4 ms·
Reading this obituary reminds me of Michael Jackson's death. Someone dies and suddenly all the bad things in their life are expunged. Berry was a very influen
by slg 10y ago
Reading this obituary reminds me of Michael Jackson's death. Someone dies and suddenly all the bad things in their life are expunged. Berry was a very influential and talented musician but he spent time in prison related to being caught with a 14 year old suspected prostitute. He spent time in prison for robbery. He spent time in prison for tax evasion. He settled a lawsuit for video taping 50+ women including underage girls in the bathroom of his restaurant. I get it, no one is perfect and a person's death is a time to celebrate their life, but these crimes are part of his legacy. Not even giving them a passing mention in his obituary sends a horrible message that if you are talented enough you can get away with anything.
EDIT: This is currently the top comment, which likely isn't fair either. These things are a part of the story of his life but they also probably shouldn't be the top line. My point is simply we should be talking about his entire life and this is a poor obituary for not even mentioning it. The New York Times has a better obituary available at https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/18/arts/chuck-berry-dead.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/18/arts/chuck-berry-dead.htm...
- djtriptych 10y agoWait was Michael Jackson ever convicted of a crime? How can you conflate the two?
- MisterBastahrd 10y agoNo, but he settled lawsuits accusing him of being a child predator before they made it to court.
- djtriptych 10y agoIt was settled by his insurance company, against MJ's wishes. He was also actually tried, and found not guilty on 14 charges. Not quite the same boat as Chuck Berry. In any case, I'm a "separate the art from artist" kind of guy. There are no saints.
- volkk 10y agoAt what point do you conjoin the two? Does the line vary? If a brilliant painter turns out to be a convicted pedophile, for instance, would you still hang their art on your wall? Just curious to hear opinions. I was just wondering about this sort of thing the other day.
- djtriptych 10y agoI guess I'd say that great art always speaks truth, and that truth has no need for morality. In particular I might argue that society might be better off if we were collectively more offended by bad art than by good art made by bad people.
- volkk 10y agoI see the argument. How bout this scenario: We uncover that Hitler (hello Godwin's law) was a master sculptor, absolutely unparalleled. His art speaks volumes, especially to those unbeknownst of its origins. How do you see the art being viewed then? On one hand, he has the legacy of attempting genocide, but on the other hand his art is amazing. What are the morality guidelines behind this sort of predicament? Does humanity keep it on display in a museum and continue his legacy in the vicinity of works such as Rembrandt's? Even though it would undoubtedly offend millions? Does the fact that it's great art outweigh the social negativity surrounding the whole predicament?
- djtriptych 10y agoSure - I did consider a hypothetical Hitler as artist argument. So, the boring rejoinder is that, yes, his work ought to be recognized on its merits. Sculpture as a discipline shouldn't be punished for Hitler's sins. Hung next to Rembrandt? Probably not, but then again how much do we know about Rembrandt? There are plenty of great artists whose personal life we know little about (see Shakespeare for instance. We don't know where he went to school or what he looked like!) If we found out tomorrow he peeped on women in the bathroom should we burn all our copies of Hamlet? Anyway, regarding Hitler, a more interesting answer (to me) is that I'm not convinced great art and the will to extinguish an entire people really exist in the same soul. We know Hitler to be a failed artist. I wonder if good art requires a sensitivity to the world that sociopaths simply do not possess.
- kasabiel 10y agoWas MJ ever convicted of a crime? NO. Maybe you should ask the question in a different way, such as was MJ the victim of a which hunt to frame him for a crime he never commuted. In that case the answer is undoubtedly, YES.
- kasabiel 10y agoWas MJ ever convicted of a crime? NO. Maybe you should ask the question in a different way, such as was MJ the victim of a which hunt to frame him for a crime he never commited. In that case the answer is undoubtedly, YES.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pthreads 10y agoThe BBC video does mention his troubles with the law. It's not at length but it does put things in context.
- justinator 10y agoTo be perfectly honest, it's rock 'n roll, not church choir music. Rock 'n Roll used to be dangerous music performed by minorities before the Civil Rights Movement, and listened by rebellious teenagers, before it was co-opted, watered down, and packaged up. If you're not listening to Chuck Berry, and you don't pick out innuendos, you're not listening hard enough. The Sex Pistols covered Chuck Berry - the bassist was a heroin addict that killed his girlfriend, then himself. The Beatles covered Chuck Berry - John Lennon is not looked upon with a positive light given how he treated his son and first wife. The Rolling Stones covered Chuck Berry. People have been murdered at their shows. Rock 'n Roll is filled with the causalities of unstable, chemically dependent, suicidal people. Chuck Berry was Rock 'n Roll.
- slg 10y agoI don't disagree. My counter would be would you ever tell the story of Rock n' Roll without mentioning how damaged, disenfranchised, and rebellious the people who created or where drawn to it were? If not, shouldn't it be mentioned in one of the creators obituary how damaged they were?
- lostlogin 10y agoThose things you mention are self destructive, the comment you were replying to was specifically mentioning damaging others, vulnerable ones in particular.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoHow could a 14 year old be a prostitute? You mean a sex trafficking victim? He got caught with a child sex trafficking victim.
- umanwizard 10y agoWhat's your point? The two aren't mutually exclusive. Sex trafficking victims are a particular subset of prostitutes.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoThat's like saying people whose homes have been burglarized are a subset of electronics stores.