21 ms·
A discussion of Fedora’s legal state
- scythe 10y agoIf I understand the situation correctly, this is actually a rather heavy and unnoticed albatross hanging around Linux's neck: it's hard for a company to ship a working Linux distribution on a laptop sold for profit, because "working" means implementing a number of patented features.
- mjevans 10y agoAs well as likely distributing firmware which SHOULD just be shipped with the bloody hardware in a small sliver of ROM, or patches to roms which have bugs because of lack of testing, etc. Also many of the WiFi drivers have such crazy firmware because they're actually (at least partly) software defined radios and thus each country needs a slightly different flavor and that's related to regulations and testing. Everything would be much easier if we could just have some part of the UN that every country agrees to follow manage a universal spectrum allocation and anyone that disagrees should just expect all of the electronics to break.
- mseebach 10y agoNo, things would be better if someone (not me, alas, with a nod to the Linus rant) would design, build and market a wifi chip with FOSS firmware. Software is great exactly because it allows for infinite flexibility, so you don't need to involve the UN when allocating wifi spectrum.
- swiley 10y agoThat would probably be illegal for unlicenced use. WiFi firmware the way it's written now is considered hardware (at least in the US) just like the parent of your comment said.
- pjc50 10y agoOther way round: you need to comply with the (national) spectrum allocation. I'm not sure it would be even possible to build a FOSS wifi device without infringing any patents. And, as with other OSHW, how much more are people prepared to pay for that open-ness? I suspect very little.
- ddebernardy 10y ago> Everything would be much easier if we could just have some part of the UN that every country agrees to follow manage a universal spectrum allocation and anyone that disagrees should just expect all of the electronics to break. Not sure it would be. As I understood that's more or less how it works today bar the UN bit. Key industry players chatter and come up with standards that all are reasonably happy with. But then throw in a few countries that want to do things differently just for the sake of it, prior spectrum allocation, and protectionist moves, and you end up where we are today... https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- digi_owl 10y agoErr, yeah, good luck with that. Sad thing is that is is USA that is the problem child in all this. Being largely isolated from Eurasia, and having just a few big neighbors that are easy to convince to play along, they can basically define the spectrum within their broadcast reach as they see fit. It is basically the same reasoning behind it as why metric is still not the default over there.
- zeveb 10y ago> Sad thing is that is is USA that is the problem child in all this. Being largely isolated from Eurasia, and having just a few big neighbors that are easy to convince to play along, they can basically define the spectrum within their broadcast reach as they see fit. Well, and that works in our situation. > It is basically the same reasoning behind it as why metric is still not the default over there. There's also the simple fact that the 'metric' system is just different, not superior in general (i.e., it's better at some things and worse in others). Why impose a bunch of costs for no net benefit? If every other country jumped off a bridge, ought we?
- FireBeyond 10y agoWhat is the metric system worse at?
- SamReidHughes 10y agoDividing by 2 or 3. Having useful amounts of precision.
- FireBeyond 10y agoBy 2? Because dividing 10 or 100 by 2 is harder than 12 by 2? Three, I'll give you. Useful amounts of precision is a nothing, if you ask me. We start teaching decimals in third grade, and the only real issue with decimals is weather, for which the difference is saying "80F vs 81F", or "26.7 versus 27.2", whose utility is ... limited. For distance, the metric system has finer grained units for precision (come on, break down inches: 1/16, 1/8, 3/16, 1/4, 5/16, 3/8, 1/2, etc... are you going to argue that is better than 25.7cm or 257mm?). I'm not really buying it, as someone who has lived in both worlds.
- bubblethink 10y agoIn the US, yes. Ubuntu, VLC and the likes are exempt from this sort of nonsense because they are not registered in the US. I don't know what happens when a US based company like Dell sells laptops with Ubuntu in the US though. They probably would have made some deals.
- simonh 10y agoThat's actually easier for a hardware vendor though because they charge money for the product so can factor in licensing costs. Even aside from free software principles, the problem faced by a distro like Fedora is fitting the square peg of paying licensing fees to patent holders through the round hole of providing their software as a free download. BTW, does anyone know if Canonical still pay licensing fees to cover Ubuntu for this sort of thing? I believe they used to.
