7 ms·
This should be a lesson to people who don't understand the distinction between "can't" and "won't". If you're running things yourself and control the encryptio
by koolba 10y ago
This should be a lesson to people who don't understand the distinction between "can't" and "won't".
If you're running things yourself and control the encryption keys required to access your data, then your service provider can't be compelled to release your data as it's not possible[1][2].
If you're delegating all of that to your service provider and they have access to the raw data, then you are putting all your trust in them to protect your data and prevent it's release. And that has to cover everything from hackers, to snooping employees, to the Feds.
[1]: Kind of ... I don't recall the Apple/FBI case going to court for a final resolution so it's possible they can compel the service provider to hack you to get the keys but at least they can't get it directly.
[2]: And obviously they can always come after you with a court order or rubber hose (or both).
- shshhdhs 10y agoThey can only reveal voice data IF the victim said "Alexa" when the crime was taking place. If the victim didn't say "Alexa" that day, then there's nothing to reveal. Your example about encryption doesn't make sense in the context of the Echo.
- IncRnd 10y agoFalse Positives. "I'll Let Some" one else discuss how false positives can affect detection.
- npongratz 10y agoI'm not certain there exists nothing to reveal. Is there a technical limitation of the system that prevents or avoids recording of "non-'Alexa'" audio? Or do I just trust Amazon when they say their alway-on device only records when triggered with the magic word? As I think about it, I'd ask the same regarding the voice-controllable phone in my pocket. FWIW, I don't trust the devices, because their operations are out of any consumer's ability to control them, but maybe I'm missing something about their technical limitations that would work in my favor.
- joezydeco 10y agoFrom looking at the internals, there's technically nothing that prevents uploading all audio constantly to AWS. Practically, it would be unwieldy to have 10,000,000 devices sending audio to 10,000,000 audio decoding and processes 24 hours a day nonstop. You'd also see a huge bandwidth hit at your ISP, which would certainly kill future adoptions if the word got out.
- austenallred 10y agoSo record the audio 24/7 and compress and send once an hour? Once a day? Or eliminate empty space first. The files wouldn't be that big
- dpark 10y agoCompression over an hour or a day won't do anything meaningful vs compression over, say, a minute. There's just not that much additional redundancy to eliminate. Uploading in a big burst doesn't save on overall bandwidth, either.
- squarefoot 10y agoTotally possible. As an example, Codec2 used in ham-radio applications can send pretty decent voice audio at a few kilobit/s or less, and it keeps sounding perfectly understandable even at 1.2 kbit/s like this short sample: http://www.rowetel.com/downloads/codec2/hts1a_1200.wav http://www.rowetel.com/downloads/codec2/hts1a_1200.wav More information here: http://www.rowetel.com/?page_id=452 http://www.rowetel.com/?page_id=452
- kbenson 10y agoTo spell it out, that's < 12.7 megabytes every 24 hours. If there are 10 million Echo devices, that's 127 million megabytes a day, or 127 terabytes a day. That's actually not that hard to handle for the company that runs AWS, so while extremely unlikely, it's not impossible. Just very, very costly.
- tonylemesmer 10y agoI happen to have met the hardware engineers who developed the chipset and microphone array PCB inside the Echo and they told me there is no recording unless the trigger word is detected. I saw no evidence to prove or disprove this and there's nothing to say that the device couldn't be altered after installation. [edited: grammar]
- jessaustin 10y agoOnce upon a time this behavior would have been determined by hardware. For a device developed this decade, however, there's no way that a PCB design would determine this. Rather, this behavior is determined by the firmware loaded onto the microcontroller. Even if one didn't know that, the fact that the trigger word is easily changed by the user should indicate that everything is in software.
- sesutton 10y ago>If you're running things yourself and control the encryption keys required to access your data, then your service provider can't be compelled to release your data as it's not possible The court can just hold you in contempt until you do[1]. They also probably won't buy "I forgot". [1]: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/04/child-porn-suspect-jailed-for-7-months-for-refusing-to-decrypt-hard-drives/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/04/child-porn-suspe...
- saycheese 10y agoIf you delete the data, prior to getting the notice to produce the data and it wasn't deleted in anticipation of such a notice, sure the court could hold you in contempt, but legally you've done nothing wrong. You cannot easily make a third random third-party delete your data.
