14 ms·
Star Citizen developers intend to drop DirectX support and only support Vulkan
- hd4 10y ago>use as it doesn't force our users to upgrade to Windows 10 and opens the door for a single graphics API that could be used on all Windows 7, 8, 10 & Linux Finally they're starting to get it.
- dogma1138 10y agoConsidering that the mGPU and VR support in the latest release of Vulkan requires Windows 10 and WDDM I don't think even Kronos gets it anymore ;)
- throwaway91111 10y agoI don't use windows. What's wrong with windows 10?
- dogma1138 10y agoNothing, I use it on a daily basis.
- Razengan 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13903519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13903519 for one.
- yulaow 10y agoThe dev are not directly against windows 10, but against forcing their users to upgrade to a new os only because Microsoft decides everytime to support latest directX versions only in their newest os version.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoIt was decent, even fine, until they started pushing advertisement aggressively. Yes even to pro users.
- krautsourced 10y agoThat took two clicks to disable. Hardly makes the entire OS bad. If I had anything to complain about Win 10 it's that they still haven't properly unified the control panels.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoyeah, the exdplorer advertisement on top of chrome took another two click, the office advertisement another two, the edge is more secure popup, two clicks.. I see a pattern there, don't you?
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoYou shouldn't have to do even two clicks to disable ads in an OS you purchased. The fact that people try to defend this is absurd.
- zuminator 10y agoI purchased a newspaper, it had ads - which I couldn't disable. I purchased a magazine, it had ads - couldn't disable. I purchased a book - an ad for another book in the back. I purchased a movie ticket - an eternity of commercials even after I arrived "late" to the show. I purchased a cable subscription - still scads of ads, no way to get rid of them. So taking ten seconds to deactivate ads in an OS isn't really the kind of outrageously onerous burden you're laying it out to be. I agree to the extent that it seems like a pointlessly minuscule revenue stream in comparison to the ill will that it generates. And it was deceitful to sneak the ads in after people had already upgraded from Windows 7 instead of making their intentions clear from the outset. Microsoft would probably generate more income with an option to permanently disable the ad experience (and telemetry) for a one-time fee the way Amazon does with their low-end Kindles.
- EasyTiger_ 10y ago- They are presenting ad 'experiences' on the Start menu, lock-screen, notification area, taskbar and now the File Manager, too. This is happening even on Enterprise. - Windows 10 will automatically install games from the Windows Store which are not wanted such as Candy Crush - Extensive and opaque 'telemetry' being sent back to MS which cannot be completely turned off - Lack of control over windows updates These are my own personal reasons why I will never be installing such an anti-consumer OS.
- arm 10y agoYep, and if that wasn’t enough, they have the gall to charge consumers for the OS too! I mean, monetizing users by tracking their behaviour and showing them custom ads is bad enough (although somewhat understandable when the OS is free), but charging users for the privilege too (Windows 10 costs money¹)? Disgusting. ―――――― ¹ — https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/get-windows-10 https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/get-windows-10
- naikrovek 10y ago- they are showing "suggested apps" in the start menu, which can be turned off. The others are OneDrive and Edge suggestions and can also be turned off. - those apps are installed at the time of installation and can be removed. If so, they are not reinstalled ever again. - telemetry. Scary. Every application you install does this. - MS found (via telemetry) that users don't like installing updates, and thus left themselves open to many vulnerabilities that antivirus systems don't even look for. So, MS has chosen to force users into a more secure paradigm. These are my personal responses why I don't mind windows 10 at all, and don't feel it to be anti-consumer at all.
- swiley 10y ago>telemetry. Scary. Every application you install does this. I'm really quite sure the applications on my machine don't. Then again I only run things I have some way to compile myself.
- 10y ago
- zamalek 10y agoI can't see VR being added to the game for a long time, there are tons of comfort issues (especially forced camera movement) right now.
- sundvor 10y agoYeah, something I find really disappointing as a platinum level backer is that it can't even do TrackIR ootb anymore. Whereas Elite Dangerous handles that with aplomb. Guess where I'm spending what precious little gaming time I have these days?
- sundvor 10y agoSorry that sounded ungrateful and came out like I had an entitlement because of the backing level. I may be just a bit disappointed it was dropped - however I trust that it'll be added back in due time. The RSI team is doing amazing work, and I keep checking in - really love how they've improved loading times, and the detail of the models etc is just amazing, however as someone who's gotten quite used to head tracking I find it very hard to play sims that don't support it. As such, I'm also a big Elite fan and now is a really good time to be playing that especially if an immersive experience is something you consider important as I do.