- digi_owl 10y agoI seem to recall that when you install Ubuntu you have to specifically check a box to say you want the proprietary and patent encumbered stuff. Likely Dell leave that up to the user to install after unboxing. And that is one reason that Mint got popular, because they took Ubuntu and bundled that stuff right on the ISO.
- jhasse 10y agoVLC is free software but still isn't included in Fedora because of patent issues. Ubuntu includes it (Ubuntu MATE even in the default install).
- TD-Linux 10y agoBeing in the EU is not a magical bullet against software patents. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/02/blackberry-sues-nokia-over-patents-as-its-phone-business-shuts-down/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/02/blackberry-sues-...
- lmm 10y agoAny organization with a per-unit revenue stream can easily just pay the MPEG-LA etc. "reasonable and non-discriminatory" fees - they're pretty low. It's only a problem for people who want to distribute linux (or anything that plays music/videos, unless it's just a wrapper that reuses the OS's built-in decoders) completely for free.
- gcp 10y agoWhich is why Chrome includes an MPEG-4 AVC/H264 decoder, but Chromium and Firefox do not.
- vetinari 10y agoFirefox nowadays downloads a blob for decoding H.264, distributed by Cisco. Cisco pays the fees and they've hit the upper cap time ago anyway. The source for that blob is available, but legally the binary must be distributed by someone, who is paying the fees.
- gcp 10y agoThe blob does not decode anything besides Baseline profile. It won't decode any web video.
- tomcam 10y agoHa! Now I can use Java in my nuclear submarine! Was too busy drinking martinis in my lair to notice that Sun finally caved. Begone, Perl 6 guidance systems! Welcome, MissilePrelaunchFactoryInit class!
- simonh 10y agoJust be careful translating that 150 character regexp that transforms the target's GPS co-ordinates into the missile's native co-ordinate projection system.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoWhat missiles? He just has a nuke powered fishie observation vessel.
- simonh 10y agoSo the MissilePrelaunchFactoryInit class is for managing the 'launch' of a fish observation application called Missile? Got it. My bad.
- Asooka 10y agoNo, it's supposed to be MissalPrelaunchFactoryInit, but the class name spellcheck in Eclipse autocorrected it. It's so you can tell the fish about their lord and saviour Jesus Carp.
- mcguire 10y agoSo we're ok with invading the privacy of aquatic animals now?
- simonh 10y agoIf they clearly mark their private area with approved warning signs and submit a privacy request notification form in triplicate at any US consulate, they can have all the privacy they want. Subject to exceptions* granted in the Patriot Act and other relevant legislation. * Warning - no actual grant of privacy included.
- i336_ 10y agoNobody's mentioned this, so here you go: the (apparently just 19:38) video. https://fosdem.org/2017/schedule/event/fedoras_legal_state/ https://fosdem.org/2017/schedule/event/fedoras_legal_state/
- kchauhan 10y agoThanks. That what I am looking for.
- hannob 10y agoSome of that reminds me when we tried to clean up the licensing situation in Gentoo. There's an incredible amount of self-invented licenses and if there's one advice I'd like to give to all free and open source devs: Don't do this. It annoys people in Linux distros who have to decide what to do with your code, whether it's free and there almost certainly is an existing, widely used license that does what you want. Choose one of the mainstream licenses like MIT, GPL (2 or 3, whatever, we know what it means, it's fine), Apache-2 or even something like WTFPL. It's all fine, we know what it means. But don't pick three chapters of license A and one of License B to have your unique mix. I also remember we had a LICENSE as-is, which was supposed to mean something very specific, but it had a horrible result: Many devs used it as the license dumpster: "I don't know what license it is, so I'll tag it as 'as-is'." Thanks to lots of work, mostly done by Ulrich Müller, all of that mess is now cleaned up.
- viraptor 10y agoIf you actually want your software used, then a known license is the best. In a corporate environment, it will be much easier to approve BSD or even GPL than WTFPL. There's most likely a preapproved list of known licenses and everything else needs to go through legal. You want your library used in the next big project? Don't use WTFPL.
- annnnd 10y agoWhy not? It is basically a public domain license, it just uses more colorful language. IANAL, but I see no problem using such code in corporate environment. What are the risks?
