6 ms·
As a contrarian defender of driving in these threads, even I hate street parking. Street parking serves no one well. Finding a spot near where you're going is
by closeparen 10y ago
As a contrarian defender of driving in these threads, even I hate street parking.
Street parking serves no one well. Finding a spot near where you're going is unlikely, searching for one brings traffic to a crawl, and getting into one creates significant and dangerous disruption to the roadway, particularly for the bike lane.
People who rely on street parking are incentivized to oppose density in the places they park. Mandatory minimum parking requirements result in wasted space, or facilitates car ownership for people who don't care about/benefit from it at the expense of those who do.
Street parking for cars should be eliminated in favor of loading zones and motorcycle/scooter/bicycle parking, which packs much more densely. (Bias towards electric ones if you care to). At the same time, garages (with street-facing storefronts) should be only the list of things you can build by-right.
Drivers should booking garage spaces with dynamic, demand-based pricing from their phones before departing, and should know exactly where they're going to park before setting out.
- davidw 10y ago> As a contrarian defender of driving in these threads I don't think anyone sane is suggesting that we should all stop driving from one day to the next, so there's no need to 'defend' driving. It's more about making driving one option among many, and eliminating some of the subsidies.
- closeparen 10y agoOf course, no one is suggesting an overnight ban. I do see an alarming level of support for engineering a steadily increasing scarcity of parking, high tolls, and a deliberately under-provisioned road network in order to degrade the experience of driving until it sucks just a little worse than transit/cycling. I think we should address the reasons people live far from their destinations, rather than the mechanisms which let them lead reasonable lives while doing so. "It's too easy" isn't the reason. "The alternatives are too hard" is the reason.
- ant6n 10y agoSo uh, you're just gonna bury your head in the sand on all the problems associated with the utter dependence on the car?
- closeparen 10y agoI'm not sure where you got that impression. You propose to degrade people's lives by eroding their access to something they depend on. I propose to erode the reasons people depend on it, so that demand falls naturally and an eventual lack of access will not hurt. Are you going to bury your head in the sand on the problems of crowded housing markets?
- AstralStorm 10y agoUntil you provide proper transit and stop expanding roads and parking (which surely will degrade driving experience) and make new neighborhoods walkable (see above) demand for driving will not fall even if it becomes more expensive. Only the poor will be hurt. There are many roads overbuilt for the kind of traffic they face. Cutting them down to size is an excellent idea. Providing light and heavy rail is also great. Buses have limitations and still require expensive infrastructure for high level of service.
- ant6n 10y agoYour attitude seems to be that it's up to others to somehow 'fix' modes of transportation until the somehow compete with driving in terms of convenience, because your convenience is apparently much more important than considerations like the planet. And I guess if other modes can't compete well, apparently then driving must be inherently better, right? The main reason other modes of transportation suck is bad development patterns, centered all around driving. Unless you fix that, other modes won't be able to effectively compete. So discouraging driving is part of the multi-approach strategy to slowly change mode share and development patterns. Your attitude is reinforcing the broken status quo.
- closeparen 10y ago
- the8472 10y ago> particularly for the bike lane. If the bike lane is not between the parking space and the sidewalk there's something wrong with your roads.
- adrianN 10y agoIf you do it like that you have to be very careful how you design your intersections. Cyclists are even harder to see when they're hidden behind a row of cars. Like this for example http://www.protectedintersection.com/ http://www.protectedintersection.com/
- osdiab 10y agoI take that over risking getting car doored, or cut off by an uber. Let the careful thinking happen at the design phase - or even better, let's have dedicated bicycle boulevards (they don't have to be wide to accommodate staggering amounts of bike traffic)
- lkbm 10y agoI actually generally prefer bike lanes that put me more closer to the moving cars, despite said cars running over my bike twice so far. Drivers mostly know to watch for cyclists, though they're pretty bad at it. Pedestrians know to check for cars when entering the street, and cyclists benefit from that caution. But that bike lane with non-driving space to its right? People will blithely step into it, hop out of their cars into it, or stand in it, assuming it's a safe, non-vehicle space. Maybe it's just because it's so unusual where I live, or because it's in a pedestrian-heavy area, but I do not like it at all, and feel safer sharing the road. (My experience with these (as a cyclist) is mostly along the Drag in Austin, TX: https://goo.gl/maps/TPi9Yyj6SFn https://goo.gl/maps/TPi9Yyj6SFn )
- cbhl 10y ago> Drivers should booking garage spaces with dynamic, demand-based pricing from their phones before departing, and should know exactly where they're going to park before setting out. I used to believe this, but the one thing that drives me nuts about San Francisco is that all the garages close at night. If I want to park a car overnight (e.g. visiting a friend), the only option in my neighborhood is to park in a street parking spot.
- MBlume 10y agoWith less on-street parking (and with a denser city), you could make more money staffing your garage overnight