10 ms·
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
- xcodevn 10y agoI think consciousness is a concept created by our brain. It likes the concept of 'angry'. We all know what it feels like. But there is no 'angry'thing, our brain created it too.
- psyc 10y agoThe user-illusion metaphor is a central idea in Donald Hoffman's work. I'm not sure who borrowed it from whom. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oYp5XuGYqqY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oYp5XuGYqqY
- fdik 10y agoIf consciousness is an illusion, who is it falling for it?
- GavinMcG 10y agoWe are, obviously. From the article: "Nor do we have to understand the mechanisms that underlie those competencies. In an illuminating metaphor, Dennett asserts that the manifest image that depicts the world in which we live our everyday lives is composed of a set of user-illusions, 'like the ingenious user-illusion of click-and-drag icons, little tan folders into which files may be dropped, and the rest of the ever more familiar items on your computer’s desktop. What is actually going on behind the desktop is mind-numbingly complicated, but users don’t need to know about it, so intelligent interface designers have simplified the affordances, making them particularly salient for human eyes, and adding sound effects to help direct attention. Nothing compact and salient inside the computer corresponds to that little tan file-folder on the desktop screen.' He says that the manifest image of each species is 'a user-illusion brilliantly designed by evolution to fit the needs of its users.' In spite of the word 'illusion' he doesn’t wish simply to deny the reality of the things that compose the manifest image; the things we see and hear and interact with are 'not mere fictions but different versions of what actually exists: real patterns.' The underlying reality, however, what exists in itself and not just for us or for other creatures, is accurately represented only by the scientific image—ultimately in the language of physics, chemistry, molecular biology, and neurophysiology."
- coldtea 10y ago>The underlying reality, however, what exists in itself and not just for us or for other creatures, is accurately represented only by the scientific image—ultimately in the language of physics, chemistry, molecular biology, and neurophysiology." They are also mediated by consciousness. Unconscious scientists rarely do experiments or interpret their results. This is epistemology 101.
- GavinMcG 10y agoAnd yes, of course it's epistemology 101. But a lot of people haven't taken epistemology, and this article is a review of Dennett's book which delves into these issues for the general public. Edit: typo has been fixed.
- coldtea 10y ago>I assume you mean "mediated" rather than "medicated". Oops, yes, fixed that. I always make tons of typos on my HN comments.
- kerkeslager 10y agoThe underlying reality is absolutely not mediated by human consciousness, and I think the author's mistake here is even bringing up the human scientific fields, which muddies their point. Dennett does end up explaining a lot of epistemology 101 because his audience isn't philosophy academia. Dennett's innovation, which isn't described well by this book review, is to assert that epistemology is driven by reproductive pressure (both genetic and memetic).
- hprotagonist 10y ago>The underlying reality is absolutely not mediated by human consciousness... and, being a conscious human who can only rely on data inferred through his sense organs: who are _you_ to say?
- manyoso 10y ago
- neom 10y agoWorld Science Festival has a slew of really awesome talks etc on this subject posted to youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4H9ul7pqezs&list=PLKy-B3Qf_RDVn61ogKUR2lEHV0dGmWUc8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4H9ul7pqezs&list=PLKy-B3Qf_R... And The Neuroscience of Consciousness – with Anil Seth is really great: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRel1JKOEbI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRel1JKOEbI Information, Evolution, and intelligent Design - With Daniel Dennett: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZX6awZq5Z0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZX6awZq5Z0
- veli_joza 10y agoThat second talk is fantastic. Thanks for sharing. One interesting note he makes is that (according to metrics they developed) the hallucinogens really do help you achieve higher level of consciousness. All those self-reports of reaching "awakening" and "enlightenment" could actually be supported by neuroscience. Unfortunately it's too hard to get proper funding for any research on subject.
- coldtea 10y agoThe very notion doesn't even make sense. Illusion presupposes consciousness.
- eternalban 10y agos/consciousness/self for a more sensible sound bite.
- GavinMcG 10y agoIt sounds like you might have skipped over the part of the article that clarifies how Dennett is using that word. I excerpted it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13791547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13791547
- hhhahds 10y agoHumour me, I'm a bit slow. It sounds like he's using the word "illusion" to mean "illusion", as in something which seems real but is fake. Does this not still entail a Cartesian theater and a consciousness watching it to be fooled by the illusion ?
