6 ms·
In Philly, Uber asked for a license, was denied, then told its drivers they would cover the costs of any fines and they should drive anyway. Offering upfront to
by tedunangst 10y ago
In Philly, Uber asked for a license, was denied, then told its drivers they would cover the costs of any fines and they should drive anyway. Offering upfront to pay fines doesn't sound like they thought they found a loophole.
- yazaddaruvala 10y agoThat is a loophole! If the fines incurred are less than margins, then you have a profitable strategy.
- jaclaz 10y agoMargins? Profit? Both seem like not a priority for Uber. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-20/uber-s-loss-exceeds-800-million-in-third-quarter-on-1-7-billion-in-net-revenue https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-20/uber-s-lo... >The company is said to have lost at least $2 billion last year and is on track to pile up a loss of at least $3 billion this year. Those are rough figures that may underestimate how much money Uber is losing and don't include interest, taxes or stock-based compensation.
- mikeash 10y agoYeah, I don't think that's too bad. If you know you're breaking the law and accept the fines and pay them willingly because it's worth the cost, I don't see a big problem with that. Where I start having trouble is when they try to hide their lawbreaking, or fight against enforcement. For a similar example, UPS and FedEx both rack up an unbelievable amount of parking tickets in major cities for stopping their delivery vehicles in places where they're not allowed. These companies do this deliberately, because it's cheaper to pay the tickets than to have drivers take the extra time and effort of locating a legal place to stop. Some big cities have gone so far as to set up special accommodations for these companies to pay their tickets in bulk rather than dealing with each one individually. In effect, these parking tickets work as a tax on delivery companies. Doesn't seem particularly evil. Interesting side note: USPS, as a federal agency, apparently has immunity from local laws like this, so they don't get ticketed. This gives them a substantial advantage over their non-governmental competitors in big cities.
- orcdork 10y agoYou're advocating for wealth being over the law. I don't see how you can feel that this is not a big problem.
- Karunamon 10y agoSome laws are dumb. There's a distressing trend on HN recently of people citing "the law" as if it were the end of any kind of practical or moral discussion.
- _jal 10y agoSo those with the money to do so should be free to break them, while those who can't need to obey, and that's just right and proper?
- jamornh 10y agoNo, but then that's an issue with the way fines and punishments for said crimes are structured, not the fault of those who takes advantage of the loophole. There are 2 types of fines: fines that are meant to stop things from happening and fines that are there to basically make the city money. Most traffic fines seem to be structured for the latter.
- orcdork 10y agoGood to know it's up to you to pick and choose which laws inconvenience you, I mean which laws are there to make those fat cats at the city office the big bucks.
- Dylan16807 10y agoWhat in the world are you talking about? They stated that different laws exist for different reasons. That's not picking and choosing laws. And they didn't say that laws to make money are inherently bad either.
- trimbo 10y agoUPS and Fedex pay New York millions in parking fines as a cost of doing business[1]. How come we don't really think of them as scofflaws, but we do with Uber? (I include myself when asking this question) [1] - http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20130526/ECONOMY/305269980/parking-tickets-all-in-the-cost-of-doing-business http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20130526/ECONOMY/305269...
- tedunangst 10y agoThat happens a lot around here too. Actually, I know (by sight) both the UPS drivers and the parking enforcement people. The UPS drivers, at least that I can see, usually try to park somewhere slightly out of the way, so they're not blocking traffic or creating a dangerous diversion. Uber drivers generally seem to act like they're the only car on the road. That's more of a driver thing than a company thing, but culture comes from the top.
- cbhl 10y agoI feel like this behavior comes from the riders -- people give bad ratings if they don't get picked up exactly at their door, double parking be damned.
- wrsh07 10y agoThat's an interesting thing: in basketball, fouls are part of the game and used in the last minutes to get the ball back In most other sports, doing that would be "breaking the rules." Not sure how such a division arises. (Maybe if the authorities make no attempt to "close" said loophole?)
- ghaff 10y agoIn general, in sports there's something of a distinction between fouls that are simply a violation of a game's rules and fouls that also cause or at least risk injuries. The former are generally regarded to be just part of the game and, presumably, penalties are commensurate with the foul. It's not uncommon for "dirty" play to have consequences in addition to the foul called at the time. The basketball example is an interesting one. One assumes that if the league wanted to eliminate that type of play they'd change the rules to increase the penalty in some way by docking points or whatever.
- exDM69 10y agoWhere I'm from (in the EU), any profits from illegal activity are confiscated upon conviction, sometimes also including "the tools" used to commit the crime. After several Uber drivers had to pay back all their earnings, lose their car and get a fine on top, there has been significantly less drivers willing to take the risk. Outside of some peak hours (new years, etc) where the risk of getting caught is minimal, the only ones left are the really shady drivers with their crappy cars.
- Zak 10y agoThis is often true in the US when the illegal activity is a crime punishable by imprisonment. It usually isn't when the illegal activity is some form of doing business without the required license.
- criddell 10y agoIn Sarasota, FL, rather than trying to regulate Uber, the city removed regulation on taxis. This was more than a year ago. I wonder why more cities don't take this approach?