29 ms·
Video Pros Moving from Mac to Windows for High-End GPUs
- stcredzero 10y agoI'm moving to an ASUS laptop with a GTX 1070 GPU. I should be able to do all of my game development on it, be able to play games and do VR, and keep my old Macbook Pro around just in case I do any iOS stuff.
- nitemice 10y agoThis seems to be a common story. I've got a lot of friends (new graduates) who are in the same position. Their other motivator for moving away from the Macbook is buying a new one would cost an arm & a leg, whereas you can get a much more powerful machine for a fraction of the price from someone else.
- adameast9000 10y agoThis has been true for years though; I'm curious as to why I hear it more often now. You've always been able to get more bang for your buck with a Windows machine, but that didn't stop MacBooks from selling.
- WildUtah 10y agoYou've always been able to get more bang for your buck with a Windows machine Actually, Apple has been selling price competitive or even cheap machines compared to other offerings with similar performance for years. From 2007-2015 Apple consistently had the best prices for pro laptops and desktop machines among offerings with comparable build quality. The $300 price bump for equivalent machines in 2016 and disappointing spec upgrades in 2015 and 2016 are a new deviation. The price performance advantage of Windows machines is returning from a very long hiatus. And for Mac users it's unwelcome. Tim Cook's Apple, of course, is all about high margins and raising average selling price. They're eating the seed corn to squeeze out more short term profits. We'll see how long it lasts.
- visarga 10y agoIt really shows that Tim is no Steve. There has been zero amazing news from Apple since Steve passed away.
- WildUtah 10y agoThere has been amazing news from Apple since Steve died. There was the introduction two years before everyone else of the new blazing fast ARM AARCH 64. There was retina notebooks. There was the design and thumbprint reader tech on iPhone5. But all of those were built and designed while Steve was leading Apple. They're like little amazing tech gifts from beyond the grave. It just takes a while to get to mass market. There has been nothing amazing that started while Tim Cook has been running the place except raising margins by making base products less useful. Keeping the crippling 16GB limit on base iPhones for three extra years while camera images grew and grew was a bold move to drive up average selling price at the expense of customer happiness.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoThat's the fundamental Cook flaw. He prioritises short-term margins over long-term product farming and ecosystem management. And he's very good at it. But it's a strategy that literally has a limited shelf life. First you get an exodus of early adopters and creative users, and eventually you get a catastrophic product failure that does a lot of damage to the brand. Apple isn't there yet, but I'll be surprised if that failure hasn't happened by 2020. Of course there may be One More Thing in the R&D labs to save the day. But Cook has a poor record with original R&D, so it's optimistic to assume that's going to be happen. I'd love to be wrong about that, but the smoke signals suggest otherwise. WWDC this year will be a turning point. The theme is the liberal arts and we'll see whether that means a return to pro hardware, or just some hand-wavey presentation rhetoric.
- snowwrestler 10y agoThere was almost zero "amazing" news from Apple while Steve was alive. The vast majority of Apple keynotes were "this year's machine is a bit smaller/ faster/ thinner etc. And a lot of the very successful products were panned when they came out, including OS X, the iPod, the MacBook Air, etc. Most of those only took off after a few iterations and changes. The iPod only took off after it went USB for Windows. The iPhone only took off after it got 3G and the App Store. The MacBook Air only took off after a redesign and big price drop.
- JohnTHaller 10y agoThe fact that a full-blown Windows gaming laptop with a GTX 1070 in it is about the same cost as the entry level Macbook Pro (with integrated graphics) is a good reason to.
- astrodust 10y agoIn my day to day work the GPU is virtually irrelevant. If you're a game dev obviously this is different, but most people aren't.
- lightedman 10y agoI think you underestimate just how much stuff is moving towards being GPU-run instead of CPU-run.
- astrodust 10y agoI think you underestimate how good the default GPU is getting. It's normally more than adequate for those sorts of tasks. If you're doing specialized work you may need a specialized system, but you're an exception to the rule. Most developers are stuck in Sublime or Visual Studio all day.
- lightedman 10y agoI think you just ignored my entire comment just to try to repeat about half of my words back at me. Care to try again?
- JohnTHaller 10y agoGame dev, video rendering, machine learning, statistical analysis, CAD/3D work, graphics design, a little cryptocurrency mining on the side, etc, etc. GPUs are used for a lot more than games.
- stcredzero 10y ago
- marricks 10y agoSo they had to switch to Nvidia for their amazing 1080 GPU, makes sense. Guess I wouldn't blame apple for not appealing to a niche market, as a reply on that post said they chase big markets and do really well in them. It's interesting that in some ways Microsoft may be doing the same. They cut support for older CPUs, they cut a lot of their workforce for QA, and seem to be focusing too. It'd honestly kind of cool if they margins reaching specialty users became so small that they stopped getting supported so Linux fills in the gap. I mean, the transition is bad, but the end opportunity for Linux and diversity in general seems good.