- rurounijones 10y agoTrackIR support is in the next release (2.6.2)
- sundvor 10y agoOoooh!! Thanks. :)
- wavefunction 10y agoThe new item/use interface seems perfectly suited to VR "touch" controllers. And I think back a few years when people said we'd never be able to fly seamlessly from orbit down to the surface of a procedurally generated planet. I understand that it's healthy to be skeptical, especially when it comes to video games, but CIG has been accomplishing some remarkable things much sooner than anyone seemed to assume so I guess I'm optimistic about VR as sooner rather than later.
- DiThi 10y agoYou mean VR optimizations that are not crucial. And I don't think the specification says it requires Win10, does it? It's an implementation issue.
- dogma1138 10y agoWDDM 2.0 and LDA as a requirement that's windows 10.
- wolfgke 10y agoWDDM 2.0: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Windows_Display_Driver_Model&oldid=763825491 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Windows_Display_D... LDA: https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/dn894177(v=vs.85).aspx https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/dn...
- DiThi 10y agoI mean Vulkan specification and its extensions. By definition it can't require Windows 10 exclusive features. It may happen that the only implementations in existence today do have this requirement.
- dogma1138 10y agoThere are Kronos extensions that require Win32 (and many of those do not have other platform equivalent from dealing with unified memory, to DX11/12 integration and other features), Vulkans mGPU support in it's current form specifically mandates Windows 10 because it's based on how WDDM and Windows 10 allow you to link devices, so do some of the VR specific functions. Vulkan was a Camel before they introduces the new extensions road map, you know have KHR which are "official" cross vendor LTS extensions which can be still platform dependant (e.g. you can have win32 KHR extensions), then there are KHX extensions which are effectively a rapid deployment branch primarily sucking in vendor extensions that can be a good idea, then there are the vendor specific extensions. Now not only that it's a camel, it seems to fall back into the same tarpit that OpenGL had in which you could not guarantee compatibility between hardware vendors and platforms.
- Twin_Snakes 10y agoThat's only true for NVidia and that's because they don't want to put the work in (They do plan to make it work on Linux though just not on pre WDDM2 Windows). There is absolutely nothing locking multiGPU support to windows 10 other than the willingness of IHVs to support it.
- orbitur 10y ago> as it doesn't force our users to upgrade to Windows 10 Why is this something to avoid?
- empath75 10y agoI'm sure people will appreciate it in 2100 when the game is released.
- bhouston 10y agoIs the game going to be released?
- techrich 10y agoNope they are going to keep changing stuff, adding stuff tweaking it. They should just make something, then start adding more on.
- jarnix 10y agoI don't know why this comment was downvoted, it's pretty obvious that one should release early and often, then make changes instead of making long term change even before the product is released!
- spacehunt 10y agoBackers have been getting regular releases for about 3 years already if not longer.
- scrollaway 10y agoThe comment you are replying to, as well as your own, are both being downvoted because they make wild assumptions about the state of the game clearly without knowing anything about it... The final product is not released, but RSI is the most transparent game studio out there. Alpha Builds of the game are constantly being released, any backer can install it, log into it, give feedback, report bugs etc. They are releasing early and often.
- kayoone 10y agoConsidering that Vulkan is faster and should be well supported on all platforms by the time this game finally comes out, i think it's a good decision. I guess only possible since they don't plan console support.
- ygra 10y agoIt's faster than OpenGL or older DirectX versions, but DX12 was pretty much on the same level of abstraction as far as I understood it.
- simion314 10y agoYes, DX12 is very similar to Vulkan but the major difference is Vulkan is present on most gaming platforms except iOS, so it makes sense if you have to choose one of those two you will choose Vulkan.
- nottorp 10y agoIsn't Vulkan AMD only though?
- glaze 10y agoNo. Mantle, on which Vulkan is based on, was AMD only. AMD gave it to Khronos and it evolved into Vulkan.
- hansjorg 10y agoVulkan is based on Mantle from AMD, but the code was donated to Khronos. Both Nvidia and Intel have Vulkan drivers.
- vetinari 10y agoDoes Intel have a vk driver? AFAIK, they only have a Linux one, but only for Broadwell and newer. Do you know something about the Windows driver?
- edem 10y agoCool. 2+ developer years of development time fore refactoring. At least I did not back this game so I have no expectations.
- krautsourced 10y agoAs I understand their post they are currently developing for both, so dropping one shouldn't be _that_ bad.
- kakarot 10y agoAs sibling said, they were developing with both in mind, but if you write smart code from the beginning and abstract enough, it's not very difficult to switch graphics APIs.
- edem 10y agoThere are too much ifs...and if you are a developer you know the probability of your statement being true.
