16 ms·
Goodbye Mac App Store
- emersonrsantos 10y agoPlease replace this title, it's misleading.
- ThomPete 10y agoThats the title of the post, so not misleading at all.
- kylec 10y agoThe title makes sense on that company's blog, but in the context of HN it could appear to mean that the Mac App Store itself is going away.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoNot with the domain indicated right next to it.
- phaed 10y agoOr a modicum of critical thinking.
- tiglionabbit 10y agoIt's what I thought at first though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vacri 10y agoCan we please not cater to this kind of anti-intellectual dumbing-down of things? Lowering the bar to spoon-feed a TL;DR of the article's content into the title - it's just getting ridiculous. Maybe for every complaint about article titles, I should respond with a demand to simplify them even further with "Up-Goer-Five" talk[1]. After all, if we're protecting people from having to think, we may as well lower the vocabulary requirements as well. [1]https://xkcd.com/1133/ https://xkcd.com/1133/
- htk 10y agoNot misleading. The phrasing might be ambiguous, but in this case it's the author leaving the Mac App Store, not the other way around.
- simplehuman 10y agoUltimately, it comes to these apps not making money from the App Store and it's not worth the hassle anymore
- chvid 10y agoThe company's products looks like a bunch of simple utilities; I would be surprised if they any made any money at all from the App Store.
- PopsiclePete 10y agoI'm amazed at the possibilities out there for some easy cash. Guy I know paid thousands of dollars for commodity "libraries" like XML parsers, ZIP utilities, FTP/SFTP, all because there wasn't anything out-of-the-box for his VB6 product.
- charlesdm 10y agoYou'd be surprised with what you can actually make money on the App Store. Yes, there's money in utilities.
- danm07 10y agoThis post just goes to show how many people use the upvote button as a way save articles without reading them first. The flywheel of clickbait titles in action.
- apeace 10y ago> For both applications, complying with Apple’s sandboxing and feature constraints to get them approved for sale would have required significant rewrites. As a user, this makes me want to get apps from the app store rather than downloading directly. It bothers me that apps can write arbitrary files. I'd much rather they be sandboxed so that when I tell the OS to delete the app, everything goes with it.
- axoltl 10y agoIt's also a rather important security feature.
- ams6110 10y agoWhen OSX and iOS merge, there won't be any options other than the App Store. Might as well bite the bullet and make the necessary revisions, or just decide to abandon the Apple market.
- hgontijo 10y agoIs that really happening? Links or you just got information from inside Apple?
- ams6110 10y agoI'm speculating. I just can't see the financial upside for Apple to continue with Mac OS X. The vast majority of their sales and profits are from phones, tablets, and music. Mac OS X and laptop and desktop hardware will become more and more of a distraction. We've seen them stagnating already. As a unix, Mac OS X is a rather elderly BSD. They may keep a laptop device in the mix, but it will be more like a chromebook and run iOS. Again, I'm speculating.
- chrisballinger 10y agoExcept you need to use macOS to develop iOS apps.
- ThomPete 10y agoI have said it before. I pulled my app from the mac app store after 5-6 months and haven't looked back since. My sales were quite good but the sandboxing made it impossible to do any real innovation on the OS X platform which my app is trying to do. Getting any help from support was impossible and so I decided to sell from my own website instead. Whether pulling it was the reason why my sales have gone up I don't think there is a way to validate but it had no negative effect on my sales quite the contrary. I was in the top 10 on the app store for a while and it had no effect on my sale. Only getting featured means anything for your sales which makes me conclude that the mac app store add no value what so ever to either user nor developer. Apple should shut it down and simply focus on featuring apps they think are worth featuring instead of creating an app store which create a million apps with no value to anyone not even the developers yet they still create a lot of noise. If not that they they should at least allow the user to decide whether they want to give access for the specific app to things outside the sandbox.
- nuxxx 10y ago> the sandboxing made it impossible to do any real innovation on the OS X platform which my app is trying to do Do you have any examples of things you needed to do but the sandbox prevented you from doing?