- netule 10y ago> It's interesting that in some ways Microsoft may be doing the same. They cut support for older CPUs Isn't cutting support for old hardware the exact opposite of what Apple is doing? These guys are mad because they can't get the latest and greatest hardware from Apple, not that their obsolete system won't run macOS.
- Clubber 10y agoPeople with the silver 2009 Mac Pros are also mad because Sierra won't run on it. It will run on a 2010 Mac Pro which is, for all intents and purposes, identical, except a BIOS version setting. Apple decided 2009 users now has obsolete hardware. It's only 6.5 years old and mine is from obsolete. 2x4 3.33, 32g, 2x1TBSSD, 2x4TBHDD, USB3, GeForce 970.
- marricks 10y agoI meant similar in the context of generally trimming support. But yeah, in terms of apple not having a system for latest GPUs it is different.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 10y agoThe current Mac Pro design seems like such a massive misstep in product design, it will be really curious to see if they will walk it back, or just drop the pro market completely. I wonder what thinking lead to that product. Did they think the pro market would be worth it to them to keep investing in keeping the product up to date and then it turned out not to be worth the investment? Although, even before then the Mac Pro was only updated sporadically... Was it all just Jony Ive design hubris? Who is the Mac Pro designed for?
- xt00 10y agoSeems like almost assuredly they will just drop it.. basically I can't imagine any engineer at Apple that is or was working on it is super excited about something that probably made a grand total of like 50 million USD during the mac pro lifetime compared to like 80 billion on iPhone sales per quarter...
- spamizbad 10y agoConsidering Apple's significant profits and cash in the bank... Apple is well-suited to fund a loss-leader products that bolster their cachet in the professional community -- putting their platform on the front-lines of culture creators. Furthermore, today's demanding professional are tomorrows Joe Schmoes: having the hearts and minds of pioneers would them better see what's coming on the horizon. It just seems silly not to invest money to keep the power-user niches happy.
- bluejekyll 10y ago> Apple is well-suited to fund a loss-leader products that bolster their cachet in the professional community They could do this, but they have yet to prove that they will do it. Ever since Jobs, Apple has been hyper fixated on focused, profitable product lines. The Pro is out of step with that, and I bet with laptops making up the bulk of their computer sales, we'll start seeing them move away from the iMac too. My only guess right now is that they still feel they need the Pro to maintain their computer business, but I fear they are slowly becoming just a gadget company and will forget their roots.
- xt00 10y agoFor the external GPU route on a mac, does anybody know how fast the bus would need to be? Like could you use two USB-C ports in parallel on the latest and greatest mac or something??
- na85 10y agoThe bandwidths can be found via a quick Google search. You'd need something like 8 usb c ports in parallel, and the CPU overhead would be punitive.
- jolux 10y agoEven with Thunderbolt 3, running at 40Gbps full duplex?
- monocasa 10y agoThat's about equivalent to PCIe 3.0 4x, or PCIe 2.0 8x.
- shurcooL 10y agoWhat about Thunderbolt 3?
- jwatte 10y agoWe tried a Razer Core on a MacBook but it wouldn't work. Works great with the Razer laptops though! (BTW, you can't even buy any Mac with a decent GPU anymore, no matter what the form factor!)
- touchofevil 10y agoThe only thing Apple has left going for it at this point in the pro video market is the ability to encode video using the Apple Pro Res codec, which is an amazing codec. But other than that, they have totally abandoned the pro market. Final Cut X was not up to the job of professional editing when released. The trashcan Mac Pros are terrible for pros because you 1) can't install internal PCIe cards like BlackMagic Decklink cards 2) can't install desktop GPUs, 3) Can't install multiple internal hdds. PCs are just so much cheaper / more powerful / more expandable and Adobe Premiere is basically a Final Cut Pro replacement. There's not much reason to use a Mac for pro video anymore.
- bluejekyll 10y ago> 1) can't install internal PCIe cards like BlackMagic Decklink cards 2) can't install desktop GPUs, 3) Can't install multiple internal hdds The story was that for this expansion, you'd add external chassis. I'm not a video person, so I'm curious why this didn't pan out?
- fake-name 10y agoI'd guess it's because the external chassis is really expensive, and it's silly. All the busses are there, inside the device, but nope, you have to drop several hundreds of dollars (or more) on a box that squirts them over a expensive wire because marketing and design said so.
- touchofevil 10y agoIt's true, you could add an external ThunderBolt chassis, but when the trash can Mac Pro first came out I recall that not many companies were making the chassis and they were pretty expensive maybe around $1000 from Sonnettech.com (which was added to the already very expensive Mac Pro). The expansion chassis prices have dropped now. But the expansion chassis won't allow you to add a second CPU which is very helpful when compressing video.
- atomical 10y agoIt would allow you to add a second GPU. The cost of the upgrade would mostly depend on the cost of the GPU.
- 12fkingheros 10y agowith GCE GPU, very little reason to have a local anymore.
