13 ms·
Spotify is gaining leverage over record labels
- quink 10y agoCan't justify Spotify as I'm paying for YouTube Red/Google Play Music as I can stand YouTube ads less than the difference between Spotify and Google Play Music. I bet that'll come up more and more. One important differentiator might be to get the Japanese record labels a bit more aligned, all streaming providers have been faring terribly on that front.
- mcintyre1994 10y agoGoogle clearly have the best offer on the table here, it's incredible how little effort they've put into making it available worldwide though. Still not in the UK...
- Itsdijital 10y agoI'm in the same boat. I actually even have a gpm/ytr subscription paid through 2019 already (I bought a ton of $5/mo coupons and redeemed them all). Despite that, I'm thinking about getting a spotify sub anyway. The music discovery and especially the user playlists I find to be far superior. GPM is really lacking hard on the social front.
- mulletbum 10y agoYou can do all that with a free account. In fact, just get Stamp to move your Google content to spotify and you can use it all free without even playing songs in Spotify. Its a little less perfect, but it gets the job done.
- yladiz 10y agoSince I started using Spotify regularly I stopped using Pandora, but during the time I did it had a really large selection of Japanese music. It had songs and artists that don't exist on other platforms. Maybe it's due to the fact that Pandora is basically customized radio? On the flip side, Spotify has a ton of Korean music, so I'm happy.
- cryptarch 10y agoWhat does YouTube Red do better than uBlock Origin?
- Emc2fma 10y agoSupports content creators instead of making them work w/o compensation
- SparkyMcUnicorn 10y agoIt's nice not having to think about it across mobile, Chromecast, gamestation, and computer. It's also not cheating creators.
- quink 10y agoYouTube Music app, no ads on YouTube for the whole family and exclusive content beyond just YouTube Red Original Series (which I don't care much about)
- SparkyMcUnicorn 10y agoSame here. Lack of an API and no real social aspect are the two big pressure points for me to move to Spotify.
- anotherthrow2 10y agoThis is nothing more than PR fluff. Spotify is in big trouble, as waging war with Apple is proving to be far more costly than they expected. I want to know how much Techcrunch got paid for this advertisement.
- foota 10y agoI don't have any real reason to believe so, but I doubt techcrunch would accept money straight up for an article.
- anotherthrow2 10y agoAccess to scoops and leaks, which translate into articles that get page views, which translate into ad dollars, is an indirect way to pay off a journalist.
- edblarney 10y agoSo by your logic they are 'bribing' the journalist and 'paying them off' by 'giving them a scoop'? Ergo - every decent news story amounts to 'bribery'? I think you bit your tongue on that one.
- shard972 10y agoIs this not the main criticism leveled at big press outlets during Obama's administration? That they were too easy on reporting and justified it by saying you need to be to get the scoops.
- im3w1l 10y agohttp://money.cnn.com/2017/02/24/media/cnn-blocked-white-house-gaggle/ http://money.cnn.com/2017/02/24/media/cnn-blocked-white-hous...
- coldtea 10y ago>So by your logic they are 'bribing' the journalist and 'paying them off' by 'giving them a scoop'? Yes, it happens often. Journalists get paid with scoops, etc (aka in the industry as "access") and that buys some favorable pieces and a sympathetic ear on the other side. Here's an example (there are countless others from all parties and from tons of companies): http://gawker.com/this-is-how-hillary-clinton-gets-the-coverage-she-wants-1758019058 http://gawker.com/this-is-how-hillary-clinton-gets-the-cover... >Ergo - every decent news story amounts to 'bribery'? Where did you came with this weirdo conclusion? Bribing a journalist/media with scoops if something that happens, not something that ALWAYS happen -- so it doesn't apply to "every decent news story". For one, not every scoop has been leaked to the outlet breaking it by the company/organization that the scoop is about. >I think you bit your tongue on that one. No, he really didn't.
- rhabarba 10y agoSpotify will not win unless they find a way to materialize and dematerialize vinyl LPs on demand.
- shmerl 10y agoI prefer DRM-free stores and musicians who release there.
- rev_bird 10y agoSo do I, but the ones on Spotify sound a lot better. Unfortunately, I'd bet most people favor listening to the music they want over supporting the digital freedoms they endorse.
- shmerl 10y ago"Better" is pretty subjective here.
- SteveNuts 10y agoI prefer the convenience of having access to an effectively unlimited music library, on demand, for a flat cost per month. I can see how it would be a fun hobby to curate your own collection, but for me it's really hard to beat services like Spotify, Steam, Netflix - DRM or not.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI like Netflix and Spotify, but dislike Steam. I just find it different to rent me content transparently, eg Netflix and Spotify, versus rent-by-pretending-to-sell, eg Steam. If you sell me something, I should be able to use and transfer it at my discretion without your permission. Steam, instead, leases you something on no fixed term and presumably without any guaranteed lifetime.
- smpetrey 10y agoIf anyone thinks Spotify has leverage over record labels, I would challenge you to compare Spotify's operating losses year over year VS. Apple Music's operating losses year over year.
- usaphp 10y agoCan you elaborate on that? What are their losses?