- ThomPete 10y agoTracking which app is currently in use. http://www.ghostnoteapp.com/ http://www.ghostnoteapp.com/ If you check out the video you can see what I am using it for. When I started developing it there was no problems, then around when I pushed it to the app store Sandbox rules got more strict (Around Maverick) in Yosemite they made it impossible to have things run in the background instead it made a spinning gear up in the menu bar because we were using applescript which was so annoying and gave us so many complaints. We were not the only ones as you can see here https://discussions.agilebits.com/discussion/33333/spinning-gear-in-status-menu https://discussions.agilebits.com/discussion/33333/spinning-... I tried to talk with support about finding ways around that but they basically told me that was I was trying to do was not really allowed anymore and I would most likely not be approved next time. The only way to get rid of the spinning gear was to use a different kind of library which wasn't allowed in the Mac App store so I pulled it.
- eladx 10y agoI'm not familiar with Apple's guidelines for publishing apps to the Mac App Store, but this post highlights an interesting point-- Traditionally, the burden of security was on consumers: which emails or files to open, programs to run/install, actions to approve, etc. Efforts to enhance the security of third-party software have been sporadic and limited, e.g. SELinux policies, changes to ports to use OpenBSD's pledge (systrace before) and FreeBSD's capsicum. This is the first time I see a mainstream OS vendor forcing third-party software authors to use advanced security mechanisms (like sandboxing) as a prerequisite for software distribution through official channels. I think it's great. I hope similar policies make it to Android and Windows.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoAndroid always required sandboxing, and Windows's Store/UWP (and the older Windows 8 variant) also require sandboxing. Unfortunately Windows "desktop apps" don't have the option of using the same sandbox, but with some effort you can sandbox your program (Chrome does this to its renderer subprocesses, for example).
- contextfree 10y agoTo clarify, the same AppContainer mechanism that UWP apps run in is available for use by Win32 apps (e.g., desktop IE11 used it for "Enhanced Protected Mode"). It's not suitable as a way for users to force existing apps designed for medium trust to run under AppContainer, which I'm guessing is what you meant?
- johncolanduoni 10y agoNo actually I wasn't aware AppContainer was available to Win32 apps, I thought the only thing they could use is integrity and the pre-Vista permission model.
- ThomPete 10y agoIt's not great because it basically hinders any real development and innovation on the platform. It's not felt as much on iOS because so much effort goes into building new features, tools and improve hardware that it feels like you are innovating even though you are sandboxed. The OS X haven't had any real love for a long time so Sandboxing it is slowly suffocating the entire ecosystem.
- smpetrey 10y agoApple should shut down the Mac App Store and open a Product Hunt style website for all Mac Apps instead.
- addicted 10y agoI am increasingly against sandboxed platforms on the desktop. We have a perfectly great sandboxed platform on every desktop already. It's called the browser. What our OS overlords need to do is create great App Stores which are intended to promote the apps that explicitly cannnot do things within a sandbox, etc., and for the rest, increase hooks that are provided to web apps so they can act as first class citizens as well.
- unit91 10y agoMy app store is homebrew. It's extremely seldom that I don't find what I need there.
- kartickv 10y agoIt doesn't make sense for Apple to enforce sandboxing at the store level, since it merely incents developers to distribute outside the store. And some apps that remain in the store have a worse UX, like not having certain capabilities, or requiring a helper app, which is a horrible solution. Instead, permissions should be implemented at the OS layer, not just for Mac app store apps. Here's how it would work: - An app could specify a list of permissions, like on Android. - One of the permissions would be "unrestricted", which is equivalent to today's unsandboxed apps. - The first time you try to run an app that requires unrestricted permission, macOS will tell you the app could be dangerous and ask for confirmation. This is similar to how Gatekeeper warns about unsigned apps, but here the focus is on what the app can do, not who made it. - If a legacy app didn't specify a list of permissions, it would be treated as "unrestricted". That way, there's no incentive for developers to leave the Mac app store. Security is increased for all users, no matter where they download the apps from. This mechanism doesn't restrict the power of the platform, what developers can do.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoUAC is basically that except only for when administrator permissions are required, and apps still abuse it. Most users just click through things like that without reading, and don't really have the knowledge to evaluate whether it makes sense for an app to need such access in the first place. I don't see how your idea would lead to anything else when it asks in even more cases that UAC does. Most developers will just not specify a list or just specify restricted, like they did on Windows when UAC came out.