- feelandcoffee 10y agoIn college I brought an iMac to learn edit video in FCP7. It was nice, not really fast but functional, a lot of my professors were apple fanboys since the Jobs era. Then came FCPX, even if it's good right now, the first version released was basically a stab in the back to those video pros who were faithful to apple for years, those were who keep buying in the hardest times of the company. I saw a lot of video professionals jumping to the Adobe Ecosystem or to things like DaVinci for the GPU rendering. In my case I ended up selling my mac, and with the money build good PC for the price. I feel stupid of not building one from the beginning. Good bye external disks and weird perif; hello SSD, RAID Storage, expandable RAM, and a GPU with CUDA that I can upgrade in two years, without trashing the rest of the system. This is not a debate of Mac vs PC (that can go forever), or a PC Master Race propaganda, but the Mac Pro it's a bad taste joke. I get the idea of the "apple tax", but it's ridiculous here. The CPUs, SSD, and RAM are old, but specially the fact that the GPU it's soldered in the Motherboard it's just stupid. GPU are one of those rare things were you can still see the double of performance in each new iteration. I love my Macbook Pro because reasons, but in Desktops, the PC it's the King.
- rz2k 10y agoWhat do you think about USB-C and Thunderbolt 3? In a dream world they'd make all iOS devices USB-C, release new Mac Pros, all types of laptops, and all of them able to use the same Thunderbolt 3 eGPUs, RAIDs, etc, albeit at different levels of performance. When you look at the public reaction to iPhone dropping the headphone jack (I agreed with) and the revenue from wireless headphones, we know nothing compared to the analysts locked in a vault at Apple who knew more about making money for their company. And yet, I still think of the not-quite dichotomy of the two Steves. Making out-of reach-tech available to everyone, and making tech available to cool-people, where cool-people turned out to be a large superset of 'everyone'.
- tofflos 10y agoI was under the impression that most people were very aware that removing the headphone jack would become a revenue stream for Apple? That's what all the fuzz was about - a lot of people didn't want to buy adapters or new wireless headphones.
- JimmyAustin 10y agoI dont understand why Apple doesn't offer a clone program for workstation Macs. Dual socket and above only (so that it doesn't compete with the iMac or the Mac Mini), restrict it to Intel, but give Dell/HP/custom builders the opportunity to build the pro systems that don't make much of a profit themselves, but support the army of content creators for their other devices.
- mrpippy 10y agoFor everyone who wants Apple to bring back an expandable machine like the old Mac Pro with dual CPUs, PCIe slots and SATA bays, I think this is the best plausible scenario. I still don't think it'll happen though, and even if it did, you'll be paying Mac Pro prices for a Dell/HP.
- KaiserPro 10y agoFrom what I remember, OSX is just wasn't cut out for dealing with NUMA
- frik 10y agoWhat video editing software are you using on Windows? Adobe Premiere Pro? Avid? something else?
- touchofevil 10y agoYeah, Adobe Premiere or Avid. Premiere is a lot like Final Cut Pro 7.
- Joeboy 10y agoPersonally I edit video in Blender on Linux. But from what I understand, these days Premier is kind of the default for general purpose, non-legacy video editing on Windows. Resolve has a free as in beer version that's supposed to be pretty good.
- outworlder 10y agoBig surprise. Video Pros now, developers next, common users last. While Apple is focusing on trying to create the thinnest notebook on every generation, other companies are actually making useful computers, laptops or otherwise. Right now, I've decided to take the money I'd spend on the cheapest Macbook to buy a desktop system, plus a chromebook. I can have mobility and a lot of performance, for a fraction of the price. Even Windows is becoming more viable again, ubuntu core and all.
- wyager 10y ago> developers next, Why would developers switch from mac to windows? If they're alienated by what Apple is doing, they're unlikely to be happy with Microsoft. Linux, sure. Of course, I think this is exactly the sort of misprediction people on HN tend to make, where it turns out that (surprise) Apple actually knows more about market demands than random internet commentators. Remember how we were predicting that the new Touch Bar MacBook Pro would fail hard, but it ended up being the best selling MBP ever?
- rodgerd 10y ago> Of course, I think this is exactly the sort of misprediction people on HN tend to make, Says the guy who suggests Linux as a desktop.
- grive 10y agoSuggesting linux as a viable desktop is not equivalent to predicting that $CURRENT_YEAR is the year of the linux desktop. You being dismissive of the idea on this ground is illogical.
- Baeocystin 10y agoBest-selling? Sure, I can believe that. Pent-up demand alone likely accounts for much of it. Best-selling to developers? Not a chance.
- 10y ago
- mayrosedgdotcom 10y agoI have been loving ubuntu. I still use windows for games, but I could never go back to windows for getting work done or running severs
- iagooar 10y agoI think that Apple forget that video pros are also consumers. And their families. Usually Apple products thrive in families where at least one member is a professional that uses Macs for work. It just fits the whole idea of an ecosystem, so these people and their family members have iPhones, iPads, an AppleTV and maybe an Apple Watch. Once these people start working on Windows machines, the benefit on an iPhone is reduced. It's still a great phone, but they might go for an alternative. Same applies to iPads. Apple should wake up quick. The extraordinary sales numbers of the iPhone seem to have made the company live in a bubble where there is just the phones that matter. But who knows for how long smartphones are going to stay relevant and if a new piece of technology is going to replace them...
