13 ms·
France’s military is training eagles to attack drones
- rodionos 10y agoReuters photo for a visual effect of an intercept: http://www.reuters.com/news/picture/photos-of-the-week?articleId=USRTSZ06O http://www.reuters.com/news/picture/photos-of-the-week?artic...
- popol12 10y agoWhat a scalable solution.
- bnegreve 10y agoIt is not meant to scale, it's a way to take down drones without shooting in crowded areas.
- ekianjo 10y agohaving high precision rifles with assisted aiming systems is surely way more effective.
- bnegreve 10y agoShooting guns in a crowded environment may cause panic.
- ill0gicity 10y agoI'm not sure if you're aware, but bullets don't always stop when they hit something... Over-penetration is a very real problem with very real consequences.
- ommunist 10y agoA simple automatic pneumatic injection gun delivering 2 laser-targeted shots of 30m distance, like this baby http://www.haevic.co.za/index.php/products-services/the-dartdrone http://www.haevic.co.za/index.php/products-services/the-dart... can put eagle to a safe sleep, and ensure mission is not interrupted.
- taneq 10y agoThat did not go where I thought it would. (I was expecting some kind of net gun for the drones.)
- ommunist 10y agoWell there are already deployed drones with tranquilizer dart guns that target humans. Used as "drone fencing" of sensitive areas. Example shooting from hexacopter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNOL9Kz2WNE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNOL9Kz2WNE
- Terr_ 10y ago> Example shooting from hexacopter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNOL9Kz2WNE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNOL9Kz2WNE Uhm, that's not real or related. That's some guy's visual-effects project, and the drone is CGI. Perhaps you meant the manufacturer's movie here? Good luck shooting a diving eagle. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OItoIIoSefI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OItoIIoSefI
- Terr_ 10y agoIs that against a moving target through turbulent air? Even easier: Build two drones, and have whichever one gets grabbed blow up immediately.
- seszett 10y agoIf you're less than 30 meters away from your drone and possess weapons though... what's the use of the drone? That's just not at all the kind of situation this is intended for.
- danboarder 10y agoThis approach is not all that new, but it's a clicky headline so it keeps coming back as news organizations cover it again and again. I remember seeing this over a year ago, and before that was well (in 2015 as I recall). A quick search shows a lot of coverage last year of Dutch police doing the same thing: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/eagle-vs-drone http://www.wired.co.uk/article/eagle-vs-drone
- Signez 10y agoThey talk about that in the article. > A solution presented itself in an experiment by Dutch police, who last year used a trained eagle to pluck a DJI Phantom drone out of the air, Peter Holley reported for The Washington Post.
- Vexs 10y agoThis is a copy-paste from what I posted on reddit in regards to the same kind of thing. Really this entire concept is stupid. Not only are higher-end quadcopters unimaginably acrobatic, to the point where a skilled pilot could easily outfly a bird, but these things are literally flying lawnmowers. Go on /r/Multicopter or any other multirotor forum, there are loads of people that have been sliced all over their arms, and if you dig further, cuts down to the bone in some cases. Given the brittle, hollow nature of bird bones, well. (maybe eagle/falcon legs are different tho?) Seriously, if I was a falconer I would never consent to this. As for people suggesting they use cords or something to tangle the props up, that's really not an impossible problem either, people have been putting mesh cages over their props to fly them safely indoors for some time now, plus if you only stop one prop the quad becomes extremely violent in it's movements, pitching and rolling all over the damn place, which again, will probably at the very least hurt the bird quite a lot. Plus, if you were using quads for nefarious purposes, if that bird catches your quad you're not gonna give up and call it a day, more likely you'll push the throttle to max, which again, will cause that bird quite a lot of harm. If I were the aforementioned falconer, I would make sure the pilot cut the motors immediately before the eagle caught it, as that's the only way this would ever be safe for anyone involved.
- Terr_ 10y agoI think a more fundamental problem is cost: Building one more explosive-drone is probably cheaper than raising and training one more bird, so an attacker would just send N+1 drones against N birds, and whichever drones detect interference can explode into shrapnel. > Given the brittle, hollow nature of bird bones Maybe they could make them little reinforced booties of kevlar and steel-sheathed talons? :P Over in the realm of sci-fi, its interesting to contemplate bird-safe EMP grenades, or a neural-tap that makes the birds part of a spotter/targeting system for ground-based lasers.
- mc32 10y agoThey could also just use one of these[1] jamming devices to take down the drone. [1]http://newatlas.com/battelles-dronedefender-beam-gun-uavs/39885/ http://newatlas.com/battelles-dronedefender-beam-gun-uavs/39...