- hacker_9 10y ago"Years ago we stated our intention to support DX12, but since the introduction of Vulkan which has the same feature set and performance advantages this seemed a much more logical rendering API to use as it doesn't force our users to upgrade to Windows 10 and opens the door for a single graphics API that could be used on all Windows 7, 8, 10 & Linux. As a result our current intention is to only support Vulkan and eventually drop support for DX11 as this shouldn't effect any of our backers. DX12 would only be considered if we found it gave us a specific and substantial advantage over Vulkan. The API's really aren't that different though, 95% of the work for these APIs is to change the paradigm of the rendering pipeline, which is the same for both APIs." This feels like a pretty handwavey statement. For one, all shaders would need to be converted from HLSL to GLSL, which could become quite a big task depending on the amount of shaders, and testing of all changes. Secondly as I understand it the Vulkan API is much more low level and barebones than DirectX, meaning it'll be a lot of work to shore up the differences. I may be wrong here, but it seems to be like the developer is saying that a DirectX -> OpenGL change is no big deal, but swapping out your foundations is a major big deal. The concepts may be the same but the APIs are still hugely different. And why is this even a concern for a game started in 2011? It's mind boggling that they are making these kind of decisions 6 years into development, surely just finishing the damn gameplay should be the focus?
- karyon 10y ago> For one, all shaders would need to be converted from HLSL to GLSL There are transpilers (cross-compilers?) that translate from HLSL to GLSL and back and into every other shading language out there, there's really a lot of such tools. > Secondly as I understand it the Vulkan API is much more low level and barebones than DirectX Vulkan is about as low-level as Direct3D 12, which has not much in common with Direct3D 11 and lower, just like Vulkan has not much in common with OpenGL. OpenGL is (very roughly) equivalent to Direct3D 11, and Vulkan is more like Direct3d 12. The thing is that switching between the similar APIs is a lot of work, but does not require large refactorings, whereas switching from OpenGL/Direct3D11 to Vulkan/D3d12 requires more fundamental work.
- wolfgke 10y ago> For one, all shaders would need to be converted from HLSL to GLSL GLSL is just one option to write shaders for Vulkan (the only inmportant thing is that SPIR-V code can be generated). I can even imagine quite well that one could write a compiler which generates SPIR-V code from HLSL shaders. > Secondly as I understand it the Vulkan API is much more low level and barebones than DirectX, meaning it'll be a lot of work to shore up the differences. DirectX 12 is similarly low level. > I may be wrong here, but it seems to be like the developer is saying that a DirectX -> OpenGL change is no big deal DirectX 11.x is similar in "level" to OpenGL 4.x (though the difficulties are a little different - I don't want to go into details here). Similarly DirectX 12 and Vulkan are similar in level (much more low level than their predecessors). No wonder since both Vulkan and DirectX 12 are "strongly inspired" by Mantle. Additionally Vulkan was intended as the succesor of OpenGL and DirectX 12 as the succesor of DirectX 11.x. > surely just finishing the damn gameplay should be the focus? That is what you wish. :-)
- random_comment 10y agoI personally think a more likely explanation of this move is that they are nowhere near completion and need a good 'technical excuse' for pushing deadlines way into the future. Then everyone begins debating the technical issues rather than the timetabling and funding issues.
- scrollaway 10y agoThere is seriously something wrong with this community whenever a Star Citizen article comes up. Did you even click the link at all before coming up with your conspiracy theory? This is a reply to a question that mentions, in passing, that for simplicity sake they are DROPPING ONE OF THE TWO targets they are CURRENTLY supporting. This is not "we need excuses to push deadlines", this is "we're cutting something to speed up development", with explanations accompanying it. And that aside, HN of all communities should appreciate the level of transparency and technical insight CIG gives to their backers. Like the one in the post here. That you did not click because you were too busy coming up with "technical excuses".
- random_comment 10y agoHello, thank you for your comment. I've followed the Vulkan/DX12 issue on and off over the last year for SC as I am an early backer. Given that they only first approached the question of Vulkan in 2016, and as recently as a few months ago were still in blackout as to the level of support: e.g. https://forums.robertsspaceindustries.com/discussion/comment/6522297/#Comment_6522297 https://forums.robertsspaceindustries.com/discussion/comment... then https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen/comments/53qsy5/any_news_on_dx12vulcan_support/ https://www.reddit.com/r/starcitizen/comments/53qsy5/any_new... I am not persuaded that this is as simple a matter as dropping one of two equally well-developed branches. Generally speaking, moving from a mature high-level API (especially one which the underlying game engine/architecture is heavily tied into) to a less mature low-level API tends to mean refactoring work and extra implementation work, as well as a whole new bunch of bugs and testing. I would agree that pursuing only Vulkan or only DirectX is probably smarter than pursuing both simultaneously in terms of a faster delivery. I also think in terms of cross-platform development and performance it will be better to use Vulkan (for any game). However, the introduction of Vulkan is a relatively recent event in the history of SC development (see above), saying 'we're only going to support it now' might actually be saying 'a rewrite (or substantial refactoring) of the game started last year, which we are now owning up to'.