- coldtea 10y agoBut there's nothing in that passage to counter what I said. Illusion still needs some conscious entity to be fooled. Besides, the idea that: "The underlying reality, however, what exists in itself and not just for us or for other creatures, is accurately represented only by the scientific image—ultimately in the language of physics, chemistry, molecular biology, and neurophysiology." That's again a certain, centuries old, epistemology. And not a very good one. I would be better if he would have said "is best approximated" rather than "accurately represented".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Eerie 10y agoHa-ha-ha. Exactly. Illusion of WHO? Anything that can have illusions is a consciousness.
- api 10y agoDoesn't an illusion imply a consciousness to experience the illusion?
- FeepingCreature 10y agoNo.
- dwringer 10y agoNo, you're an illusion!
- kerkeslager 10y agoBetteridge's Law holds, and the author misrepresents Dennett's thesis. Dennett doesn't deny the existence of consciousness, animals, etc. as claimed, but rather says that our conceptions of consciousness, animals, etc. represent only the subset of existent phenomena that can be conceptualized with hardware that evolved via natural selection. Dennett posits that this effect favors conceptions that benefit the conceiver's chances of reproduction (either in a genetic or memetic sense) rather than conceptions that accurately represent the phenomena. Dennett's work is much better than this review, and I recommend reading the book rather than the review.
- manyoso 10y agoThat's just a wordy way of saying that we evolved according to Darwin and our consciousness was selected. Not terribly original or deep. Yawn.
- simonh 10y agoIs that a critique of the few sentences in the post you're replying to, or a considered rebuttal of your reading of the content of the book?
- manyoso 10y agoIt is a critique of the criticism of the review. If the review is wrong and Dennett's point is really just the standard materialistic worldview plus the trivial observation that consciousness evolved according to Darwin's laws, then it is really trifling.
- rocqua 10y agoI'd expect the book to contain well thought-out non-obvious conclusions from those rather obvious assumptions. Perhaps expanded by giving examples of potential underlying mechanisms.
- kerkeslager 10y ago
- kylek 10y agoThe idea of the illusion is not really a new one: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_(illusion) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_(illusion) .
- cscurmudgeon 10y agoThat is completely different though. Hinduism states that other than consciousness everything else is an illusion.
- ThomPete 10y agoYes consciousness is an illusion but the illusion is real. We are pattern recognizing feedback loops (with memory) who simulate a reality not the reality. This simulation happen to be calibrated in such a way that it allow us to navigate the reality with some success by proxy of our simulation of it.
- atomical 10y agoWhat is the reality?
- criddell 10y agoMathematics.
- CuriouslyC 10y agoYou might make the case for a stochastic simulation, but given how easy it is to produce analytically intractable equations, and the fundamental limits of logical systems demonstrated by Godel's incompleteness theorems, I highly doubt math is anything more than a clever method for approximating the universe.
- justifier 10y ago> stochastic simulation .. approximating the universe your education is showing.. perhaps you have a different definition of mathematics among many definitions you can define mathematics as an abstract science or as what those abstractions are studying but holding the first definition is insufficient evidence for the inexistence of the second i'm unclear what you think intractable equations.. whether easy or difficult to form and what the definitions of easy and hard are or why they are of consequence.. say of mathematics a computer is a system literally built as an electrical manifestation of mathematics, albeit a subset, and in its case suffers limitations of intractability but the mathematics underlying its structure still remain can you defend the position that the limitations of a nand gate somehow disproves quantity(o)? also, I think Godel would be distressed to have heard the incompleteness theorems being used to deny the existence of mathematics incompleteness is intended to show mathematics exists beyond the scope of proof for me incompleteness does go beyond its intentions but as proof of paradox such as the existence mathematics (o) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantity
- transfire 10y agoNo.
- carsongross 10y agoIf it is, is this an indictment of consciousness? Or of illusion?
- manyoso 10y agoDennett denies his own first person evidence of his own consciousness so that he can sustain his belief that all that exists is the materialistic world view. Motivated reasoning in the extreme and completely violating Occam's Razor which is quite ironic.
- ThomPete 10y agofirst person evidence doesen't lead you anywhere. Its a = a, true but quite trivial.