- citruspi 10y ago184.5 MM € in 2015[0]. [0]: http://www.businessinsider.com/r-spotify-revenues-grow-80-percent-to-19-billion-euros-in-2015-operating-loss-widens-2016-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/r-spotify-revenues-grow-80-pe...
- ikt 10y agoAnd what is Apple music's operating losses? Spotify has always talked about losses being expected, they want user growth at any cost. http://www.recode.net/2016/5/23/11749122/spotify-losses-revenue-2015 http://www.recode.net/2016/5/23/11749122/spotify-losses-reve...
- caryhartline 10y agoIt is certainly normal for startups to expect losses and only want to gain users, but it's not a sign of strength in themselves or their business model. If you're trying to gain users at any cost then other businesses will take advantage of that desperation.
- adventured 10y agoAnd meanwhile there's SiriusXM with $745 million in net income, up nearly 50% over 2015.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rotwood 10y agoThis article is nonsense.
- visarga 10y agoI got 99 problems but Spotify ain't one! because I live outside their small map. I don't exist for them and they don't exist for me. Edit: just joking, I am actually irritated I can't check out the Discover Weekly playlist, whenever it comes out in discussion. I just checked, my country is still not on their list.
- bergjs 10y agoSpotify is the one service I'm happy to pay for. Their weekly mixes keep blowing my mind because it's such a great way to discover new music tailored to my taste. Plus, Spotify connect is a genius way to play music on loudspeakers. It works incredibly well with my Bose speakers. My impression is that they will continue to innovate in all kinds of areas so I think they have a good chance of winning. I needed to write this because just yesterday I thought how happy I am with Spotify. In case it sounds too fanboy-ish.
- dom96 10y agoWhile i have discovered a couple good songs in Spotify's Discover Weekly playlist, i do find it a common occurrence nowadays that songs which i have listened to in the past are included. Does anyone else have that experience? Perhaps Spotify is just having a really hard time finding music related to my tastes?
- andymurd 10y agoDiscover weekly is the reason that I pay for Spotify. I'm an old guy that prefers vinyl to mp3s, misses the local record store terribly and hates radio, so modern music distribution sucks for me. I first tried Spotify many years ago, back when playlists were quite new. At the time, I was living in the UK and a big user of last.fm but, out of curiosity, I spent an afternoon building one playlist out of the few tracks they had that I liked. I was/am into house and techno but the tracks were not yet available on Spotify back then - but the originals which were heavily sampled sure were. So I ended up with a playlist of funk, disco, blues, hip-hop and jazz that was kinda familiar, lotta fun. Fast-forward several years and I'm living in Australia, where last.fm is a paid service that had stagnated, so back to check out Spotify again... It had millions more tracks. It had learned from my playlist. Discover weekly is soooo good. It had my attention and my credit card. To the parent poster, I suggest you treat Spotify like a friendly muso willing to lend you her near infinite collection. I've you've ever wondered about $GENRE, go and play. I have no relationship with Spotify except as a very happy customer.
- JohnJamesRambo 10y ago
- iUsedToCode 10y agoSpotify is the only content provider i pay for gladly, due to their Family accounts and Discover Weekly. I listen to music 5-6h a day now, all for dirt cheap (less than $2/month/person). I wish somebody would do the same for video content. Right now you have to subscribe to many different providers to get all the good content. So pirating is still more convenient and i still download rather than just pay a small, fixed amount. Well, maybe music is just cheaper to make and easier to sell as a bundle.
- Vinnl 10y agoI really hope the music industry isn't going that way as well...
- bogidon 10y agoPretty remarkable how bad the writing is in this article.
- quanticle 10y agoAs we said above, their artists would suffer from the loss of distribution, but they’d also suffer a loss of revenue. Not much revenue. Spotify is famously stingy in how much it pays artists, to the point where big names like Taylor Swift are keeping their releases off Spotify.
- raverbashing 10y agoI'm not worried about Taylor Swift outside of Spotify. I'm happy to listen to the artists I favour, as much as they get paid little, they do get some revenue from it https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/5h2lmk/i_am_an_independent_musician_i_publicly_published/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/5h2lmk/i_am_an_indep...
- bobsam 10y agoTo add to what you said: when Mrs Swift demands to get paid much more than everyone else, that money is taken from the payout of less famous artists.
- tjoff 10y agoIsn't that because the artists are having shitty deals with the record labels though?
- k-mcgrady 10y agoIf you are completely independent the amount you get per play (before your distributor - e.g. CDBaby - takes a cut) is $0.006 - $0.008. If we say you get the max per play and you're a one person act (not a band) you need about 250,000 streams to make $2000 (just about enough money to live on). Obviously you have other ways to generate income (merch, touring) but even getting anywhere near that number of monthly streams for an independent artist with no marketing power/skill/money is almost impossible regardless of how good your work is. If not going to get into the usual debate about free market and value but I thought it was worth laying out some actual figures as 'labels are taking the money' is the go to argument here when in reality having no label isn't going to work for most artists either. NB: To get your music on all of these digital services you need a distributor like CDBaby (many others are available). I left out their cut in the figures above but for digital services it is 9% of net income.