- visarga 10y agoIn the meantime: > Apple reports record profits in first quarter > It was Apple's most profitable quarter ever, raking in $78.4 billion. It also sold 78 million iPhones in the three months leading up to New Year's Eve — more than any previous quarter. > Net income was almost $18 billion. In other words, a license to print money. http://www.marketplace.org/2017/01/31/tech/final-note/apple-reports-record-profits-first-quarter http://www.marketplace.org/2017/01/31/tech/final-note/apple-... So, tell me, why should they make an extra effort? They're good as they are.
- iagooar 10y agoYou are right. I'm not saying Apple is doing bad. It's just short-sighted to let the Mac (Pro) die. They might need a more colorful palette of products in the future. It's easier for them to keep the Mac alive than having to rebuild it if they abandon it. It will take them years to get the professionals back if they do so.
- crowbahr 10y agoBecause they're resting on their laurels. It's dangerous to coast the way they are.
- blunte 10y ago
- Fomite 10y agoI've begun painfully shifting away from Mac Pros for scientific computing work as well, which six or seven years ago I wouldn't have believed. But my lab recently bought a high-end workstation and the MP didn't make sense, and my current MP is getting a bit long in the tooth and, unless something very unexpected happens, it's replacement won't be made by Apple.
- dcw303 10y agoFor a company that understands computers are very similar to fashion (their SVP of retail was poached from Burberry), they show a disappointing lack of foresight by not keeping their taste makers happy. Introducing OS X as the mobile Unix platform of choice on top of the first ever drop dead gorgeous notebook (The Powerbook G4 Titanium) declared Apple as the platform for discerning power users. Those power users could confidently brag about their systems, giving free advertising to non-power users. The halo effect of which can still be seen today, trickling down to Joe Coffee in your local cafe. How much longer that lasts in the wake of mis-steps like the touch bar is questionable though, even in the wake of massive unit sales to the broader public. This article is about high end video / graphics users, and workstations are a slightly different use case. But not much. Once these users move off Mac, who is going to be left to champion the desktops?
- WayneBro 10y ago> ...declared Apple as the platform for discerning power users. Incorrect. There are plenty of discerning power users who prefer the power of a good UI over a good CLI. What you meant to say is "for power users who happen to use UNIX". Even at peak reality distortion Apple had a whole 6% share of the desktop market. Just enough to be annoying to the rest of the world. They definitely never had a monopoly on these so-called "discerning power users".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cxromos 10y agoI'm finding problems with the escape key, not the hit/miss which is not a problem at all, but while coding I like to rest my finger on Escape key on certain occasions. That's not possible on MacBook Pro Touch. Also have to adjust that my Launchpad button is now where Siri is by default, next to the Touch Id Sensor. Everything else is better, touch pad, for which I thought I won't have use for included. Also, up and down keys are somehow easier to miss which is strange, probably due to keyboard elevation. As for the keyboard, finally, this is keyboard. I started developing on Mac as iOS and Android developer in 2012. Had hard time to get used to gummy MacBook keyboard. Touch Bar is something keyboard manufacturers in the PC world tried to make for years ending up with horrible keyboards no developer would touch. Industrial design is better as well. My 'old' MacBook Pro Retina now seems big and clumsy (both are 15"). This is the feeling I have when I use it.
- randsp 10y agoAfter thinking a lot about buying an iMac for development (I've been using MacBook Air for five years now), I just decided to forget about it and consider another platforms as ASUS VivoPC X, it is good looking enough, incomparable horse power and way too much less expensive. The only thing I am sure I am going to miss is MacOS.
- ramigb 10y agoI use Windows 10 as my gaming PC, I own two MBPs one for work and one for personal use, I also make music on both Windows with FL studio and macOS with Logic Pro X. Lately I've been feeling that Windows 10 is really smooth and easy to deal with unlike my previous Windows experience so I've started coding -again- on my Windows and to be honest minus some built in macOS applications like QuickTime and preview I don't really mind going back to Windows at all, Unlike Windows 8 or 7 I feel that Microsoft has started listening to users which is really good.
- jlebrech 10y agoIf apple reinvent the IDE for use with touch on ios they might be able to drop their laptops altogether for development, and maybe market some kind of cloud-cube that people who want more grunt could purchase, rather than be limited to what can fit in a 2mm thick laptop.
- redsummer 10y agoTim Cook has just been repainting Jobs's toys for the last five years. Cook's success is a testament to how good the toys were, but nobody wants Woody and Buzz Lightyear anymore. I'm an iOS developer. I'm sure if Apple were making decent machines I would be more optimistic about my job. But the current situation is making me prepare for an escape route. I'm sure there are many others who feel the same, and that will have a knock on effect on the iOS world.
- tempodox 10y agoI found the top comment on the site (from `has`) quite illuminating. I don't like the message at all but it seems to explain a lot.