- sdfin 10y agowhat would a 3rd person evidence of consciousness be like?
- jnicholasp 10y agoIt does when the question is, "Does first person evidence exist?"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Aardwolf 10y agoIt doesn't really matter what is running the physics, whether it's a "real" world doing that, or some other process that some then call "illusion" which imho the same anyway after all it's real enough that we're able to think inside of it. Whether it's an illusion or not, the fact is that the consciousness is still there. The process that makes us aware (not just the sensing, the ability to know you think about it etc...) of the information (the world, no matter how it works) needs to be explained. Imho Douglas Hofstadter comes closest to trying to explain it without all that kind of pitfalls in "I Am a Strange Loop". Not that it actually truly explains it, but at least it acknowledges those things that make me normally dismiss theories that could explain consciousness.
- GavinMcG 10y agoI think you might be dismissing the article while actually agreeing with its core argument. It's not about a substrate on which reality is running - it's about access to the mechanisms of consciousness and how our view of consciousness doesn't reflect those mechanisms fully. Dennett's explanation basically uses Hofstadter's conception.
- beefield 10y ago>fact is that the consciousness is still there. There is a small problem with this claim. Or, at least there is a problem if you happen to believe in popperian philosophy of science that says that claims that are not falsifiable are non-scientific. Obviously, from popperian point of view that claim is about as unfalsifiable as is the claim that God created earth and everything on it. Which may be true or may be not, but the claim is not a claim in the scientific realm but in religious realm, and I would be a bit vary to consider claims in religious (or non-scientific if that is a bit less sensitive word) realm "facts". I mean, it feels obvious that I have conscience, but how do you prove or disprove that claim? I have no idea. It feels obvious that earth is flat, but there are ways to prove that wrong.
- mistersquid 10y agoPresence of consciousness is falsifiable, albeit indirectly and after the fact (unlike existence which is real time). Self-awareness/consciousness can verify its own falsifiability by using periods of unconsciousness such as dreamless sleep, fainting, etc. as evidence.
- anon0 10y agoSam Harris disagrees, arguing "Consciousness is the one thing in this universe that cannot be an illusion" https://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-mystery-of-consciousness https://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-mystery-of-conscious...
- coliveira 10y agoIf rats could talk they would say they have consciousness. This is not a human trait as even some philosophers seem to believe.
- danbruc 10y agoThis still seems not to [try to] answer the really hard question - how does a bunch of quarks and electrons go from mindlessly following the laws of physics to saying »Look, we are a bunch of quarks and electrons!«? I admittedly found it somewhat hard at times to follow the argument of the article, but in the end it seems to argue that consciousness is just one of many models embedded in our brain, more specifically a metamodel of the other models. But, assuming that I did not misunderstand the argument, that seems not to help much to explain how the laws of physics manage to reflect on themselves and bring the the awareness of existence into existence.
- rocqua 10y agoThe reason for this is solidly rooted in evolution. Having an internal model of your surroundings allows you to better interact with your surroundings. This is an evolutionary advantage. At some point, this expands to a model of yourself. I can see 2 ways for this model to come about. The first is directly, where being able to anticipate your own reactions is advantageous. The second is socially. That is, you need to model others to better anticipate their reactions. When those others are similar enough to yourself, those same modeling procedures also start working on yourself. This kind of modeling can get started by very simple correlations. Say you accidentally get some photo-sensitive cells. Over time, if their output starts affecting what direction you move (say away from the cells when less light falls on them) and all of a sudden you are capable of fleeing from predators.
- danbruc 10y agoThat is certainly a point of view I would agree with, but that is not what I meant. I did not mean how the structure forms but how the structure becomes conscious and self-aware. Let me try to explain with a though experiment, assuming humans are purely physical. You build a human-like robot with cameras, and microphones and actuators. You also build a gigantic mechanical computer out of gears and hook up the sensors and actuators of the robot to the mechanical computer. Finally you run a quantum mechanical simulation of a human brain and nerve system on the mechanical computer. Shouldn't the whole thing now be equivalent to a human? Shouldn't it be conscious and self-aware? This then raises the question, when and how did the gears stop to just turn according to simple rules and became a mind capable of exploring and thinking about the world? There seems to be some kind of large jump between mindless rotating gears and becoming aware of you own existence. I have a hard time making really precise what I mean, but I hope you get the idea.