- mc32 10y agoWhy not use autonomous drone swarms to attack enemy drones (any that does not respond with correct security certificate, for example) rather than a very costly solution, which while interesting and clever and lo tech, isn't viable in warfare scenarios.
- alex_duf 10y agothen you just need the correct certificate
- usrusr 10y agoLikely because falconers want funding just as much as drone builders. But there might be more: having a heavy hunter-seeker drone over a crowd would be nearly as bad as having the occasional rogue drone there. Birds, with their amazingly low mechanical failure rate might be the preferable way of keeping reasonable people reasonable. Sensitive parts of the sky need to be kept clear of non-malicious, but nonetheless rogue drones not only because of accident risk, but also to get a clear threat indication from the malicious ones. "Probably just some kid who ran out of things to film with their gopro" is not very helpful when assessing the relative risks of a violent takedown over a crowd.
- falcolas 10y agoBased on the existing drone combat leagues - a lightweight drone with lots of streamers would do better than a heavyweight drone with any form of weaponry. Foul the props, and the drone will go down. Of course, I've also watched an expensive camera octocopter tip itself over and dive bomb the dirt because of a nearby antenna overpowering their delicate GPS.
- ChrisEbner 10y agoRead this months ago, why is this news?
- njharman 10y agoThat is a seriously large bird!
- Synaesthesia 10y agoWonder how this would fair on a predator drone firing hellfire missiles.
- sschueller 10y agoYou mean the drones that are actually inflicting fear and terror on populations unlike the little camera drones the west is so afraid off.
- Synaesthesia 10y agoYep!
- crpatino 10y agoWith stakes that high, you can always put an explosive payload on the eagle.
- lend000 10y agoMagnets? EMP's? Is that still considered too sci-fi?
- sslnx 10y agoI am very sceptical about using eagles to stop drones. Eagles are more expensive to train and maintain, and they die. The only viable solution against harmful drones are drones themselves.
- crpatino 10y agoThe more I think about it, the more I think this is a bluf to push drone designers to overengineer their devices. Eagles are not scalable, but it is way simpler to train a handful of them as a proof of concept than to eagle-proof existing designs of drones. And given physical and engineering limits, every countermeasure implemented in a drone will cut into the effective payload that is available for the drone to carry on its actual function. The eagles were never meant to defeat the drones, but to force their designers to handicap those.
- superzadeh 10y agoYou can't hack an Eagle!
- CraigJPerry 10y ago"on the other side of the world" - half way down the article but omitted from the title.
- wapz 10y ago>four eggs "were placed before birth on top of drones while still inside the eggshell and, after hatching, kept them there during their early feeding period Why did they put the eggs on drones? Wouldn't that make the eagles think they are parents or related.
- nepotism2016 10y agoTalk about animal abuse lol
- msl09 10y agoI think the reason that the French are investing in this solution is because other cheaper (or more effective) interceptor drone technology is still not ready to be used. To think that the French army is not also investing on hunter drones is to severely underestimate the intelligence of that army.
- upofadown 10y agoThe article doesn't actually mention any examples of drones used by terrorists. The closest they get is a purely military action somewhere in Iraq.
- owenversteeg 10y agoThis is incredibly stupid. As I've posted elsewhere here, drones have a chance to outfly and outmaneuver the golden eagles used in the program. Then, assuming the eagles catch up, they still have to deal with blades - with wingtips spinning at hundreds of miles per hour. There's no way they can survive the blades: every bird I've seen that encounters a UAV either was instantly killed or permanently disabled. I've worked with drones enough to know what will and won't stop them. A bird won't: it'll brush the blades and fall to the ground in a bloody mess. A bullet will. Bullets are tried and true technology, we know how to use them, they're not ridiculously expensive, and they will certainly take down any drone of reasonable size. This is PR, plain and simple. There's no other explanation for it, unless France's air force is hilariously incompetent, which I would doubt.
- spiderfarmer 10y ago"The military is designing mittens of leather and Kevlar, an anti-blast material, to protect their talons" Also, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HifO-ebmE1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HifO-ebmE1s Maybe it won't work for all drones, but bullets would drop drones into the crowds below, so the idea catching them in the air is not that stupid. It's just one of the ideas the police is exploring.