- 5ersi 10y agoI agree on the 'has' comments. The only thing that he got wrong, IMO, is that Alexa is going to be a success. If personal assistants are to take off it's going to be inside the phone (the most personal of all devices), not some speaker in the living room. Phones are much more available (always with you) and personal (sometimes you don't want to share stuff with your whole household).
- astrodust 10y agoThis is a reblog of the same article from 2016 that's been revivified and is making the rounds again.
- sneak 10y agoITT: People pretending the world's wealthiest company isn't building a 64 bit ARM desktop powerhouse. Why would they continue dumping money into refreshing Intel-based systems when they screwed them on 32GB of ram in the LPDDR4 thing on the new rMBP? Can you imagine how annoyed the Apple people are that they can't sell you a $499 32gb ram upgrade along with your $1299 1500gb SSD upgrade on your $4299 computer? Apple's future is ARM and to expect any more powerhouse Intel systems from them was folly even a year ago.
- ksec 10y agoA lot of Pro are also moving from Mac Pro to iMac. Where the current processing power fits their needs. But Video / CG Pros seems to have infinite appetite for CPU and GPU processing power, and Apple's line up are not catering for them. Not only do I wish they could rethink the Mac Pro trash can, I wish they could design the Mac Pro with Server Rack in mind.
- kondro 10y agoVideo pros need high-end, fast, high-memory machines with fast storage. 99% of us developers don't. Even if you have a lot of VMs.
- VeejayRampay 10y agoApple is the Teflon company. It seems like no matter how many subpar (yet overpriced) products they put on the market, their reputation and public perception never suffers. To this day, I have a negative opinion of Microsoft for their questionable practices in the past and god knows they've been lambasted in the past for their general attitude (though it feels like this is starting to change). Apple on the other hand can totally afford to rehash their products from a few years ago, sit on a stash of gold, disappoint designer and programmers alike for years, leave Mac OS on a sidetrack and never has to face any kind of serious backlash. It really says a lot about their marketing genius.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoIt also says a lot about the composition of their market: Apple is likely not super concerned about snubbing professionals because they've moved on to bigger fish. I seriously doubt that it simply has not occurred to anyone at Apple that not providing higher end GPUs and other features that various professions rely on will mean losing their business. Especially since the internet has been screaming that at them for a good while now.
- jp555 10y agoHave you thought that maybe the tech pundits are just wrong? If they say Apple gear is "subpar" and yet it still sells like gangbusters, that tells me that the products were probably not "subpar" at all. Critics can be wrong, but audiences are never wrong.
- alkonaut 10y agoThey aren't stupid - it's entirely possible that Apple have run the numbers and found it uneconomical to keep pro gear up to date. So they simply give up the share of the market that contains video pros and similar. Obviously they'll lose the whole families of those professionals, and perhaps their whole businesses too - but Apple must have calculated that risk. So most likely it's simply better business to cater to the consumer/prosumer part of the market and ignore "true pro" gear.
- pvdebbe 10y agoUsually companies make the money with the boring products and then they showcase their talent with superbly designed and not-all-around-versatile demos that make a loss. It's kinda neat that with Apple it might be exactly the reverse.
- jbmorgado 10y agoHistory proves again and again, that yes, big companies - even when they are presently turning record profit - can be indeed stupid. Very, very stupid. Thinking that just because a tech company is big and therefore has the brightest minds there running the products and as such they can't go wrong and it's us, the users, that just don't understand their fantastic strategies is, as we can clearly see from the past, just not true. Just look at Microsoft in the 2000's for instance. Or at Yahoo in the end of the 90's.
- alkonaut 10y agoI'm not saying it's not a mistake but the possibility that it's deliberate must at lest be considered.
- JofArnold 10y agoWhat about external GPUs? I wonder if Apple should be doubling-down on that because it turns even the weakest MBs into incredibly capable machines.
- intoverflow2 10y agoDid exactly this in December for CUDA based 3D rendering. Been a mac user for 15 years. It was hard to make the jump but I came to the realisation Apple just doesn't care about my work and therefore my money anymore.
- pasta 10y agoIt's estimated that there are 20 million developers world wide. Stack Overflow surveyed that 20% of developers use a Mac. So lets say there are 4 million developers using a Mac. And lets say they buy a new Mac every 3 years. Then 1.3 million developers buy a Mac each year. Apple sold 20 million Macs last year. So lets say 6.5% were developers and 10% of those developers are complaining about the new Mac series. If I am right that means that 130 thousand developers are complaining. That's 0.65% of Apple's customers. Now I don't believe Apple is stupid. They are in business longer than some people here are alive. So I can very much imagine that Apple decided to go for 2% more customers while losing 0.65% of them while making even more profit.
