4 ms·
I would be very interested to know how much of this is caused by a change in housing preference v/s a change in the nature of employment/wages for millennials.
by pm90 10y ago
I would be very interested to know how much of this is caused by a change in housing preference v/s a change in the nature of employment/wages for millennials. When you had reasonable expectation that your job would last for several years, you are more willing to invest in building up equity in a suburban home/community.
Also, the no.1 reason why people seem to want to move to suburbs is children (IMO, anecdotal etc.)... perhaps the falling fertility is making married/live-in couples more willing to live in a dense, urban communities?
- gozur88 10y agoI think that's the case. Americans tend to move out of the city and buy a house in the suburbs when they have children. The perception (true or not) is suburbs are safer and offer better schools. Also, I suspect you can almost buy a house in the 'burbs for the difference in rent between a one and two bedroom apartment in SF.
- alistairSH 10y agoYou're suspicion on the cost of living downtown vs the suburbs is correct for DC. My son lives in a new 500sqft flat in a nice downtown neighborhood. His rent in $2200/month and that seems fairly typical for that area. You can spend less for an older unit or one in a less desirable area. That $2200 is definitely enough to pay a mortgage in many parts of Fairfax County (assuming a moderate downpayment).
- ghaff 10y agoI know many people who have been in that position when they had children. They like the city but they have a kid and the combination of $/sq ft, schools, and general environment made them, however reluctantly, move out. (The few I know who remained in Manhattan or wherever were very well off and used private schools.)
- otoburb 10y ago>>(The few I know who remained in Manhattan or wherever were very well off and used private schools.) ... or managed to survive the seemingly insane NYC Department of Education admissions process to enter your child[ren] into public Pre-K, Kindergarten or Middle School. There are good schools in the city, but most are difficult to get into for a variety of reasons.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoI have a one bedroom apartment next to work in a fairly urban location. This fits my wife, my MIL, and our newborn. It doesn't feel small at all (helps that this is more space than we had in China, but still...)
- jimbokun 10y agoWhen your child starts school is when the big decisions will come.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoYa, but for the first few years, at least, it doesn't feel crowded.
- pm90 10y agoIf you/your wife/MIL grew up in an urban community, this might be easier. For instance, I grew up in rather dense urban communities in India, and for the longest time, my family did not even have a car (my dad had a 2 wheeler). So I don't find it that weird to live in an apartment with the whole family. For Americans that grew up in Suburbia though...this might be different.
- mhneu 10y agothe no.1 reason why people seem to want to move to suburbs is children (IMO, anecdotal etc.) I don't think it's anecdotal. In nearly every city in the US the urban schools are bad and there are much better suburban schools. It's not just a funding difference as many urban schools do get decent funding. It appears to be a complex issue of parent engagement, varying leadership quality in different urban schools, and peer role models and family life. Whatever causes suburban schools to be better, I believe the gap is narrowing. Today's high school population reflects parents' housing choices ten years ago. Urban elementary schools are already far better than they were a decade ago.