's how it looks to me.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nadaviv 10y ago> funded a company called Blockstream to infiltrate the Bitcoin development team kick the lead developers off it. Blockstreeam was founded by long-time bitcoin lead developers. The rest of your post is paranoid nonsense.
- zik 10y agoGavin Andresen was left as lead developer by Satoshi Nakomoto. He was forced out.
- chx 10y agoForced? I thought he have withdrawn voluntarily and then during the Craig Wright controversy Wladimir took one good look at https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/commits?author=gavinandresen https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/commits?author=gavinandre... and said, you know what, Gavin is barely committing any more, let's not just have that access lingering around.
- nadaviv 10y agoForced out by who? He stopped contributing on its own for a long, long time prior to losing his commit access (due to fears of his computer getting hacked, in addition to him not actually using that commit access). He's still welcome to contribute (hundreds of people contribute to Core, only 3 of them has commit access), but it doesn't look like he's interested in that.
- nullc 10y ago> left as lead developer by Satoshi Nakomoto No he wasn't, he granted himself that title. Then largely left on his own in ~2013 to focus on the (now discredited and defunct) "Bitcoin Foundation" that he created. The people developing the Bitcoin project have been pretty stable since 2011. There is this lovely time coded git-blame chart that was put up last year: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1337008.0 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1337008.0 People like Mike Hearn were always outsiders to the project, and have spent a lot of time doing this like arguing for blacklisting, blocking tor, and other things that most contributors think of as strongly at odds with the principles of the project.
- ubercow 10y agoFor someone who isn't "in the know" when it comes to Bitcoin, what is Bitcoin Unlimited and what does it mean for the average user?
- pat2man 10y agoIt's a fork of the bitcoin block chain. Since there could be multiple competing chains any exchange or wallet needs to indicate which chain it is based on.
- kristianp 10y agoHere's a recent article and discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13862361 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13862361
- rwx 10y agoInternally, Bitcoin is undergoing growing pains with regard to scaling and how to manage higher volumes of transactions. The community is fragmented between the competing ideas of how to best achieve higher transaction throughput in the future. The two "leading" sides of the debate are engaged in a heavy propaganda war with each other and it seems that consensus is going to be tough to come by. These two factions seem to be essentially competing for "control" of the network. To make matters worse, the network has periods of huge transaction backlogs due to blocks being full. Bitcoin Unlimited is the incarnation of one of the methods to scale the network. Supposedly, there is a large amount of mining power, which is fairly centralized in China, supporting this method. I can't say much more than this with certainty, as there is a TON of propaganda to sift through. From what I can gather the argument boils down to the BU developers believe their method is an immediate fix to the current scaling problems. Core contends that BU has been spamming the network to create a false sense of urgency, and that the BU solution will allow miners too much control over "Bitcoin" (whatever fork it ends up being) in the future. WRT to immediate impact, expect huge volatility in the price. Some of the trusted BTC analysts are calling for further, significant shedding of value due to the uncertainty in the future. Additionally, keep your coins in your own wallet. If you're using a web-wallet, there's no telling what you'll end up with if the fork happens unless they've made specific statements regarding their plans. Held in your own wallet, if a fork occurs, you'll hold both BTC (in the classic sense) and the BU-BTC.
- joshschreuder 10y agoAre GDAX related to Coinbase? This is almost word-for-word a copy of Coinbase's statement: https://blog.coinbase.com/update-for-customers-with-bitcoin-stored-on-coinbase-904dea08ac5f#.l9vomon79 https://blog.coinbase.com/update-for-customers-with-bitcoin-...
- nadaviv 10y agoYes. Coinbase is the brand for their consumer-facing products, while GDAX is the brand for their exchange/trading products.