- golergka 10y agoThe article was about video editors, but it doesn't chnage the essence of your point. However. That little group is power users. New adopters. Influencers. In the late 2000s, if you saw someone using a macbook pro, you knew he was some kind of professional, and most likely, something "sexy" - a developer, photographer, designer... This user base, professionals who care about quality over price, helped create the Apple company image. They loved Apple products and were voluntary apple advocates - I know I was. I convinced several friends and family members to switch to Mac because I sincerely believed that the extra cost is worth ease of use. And because I'm a power user (in their eyes), they believed me. And that same company image helped sell iPhones - the main Apple profit driver. But now the same high-paid professionals are switching away. "Regular" users are going to see it, sonner or later; how do you convince them that this "Apple quality" still exists, when they see the power users trashing it?
- wastedhours 10y agoAgree - today's video editors are tomorrow's video editing teachers. Who'll teach the ecosystem they see and work with best, informing opinion down the line. I would be surprised if Apple didn't augment their line up with other power products in the medium term though.
- yAnonymous 10y agoLosing 0.65% of customers that work in IT could very well cause long term damage that the 2% of regular customers can't make up for. People working in IT often have a much bigger influence on others in that area and you don't want to lose that. Look at Microsoft. They've been there and are currently investing quite a lot to get developers to use their software. If Apple were clever, they'd look ahead, but it seems they go for good quarterly results instead and repeat the same mistakes others have already made. It has all the markings of a company in decline.
- amelius 10y agoApple suffers seriously from NIH syndrome, so they will probably never let NVidia play a major role in their ecosystem. Too bad, customers move away.
- al2o3cr 10y agodue to the inherent bandwidth limits that Thunderbolt has as compared to the buss speeds of these GPU cards [citation needed] There probably are applications that need every single GBps of the x16 connector, but just saying "bandwidth limitations" isn't sufficient - see also the common SLI setup which switches to x8/x8 if two cards are installed.
- taude 10y agoI was under the impression from friends who work in Hollywood and television that not much video editing was done on Macs, anyway. That Avid software running on proprietary/custom hardware was standard. But this was five or six years ago. Maybe people had been switching to Macs in more recent times? (I remember a similar discussion came up when Apple consumerized Final Cut, and was told that pros don't use it anyway.)
- dcdevito 10y agoHas anyone else realized this article is almost a year old? I agree with the whole macOS exodus, as I was a Mac user of 9 years before switching to PC in mid-2015 (you know, when it wasn't yet cool to do so). At first I thought I made a huge mistake, but since then I built a powerful rig last summer and I love it. Windows 10 is fast, stable and reliable, three words I used to describe OS X when I switched to Mac in 2006. As a former developer now Project Manager, I don't code much anymore, but I tinker with stuff every now and then. I got into gaming for the first time since I built a custom PC back in 2004, and you know what? I love it! I thought I was "past that" phase in my life, but I enjoy my Windows 10 Desktop PC. I still miss the Mac, and man do I miss the retina screens! But I feel macOS is simply now a legacy product to Apple that they simply cannot afford to ditch, not so much for business - obviously that would be bad - but I think it would be much worse from a PR perspective more than anything. And the whole thing bothers me. I feel like macOS is now an obligation for Apple to string along, but its real focus is now iOS. We all know iOS is the future, who are we kidding? At least with Windows 10 I feel Microsoft is trying to add neat features and updates annually now, and since mobile passed them by in the dust they have to scramble desperately to get Windows 10 in the forefront of tech enthusiasts again. I think for developers it's working (or at least they're trying very hard). I'm kind of excited for built in VR functionality, ubuntu core (WSL) seems really promising for developers.
- anjc 10y agoMan I'm the same. I ran PCs since the 90s and put my own together through the 00s, but switched over to Apple fully in the late 00s. Having gone back to a Surface Pro and putting a desktop PC together again in the last year...I don't know what I was thinking moving away from it. Windows 10 is amazing, and being able to pick and choose components is personally very freeing.
- baldfat 10y agoI contract for video work from time to time for a few decades now. Windows has always been the majority of video editing till about 2009 when Final Cut was the buzz word. I HATE Final Cut and just its vocabulary was so frustrating. Most were either Premier or some special Linux farm for HUGE projects. Apple won due to the idea that creatives used Apple and nerds used Windows. I always was the Amiga guy then the Linux nerd (Light Works is great but the plug ins are limited)and now I just am happy to not have to use Final Cut for anything.
- rayiner 10y agoThe idea of video pros, programmers, and IT guys being "tastemakers" is laughable. People used to ask me for computer recommendations 15 years ago, when specs mattered and computers were scary. Today, people just get a Mac because their fellow non-technical people have one, or because they have an iPhone or Apple Watch already. Indeed in our household it works they other way around: My completely non-technical wife has prohibited me from buying non-Apple products. ("You know how whiney you get every time you buy a non-Apple product.")
- bartvk 10y ago> "You know how whiney you get every time you buy a non-Apple product" That's pretty damn cute. I can see why you married her :-)
- Corrado 10y agoHere is a more recent take on the original article - http://finance.yahoo.com/news/apple-strategy-forcing-pros-ditch-mac-windows-232146389.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/apple-strategy-forcing-pros-di...