- samfisher83 10y agoIts almost been 6 years and they have raised 140+ million. I would be kind of mad if I had contributed and the haven't released a full game yet and they are changing something else.
- scrollaway 10y agoI contributed on day 1, the main thing that's had me worried is the lack of updates on Linux support (which was promised in the KS). This reply reinforces their commitment on that, which is really nice.
- TillE 10y agoIt's been less than 4.5 years. Dunno how you got 6. Funding started in October 2012. I did contribute $30 to the original Kickstarter, and I think the vast majority of scorn and rage about Star Citizen has been coming from people who haven't. Personally, I never expect a software project to finish on time.
- georgeecollins 10y agoI played a demo at the Game Developers Conference and it was fun. The thing I played was like Wing Commander with nicer graphics. I'm sure they are building lots of other things as well. Whenever you make games you wish you had more resources. But at some level if you have too much, you become unbound by the practical trade-offs that are necessary to the art. The more you have to work with the more you need to promise, the less it makes sense to compromise. I'm sure they will ship some games and I look forward to playing them. If they don't succeed they will move the art forward and train a lot of people who will do great things in their wake. More power to them.
- hyperpallium 10y ago> unbound by the practical trade-offs that are necessary to the art. Like Duke Nukem Forever? They wanted to keep updating to the latest technology instead of shipping... and had the resources to do it.
- cjslep 10y ago
- frik 10y agoStar Citizen is one of the only Triple-A games in development that is PC first. Good that they value their Win7, Mac and Linux gamers. Both DirectX 12 (which has nothing in common with DirectX 11) and Vulcan originate from AMD Mantel and the work of the Frostbite devs. Vulcan is the better choice nowadays, and several Triple-A games incl Doom 2016 support Vulcan. There is no reason to use Win10 as a gamer, all games (beside the arcardy FU3) run on Win7, even the older one that stopped working with the infamous adware & spyware that Win10 is - as of today Win10 has ads in Windows Explorer, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13903519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13903519
- cmpxchg8b 10y agoThe great irony here is that Doom 2016 has no official Linux support and Windows was necessary to play it. It only became usable under WINE within the past couple of months.
- pikzen 10y agoThis was mostly an issue coming from Denuvo, which doesn't offer a way to generate linux executables. Now that Denuvo has been stripped, it runs on Linux, and pretty damn well with the Vulkan backend.
- wmf 10y agoThere is no reason to use Win10 as a gamer Other than, like, having a supported version of Windows.
- falcolas 10y agomacOS supports Vulcan now? That's news to me.
- wlesieutre 10y agoIt doesn't. There's a 3rd party middleware that implements it on top of Metal, but I don't know how it performs. https://moltengl.com/moltenvk/ https://moltengl.com/moltenvk/
- wnevets 10y agoThe duke nukem forever of kickstarter games.
- admax88q 10y agoWhy does this vaporware still get news? This game is never going to be completed. They've already made their money and have taken on a job that's way more more ambitious then the developers or any of their backers realize.
- throwawaysbdi 10y agoThat's the crux backers are lying to themselves about. The game doesn't exist and has already made more money than most blockbusters. Why waste profit developing it when you've already had your payday? The best thing to do from a business perspective is just enough "development" to keep lawsuits at bay. In the meantime you start throwing as much money as you can off the train and jump clear right before it flies off the tracks.
- wtfishackernews 10y agoI don't what the problem is. They are extremely transparent with development and internal timelines. No one expects the game to be finished anytime soon, but there is continuous progress. (I'm not backer, just interested in the game)
- cercatrova 10y agoYeah, as many backers exist that apparently delude themselves into thinking the game will be done soon, there are just as many that call it vaporware when there is clear progress every single week. They made presale money, sure, but it seems like the latter just can't comprehend that, just as with open source projects, the developers are building the game because they want to build it, not just because it will make money.
- _Codemonkeyism 10y agoWhich is the point, "the developers are building the game because they want to build it" - they don't want to finish.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- partycoder 10y agoI hope more game developers do the same. And I hope if this time Microsoft comes up with a FUD campaign against Vulkan (like what happened with OpenGL) people can just uninstall Windows and try another OS.
- TylerH 10y agoIs this gonna push release back another four years?