- ptaipale 10y agoYANAL, and IANAL, but those who are, are always suspicious of modified license texts. They always fear there's a hidden catch that the language (colourful or not) tries to hide and get you tricked. And they are not entirely unjustified to do so. Also, in a corporate environment, there's typically some additional overhead cost and bureaucracy and approvals that a new license text brings in, even when the engineers and lawyers manage to agree everything is OK.
- raymond_goo 10y agoYoutube (mirror?) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjflNTd2kho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjflNTd2kho
- stoolpigeon 10y agoThis is off-topic, please feel free to downvote/delete whatever but I've really not done well trying to find the answer to this question and there seem to be knowledgeable people here. I'm joining in on a project that uses the Zend framework. The Framework is under the New BSD License. We'd like our code to be under the same license. Do we just leave things as they are? Do we add our license to the files we create and leave the Zend files as they are? Do we need to add our stuff to all the files, even those that came with Zend? I apologize if there is an obvious place to go to understand this, I have not been able to find it.
- lmm 10y agoIf you're a serious business you need real legal advice. That said: put the license in the root of your project (as Zend probably does). Put your own copyright headers on any files that you create. Leave Zend's copyright headers on any files you don't modify. Add your own copyright to the a copyright header on any files you do modify.
- lmm 10y agoContribution agreements without assigning copyright seem to be a missing part of FOSS legal infrastructure. Everyone knows the standard open-source licenses, but there's no standard text you can have contributors sign to say that they understand that they're irrevocably licensing their contributions to you under that license. I ended up adapting the text from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Declaration_of_consent_for_all_enquiries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Declaration_of_conse... for my own project, but it would be good to have a well-known standardised statement along these lines.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> there's no standard text you can have contributors sign to say that they understand that they're irrevocably licensing their contributions to you under that license If you feel you need something like that, use the Developer Certificate of Origin: https://developercertificate.org/ https://developercertificate.org/ That's what "Signed-off-by:" lines indicate agreement with, and conveniently, git has built-in support for adding such lines.
- lmm 10y agoThanks, I wasn't aware of that. That said I'd prefer something closer to the Wikipedia language; I'd like it to be clearer that I might not retain contributions, and that contributions may be modified by subsequent contributors. > That's what "Signed-off-by:" lines indicate agreement with Not to me (I've been using -s for years, assuming it was just a way to include developer information in the commit message), so I doubt that would hold up in court.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoMy hat is off to this guy! License clearance is a pain. It was the single biggest task Blekko had to do after being acquired by IBM was to go through and vet all of the licenses in all of the bits of code and sort them. There was a bunch of tools to help but I don't think I could sign up for a job that had me in a meeting with lawyers twice a week discussing the various ways something ambiguous might be interpreted as the whole job.
- fencepost 10y agoCompletely aside from the content of the article, this is the second subscriber-only LWN.net article I've seen posted in the past week or so, and I'm sure there have been others. Please be careful with the articles you choose to post. While this may indicate that LWN needs to improve (or create) its paywall, if articles like this lead to new subscriptions they may be able to just chalk it up to "advertising" without breaking limited sharing of articles.
- jcrawfordor 10y agoAs an optimistic anecdote, this being the second such article in a week that I've really enjoyed just pushed me over the edge and I'm now an LWN subscriber. Hopefully I'm not the only one. I really wasn't familiar with LWN prior to seeing links to subscriber-only articles semi-frequently on HN, and honestly these days I'm embarrassed I didn't know about it sooner as I'm a Linux sysadmin and LWN's weekly edition is just about exactly the news I want to keep up with my job.
- sohkamyung 10y agoWelcome to the lwn.net subscriber gang! I'm an ordinary desktop linux user and have been a subscriber for many years. It has been, and still is, my go-to site for in-depth news on linux, whether on kernel matters or on the linux ecosystem. I'm the one who posted this article and so far, I have not had any warning mail from lwn.net about posting subscriber only content. But I do take care to try to only post content that I believe is of interest to HN.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoThe editor of LWN's statement on subscriber links on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5689018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5689018
- pimeys 10y agoI just need to come back here to say, that after reading your comment I subscribed to LWN. Really worth every penny. Thank you!