- tibbon 10y agoI moved to OS X for Protools circa 2002, when Windows support for it was just awful. When I build my next studio machine, I think I'm moving back. I need a machine that is large, powerful, and expandable. The Mac Pro isn't this. I don't like Windows, but the only programs I'm going to use are Protools and Ableton Live. Just like on my gaming computer, which essentially just runs Steam (and games) I can deal with it. For live sets, I'll keep using a Macbook Pro, because if one breaks I can buy another in any city in 5 minutes and I will know it will work almost immediately for what I need.
- Corrado 10y agoI agree that Apple shouldn't be chasing every bit of chickenfeed and producing lots of similar products. In fact, I would like to see Apple go back to 4 main macOS products; home desktop, home portable, pro desktop, pro portable. Getting rid of the MacBook Air/MacBook/MacBook Pro/iPad4/iPad Air/iPad Pro/iPad Pro2 confusion would go long way to making it possible to recommend an Apple product to my friends & family. As it stands now, when someone asks me what computer to buy I have to interrogate them on their exact usage pattern and then spend a couple of hours looking at all the different Apple products to see which one might serve them best. 10 years ago it was simple; you just want to send email, browse Facebook from home, get an iMac. If you wanted to compile code at Starbucks, get a MBP. Goofing off at the library, get a MB. Simple.
- simonh 10y agoThe Apple product line has expanded because their user base has expanded. They're no longer selling a few hundred thousand Macs to a few categories of creative professionals. They're selling many millions of them to people all over the world. Even so, Apple to this day doesn't chase after every conceivable ecological niche in the market. They only sell two headless Mac models (ignoring internal component options). The Airs are likely on the way out, so their clash with the MacBook is likely just a temporary transitional thing. Many of the products you listed are actually just different generations of the same thing.
- hunvreus 10y agoIt isn't just video pros. I've purchased Apple products for 12 years (and for my entire company for 7 years). It always seemed to be the obvious choice; it just worked, reliably and with a better user/developer experience than alternatives. This year both me and my team have started moving away. My next phone will be an Android device and we're now not buying Macbook laptops for new recruits. Windows, Ubuntu or Elementary OS offer a better experience. I personally can't take the restrictions I'm getting from MacOS and iOS. I'm also infuriated to see my machine being close to unusable a couple times a week while "kernel_task" eat up 120% of my CPU. The only reason I was still sticking with Apple was the hardware, but that too went downhill. The iPhone's screen is brittle. The battery is capricious. My latest 2 visits to the Apple store resulted in a unusable track pad and a damaged screen on my Macbook (which were then claimed to not be covered by Apple Care). Others around me share my frustrations. It may be anecdotal, but 3 years ago I would never have considered buying anything but Apple. I've reached the tipping point and I'm not the only one it seems.
- sixothree 10y agoAs much as I have had this love/hate relationship with Apple products over the last few decades I just cannot bring myself to use a Google phone.
- ryanisinallofus 10y agoJust dogma around the phone OS wars or some reasonable explanation?
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoMaybe because using Android is a bit like training your dog to guard your sausages without eating them :)
- phaed 10y agoI always see these types of comments, and it seems like they are either talking from pure bias or outdated experiences. Flagship android phones are close to flawless not only in hardware but in the integration with Google services, which are far beyond anything Apple has the ability to provide. As a Samsung S7Edge owner I simply cannot relate.
- iampliny 10y agoPro was always a stepchild at Apple. Steve Jobs never stopped by NAB for the Final Cut Pro press events. And more than a decade ago I started seeing middle managers being "promoted" from Pro Apps to other divisions like iTunes. The hard truth is that we pro folks aren't that lucrative. Pro users probably sit in the bottom of a smiling curve with high-volume consumer products on the one side, and high-revenue Enterprise on the other. To a company like Apple, pro users represent the worst of both worlds. That's why you also see "media storage" companies like G-Technologies, who introduced pro products (like the late G-Speed) only to abandon that market for high-volume, low-touch consumer products like LaCie Rugged. I want a new MBP with an nVidia GTX 1080 as much as the next guy, but I'm not holding my breath.
- rayiner 10y agoLet's not forget that long before Apple exited the "Pro" market, companies like SGI went out of business. So did all the companies that used to make graphics hardware targeted to pros. They were overwhelmed by ATI and NVIDIA's repurposed gaming GPUs.
- iampliny 10y agoYep. Tricked-out gaming rigs catching up with the heavy-iron graphics workstations was hugely disruptive. Low-overhead boutiques could suddenly do the same work as high-overhead facilities. But then you blinked, and the same work was happening in no-overhead places like The Director's Living Room.
- draw_down 10y agoTheir neglect of the pro market and the Mac Pro continues to be an embarrassment.
- cdnsteve 10y agoWhen you solder SSDs and RAM into a machines logic board that doesn't exactly make your very expensive investment future proof. Let alone glue a battery into the case and the battery life is horrible on my touchbar MacBook Pro. Apple machines are now appliances that cannot be modified. They are throw away, so spend your dollars wisely.