- kartickv 10y agoI haven't used UAC, so I can't comment about it, but permissions on iOS work fine. I'm asked only once, usually the first time I use an app, or access certain functionality in an app, not constantly.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoYes, but there's no broad "catch all" permission, and the permissions are things every user will understand (e.g. access contacts). Additionally you don't have the option to pretend your app is older than it is and bypass permissions altogether. Your proposal is very different from the iOS model.
- Khaine 10y agoAs a user this frustrates me no end. I want my apps to be sandboxed to protect my computer. I want my apps to all be in a central repository that automates a bunch of painful processes (buying, updating, etc). But the Mac App Store is a dumpster fire at the moment. Its impossible to find the thing you want, its hard for developers to comply. Its the worst possible outcome of the store concept. Apple really needs to lift its game.
- emodendroket 10y agoIf you think it looks rough check out the Windows app store.
- twhb 10y agoThe Mac App Store provides real benefits: reduced app permissions, effective malware screening, improved auto-update, and easy uninstallation. I do see that it's incompatible with many OS augmentation programs, but for the App Store to reduce security would be pyrrhic. What we need is a user-granted sandbox opt-out, so that I can unencumber only programs I believe need it and won't abuse it, without taking the App Store's benefits from those programs.
- kilon 10y agoI am against any form of sand boxing and crippling my control of a system as a developer. Which is one of many reason I hate web developing with a vengeance. Even more than I hate Windows ( though win 10 seems to have potential ). I am a big , not huge, but big fan of Apple but in this case of me surrendering control. Μολων λαβέ
- frusciante29 10y agoIf any developer thinks that in a few years, sandboxing won't be mandatory and fundamental on macOS, I don't know what to tell you. So running away from it now is prolonging the inevitable.
- bsaul 10y agoAs an iOS developper, i feel really jealous. I see those mac developpers running away from the jailhouse, dancing and chanting about their freedom, while i miserably keep giving 30% of my revenues to a company that keep looking at third party developpers as a burden.
- oneplane 10y agoJust because you can't or won't use the sandboxing required by the AppStore, that doesn't mean that you should just not go to the MAS and ignore sandboxing... maybe you should _always_ sandbox?
- zimbatm 10y agoThere is a big opportunity for Homebrew Cask[1]. It's already a fully-fledged app catalog. It's only missing a GUI for normal people to use it. [1]: https://caskroom.github.io/ https://caskroom.github.io/
- nthState 10y agoIt would be interesting to do a study of what features developers require no-sandbox for, then maybe Apple could address those specific areas. Most of the apps I make use the sandbox with no problem.
- endemic 10y agoA common theme I'm noticing in these comments is that the MAS provides value by 1.) allowing easy reinstallation of all apps on a fresh system, and 2.) mitigating malware risk. I'm very surprised by these opinions, to be honest. Reinstallation of applications on a fresh OS is such an infrequent event that it makes no sense to optimize for it. And malware? Really? Was it such a problem before the MAS? I agree these things have value, but not enough to give away so much power to Apple.
- ryanwaggoner 10y agoMany users don't seem to agree :) I'd add a third one: buying is 1-click and shares no info with the seller. As opposed to the usual "navigate this crappy checkout process and get spammed forever" one.
- dilap 10y agosomehow or other, i find myself reinstalling apps on fresh systems what seems like "a lot". it's really fucking annoying to have to chase through custom app registration and download systems.
- __mp 10y agoJettison looks like a nice app.
- stevefeinstein 10y ago>let’s just say that while the Mac App Store is convenient for consumers, it doesn’t really serve the needs of some developers Boo fking hoo. If you didn't want to sell to consumers then the choice of selling your app in a less consumer convenient way would make sense. If you just don't want to do a little extra work or are put off by Apple's consumer focused restrictions, you can just go away if you ask me.
- searchfaster 10y agoThe other day I tried PixelMator and loved it right away. Only thing holding me back from buying it is the 'Mac App Store' :(
- cdransf 10y agoAt this point Apple may as well just shutter the Mac App Store and bring back the software update utility. The restrictions the place on apps in the store are too onerous and are inconsistent with the nature of the platform.