9 ms·
Chatbot that overturned 160k parking fines now helping refugees claim asylum
- emodendroket 10y agoI think one of these processes is a lot easier than the other.
- NegatioN 10y agoI totally agree. But the common denominator is that both of these battles can be won by deep knowledge of the beurouchratic process. I believe bots can be better equipped to deal with this than humans in the long run.
- emodendroket 10y agoI can see that, especially with the language barrier (even if you want to apply for a visa for a foreign spouse, as I did, the paperwork is voluminous and complex), but if your case is anything other than dead-simple you can't really duplicate a lawyer's experience dealing with immigration officers (and judges? I don't know exactly how this process works), knowledge of their particular individual tendencies, etc.
- ramses0 10y ago"A good lawyer knows the law, a great lawyer knows the judge"
- icebraining 10y agoSure, but a chatbot is better than a lawyer they can't afford.
- elandybarr 10y agoSo what happens when all 10.5 million Somalians, 22.85 million Syrians, 24.41 million Yemenis, 33.42 millions Iraqis, 37.96 million Sudanese, 6.35 million Eritreans, 77.45 million Iranians, etc apply?
- parhurs 10y agoAh, the infamous slippery slope.
- AckSyn 10y agoFrom my position, people should seek refuge in their region and eventually return home. The USA can always send aid in the form of workers, money, logistics, and more.
- parhurs 10y agoThey do. The vast majority of refugees reside in third world countries. Edit: 86% actually [0] [0]https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2015/10/global-refugee-crisis-by-the-numbers/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2015/10/global-refuge...
- roywiggins 10y agoPeople do. Dadaab is the largest refugee camp in the world. It's in Kenya, near the border with Somalia. It houses >250k people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dadaab https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dadaab There are millions of Syrian refugees, and a vast majority of them have taken refuge in neighboring countries: Turkey, Jordan, Lebanon.
- earthtolazlo 10y agoTo be fair, climate change will very likely create hundreds of millions if not billions of refugees fleeing north in the coming decades.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dao- 10y agoSince this certainly won't happen, what's the point of your question?
- 10y ago
- fnbr 10y agoWhat worries me about this is the liability- if you mess up someone's asylum claim, they can die, or suffer extreme harm (e.g. if they're tortured). I'd be interested in seeing how DoNotPay manages their liability.
- taurath 10y agoAt what level are they allowed to say something to the effect of "We are trying out very best to make this as useful and applicable to everyone, and in order to help as many people as possible we'd like you to agree to not hold us liable for anything bad that happens. Use us as a resource but we are not fully authoritative."
- ksdale 10y agoI'm not sure how close this is to being the practice of law, but lawyers are generally not allowed to contract away malpractice liability. As a lawyer, I feel like it would be beneficial for everyone to allow it in certain cases, like here, but as with everything, there's the potential for abuse.
- dao- 10y ago> The 20-year-old chose Facebook Messenger as a home for the latest incarnation of his robot lawyer because of accessibility. “It works with almost every device, making it accessible to over a billion people,” he said. That can't be the whole story... A web app could have been at least as accessible. I guess Facebook offers APIs that make developing this kind of application easier than looking for other frameworks or starting from scratch.
- RangerScience 10y agoSure, but the dev already has experience with the tech behind a chat bot, and may not have the experience needed to make a web app as easily. Think about all the "obvious" steps involved (text input, message chain display, page/server communications), the extra features FB messenger has (in-message buttons); then the issues with cleanly displaying on multiple screen sizes; and then you start getting into the fiddly bits like page reloading, form submission failures (say, due to internet disconnect).... ...All of that is done for you. You just need to have the meat of the program (the chat) and you're good to go. Makes a lot of sense, actually.
- andrenotgiant 10y agoThe idea of Facebook platform being more accessible than the web is scary to me, but not surprising. Think about non-tech-savvy users on low-end devices, Facebook is familiar, and there's no responsiveness or web accessibility issues, it can feel faster because Facebook can optimize what is getting downloaded. It is scary when you extend this out a few years, FB and Google continue to extend the line of what gets consumed on their platform vs what sends people off to a web page. Your company's branded app is already dead, soon your company's website will be dead.
- jlev 10y agoGreat to see more chatbots that encourage real world civic action, not just make it easier to order pizza. I did similar work with Hello.Vote for voter registration, and there are so many offline forms that could be improved with a bit of web/messaging UI. Also see snapfresh.org for a CfA project that helps find places that accept EBT cards.
- ending 10y agoAwesome projects, and I love the civic spirit from which they arise. Any others worth checking out? Other than chat bots, just making forms and bureaucratic processes more accessible online seems like an arena that still has vast potential for improvement.
- ptaipale 10y agoNot sure if this is actual "civic action". At least if this is deployed in Europe, it sounds to me more like a deliberate action to completely destroy what remains of the asylum system, which is already struggling both technically and with its political and popular support, due to the large number of applicants who are economic migrants rather than actual refugees. It may be different with U.S. and Canada, though - things are a bit easier when asylum applicants are not coming over unguarded land borders. (FWIW, I've assisted an immigrant, an old woman, in composing her complaint to the national courts and ECHR. The system is rigged against honest applicants because of the overload caused by more or less frivolous cases. We lost, too, technically, but she was in too bad shape to be deported so eventually got permission to stay.)
- taurath 10y agoCapital flows completely freely between borders, but people can't. I don't really blame anyone for being economic migrants - they're just refugees of a different type.