- bleair 10y agoDoes Apple really need or care about the "Pro" market? It seems like all of their priorities are related to everyday consumers (beats headphones, air buds, several new phone models every N months, etc.). Why would apple waste their engineering man-hours building products for any market except the common consumer who aspires to be part of the wealthy crowd?
- shuntress 10y ago"Creative Professionals (or students)" has been a very visible, if not core, segment of Apple consumers. To me, this may seem desirable due to the perception that these people prefer to use tools that are 'the-best-of-the-best'.
- no_wave 10y agoBecause if you're going to buy an aspirational product it should actually be used by the demographic you're aspiring to be a part of.
- soundwave106 10y agoI guess this might be their direction now, but at one time Apple did market heavily towards creative professionals. I think this helped Apple's "hip" image among consumers. When you, say, see your favorite electronic band in concert and notice the Apple logo on their laptop, that reinforces the impression that these computers aren't "stodgy" Windows PCs (ala the ads 10 years ago in this direction -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Get_a_Mac https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Get_a_Mac) Many "common" consumers have a creative hobby to be honest as well, and I think developing pro tools can help develop consumer / prosumer versions. See: Garageband, a consumer oriented DAW from the folks that made Logic Pro.
- znpy 10y agoWindows has improved a recently, and many of those might actually like it. I guess no one cares at Apple: if the hugest slice of revenue comes from phones and tablets...
- krschultz 10y agoApple should license a single boutique manufacturer to make high quality workstations. It's clearly not a big enough market to interest Apple, but with the right agreement in place they could come up with a satisfactory solution. Signed - A Mac Pro owner that is seriously considering getting something else.
- dimillian 10y agoYes Apple, it's not rocket science, please stop using 2 years old GPU in your latest laptop...
- elif 10y agoI am curious if there is a single person that doesn't regret their 2013 mac pro (trash can) purchase. I feel like an idiot. I multibox videogames and my $1,000 entry-level alienware frequently out performs this $5,500 art piece.
- intrasight 10y agoFor those complaining that all PCs have flaws, the great thing about PCs is that you can build your own. All the parts for my new Skylake Xeon arrived this week. Can't wait to see what it can do! I'd been waiting for the Samsung 960 Pro 512GB which finally arrived. The 960 Pro is my boot drive. A 960 Evo 1TB is my data drive. No more spinning glass platters for me. Build your own and you get to make your own compromises.
- jscipione 10y agoThe performance gap between Apple's latest today and the industries latest is not nearly as great as in the late PPC era.
- modfodder 10y agoAs someone who is a video pro, cutting commercials in NYC and LA (and former post facility engineer), I'm not seeing it. I don't know of one editor or post facility that has moved from Mac to Windows or Unix. One River Media (the co. that posted the blogpost about switching) is using Davinci Resolve as an NLE, a far more niche choice than cutting in FCPX. Resolve is a color correcting tool (a very popular one that I've used to color grade features) that has added editing support. I've yet to meet anyone in the wild using it for editing. Even the editors I know that cut on Adobe Premiere which is available for both PC and Mac aren't switching from Mac, which honestly has surprised me a bit because of the greater choice in hardware. But for most video editors at this level, you're just trading speed in one area for problems in another. Editors whine and complain every time there is a tiny change in the interfaces they use, they hate change. They have been forced to embrace FCP and Premiere over the years (and complain about it incessantly). Very few will choose to make the jump to Windows for the same reason. As you step down the ladder, the move will make sense for some. Your all-in-one facilities or one man bands (production and all aspects of post handled by one or two people). But in my experience, this group has already been heavily invested in the Windows side because of the cheaper initial costs (that money you save early will be spent later and the Windows post-house will cost as much or more than a comparable Mac post-house, at least it did when I was an engineer). And the other aspects of video post production, the CG, 3D and compositing sectors already heavily lean toward Windows or Linux and have for over a decade. There just isn't a huge need for massive speed increases in the hardware side for most video editors. We've gone from needing very fast, high end systems with fast (and expensive) SAN storage to laptops and SSDs that allow us to do more, faster than ever. iMacs or MacBook Pros are all the average editor needs, with more and more working remotely from home. I cut a project for the NBA over the holidays on the first gen USB-C MacBook and years ago cut a project for REEBOK on the just released MacBook Air. Both these projects came up unexpectedly while I was traveling but went off without a hitch on underpowered hardware (that I bought for web surfing and writing). That's not to say that I wouldn't appreciate (and most likely purchase) a new and expandable Mac workstation. But for the most part, I'd be spending money to just spend money. It wouldn't speed up 98% of my job. And that other 2 percent isn't slow enough to cause me any issues.
- Mankhool 10y agoI work in a video production facility. We hate the trash cans. 3rd party chassis for them all fall short of an "all in one solution". These are our last Macs for production. We'll be on Windows boxes by this time next year. As a lifelong Apple user (Starting with the Apple II) this makes me sad, but Apple has done this to themselves.
- unicornporn 10y agoYup we do. OS X user for 11 year, recently switched to two laptops. One Window 10 laptop for video and photography work, one Linux laptop for the rest.