- doener 10y ago>MARCH 9, 2017 ISSUE That's from the future!
- ygmelnikova 10y ago"Our user-illusions were not, like the little icons on the desktop screen, created by an intelligent interface designer." Once again the belief systems of billions are written off with a single sentence. Who would have thought the question of an existing "intelligent interface designer" could have been answered so tersely? So just how do atoms and quarks, following the fundamental laws of physics, say "we are atoms and quarks"?
- rocqua 10y agoAs I read it, this is an argument about what it means to be 'real'. The argument goes along the lines of consciousness can only be described behaviouristically. Therefore it is a behaviour. Moreover, consciousness only is a 'metaphor' for the material world, rather than a description of the material world. This is then taken to mean that it is so far divorced from the material world so as to merely be an illusion.
- kordless 10y agoI came up with this analogy to think about prior and new knowledge: Aliens. If aliens exist, they will have existed a priori, or before thought or knowledge. Granted, they wouldn't have existed a priori from their standpoint, but the logical conclusion, once you've found some aliens, is that there are always more aliens. i.e. If life is a "thing" in the universe, it is a "thing" because of a priori knowledge. If aliens don't exist, then that fact would also be a priori, given you could do an exhaustive search for aliens in the universe. As you probably can't do an exhaustive search because of size/energy constraints, you can look at the claim "there are no aliens" as one which is unprovable, and thus irrational. i.e. If we never find aliens in the universe, it is a "thing" that can not be a priori (or a posteriori for that matter). This "alternate fact" itself may be a priori, inasmuch as the state of being of some things may not be proved while being limited to observations (and perhaps perception) within the search scope. Edited for logic errors. Also, the last statement here takes a stab at why the current administration's use of alternate facts can be considered a "tactic" in which the scope of observation and perception of others is greatly limited.
- hhhahds 10y agoIf you ask me, the idea that consciousness is an illusion is an illusion...huh
- visarga 10y agoNo. It's not an illusion. It's an ability to perceive abstract meaning from raw data, evaluate and act in order to maximize future rewards and the ability to learn in order to improve perception and acting. The article says that abstract concepts representing whole classes of perceptions are user-illusions. They are just patterns, and the concepts they represent are the best explainers of the data. The patterns exist in the data, they are not made-up as the article might imply. They are patterns discovered by experience, and learned. Even if consciousness and abstract concepts were all "illusions", that would expand the meaning of illusion, they would become equal to the concepts of mind and soul of the past. My position on consciousness is that we don't need the concept of consciousness. We should use the concepts of Reinforcement Learning instead. Instead of consciousness, we're concerned with an agent. The agent is just an entity embedded in a world, an external environment. It can sense the environment and act, trying to maximize its rewards. For humans, the ultimate reward is survival and reproduction (which is another kind of survival). So it's a loop of perception-judgement-action-reward. We don't need the often mystical and imprecise concept of consciousness because it generates useless debates. It's too loaded, everyone means something else by it, the experts can't even define it in a way they can all agree upon. It's a legacy from the past, one step above the concept of soul, but one step behind that of autonomous agent optimizing actions and learning from rewards. The concept of agent is much more parsimonious, it can be easily defined, measured, simulated and studied from the 3rd person perspective, unlike consciousness.
- lafay 10y agoOne thing that always strikes me about this kind of analysis or discussion is that it presupposes we have reached some kind of evolutionary final state -- that humans now possess all of the "competence" and "affordances" that will be necessary to comprehend the true nature of our existence and experience. Personally, I think that's naive, and that we are still very far from true understanding. In the same way that a cat is very far from comprehending geopolitics or calculus. Related to "final state" is the assumption that there will be no successor beings. Surely evolution will continue to create beings (bio or silicon) that are more competent than humans -- perhaps it already has. Cattle can observe humans and their actions, but the cattle do not comprehend that they are captive and food. I'm not sure why it would be any different between humans and successors.
- dreamlayers 10y agoThe question is incredibly ridiculous. Consciousness is the most first-hand evidence we have. Everything is experienced via consciousness. You could ask if neurons are illusions, or if matter and energy are illusions, but it's ridiculous to ask if consciousness is an illusion.