- lucb1e 10y agoAs a paying Spotify member, practices like these only make me want to switch to DRM-free music more. Blackmailing artists with "we won't promote you if you don't lower your prices" and wasting half a million on 2 weeks of exclusivity. That's not what I'm paying them for; I pay them because I want to compensate artists.
- bobsam 10y agoWhat if some artists demand to be compensated more than everyone else? It's a zero sum game after all.
- lucb1e 10y agoI don't understand what you mean by that. I'm talking about promoting artists by pushing their numbers into people's auto-generated playlists (the weekly discovery list and the top charts), not being on Spotify at all.
- thirdsun 10y ago> I pay them because I want to compensate artists. You're paying the wrong people then. If you want to help artists buy their music instead of renting it from streaming services, which may lose access to it at any time.
- tormeh 10y agoLabels take most of that as well. Spotify isn't the problem - the labels are.
- StavrosK 10y agoAren't the labels basically the VCs that enabled the artists to reach you in the first place?
- lucb1e 10y agoIn the old days where you needed to print lots of CDs and distribute them, maybe. These days, I'm not sure they're really necessary. But then I'm not an artist so I can't really say.
- yladiz 10y agoI would rather pay slightly more per month (let's say $12 USD rather than the current $10) than pay the artists less, even if the effect is relatively small due to the labels taking so much cut out of the payout. But in any case, I do believe that the way Spotify will be able to have real leverage is for it to start being their own label, not just getting exclusive content. I feel like it would be cheaper to just bring on either independent artists or artists that are kind of not "into" traditional labels but are popular, rather than pay for exclusive content since it is probably less work but more expensive to do the latter, while the former would take a by of work but cheaper in the long run. It's subscriber base being so large may be a bargaining chip but I would guess that a lot of its current subscribers would move to other services were it to shut down, so it can't be that big? Sheer volume in a market with competitors that would be basically the same but with a different UI and maybe some different content can't count for that much can it?
- mtgx 10y agoI'm not a Spotify user, so I will assume they don't already have what I'm going to propose. But I think it would be in Spotify's interest if it started focusing more in indie artists, and maybe even offer a special plan for "indie music", which would promote indie music, and may even give those artists more money because there would be much less indie music to listen to, and because there would be no corporate labels to take their large cuts. The more indies Spotify gets, the more it can tell labels to go screw themselves if they don't want to take a deal, in the future. Alternatively, Spotify could also try to do what Netflix is doing with shows and movies and start funding indies through their own label.
- dilemma 10y agoYes. They should buy Soundcloud and set up a semi-automated publishing system for that pipeline. That's a new generation of artists that the corporate labels have no way of reaching, generally. Some of that IP will be enormously valuable, like seed equity.
- wcummings 10y agoTheir contracts with major labels could preclude them being a label themselves.
- ilamont 10y agoI wonder what Apple, Google, and Amazon Music can do to compete. They have advantages that Spotify cannot duplicate (large war chests, existing device/platform control, etc.) and one of them (Apple) is really strong when it comes to playlists. Apple is also doing a fair number of exclusive deals with music publishers and artists, although Billboard says the industry is moving away from this trend (1) although that could be wishful thinking on Spotify's part. Another issue that's worth bringing up: Artists are getting screwed by these models as well as YouTube (2, 3). Only the largest stars can hope to make a lot of money on scale or exclusives. Everyone else gets scraps. While platforms struggle for dominance, we as consumers benefit from low-cost subscriptions or "free" music but I feel the bands and musicians who make the music we love are getting seriously short-changed. It's not right. 1. http://www.billboard.com/articles/business/7625650/are-album-exclusives-dead-apple-music http://www.billboard.com/articles/business/7625650/are-album... 2. http://www.billboard.com/articles/news/7408970/taylor-swift-paul-mccartney-180-artists-signing-petition-digital http://www.billboard.com/articles/news/7408970/taylor-swift-... 3. http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2015/01/28/songs-got-151781-plays-youtube-received-10/ http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2015/01/28/songs-got-151781-...
- siproprio 10y agoAs a user of Apple Music and Spotify, I tell you, Apple is absolutely not strong when it comes to playlists. Just the fact that in Spotify you can have user created and shared playlists makes Spotify much stronger, for all the playlists their users have. Also, in Apple Music most of the playlists for genres other than Hip-hop and Pop are yearly "Hits" compilations. I think that Apple is much worse than Spotify in this particular point.
- ilamont 10y agoI was thinking of Apple vs. Amazon Music, whose playlists are sometimes laughably bad. Amazon is trying hard to be a contender in this space with low-cost plans but if they don't figure out playlists it will be an uphill battle against Spotify, Apple and other services that do better.
- genericpseudo 10y ago
- dano 10y agoSpotify, Pandora, slacker, and all the rest will all get the same deal from the copyright holders. Google, Apple, Amazon will be the long term winners because they have ancillary revenues and music is a loss leader.
- TylerH 10y agoNow if only they'd bring back the ability to pause, play, skip, and go back when right-clicking the icon after the program is hidden from the start bar, like we could back in 0.9.7... and bring back the extension API...