- owenversteeg 10y agoIf a bird catches a UAV, it's not going to be able to carry it off either. Golden eagles in particular cannot carry very much. You can find videos of them using their impressive wingspan to momentarily generate enough lift to carry dogs or goats, but that is only momentary. As you can see here [0], golden eagles can't even carry 1kg for more than a brief amount of time. And you've got to be kidding me. "Mittens of leather and Kevlar"? How about you put on some leather-kevlar gloves and then try to touch a spinning blade, with the tips going hundreds of miles per hour. It would be like a heavy caliber bullet against a bulletproof vest. This is PR, plain and simple. It's completely and totally ridiculous and wouldn't work unless the 'terrorists' were completely incompetent and flying tiny drones. (I'll remind you that a tiny drone can't carry much payload, which would probably be the purpose of a terrorist attack.) Somewhere, entirely separate from the people working on this PR project, someone in the French military is hopefully looking at realistic ways to take down drones safely, e.x. bullets. But I can only hope that this isn't a serious effort and is only PR, otherwise I'd be extremely worried. [0] https://raptorresource.blogspot.nl/2015/11/how-much-can-bald-eagle-carry.html https://raptorresource.blogspot.nl/2015/11/how-much-can-bald...
- gonzo41 10y agoThis is not an unreasonable idea. I'm just going to leave this here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hr-xBtVU4lg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hr-xBtVU4lg
- ndh2 10y agoAlright, so they're getting leather gloves and are named after musketeers. How about equipping them with rapiers? Disable the drone blades with blades!
- redtuesday 10y agoWhy not use drones to catch drones? The japanese, or more specifically, the tokyo police is doing that. Is that not really viable?
- arikrak 10y agoThat sounds a lot more realistic but it's not as cool and romantic as eagles swooping in. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgCNVdYzIcw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgCNVdYzIcw
- sir-alien 10y agoGot to wonder the damage that will happen to the bird. The larger drones which these tests are for would do some serious damage to the birds legs if the pilot kept the motors turning. If the pilot is intent on breaking away, they would not care about the birds well being. Some of these drones also put out a fair amount of thrust so even if the drone is upside-down it could quite easily pull down the bird. Somehow I feel that this training of large birds to catch drones just has not been thought through. Would a net cannon not but more successful especially when using high tensile netting. For mobility, attach net cannon to police multi rotor.
- falcolas 10y agoA multirotor carrying a heavy payload is not going to have a lot of thrust to spare to apply to the bird. The rotors only typically run in one direction as well, so it couldn't suddenly apply counter thrust. Most multirotor autopilots also would behave in a very expected fashion when disturbed, making them pretty predictable.
- gaius 10y agoIn the movie Legends of the Guardians the owls use steel over-talons to battle their enemies, that approach could be used here too.
- helb 10y agoFrom the article: "The military is designing mittens of leather and Kevlar, an anti-blast material, to protect their talons"
- mathattack 10y agoWouldn't it just be easier to shoot the drones down?
- nradov 10y agoWe had a related earlier discussion about ISIS terrorists using commercial drones as bombers. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13497150 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13497150
- ill0gicity 10y agoConsider for moment why the French are training eagles to take down drones: bombs. Now think about how the eagles are dealing with the drones... They knock them out of the sky. I can't be the only one seeing a problem with this. "Use the 'interference gun'". If that works, and it's a BIG "if", the drone will either land or fall to the ground. Bombs away! Seriously, it's just as bad as an eagle crashing into it. Real gun? Same problem with the added bonus of a bullet going through the drone and continuing on its journey to who-knows-where. So what's a government to do? The only solution I can see that removes the threat of a bomb going off is this: a much larger drone (650mm and above octocopter) armed with a net gun. The key here is to have the net tethered to the drone so it can carry the hostile drone away to a safe area. The drone-mounted net gun already exists (Excipio), just have to get the net tethered to the drone.
- seandhi 10y agoBombs have an arming mechanism that triggers some time after they're released. They won't automatically explode just because they hit the ground.
- XorNot 10y agoA free falling drone bomb might. But more importantly: this isn't military grade munitions. This is home made acetone peroxide and the like I.e. highly unstable
- dmix 10y agoIron Beam is an already commercialized laser system, an alternative to Iron Dome missile defense against rockets and UAVs: https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Iron_Beam https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Iron_Beam This sounds much better than eagles. One issue with eagles is that they have to be taken care of, fed, and deployed when needed. This is like the old mechanization vs cavalry debate. Machines have many more benefits than just how they function at a specific task (ie, they dont get tired).
- squarefoot 10y agoNot going to work well, save for small drones capable of ridiculous payloads; a big one with more powerful engines and stronger props would seriously damage or kill the bird. To me the best way to neutralize a drone is by shooting it with a thin but strong steel net from another smaller and faster one: instant stop + faraday cage effect that probably also severs its connection with the launch base instantly.
- pvaldes 10y agoAnother fact to consider here also is that eagles do not fly at night.