- joshschreuder 10y agoThanks, I thought it might be something like that. I think this would be better linked / re-titled to Coinbase as that is what most would be familiar with.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoBitcoin Unlimited is at the moment the dominant version, as measured by mined blocks: https://coin.dance/blocks https://coin.dance/blocks The vast majority are picking a side for political reasons - "Core" is embracing censorship as method to push their client, Unlimited believes in open discussion. This is best exemplified on Reddit, where /r/bitcoin is moderated, heavily, by core, but /r/btc has a no-censorship policy. This makes the technical differences between the two almost irrelevant, most are picking a side because they don't (or do) believe in censorship. "Bitcoin" is normally defined as whatever is the longest continuous chain of blocks, which if the current state of affairs continues, will be Bitcoin Unlimited. But somehow Core have managed to stake a claim to the name "Bitcoin", which is going to cause massive confusion if a fork happens.
- nadaviv 10y ago> "Core" is embracing censorship as method to push their client > where /r/bitcoin is moderated, heavily, by core This is entirely false. No one in the Bitcoin Core development community has anything to do with how subreddits are being moderated. Dismissing their technical contributions due to how unrelated persons are moderating online communities is nonsensical. > /r/btc has a no-censorship policy. https://gist.github.com/chris-belcher/c9f4b90bec1b2fbf8caaab178719ac24 https://gist.github.com/chris-belcher/c9f4b90bec1b2fbf8caaab... > This makes the technical differences between the two almost irrelevant, most are picking a side because they don't (or do) believe in censorship. The censorship claims are artificially manufactured and blown out of proportion. The /r/bitcoin moderators engage in standard moderation and enforcing the community's rules, a job that became even harder due to all the manipulation, shilling, sockpuppet accounts and voting robots that infiltrated the communication channels of the bitcoin community. https://medium.com/@shesek/observing-forced-narratives-and-manipulation-of-public-opinion-on-r-btc-847f0c65f802 https://medium.com/@shesek/observing-forced-narratives-and-m... (an article I recently wrote. see the "Related" part at the end for more details.) Moderation is an essential part of healthy online communities. It is not censorship. https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/c1/wellkept_gardens_die_by_pacifism/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/c1/wellkept_gardens_die_by_pacifism/ https://www.stevepavlina.com/blog/2009/09/free-speech-in-online-communities-the-delusion-of-entitlement/ https://www.stevepavlina.com/blog/2009/09/free-speech-in-onl...
- canistr 10y agoSo does this mean we need to stop trading BTC on GDAX until Coinbase considers the issue resolved after the fork? What if we haven't touched the BTC on GDAX in a while? Wouldn't those chains still exist post-fork? They left a bit of ambiguity in there specifying that we should move BTC out if we want access to both Unlimited and Core. But I'm unclear what to do since it doesn't matter to me either way. I just don't want to lose anything and I want the ability to continue trading.
- Frogolocalypse 10y agoYou have no idea whether GDAX will allow you to collect both coins in each chain if there is a fork. They might only honour one of the chains. Unless you own the private keys yourself, you have no idea whether your bitcoin is going to be worth anything at all.
- xiphias 10y agoActually it doesn't look like an ambiguity: they select a winner chain (hopefully the one with the higher price) and keep the money that's on the other chain. I don't think that this is a good strategy for an exchange, but it's their choice.
- chabes 10y agoGreat.. Some /r/btc extremists found a YC thread to troll. Is nothing sacred anymore?
- elastic_church 10y agoExtremists are trolling, what a productive way of dismissing opinions I'm sure everyone is here just to illicit a reaction from others
- jungletek 10y agoYou want to use 'elicit' here, my dude :) -Your local HN spelling pedant.
- hectorr 10y agoI don't think I'm literate enough on the technology and economics to know which is better, but the amount of vitriol in the Core/Unlimited debate has convinced me to sell most of my BTC. I'm incredibly appreciative to the community for all the work it has contributed to the blockchain/crypto space. That said, I see the current anger and resentment a major risk factor to the future of the currency, far more significant than the outcome of this decision either way. I sincerely hope cooler heads prevail soon. Until then however, I'll be keeping my capital away.