- ptaipale 10y agoOf course I don't blame anyone for being an economic migrant. It's a very natural thing to do: search for a better life. It's what I would do. Economic and technical development has progressed in Africa and Asia so that larger numbers of people than ever are able to consider migration. We see that now on the Libyan coast. However, particularly for European governments, it's now becoming visible that there is a selection to be made: you can have completely open borders, or you can have a welfare state, but you can't have both.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nanistheonlyist 10y agoJust need a bot that submits fake applications to this bot. This will overload the system and reduce the probability of human-generated applications being processed.
- willyyr 10y agoAnyone knows what technology he is using in the background? Is it Facebooks own BOT-Framework?
- sjroot 10y agoYes, Facebook has a Messenger bot framework.
- omash 10y agoCan someone explain how the first chatbot was any better than an interactive form?
- wutbrodo 10y agoIt's something I personally find very bizarre, but I've definitely noticed that a lot of people have a very strong mental block about doing things on a computer, or even a browser. These tasks instantly seem 10x more daunting, and people feel like they can mess it up easily. Chat interfaces that are thin wrappers over web forms don't provide any actual functional value, but on the basis of these observations I could understand them helping with people's feelings of being "overwhelmed by the system".
- cordite 10y agoIt likely gives end users a sense of itemized reward. Rather than showing a vast huge form, or even a progress bar, a chat bot can choose what next to prioritize and present. Not all parts of a form may be applicable, showing what is needed and letting the end user continue at their leisure reduces stress and cognitive overhead. The above is likely why tax companies have been doing better as of late when it comes to completing tax forms.
- r00fus 10y agoSo it's like a 90's-esque UI wizard?
- elastic_church 10y agobefore you know it we're going to be using chatrooms with pound signs for each channel and addressing users with @ symbols again at least I don't have to wait for the mod to +v me. we'll have a chatbot for that
- vertex-four 10y agoYou should check out Matrix[0]. :) [0] https://matrix.org https://matrix.org
- nyolfen 10y agocapital is also an abstract concept and doesn't commit sexual assault. the two categories have little in common and it's a bizarre comparison to draw.
- nsajko 10y agoYou think migrants are more rape-y than capital? ;) Edit: Are you insinuating that all migrants commit sexual assault, or maybe even that sexual assault is only perpetrated by migrants?
- vanjoe 10y agoI think adding absolutes is not helpful
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nyolfen 10y ago>Are you insinuating that all migrants commit sexual assault, or maybe even that sexual assault is only perpetrated by migrants? only that there is a disproportionate amount of sexual assault committed by migrants in europe. [0][1][2] this is a real cost associated with immigration, even if verboten to speak about amongst liberals. women pay the price for their silence. [0] https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-eez6Ab6u1C0/VmO6u36KY2I/AAAAAAAAILk/7hKxdcW_Swg/s1600/Norway%2BOslo%2B2011%2Brapes%2Bby%2Bcategory%2Band%2Bimmigrant%2Borigin%2Bbar%2Bgraph.png https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-eez6Ab6u1C0/VmO6u36KY2I/AAAAAAAAI... [1] https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-7lHPdsLuFLU/VmOgQS6thEI/AAAAAAAAIKY/uJ7o8nbgEo0/s1600/Sweden%2BRape%2Bstats%2B1997%2Bto%2B2001%2Bby%2Bimmigrant%2Borigin%2Bbar%2Bgraph.png https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-7lHPdsLuFLU/VmOgQS6thEI/AAAAAAAAI... [2] http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-McMd_WvVqRk/VmQsLZ_rwUI/AAAAAAAAIL0/qyn1JFZdP0I/s1600/Denmark%2Brape%2Bstats%2Bimmigrant%2Borigin%2B2000%2B02.png http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-McMd_WvVqRk/VmQsLZ_rwUI/AAAAAAAAIL...
- throwaway_374 10y agoThis isn't Breitbart. Your nazi kind aren't welcome here. Edit: Let the Trump boys downvote away but this is precisely the hallmarks of nazism, blaming an entire group of people. I will not sit silently while this happens before my eyes. Go ahead, downvote away.
- PoarNeemn 10y agoJust what we need, more "refugees" sucking us dry
- roywiggins 10y agoI bet you could do a lot of good with an equivalent for eviction proceedings. Most people being evicted don't have representation.
- etjossem 10y agoThe author may already be working on this. He "decided to expand the bot’s capabilities after DoNotPay began receiving messages about evictions and repossessions." [1] For now the evictions/homelessness feature seems to offer only assistance in applying for public housing. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/aug/11/chatbot-lawyer-beat-parking-fines-helping-homeless-do-not-pay https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/aug/11/chatbot-l... [1]
- razakel 10y agoThe guy who created the parking fine chatbot did so because he kept getting parking tickets. He could quite simply have stopped parking like a cunt. Shameless self-publicity disguised as public service from an arrogant, self-entitled man.
- dang 10y agoThis comment breaks the HN guidelines. If you have a substantive point, please make it thoughtfully; if you don't, please don't post.
- MattRix 10y agoHow do you not understand this, the entire point of DoNotPay is to fight unfair tickets. If the tickets were valid, he wouldn't be able to fight them. It is designed to help PEOPLE rather than the government. And top of that, helping refugees is even more of a positive thing. I sense some jealousy...
- canadaj 10y agoOr maybe he did so because he kept getting unfair or incorrectly issued tickets.