- ghshephard 10y agoYou might put yourself in a worse position if the court compels you to produce the data, but now you can't. You better be very certain that you are able to prove that you deleted the data prior to any notice, or you might find yourself in for a long jail stay. This is what a lot of people overlook - when the court compels you to produce evidence, or ill gotten gains, saying ,"I can't" - isn't a legal defense.
- koolba 10y ago> This is what a lot of people overlook - when the court compels you to produce evidence, or ill gotten gains, saying ,"I can't" - isn't a legal defense. We're getting closer and closer to testing that. IANAL but I'd imagine that some combination of the 4th and 5th amendments should cover that situation. The onus would be upon the prosecutor to prove that you destroyed the evidence after the fact. As a general rule, one does not have to prove they didn't commit a crime, the prosecutor has to prove that they did. Where this gets murky is if a judge orders you to present the non-existent data as contempt of court may apply.
- icebraining 10y agoOr as cperciva put it, "Playing chicken with cat.jpg" http://www.daemonology.net/blog/2012-01-19-playing-chicken-with-cat-jpg.html http://www.daemonology.net/blog/2012-01-19-playing-chicken-w...
- leeoniya 10y ago> In Tarsnap I might take this to an extreme — in addition to the aforementioned encryption, I encourage users to read the tarsnap source code rather than trusting that I got everything right You still have to trust that what's running on your machine and on the servers is compiled directly from the source you have access to, right?
- cperciva 10y agoYou don't need to trust the code on the server -- that's the point. You can compile the client code yourself. In fact, until recently you had to compile the client code yourself.
- leeoniya 10y agoah yes, sorry. is there a trusted compilation service that uses a distributed agreement mechanism, à la blockchain or DHT for validating some git/svn hash against a binary. every downloadable source publishes its own binary hashes but the whole practice is somewhat moot in the event of server compromise, not to mention build reproducability.
- beojan 10y agoYou can compile the code yourself, then you would know the binary matches the source. Of course, you have to trust your compiler and OS, but with a service you would have to trust their compiler and OS.
- williamscales 10y agoDo you trust your compiler?
- Kiro 10y agoI much rather put my trust in them than myself. I am clueless about security.
- verelo 10y agoMakes me think in future cases when someone says in court "I do not recall", we are going to see Google Home / Echo data being called into play. As someone with 3 google home devices in the house, I feel like my feara I've been suppressing are all coming true.
- andrepd 10y agoThen why did you buy 3 Google home devices?
- simplehuman 10y agoAdrenaline rush
- Neliquat 10y agoYou need hobbies.
- vollmond 10y agoI have these same fears, yet there are 4 android devices, an ipad, and an echo dot in my home. High utility and low chance of me being in the specific situation where internal home recordings are requested. High downside if I do end up there, but low risk of ending up there (hopefully).
- verelo 10y agoHome automation is an amazingly cool thing to do, and i theorize that it doesn't become a true part of your home unless you remove as many of the barriers to regular use as possible. Voice is very convenient, and access on every floor of the house was therefore something I wanted, so I bought 3. The experiment is still in progress, but I can tell you they're 90% used for playing music right now :)
- pizzetta 10y agoBut in this case, even if defendant had developed a system by themselves and had complete control over the data, nothing is preventing him from turning it over as well. Here they are complying with a customer's wishes and I imagine the same person would decide to open their own data if they had developed their own system.
- nojvek 10y agoThat assumes the data is there in the first place. What if Alexa just didn't record everything everyone said. It just sounds really really dumb. Like snapchat saving every image privately shared on a server. It's such a big scam. Sole reason I'm not buying their shares. I'm hoping someday we'll get true offline speech to annotated text translation that we as consumers control. Like I control what data is in my machine's hdd.
- dheera 10y agoApple and Amazon also have some amount of clout that helps them stand their ground to a great degree in situations like this. The Feds realize that if they shut down Amazon or Apple, the country is going to fall to pieces. As usual, startups are the ones that will suffer if faced with a situation like this.
- mikeash 10y agoThat's a good lesson, but I don't see how this example teaches it. The defendant consented to releasing the information. If Echo were designed to give the user total control over the encryption keys required to access their data, they still could have consented.
- njharman 10y agoExcept Amazon refused until defendant said it was OK. It's often easier to coerce single person rotting jail on contempt charges than a huge corporation. Point being, like everything, it is not as b/w, not as simple as you imply.
- strunz 10y agoSeriously, did anyone read the article? The defendant consented, Amazon didn't want to.